Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
asha456 · 07/12/2021 11:10

@Badbadbunny

There's a lot of VERY poor customer service/support at the moment. Customers/clients won't put up with that forever. Short term, organisations could get away with it "because of covid", but now that excuse is wearing thin.

WFH will cause a lot of reduction in services, not just shops/cafes/takeaways. TFL are already talking about closing down an entire London tube line due to lack of demand/reduction in income. There is also talk of London bus services being scaled back. That's inevitable as it has only been huge numbers of commuters which has made public transport viable. Take away a large chunk of regular commuters and you're going to see a much lower public transport provision. London will suffer it first, but it will also affect other cities. That will have a knock on effect on tourism and leisure.

If the centre of London was less crowded it would actually be more pleasant to visit.

People will still drink coffee and eat sandwiches, just in their local area instead. So shops and cafes in suburbs can thrive. That might be quite nice for those of us who can't afford to live in Zone 1.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 11:08

[quote Mittenmob]@requiredusername women are going to be worse off because although WFH allows you to be more flexible (sometimes) it means you're not visible at work. Women already have slower and more challenging career progression because of this and it's amplified in an environment where women are at home and men are in the office. It also means women start to take on MORE home responsibilities than before. Dr Heejung Chung writes about this in her 'flexibility paradox' book, it's worth a read.[/quote]
We hear this said a lot, but the other side of the coin that isn't being advanced is that there's significant potential benefit for women not having to work in workplace structures designed for and around men, with male as default. I can well believe promotion opportunities may go to those who are most able to be present. It was ever thus (there's that male as default thing again). But women's interests in the workplace boil down to much, much more than getting the next promotion.

There's also quite casual dismissal of the benefits of flexibility inherent in this approach too. Sure, we all know why women are the ones who benefit more from it. But identifying that need as stemming from sexism, which it does, isn't actually making it go away!

It's infinitely more complicated than 'women are going to be worse off'.

julieca · 07/12/2021 11:00

Honestly, the productivity angle always makes me eye roll. Open-plan offices are shit for productivity. Research shows the average productive working time for an employee in an open plan office is 5 and a half hours a day.
If you were starting from scratch to design the most productive way of working, you would not choose open-plan offices. And yet suddenly according to the media, they have become hubs for creativity and dynamism.

FinallyHere · 07/12/2021 10:56

genuinely curious to know what anyone gets out of the telegraph these days

@ManicPixie

DH does the cryptic cross word, never reads the rest. When I first knew him, I sort of discounted him even as a friend, because I assumed the paper reflect his own views. Couldn't be further than the truth. He enjoys the crossword so much, he shrugs at my idea they are spreading filthy propaganda.

Badbadbunny · 07/12/2021 10:41

@CaMePlaitPas

Big business protecting big business again. They don't give a shit about working conditions or the risk of falling ill and/or dying as a result of the pandemic. They want you back in the commercial property that is being rented for £££ each month and generate their £££ on your £21K a year salary.
Except a huge amount of commercial property is owned by pension funds, providing funding for pensions for millions of "ordinary" workers. If commercial property values fall off a cliff, millions of ordinary workers will see a fall in their future pensions. Likewise, a huge amount is owned by local councils, so council tax payers are likely to see further hikes in council tax or reductions in services to make up any shortfalls/losses in property income/values.
thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 10:38

In other words, service is driven by need, not the other way around! You don’t artificially force the need to be there because the service is there.

That's true.

But there has been this narrative bubbling along throughout the pandemic that politicians are pushing the economy and jobs ahead of our health because that's just what the Tories do etc... which is kind of childish.

In reality the economy and people's jobs matter a great deal. While I would agree that the government has frequently been reckless about the health element of COVID, you can hardly blame people from wanting to keep the economy afloat I think the narrative that the economy doesn't matter is not helpful.

Badbadbunny · 07/12/2021 10:37

There's a lot of VERY poor customer service/support at the moment. Customers/clients won't put up with that forever. Short term, organisations could get away with it "because of covid", but now that excuse is wearing thin.

WFH will cause a lot of reduction in services, not just shops/cafes/takeaways. TFL are already talking about closing down an entire London tube line due to lack of demand/reduction in income. There is also talk of London bus services being scaled back. That's inevitable as it has only been huge numbers of commuters which has made public transport viable. Take away a large chunk of regular commuters and you're going to see a much lower public transport provision. London will suffer it first, but it will also affect other cities. That will have a knock on effect on tourism and leisure.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 07/12/2021 10:32

@icedcoffees

And silly dismissive comments about Pret really piss me off, people are employed by Pret, their jobs matter just as much as yours

Exactly this.

The Prets &co were there because there was a need - office workers wanted lunch. Now that a lot of people WFH there is less need. The answer is to adapt the services/shops, not to force people to use something they don’t need anymore.

In other words, service is driven by need, not the other way around! You don’t artificially force the need to be there because the service is there.

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 10:28

Employers have good reason to have an opinion, but it's not at all clear what it is. For every employer I've read of who wants to go back to the pre-covid status quo there's another who has made a firm decision to go in the opposite direction. But the vast majority seem to be playing it by ear, and have no strong feelings in either direction.

This is one of the problems: employers seem to be making it up pretty much on the hoof, with policies changing often week by week even within firms and as you say, firms have wildly different approaches to this.

There's also the "official" line versus the unofficial one: a lot of companies realise that its politically unacceptable to actually force people into offices when its borderline unsafe, but make it very clear unofficially that those who do go in will get promoted faster and will be seen more positively etc.

It's shit for everyone and no doubt shit for employers too.

FreedomFaith · 07/12/2021 10:27

[quote flashbac]@FreedomFaith

It's not just about promotion, it can also affect you when cuts are made.[/quote]
Not if everyone is at home. Smile

flashbac · 07/12/2021 10:26

@FreedomFaith

It's not just about promotion, it can also affect you when cuts are made.

FreedomFaith · 07/12/2021 10:24

[quote Mittenmob]@requiredusername women are going to be worse off because although WFH allows you to be more flexible (sometimes) it means you're not visible at work. Women already have slower and more challenging career progression because of this and it's amplified in an environment where women are at home and men are in the office. It also means women start to take on MORE home responsibilities than before. Dr Heejung Chung writes about this in her 'flexibility paradox' book, it's worth a read.[/quote]
Not everyone cares about progressing though. I certainly don't. Ooh yay make me a manager PLEASE, I totally want to hear about how everyone's problems were caused by me and I need to fix them. Not all employees are like that of course, but if you get one, oh boy you're up shit creek.

I don't want kids, I'm fine with where I am pay wise etc, I don't live to work. Work pays my bills and for my hobbies. I have zero interest in it otherwise.

RandomLondoner · 07/12/2021 10:06

I am one of this retired people with big pensions invested in commercial proprerty. In fact I manage my own investments and am much more invested in it than is considered normal. My self-imposed rules for allocating money do not allow me to change my investments based on theorising about the impact of covid, even though I am nervous about it. I'm continuing to hold property, no idea if that will be something I regret. I have no desire to force people back to the office, quite the opposite. I wish I could have worked from home my whole life, and think the world will be a better place if in future people like me can work from home more.

RandomLondoner · 07/12/2021 09:56

I haven't been reading the Telegraph, but at one stage a few months ago Boris and other senior politicians were wittering about it being time to go back into the office.

I was very puzzled by that. Why do they care? What difference does it make to them?

Employers have good reason to have an opinion, but it's not at all clear what it is. For every employer I've read of who wants to go back to the pre-covid status quo there's another who has made a firm decision to go in the opposite direction. But the vast majority seem to be playing it by ear, and have no strong feelings in either direction.

So why the heck did politicians have an opinion?

FinallyHere · 07/12/2021 09:56

I’m still waiting for a form from teachers pensions to arrive and I asked for it some three weeks ago.

Productivity impacts of WFH depend to a very great extent on the infrastructure support provided to anyone WFH.

In our organisation, there are no paper forms left. There are vanishingly few things that need to be done in person. Some support which was always considered too expensive has been funded by the arrangements set in place for the pandemic.

Even back office processes have been impacted. All our pension administration is now online so there is no question of waiting three weeks for a 'form' to be produced. All the figures on contributions etc are available to recall. Any form that still needs a signature is downloaded, signed and returned.

If the 'forms' are in a box in a cupboard in the office, it will of course take much longer for a copy to be provided to you.

Hope it arrives soon.

It's not really about WFH, it's about the infrastructure provided to those WFH.

Grida · 07/12/2021 09:55

The Telegraph is very anti lockdown and probably sees wfh as an extension of lockdown. I always assumed a lot of newspaper journalists worked from home anyway.

Mittenmob · 07/12/2021 09:53

It's not just women working from home, of course not, but women are already those who are more likely to stay working from home and/or wfh more often. It's less easy for women with caring responsibility to drop everything and go in for drinks at the pub with colleagues, particularly if WFH routines mean no childcare is set up for such occassions. yes men might be impacted too but there is no point pretending that women and men have equal roles at work and at home, you might, but the vast majority of women take on 'the second shift'. So they will be disproportionally impacted by WFH, maybe not now, but 10 years down the line all those face to face meetings and catch ups are the ones where bonds are formed and promotions are decided. You can be as productive as you like but if no one notices your productivity at home then you're screwed. Eventually you may find organisations where women are the work horses at home while the men talk strategy in the office. I love WFH but I'm not blind to the risks of it career-wise.

requiredusername · 07/12/2021 09:45

Why would it only be women WFH?

Same question as above?

asha456 · 07/12/2021 09:34

[quote Mittenmob]@requiredusername women are going to be worse off because although WFH allows you to be more flexible (sometimes) it means you're not visible at work. Women already have slower and more challenging career progression because of this and it's amplified in an environment where women are at home and men are in the office. It also means women start to take on MORE home responsibilities than before. Dr Heejung Chung writes about this in her 'flexibility paradox' book, it's worth a read.[/quote]
Why would it only be women WFH?

CaMePlaitPas · 07/12/2021 09:27

Big business protecting big business again. They don't give a shit about working conditions or the risk of falling ill and/or dying as a result of the pandemic. They want you back in the commercial property that is being rented for £££ each month and generate their £££ on your £21K a year salary.

Juneberries · 07/12/2021 09:27

My husband has been WFH since March 2020; his employer recently totally gave up their city centre base when the lease came up for renewal.
Clients are still seeking teams meetings rather than face to face and there hasn’t been any drop in productivity since sending everyone home with a laptop, so from a business perspective it made no sense to keep it on.
They have an out of town industrial park type base for the limited jobs that can’t be WFH.

My husband has saved a small fortune and our lifestyle has changed a lot. He used to spend £80 a month on his public transport ticket, would eat lunch out half the days, and I would regularly meet him to grab dinner in town after work.

We now go sometimes months between visits to town. We spend our money in a different way- we order more online even compared to dropping into a city centre shop.

When we recently had a day off we travelled into town to have lunch, and you can clearly still see the effects of everyone WFH. His old office block now has multiple floors visibly empty. Shops have closed. The only place with a queue still is Greggs. You get a seat on public transport!

We are the some of the pandemic ‘winners’ but it’s not hard to see the losers in retail, hospitality and commercial property.

I obviously have more sympathy with those working in minimum wage jobs in those sectors rather than landlords, but whilst the high st etc was dying off a bit, the pandemic has set off a rapid decline.

Meanwhile though it’s great locally in our suburb-local restaurants and cafes are doing really well and more places opening up as people are around to spend their money there.

It’s a big cultural shift and there will be those invested on both sides.

Of course from our perspective it’s great- but it’s also changed the way we will probably move in future too now he is going to be remote working for potentially years to come. We have given up a bedroom to be an office, but also don’t really need the great proximity to public transport anymore. We will probably move further out of the city to get a house with more bedrooms.

Not all jobs but many WFH jobs are the preserve of the well educated and middle classes. One could argue it opens a divide where people on minimum wage are still having to pay for public transport etc whilst those earning more are at home saving on those costs.

You need childcare no matter what of course. I would argue if they want people back in the city centre offices companies in general are going to have to offer more flexitime to entice people in.

FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 09:27

[quote Mittenmob]@requiredusername women are going to be worse off because although WFH allows you to be more flexible (sometimes) it means you're not visible at work. Women already have slower and more challenging career progression because of this and it's amplified in an environment where women are at home and men are in the office. It also means women start to take on MORE home responsibilities than before. Dr Heejung Chung writes about this in her 'flexibility paradox' book, it's worth a read.[/quote]
Definitely! I have experienced that in a previous job where i was one of the few people working form home and, although I was enormously productive, i got promoted relatively late comparatively to the people who were in the office (men)

However if the whole office is fully remote that evens the paying field up. I have experience of this as I am in a fully remote company now and my moving up has been a lot quicker.

YouGotThisKeepGoing · 07/12/2021 09:24

As wel as political agendas, one thing your question made me think about was one of the last places that sees a good volume of physical paper sales is the railway station newsagent. Especially with promotions like ‘buy a bottle of water, get a paper free’ promos.

So that will be a really important location for print media to keep up their physical circulation figures which impacts on ad rates and revenues etc.

WFH = no commute = lower uptake of papers

Mittenmob · 07/12/2021 09:22

@requiredusername women are going to be worse off because although WFH allows you to be more flexible (sometimes) it means you're not visible at work. Women already have slower and more challenging career progression because of this and it's amplified in an environment where women are at home and men are in the office. It also means women start to take on MORE home responsibilities than before. Dr Heejung Chung writes about this in her 'flexibility paradox' book, it's worth a read.

FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 09:21

More flexibility helps the employers as much as the employees. I work a lot with the US and if I need to call them now I can adjust my home working hours without being paid overtime/time off in lieu.

Swipe left for the next trending thread