Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 15:16

@Wizzbangfizz

It isn't hard to understand but then neither is the fact that a lot of people aren't working more effectively Confused
No but the people who WFH are the ones accused of being the skivers. While people who spend hours dicking about in the office chatting about Eastenders and sharing football memes tend to get the benefit of the doubt.
julieca · 07/12/2021 15:09

"offices are hotbeds of skiving and there’s no point pretending they’re not."

Agreed. This whole conversation seems to be driven by the pretence that offices are models of productivity. In reality, I have been in loads of meetings in offices where half of it is general chit chat. I have travelled to meetings at other venues and dropped in for a bit of shopping. I have seen people chatting for ages at the photocopier or in the office kitchen or at desks.
Good managers measure what staff achieve. You should be able to do that wherever they are working. If you cant its because you cant do your job properly. And simple busyness is not the same as productiveness.
In my current job I work with someone else who does a similar job. They are much busier than me, they also achieve less.

Wizzbangfizz · 07/12/2021 14:50

It isn't hard to understand but then neither is the fact that a lot of people aren't working more effectively Confused

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 14:42

I get far more done at home than I ever did in the office. Partly because complex deep work is very hard to do when three people next to me are talking about the football results and two people behind me are discussing Strictly. Also I’m not running around to different meeting rooms or tired when I arrive from a pointless commute. It’s all killer no filler at home for me, and I can do the school run.

Yes!

Why is this to hard for people to understand? WFH frees up vast amounts of time. Unless you're totally lacking in motivation, in which case you'll be next to useless in an office as well.

Deborah02 · 07/12/2021 14:39

I know someone who works pretty high up in the Telegraph and they don’t let any of their own staff work from home either. Even during Covid they wanted her in.

Nc123 · 07/12/2021 14:32

[quote Wizzbangfizz]@chipsarnie you are basing your assumptions on your own experience as I am on mine, I'm glad it has worked out so well for you and fwiw I don't disagree with a hybrid wfh (pref would be 3 days in 2 off) model but in my own lived experience I know and work with many people who take the piss. I also think the office is more productive, just by being face to face and asking someone something instead of e mailing or setting up a meeting and is especially important in a mentoring younger colleagues way. [/quote]
I get far more done at home than I ever did in the office. Partly because complex deep work is very hard to do when three people next to me are talking about the football results and two people behind me are discussing Strictly. Also I’m not running around to different meeting rooms or tired when I arrive from a pointless commute. It’s all killer no filler at home for me, and I can do the school run.

Appreciate this may not be the case for everyone, but offices are hotbeds of skiving and there’s no point pretending they’re not.

Suspiciously · 07/12/2021 14:01

Sponsored by the patriarchy…

julieca · 07/12/2021 13:55

Honestly, it is very easy to skive in an office. I actually think easier than at home if you have a decent manager.

Wizzbangfizz · 07/12/2021 13:52

@chipsarnie you are basing your assumptions on your own experience as I am on mine, I'm glad it has worked out so well for you and fwiw I don't disagree with a hybrid wfh (pref would be 3 days in 2 off) model but in my own lived experience I know and work with many people who take the piss. I also think the office is more productive, just by being face to face and asking someone something instead of e mailing or setting up a meeting and is especially important in a mentoring younger colleagues way.

chipsarnie · 07/12/2021 13:45

@Wizzbangfizz

Because maybe like the rest of us they are sick of shitty customer service, poor response and return times, endless colleagues complaining about the safety of the office as a convenient excuse not to come in and sit of their arses at home and don't get me started on colleagues who want to self isolate before a holiday ffs!

People are also taking the piss with childcare and using it as an excuse to save money but not using breakfast clubs. The sooner we return to something more normal the better.

The large news organisation I work for brought in a hybrid WFH system, with two days a week in the office. I've managed to get a permanent WFH contract, so I don't go into the 'mothership' unless I want to. My job has not changed materially. The only difference is that my commute is 30 seconds to my desk in the dining room, rather than a half-hour bike ride. If anything I work far more efficiently.

My employer is happy too. They've reduced our office space from two floors of a landmark building to one, cutting the exceptionally expensive (millions per annum, literally) rent by about half. As with most major media/news companies it's only in a prestigious building because all the competition is.

I also see a lot more of my partner and child.

This is my 'normal' now. And it's a fuck-ton better.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 13:42

[quote CaveWoman1]@thepeopleversuswork

No surprise whatsoever that the senior jobs in these industries are dominated by men who have wives and partners at home to deal with the children. They've always scorned flexible working officially because its seen a sign of poor commitment but I suspect in reality its actually because its something which hands more power to women.

Yes, 100% this. A working culture that embraces more WFH as a viable option opens up more opportunities for women in terms of their careers. It’s a fair & justifiable change that’s long overdue IMO[/quote]
To that we can add many people with disabilities, chronic health problems and who are neuro diverse and find busy workplaces unhelpful (yes I know not all ND people fall into this category)

CaveWoman1 · 07/12/2021 13:37

@thepeopleversuswork

No surprise whatsoever that the senior jobs in these industries are dominated by men who have wives and partners at home to deal with the children. They've always scorned flexible working officially because its seen a sign of poor commitment but I suspect in reality its actually because its something which hands more power to women.

Yes, 100% this. A working culture that embraces more WFH as a viable option opens up more opportunities for women in terms of their careers. It’s a fair & justifiable change that’s long overdue IMO

julieca · 07/12/2021 13:31

I agree that big city centres being carved out is not a bad thing. I have seen places opening up near where I live, all independents, while the city centre suffers. This is an improvement.

julieca · 07/12/2021 13:30

@thepeopleversuswork that sounds an awful culture.
Where I work is not as bad as that, but everyone except the men involved, has commented how much better internal meetings are. To the point.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 13:30

@julieca

Some places have cut staff, other places have problems recruiting staff. Easier for companies to blame wfh than their own staffing levels.
Bingo.

There also seems to be a tendency for people who are against wfh on productivity grounds to conflate everything with customer service. Let's assume for the sake of argument that we had empirical evidence customer service was worse because of wfh rather than cost cutting, the great resignation, months with children and sometimes toddlers needing care while employees worked. Even then, why on earth would this be relevant for wfh across the board, instead of just in one type of role?

Thecurliestwurly · 07/12/2021 13:29

@LaurieFairyCake

The people who are really rich - ie. big commercial landlords/chain sandwich shops leech off us

They don't give a crap about people having a better life balance

What is it - 3% of the population own 95% of the wealth ? Hmm

Of course those fuckers want you to go back and line their pockets a bit more

They're fucking leeches - the leeches ARE NOT benefit claimants, the working poor, the disabled

Good point. No wonder they like to stoke up an argument in these areas, a nice distraction from them bleeding the system dry.

The things is, lots of companies are embracing WFH. Even if you don't want to WFH yourself, I expect having the choice to when you might need it would persuade people to choose one company over the other. It's very short sighted, but once workers vote with their feet (I expect young people who have never known office culture will expect it now), they will have to embrace it. No amount of bleating in the Telegraph about perceived limitations of WFH will change that, they are just preaching to the converted.

TedMullins · 07/12/2021 13:27

@olivehater

Right then the ones that have to go to work should be paid a premium. We don’t get to have any of this lovely flexibility and most parents in my sector have to work part time so that they can be their for their kids at least a little bit. We are also the ones having to fork out childcare. If you want to have nurses and midwives in the futureetc then you need to make that attractive too. Just saying change your job then to someone in and established career is thoughtless.
People shouldn’t lose flexibility just because not everyone can have it. Yes, nurses and midwives can’t work from home, and I do wholeheartedly agree they should be paid much more than they currently are, but maybe other sectors that could offer more flexibility but don’t, will respond to the rise in WFH by offering more flexibility. It’s a good thing. People who previously just accepted that work-life balance wasn’t a thing discovered that it can be and understandably many people want to keep it. it’s so important - look at Sweden and the four day weeks, six-hour days. They work less but still have better public services especially for mothers and children. It is possible, and the sooner UK work culture realises this and has a shift towards flexibility for all, the better
julieca · 07/12/2021 13:25

Some places have cut staff, other places have problems recruiting staff. Easier for companies to blame wfh than their own staffing levels.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 13:25

There's also the point that there are loads of reasons why any particular customer service team might be doing worse. I've yet to see anyone who has experienced declining customer service and blames wfh even acknowledge the potential impact of school closures, for example. Or people leaving and their roles lying vacant, or shitty employers who abused the furlough scheme.

RashifBees · 07/12/2021 13:23

I recognise the trend, but I didn’t realise the Telegraph in particular was vehemently anti-wfh. It explains why my long-retired DF is so anti. We were out and about a few months ago and he said it was awful things weren’t back to normal, which was puzzling because everything was open where we were. Turns out the whole of society is waiting for everyone to get back to the office.

He didn’t have any solid arguments for his position other than the old it’s work, it’s not meant to be fun chestnut. He was ranting about the terrible example set by civil servants on Pelatons. Tbh I was quite upset at how bitter he seemed to be about wfh-ers since I am one!

He’s a Telegraph reader.

Iggly · 07/12/2021 13:19

@Wizzbangfizz

Because maybe like the rest of us they are sick of shitty customer service, poor response and return times, endless colleagues complaining about the safety of the office as a convenient excuse not to come in and sit of their arses at home and don't get me started on colleagues who want to self isolate before a holiday ffs!

People are also taking the piss with childcare and using it as an excuse to save money but not using breakfast clubs. The sooner we return to something more normal the better.

Better for who?

A lot of customer call centres I ring are offshore. I haven’t noticed a dip in performance and think that those who claim it has is based on anecdotal instances.

A return to “normal” just means being a slave to the commute

We don’t have to wfh all the time. It can be a combination of office and WFH. Not sure why people are so binary/dense about it.

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 13:17

@julieca

Its interesting about the boozy meetings under the guise of networking. Because one thing we have found is that internal meetings are way better on zoom. The men (and its always a man) who goes on for ages in meetings with a pretty useless contribution, seem to do it way less over zoom. Our internal meetings have been way better. I used to dread them, now I think they are fine.
Indeed. There's far less joshing and "all lads together" behaviour on Teams and Zoom.

A lot of people at my gaff are bemoaning the loss of the great "culture" of City workplaces which apparently is the deepest casualty of COVID.

If by "culture" what is meant is a lot of gammons in fake Saville Row getting pissed at the rugby all afternoon and getting their secretaries to do all the dog work then you can keep it.

I don't love video calls but I'd rather that than lose five hours of my day being the support to a load of backslapping by blokes who went to school together.

Iggly · 07/12/2021 13:16

@julieca

If the economy relies on me buying a sandwich from Pret at lunch time, its in worse shape than I thought.
Well clearly one person does not make a difference, but millions of people do.

More people WFH would dramatically change the economic make up of cities where people commute in and I don’t think that’s a bad thing to be honest.

julieca · 07/12/2021 13:16

@Nc123 I suspect the owner of Pret is a Tory donor.
The Tories have no problem saying manufacturing or farming has to adjust to changing commercial markets, but Pret and commercial offices have to be safeguarded.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 13:15

@julieca

Its interesting about the boozy meetings under the guise of networking. Because one thing we have found is that internal meetings are way better on zoom. The men (and its always a man) who goes on for ages in meetings with a pretty useless contribution, seem to do it way less over zoom. Our internal meetings have been way better. I used to dread them, now I think they are fine.
Mmm, there's a good deal of truth to that.
Swipe left for the next trending thread