Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
julieca · 07/12/2021 20:27

@Wizzbangfizz

And also again focussing once more "well it suits me and my life goals" so it should suit everyone and no one can force me to come back in. And I support a hybrid approach, did it before do it now. Covid really has shown the best of everyone.Hmm
This is VERY unfair. I very specifically talked about how wfh suits some people and not others. I will continue to wfh and got a new job during the pandemic that is permanently wfh. There is nothing wrong with that.

And I did not say it suits me and my life goals, although that is true it does. Firms will offer what they have to in order to recruit good staff. I am not brilliantly paid, but I am good at what I do and happy to carry on doing it. I don't need to present at meetings in work to learn. I have done plenty of presenting in the past. But the people I learn from are others in other organisations doing similar jobs, not from my work colleagues.
A lot of jobs these days are far more specialised, and apart from the odd IT issue, others at work really cant help me. In fact, one of the challenges of being in the office was always fending off politely suggestions of how I could improve things, from people who have no understanding of the legal underpinnings of my role that I have to comply with.
Work environments change. When I started work most people were in small shared offices built around teams, and then open plan offices came into being. Then there was the rise of the cubicle, followed by hot desking. Nothing stays the same. You either have to adapt or find a firm stuck in the old ways of doing things, and they do exist.
Personally, I think small offices based around teams worked best. I was in an office with two other people. Small enough to have quiet to get on with work, but also people who knew your job you could talk to. But open-plan offices were supposed to prevent cliques, make people work beyond their immediate team, and make it a more dynamic -place to work.

MasterGland · 07/12/2021 19:58

Also, The Telegraph have also ran quite a few articles in the lifestyle sections about moving to the countryside now you can work from home. Tips on surviving winter in the sticks, type of thing. So coverage has been mixed.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 19:31

A cynic would think it has something to do with the evidence the select committee heard about Johnson and the Pen Farthing flight.

Starcaller · 07/12/2021 19:30

I work for a newspaper and we've worked quite happily at home since the pandemic began. Some people are back in the office now, mostly out of choice, but most are still at home much of, it not all, the time. There has been very little disruption besides the initial few days of getting everyone hooked up with laptops and to the system.

It has given us a lot of freedom to be able to employ some great people that wouldn't otherwise be able to work for us due to distance, commitments as a carer, childcare, etc. And there's a lot of chat on Teams that even the introverted people feel comfortable in joining in, which was not always the case in an office environment.

As our boss said on a call the other day, 'Working from home is not the bogeyman we all thought it was'. I for one am going to be permanently home-based and I imagine quite a few others will remain so too.

manysummersago · 07/12/2021 19:22

No idea, I just caught it on the news. But there do seem to be a few people who have found that wfh isn’t brilliant service, tbf.

Frankola · 07/12/2021 19:20

That reader demographic is more likely to be business owners, retail and commercial property owners.

Nothinbut · 07/12/2021 19:06

@manysummersago

BBC news is discussing the problem with Afghanistan. Seems to be implying civil servants certainly weren’t effective when WFH.
Do you mean one department, actually one team within the department or the entire civil service?
manysummersago · 07/12/2021 18:52

BBC news is discussing the problem with Afghanistan. Seems to be implying civil servants certainly weren’t effective when WFH.

LakieLady · 07/12/2021 18:47

For companies in the city i.e. the civil service the London weighting is being removed for many jobs where people work from home, so while they may not be commuting, they will be financially Worse off.

Civil service London weighting is £4k, so less than £3k after tax/NI. An annual season ticket to London from my Sussex town is over £4.5k, so for a lot of commuters it's well worth losing the London weighting for.

Not to mention the 2+ hours a day you lose, crammed into a cattle truck and standing for over an hour in the morning, and the joys of the train terminating at some tiny station in the middle of nowhere because the track further down floods during periods of very wet weather.

Everyone I know who commutes to London, even if not central London, vows they'll never go back to it.

gannett · 07/12/2021 18:47

[quote Wizzbangfizz]@julieca I think part of being an effective manager is being in a room with people you are line managing. It is particularly difficult with introverted members of the team to get them to speak up and participate on bloody teams - they get so much more face to face by spending time with other team members. Also work isnt drudgery what is wrong with having a social conversation in the office?

It's not a case of "I'm alright jack because I don't have the time and cost of a commute to worry about" it's about wider issues. [/quote]
I work for an international company (the only person in the UK with my specific role) so all my direct colleagues are overseas. The entire job is remote, Covid or not. There's been absolutely no problem managing or being managed remotely, nor in building social bonds with colleagues by chatting online.

You can't generalise about a mode of working being best for all companies, all managers, all staff across the board. Companies will end up choosing the people who can do the job best in whatever their chosen format is. Sure, not everyone thrives on WFH. But plenty do - easily a majority of people I know - and they will therefore thrive in what's obviously the future of the labour market.

Newcomer68 · 07/12/2021 18:34

If you look at the property-worshipping-and-owning, money-grabbing, money-munching people who own most of these "WFH is the Work of the Devil" spouting rags, that'll give you a clue as to why they take this editorial stance.

I've recently moved into a different role where I work (still WFH). And despite my having successfully worked from home for almost two years (since before the pandemic), the ghastly recruitment and HR people (and they ARE ghastly - they all seem to have gotten much, much, much worse in the last 18 months and much more power-hungry, in their little kitten heels and totally impractical fashionista getups) are refusing to allow my backfill to be a "remote" worker. There are outputs they can measure, actual things (in the form of documents and other information results). It's not like I'm sitting in the pub drinking gin all day. That's quite apart from all the meetings, presentations, and training sessions!

I think it's a bit o a power thing, generally, and some of them are gradually feeling (what they perceive as) their power over others slipping away (that's what I tell myself on the days when they're being more idiotic than usual, anyway).

Nothinbut · 07/12/2021 18:28

[quote Wizzbangfizz]@julieca it's not about forcing people to go for a pint or anything to do with friendships or making work your life fgs it is about the learning opportunities, giving the people the opportunity to present/be present in meetings which just isn't the same over a goddamn computer screen. [/quote]
I agree with this, we had a new member of the team who wanted to be in office learning face to face so I went in for a fortnight no issue and then they were happy to do a mixture. I think flexibility is important.

usernameshistory · 07/12/2021 18:22

It's a very simple reason and is to do with money. The tory allies have massive wealth tied up in the office rental income in the city - these newspapers are run and supported by eachother. They simply want to retain that income and people working from home will prevent that.

Wizzbangfizz · 07/12/2021 18:22

And also again focussing once more "well it suits me and my life goals" so it should suit everyone and no one can force me to come back in. And I support a hybrid approach, did it before do it now. Covid really has shown the best of everyone.Hmm

Wizzbangfizz · 07/12/2021 18:18

@julieca it's not about forcing people to go for a pint or anything to do with friendships or making work your life fgs it is about the learning opportunities, giving the people the opportunity to present/be present in meetings which just isn't the same over a goddamn computer screen.

Nothinbut · 07/12/2021 17:50

We are going to have a blended approach going forward which I think is great. I have enjoyed working from home but also enjoy being in the office. Productivity I would have thought depends on the job and the team. Ours has worked well as we have been fortunate to have the equipment to work collaboratively from home, and if the work wasn't getting done, due to the nature of it would be found out pretty quickly!

chipsarnie · 07/12/2021 17:46

I'm 53, and an introvert.

The social aspect of work was important when I was a lot younger, it's not any more - although I am fond of my team and we do meet up for a pint about once a month.

Pre-covid we had an "ideas meeting" at least a couple of times a week where we spent most of the time eating biscuits and talking about music and films. Great, but not productive. Now we do it all by email. Straight to the point, no messing, and I can get on with what I'm paid to do.

Another benefit of WFH is that 'H' could be literally anywhere in the UK with a decent internet connection. If the stars align, in a couple of years my 'H' could even be a houseboat in the Netherlands. My quality of life has dramatically improved. There is not one single thing I miss about being in an office.

julieca · 07/12/2021 17:24

@Wizzbangfizz I know some employers want you to socialise with the team as they want to make your job your life. To hell with that, it is not. It's what I do to earn money.
If I am not meeting expectations I expect to be pulled up on it. I don't accept any idea that I should be friends with those I work with.

julieca · 07/12/2021 17:20

@Wizzbangfizz you would probably see me as an introverted colleague. I am not really, I just rarely have much in common with colleagues. And no I don't particularly enjoy socialising at the office although I do it to be polite.
I get that socialising at the office suits some people though. DP loves it and misses being in the office. I would rather have zero commuting time and talk to friends after work.
I don't want to talk to my line manager in a chit chat way. I raise issues and talk about work. But I have zero in common with him and would never in a month of Sundays choose to socialise with him. I am also not looking for promotion so I don't care about that. I just want to do the job and get paid.

Wizzbangfizz · 07/12/2021 17:07

@julieca I think part of being an effective manager is being in a room with people you are line managing. It is particularly difficult with introverted members of the team to get them to speak up and participate on bloody teams - they get so much more face to face by spending time with other team members. Also work isnt drudgery what is wrong with having a social conversation in the office?

It's not a case of "I'm alright jack because I don't have the time and cost of a commute to worry about" it's about wider issues.

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 16:48

@manysummersago

I don’t think anyone is saying everyone who works from home is a ‘skiver’, just that in a lot of cases, what people might think of as more effective isn’t.
All I can do is point to my own experience.

If I'm at home I'm working straight through from 7am to 6pm without a break. I can get four or five major pieces of high quality written work done in that time.

If I'm in the office I wouldn't start work - if I was lucky and my commute had gone smoothly until 9.30am. If I have a couple of calls plus a guaranteed half an hour of chit chat in the morning and another in the afternoon I've compressed my morning down to about two hours maximum with maybe another two in the afternoon. I am literally twice as productive as I am in the office.

The biggest problem by far is the commute which is just an hour and a half of dead time.

But there's a vast amount of time-wasting in offices on top of that. A lot of people basically tread it as an extension of their social life.

julieca · 07/12/2021 16:28

@manysummersago managers need to look at outcomes then. What are staff achieving. If you can manage someone effectively in an office, you can manage them effectively working from home. If you are a poor manager you cant.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 16:22

Which is a reach, really.

manysummersago · 07/12/2021 16:15

I don’t think anyone is saying everyone who works from home is a ‘skiver’, just that in a lot of cases, what people might think of as more effective isn’t.

julieca · 07/12/2021 15:20

Honestly, I can fake busyness with the best of them in an office. If that is what is required I will do it. But it achieves fuck all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread