Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbadbunny · 09/12/2021 14:35

@fakereview

As for conversions to residential, that's usually prohibited by local planning regulations, hence why so much is left empty in city centres - it takes a lot of time and effort to get through planning approval stages for change of use

I am not sure it's that difficult, quite a few office blocks in our town have been converted to residential use. Some look quite nice, but they are all flats with little or no outside space and I also don't know what the quality of the build is like.

Depends on the council and their "local plan". If their "local plan" cites areas of the town/city centre as commercial, it's virtually impossible to get change of use.
Badbadbunny · 09/12/2021 14:34

@riceuten

The people saying that people working from home "think they work harder but they're not" - why don't you just come straight out with it and say "I don't like people working from home" ?

I suspect it's for all the reasons outlined above, but mainly pandering to a reactionary, elderly demographic who regard working from home as "not proper work" and who hark back to a bygone golden age of deferential workers calling their bosses "Sir", and accepting their lot in life.

If WFH is so efficient, why is virtually every organisation struggling with customer service etc? Nearly every time, it's always "due to covid" when phones aren't answered, simple things take weeks, etc. Look at HMRC, DVLA, etc - huge delays and really crap customer service at the moment.
NeedAHoliday2021 · 09/12/2021 12:52

When I was a journalist in a local paper they were managed by low paid editors who had no management/people training and were obsessed with bums on seats. Even in the first lockdown our regional team had to be in the central office in the city (an hour and a half away) as their local office was closed. It’s nuts but they don’t trust their low paid staff to do a good job unless they are in an office chair. It’s a bizarre old fashioned world where mums are (were) particularly looked down upon. I left when dd was 18 months old.

fakereview · 09/12/2021 12:37

As for conversions to residential, that's usually prohibited by local planning regulations, hence why so much is left empty in city centres - it takes a lot of time and effort to get through planning approval stages for change of use

I am not sure it's that difficult, quite a few office blocks in our town have been converted to residential use. Some look quite nice, but they are all flats with little or no outside space and I also don't know what the quality of the build is like.

fakereview · 09/12/2021 12:35

@manysummersago

Not at all. I used to be a massive fan of working from home, but I’ve just had awful customer service too many times now.

I don’t think my own husband works any less hard in the house but I also don’t think it’s good for him and I don’t think it’s good for or fair on families.

Bad customer service has nothing to do with WFH.

And if it's bad for your DH to work from home he can go into the office. My husband's employer sent an email out to say people should work from home but can go in for business or wellbeing reasons and I suspect I will receive something similar. Plus the fact that we're not in lockdown, so libraries, co-working spaces, even a cafe is an option depending on if you need two screens etc.

julieca · 09/12/2021 12:32

Anyone I know who has said that working from home is not really working has never had an office job or is a manager. I think people should have the choice whether to wfh or not. But anyone who has worked in a number of offices knows how inefficient most open-plan offices are. I have found it amusing to see them being typified as a hub of efficient working practices full of dynamic colleagues helping each other out. Its fantasy land time.
And most people decrying working from home in terms of customer services are dealing with call centres. If you work in a call centre everything is measured from the length of time you spend on a phone call to the dead time in between calls. It does not matter where you work, if any of your measurements look poor, you are at risk of being sacked.

manysummersago · 09/12/2021 12:23

Not at all. I used to be a massive fan of working from home, but I’ve just had awful customer service too many times now.

I don’t think my own husband works any less hard in the house but I also don’t think it’s good for him and I don’t think it’s good for or fair on families.

riceuten · 09/12/2021 11:29

The people saying that people working from home "think they work harder but they're not" - why don't you just come straight out with it and say "I don't like people working from home" ?

I suspect it's for all the reasons outlined above, but mainly pandering to a reactionary, elderly demographic who regard working from home as "not proper work" and who hark back to a bygone golden age of deferential workers calling their bosses "Sir", and accepting their lot in life.

Badbadbunny · 09/12/2021 08:16

@Sallybates

Because it represents those who own offices, property who want the worker drones in there. Wouldn’t it be great if offices were made over for folk to live in instead? Families could chose if WFH suited them, save money on fares, drycleaning, parents spend more time with children
Lots of commercial properties are owned as investments by local councils and pension funds. Loss of rental income and reductions in value will hit "normal" people, i.e. reduced services by local councils due to loss of revenue and reduced pensions for ordinary workers.

As for conversions to residential, that's usually prohibited by local planning regulations, hence why so much is left empty in city centres - it takes a lot of time and effort to get through planning approval stages for change of use.

Circlesandtriangles · 09/12/2021 07:01

They'll have to suck it up and be fans of it again now given the latest guidance I guess. I really disliked the general "it's time to get back to work" narrative in September that implied we had all been sat home twiddling thumbs for the past year and a half. I've got a job which has always involved hybrid working, mix of home and from office, which feels like a great balance. I think it's really short sighted to vilify WFH - it's best if people have choice and can choose what suits their circumstances best, and the flexibility is really appealing and works well for so many people, particularly with caring responsibilities or kids. It's not something that works for everyone or every job by any means but I hate the creation of another division between people and the construction of the "wfh isn't real work/ is lesser work" narrative.

I definitely understand more about the telegraph from this. I moved to UK a few years ago so feel like I missed the understanding of the background of the different media outlets and naively thought the Telegraph occupied the middle ground. I don't even know if there is any newspaper occupying the middle ground now that I think about it!

OP posts:
asha456 · 09/12/2021 01:23

@Mirw

There are lots of reasons for people not working at home. One that really affects women much more than men is that people in social housing and in private rented housing breach their tenancy agreement if they work from home now that lockdown is over. If they push it, they are making themselves homeless. Far too much of a burden and also a breach of their rights. So WFH has to be a choice for everyone who works in offices, not the new norm. I personally work from home but it is my choice rather than forced on me by an employer. But it has to be a choice.
Equally, I would want people in rented accommodation to have the choice to WFH as well, and not be forced by landlords into an office. If the government can make it legal temporarily then they could also make it a permanent right.
ThistleTits · 08/12/2021 23:06

@manysummersago

Where is a universal basic income being seriously discussed?
Never, not positively in the Telegraph anyway.
Wizzbangfizz · 08/12/2021 22:43

@requiredusername I'll be interested to see who complies, I'm hoping my govt dept keep offices open and give people the choice.

Lifetheuniverseandeverything · 08/12/2021 20:11

The same Telegraph that is denigrating the survivors of Ghislaine Maxwell and Epstein? That Telegraph? It’s a mystery.

Lovely13 · 08/12/2021 20:08

It’s about control, I think. Mainly white privileged men have always sat at head of business table. Now it’s all gone a bit wavy for them. They don’t like it!
Having said that, for younger generation, think they’re missing out on being inside the workplace. Skills to be learned there that you can’t get online.

exaltedwombat · 08/12/2021 19:54

They're attacking the government, not WFH specifically. 'Boris commanded it, therefore it's wrong'.

Not a bad maxim, actually...

Sassoon · 08/12/2021 19:29

They're a paper who represent Tories, capitalists, and those who make money from workers so they're never going to like workers having any autonomy or not being forced to buy lunches, petrol or clothes. Also some people seem to object to it out of pure jealousy, for no other reason than they can't do it themselves 🤷‍♀️

FanGirlX · 08/12/2021 19:28

Let’s be honest a lot of these work from home job could be done in the half the time they are claiming for.

Do you have actual evidence for this statement?

FanGirlX · 08/12/2021 19:25

It's a right wing newspaper. Flexibility helps women to work, and of course the Tories would like us all back in the kitchen with the baby on our hip.

Are you including Margaret Thatcher and Theresa May in that. Can you name a Labour or Lib Dem prime minister?

FanGirlX · 08/12/2021 19:23

@olivehater

Right then the ones that have to go to work should be paid a premium. We don’t get to have any of this lovely flexibility and most parents in my sector have to work part time so that they can be their for their kids at least a little bit. We are also the ones having to fork out childcare. If you want to have nurses and midwives in the futureetc then you need to make that attractive too. Just saying change your job then to someone in and established career is thoughtless.
It doesn't work like that though. It's supply and demand. For example shortage of HGV drivers meant salaries went up. It's always been the same.

Lower skilled jobs tend to pay less and have less good terms and conditions because there are a lot of people who can do them without much training - retail, warehouse workers etc. Higher skilled jobs pay more because there are less people who can do them, as they need years of training - doctors etc.

FanGirlX · 08/12/2021 19:14

@olivehater

As someone who has never worked from home it pisses me off. I am still paying out childcare, petrol etc. I choose to work part time and take the equivalent pay cut that goes with that while I see people on the school run that then nip to activities/coffee shop/playground with their kids. Sure there are some that put all the hours in later but their are plenty more who don’t whilst taking a full time wage. Civil service appears to be the worst for it. If this is going to carry on then this that those that have to travel to work need to be paid a premium or no one is going to choose these careers going forward. And why the hell would you when this jobs that allow working from home have it so cushy?
Civil service offers flexi time. You still have to do the 37 hours a week but you can do them anytime between 7am and 7pm, Monday to Friday. Civil Servants are also sometimes part time, if someone is on a 30 hour contract they can do their 30 hours between 7am and 7pm, Monday to Friday. This all has to fit with organisational needs though and is therefore agreed with their manager.

Hope that helps.

requiredusername · 08/12/2021 19:05

Well Boris is sending everyone back home again now anyway.

Sallybates · 08/12/2021 18:27

Because it represents those who own offices, property who want the worker drones in there. Wouldn’t it be great if offices were made over for folk to live in instead?
Families could chose if WFH suited them, save money on fares, drycleaning, parents spend more time with children

Mirw · 08/12/2021 18:26

There are lots of reasons for people not working at home. One that really affects women much more than men is that people in social housing and in private rented housing breach their tenancy agreement if they work from home now that lockdown is over. If they push it, they are making themselves homeless. Far too much of a burden and also a breach of their rights. So WFH has to be a choice for everyone who works in offices, not the new norm. I personally work from home but it is my choice rather than forced on me by an employer. But it has to be a choice.

Zipper666 · 08/12/2021 18:24

@ClintBartonsWife

Owners probably have a lot of money invested in commercial property.
There may be something in that theory! Here in the US, the big cities like New York and Chicago have millions of square feet in commercial property lying empty. Some businesses like Insurance and money management which always had offices over several floors with hundreds, sometimes thousands of workers beavering away have found that they work still gets done, the workers are not a stressed and actually work harder and longer because they no longer commute. Meanwhile the acres of empty offices still on long leases are leaking money. Several companies are looking to convert those slab like offices in the heart of Manhattan into luxury condos with prices for even the smallest in the millions!
Swipe left for the next trending thread