Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD and charging rent?

233 replies

Nolongerachild · 06/12/2021 22:37

Long time poster, NC. Need some advice please, in case I am not being reasonable.
Single mum, no partner. DD living at home, and has finished her Masters, and started new job with a good salary.
I feel I should start charging her rent to include bills and food. Does £500 a month sound OK? My rent is £1300 a month, CT is £170 and who knows what energy bills will be this year but guessing around £100 a month. Then there’s water, internet and our food bill. She has to pay her mobile and her transport (no car). I just feel I need to put more into my pension, and I have literally nothing left at the end of every month. We’re in Bristol area, for my work, but it suits her very well for now. If she moved out I’d get a lodger. I’d really appreciate any advice particularly if someone else has had similar experiences. DD is 24. Thanks.

OP posts:
RockinHorseShit · 07/12/2021 08:02

I'll never understand posters who comment on rental or other prices in an area they clearly know nothing about Confused

£500 is cheap for Bristol, it would be very cheap here

I'm also shocked so many choose not to teach their DCs a life lesson in taking care of themselves as adults... eg, paying your own way in life & not expecting hand outs ... even if you can afford not to, put it in a savings pot for their future mortgage or something by all means, but FFS teach them to pay their own way, that's not an option to duck out of in life & not charging them does them no favours at all

BrightonOrLancaster · 07/12/2021 08:00

Shes getting an even better deal than if she went into a houseshare as living with mum presumably means a guarantee of living somewhere with a properly fully equipped kitchen, nice comfy surroundings, the opportunity to do all the telly hogging and slobbing you want, no mould or cold issues, presumably "naice" food and home cooked meals.
I did a decade of house sharing and some were better than others but pretty much every time there was some kind of rub - either a low equipped kitchen, or a non responsive LL, or that one housemate who was always bringing her BF over to hog the living room, or the one who was ALWAYS. HOME.

Talk of independence isnt really relevant here, the DD actively wants to live at home, so shes not looking for independence

jay55 · 07/12/2021 07:57

@vodkaredbullgirl

Bristol is an expensive place to live, outside of London.
Bristol can be more expensive, council tax is way higher, public transport costs are high and if you're on Bristol/Wessex water the water bill is higher.

My rent is more in London but my bills were a lot higher in Bristol.

PheasantsNest · 07/12/2021 07:48

Far, far too much. I would say £200 at most.

x2boys · 07/12/2021 07:37

I mean if you have nothing left at the end of the month and are living in poverty why wouldn't you charge your daughter £500 ,for bed and board it sounds a reasonable amount ,
Ignoring posters of course who live very comfortable lives and would never charge their adult children 🙄

RockinHorseShit · 07/12/2021 07:11

More than fair. We've told ours that when she's earning, she'll be expected to pay 1/3 of her wages up to -20% of the local market rate for inclusive rents.

That amount sounds cheap, & we live in a similarly priced area

Undertheoldlindentree · 07/12/2021 07:07

Given the rent amount, household costs and both your circumstances, I think £500 is fair. I'm in Midlands (cheaper than Bristol) and 25 yr old DC in rented house-share ( nice residential area) was paying £450pm. Included bills and council tax. With food and contribution to household stuff like loo-roll, cleaning and laundry liquid, it was easily £600-650 a month just to live. In Bristol likely at least £700-750. Ignore the people whose experience is different to yours (two working parents, council tax already covered etc...it just doesn't compare).

You're about right on this and need to start building some security for yourself.

vodkaredbullgirl · 07/12/2021 07:07

When their adult child is working full-time.

vodkaredbullgirl · 07/12/2021 07:06

Must be nice for some parents not to ask for a contribution from their kids.

Porcupineintherough · 07/12/2021 06:40

Yes its fine. You dont have to spend retirement in poverty just so your dd can put together a house deposit without a moments sacrifice.

MrsLarry · 07/12/2021 06:24

Oh, I should add that he would've paid his own food on top of the £200.

MrsLarry · 07/12/2021 06:18

I think £500 is way too much. It's not her place to pay your mortgage.

My son graduated last year. The plan was that if he returned home I'd charge him £200 so he could also save a deposit for his own home. He earns more than I do.

halloweenie13 · 07/12/2021 05:57

It is too much considering she will probably be wanting to save for her own place and pension and not be in the same position as you, but taking a large chunk of her earnings after paying student finance and transport costs will make it difficult for her to save.

malificent7 · 07/12/2021 05:53

Id charge her less on the understanding she saves a bit for a deposit.

ThinWomansBrain · 07/12/2021 05:35

@lastqueenofscotland

£500 as market rate in bristol… dream on. Sounds fair OP.
my thoughts entirely - sounds more than fair!
HadaVerde · 07/12/2021 04:59

@ikeptgoing

If 24 year old DD is earning £21k or more, Her monthly take home will be £1250+ after pensions, tax etc. If she budgets £200 month for spending & phone and £50-100 for travel costs for work, paying mum £500/month rent, leaves DD still with £450-500 month to save towards deposit for house. That's pretty good when mum's (OP's) rental, bills, CT, food, etc will be in excess of £1850/ month as her rent is £1300/month alone. She's not overcharging her DD at all

PP who say "I wouldn't charge my DD any rent or only £200" clearly have the luxury of not being single parent, and very different circumstances.

It won't help DD if her mum loses rental home as defaults on bills as DDs not even slightly covering her own extra costs.

Adults don't actually live for free ..

This.

My son of a similar age (works full time and earns well) pays a similar amount.

HoppingPavlova · 07/12/2021 04:52

Sounds quite steep. I don’t charge mine on the basis they earnestly save for a deposit (current plan is they all kick in together to purchase collectively as an investment and some may also move into it). If they were pissing it up against the wall I’d then be charging, and putting it away behind the scenes as enforced savingGrin.

If you are in a position where you are literally going to lose the roof over your head, then I can understand charging something to prevent this as that’s to their benefit as well, but I’d make it the minimum to avoid this happening.

ikeptgoing · 07/12/2021 04:43

If 24 year old DD is earning £21k or more, Her monthly take home will be £1250+ after pensions, tax etc. If she budgets £200 month for spending & phone and £50-100 for travel costs for work, paying mum £500/month rent, leaves DD still with £450-500 month to save towards deposit for house. That's pretty good when mum's (OP's) rental, bills, CT, food, etc will be in excess of £1850/ month as her rent is £1300/month alone. She's not overcharging her DD at all

PP who say "I wouldn't charge my DD any rent or only £200" clearly have the luxury of not being single parent, and very different circumstances.

It won't help DD if her mum loses rental home as defaults on bills as DDs not even slightly covering her own extra costs.

Adults don't actually live for free ..

ikeptgoing · 07/12/2021 04:30

Whoops first sentence ..
Not a recent school or uni leaver who hasn't got a job yet...

ikeptgoing · 07/12/2021 04:30

Goodness sake, people are missing out that 'rent' in this case is for a 24 year old adult DD who has chosen to stay home and is earning decent wage, not a recent

The £500 includes council tax and her food!! Food and CT bill be £250/month there (£42.50 food/week and £50 single council tax exemption that her mum lost as a result, not even half of it) and all her bills,.

So OP charging £500/ month means effectively DDs rent and all the other bills she contributes to are £250/ month ...!

Doesn't sound like a bad deal to DD at all. She'd pay far more in house share and in renting a bed sit and be colder and hungrier.
(I paid more than that in shared student lodging in Bristol a few years ago . My uni son living costs - rent and good- as undergrad are more than that and he doesn't have to pay council tax)

Adult DD is 24 she can chose to move out so that mum can get a lodger. That level of rent for a two bed, sounds like is nearer central Bristol and a nice property (not student digs) so lodging costs would be far higher and house shares would mean share of bills that would be far higher than £500/week and not include any food nor being cooked for!

vodkaredbullgirl · 07/12/2021 03:23

My daughter has enough money to move out, but chooses to stay at home. She has more money than me saved.

peboh · 07/12/2021 03:08

If you were to charge her £500 a month would that leave he enough money to save for her own place and enjoy a social life? That's a lot of money, and I think you need to consider if you're going to impact her ability to move into her own home.
I honestly don't agree with taking a big chunk of your child's money, and personally I think 10 or 20% of their wage is what I would take off my dd.

Redrosesandsunsets · 07/12/2021 03:03

She’s an adult. It’s fair to charge rent.

buddythemum · 07/12/2021 02:45

It obviously depends on personal circumstances really. I have every intention of making my kids work hard to keep up with money and rent etc but to then put aside to save up for a deposit on house if they earn it. I will do my best to teach them but ultimately have very strong limits to earn the help.

Redsquirrel5 · 07/12/2021 02:29

Wow I still think you should be contributing with that wage.

My DD was at uni in Bristol and her final student house was £370 a month plus bills. They stayed there for a while after uni but were priced out when they tried to move out of student accommodation and because DD wasn’t working full time because she was trying to get her career established. They moved further south and were paying £850 for a two bedroom house. Tiny kitchen rest was ok and it had a small garden.

I think it is fair for her to contribute but not to top up your pension. Sit down and explain why as there will be lots of hidden extras she won’t have thought of then discuss. What is fair. If she has a good wage then I think £500 inclusive is probably ok.

Swipe left for the next trending thread