Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD and charging rent?

233 replies

Nolongerachild · 06/12/2021 22:37

Long time poster, NC. Need some advice please, in case I am not being reasonable.
Single mum, no partner. DD living at home, and has finished her Masters, and started new job with a good salary.
I feel I should start charging her rent to include bills and food. Does £500 a month sound OK? My rent is £1300 a month, CT is £170 and who knows what energy bills will be this year but guessing around £100 a month. Then there’s water, internet and our food bill. She has to pay her mobile and her transport (no car). I just feel I need to put more into my pension, and I have literally nothing left at the end of every month. We’re in Bristol area, for my work, but it suits her very well for now. If she moved out I’d get a lodger. I’d really appreciate any advice particularly if someone else has had similar experiences. DD is 24. Thanks.

OP posts:
mewkins · 07/12/2021 12:45

@MorningStarling

£500 seems grossly excessive given that she's your daughter. I think it's wrong that you basically want your daughter to pay your pension fund for you. It would be more sensible to say she has to pay £500 into her pension each month, or maybe split 50/50 between her pension and a savings account to put towards a deposit on a property of her own. It's not right to squeeze money out of your own children, the parent should be giving money to their child, not the other way around.
So the OP is responsible for saving for her adult child and/or providing her with a pension while she lives in poverty in old age. This sounds like a great plan to me.
mewkins · 07/12/2021 12:41

@SpidersAreShitheads

I just looked - there are plenty of house shares in and around the centre of Bristol for around £500 per month. One example I looked at had a large, furnished bedroom, ensuite bathroom and a cleaner included in the cost, plus all bills.

For the sake of buying her own food, if I was your daughter I'd leave and get my own place. More or less the same price, but with all the freedom of not living with your mum.

I guess it depends though OP - are you actually hoping that she'll move out so you can get a lodger to top up your income? If that's the case, rather than charge your daughter a market value rent, you need to have an honest conversation. Tell her you're struggling to cover everything, and need more income - either she's willing to pay a market rate of £500 while she stays at home or else she starts making plans to move out so you can advertise for a lodger.

Of course your DD needs to contribute but £500 is way too much. I was your daughter once, my DM charged me close to market rent when I was earning less than £8k a year so I just moved out. As I say, what you charge depends on what you're hopng the outcome will be.

But this is the thing. Her daughter should be paying around that much to live anywhere. I'm sure op could either get a lodger of find a smaller place that she could afford if her daughter moved out.

Op, a 24 year old who is working needs to be paying for their own accommodation wherever that is. It's being an adult.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 07/12/2021 12:39

@MorningStarling

And maybe the parent hasn't been able to build their own pension fund because they have been spending the money, keeping a roof over their dcs head, feeding them, clothing them, helping fund their uni studies. Now as a fully grown adult, earning a fully grown wage the OP is expecting the DC to pay their own way. That isn't squeezing them for money.

When OP has to work until she is 70 so is then unable to provide child care I bet half of you spouting how awful OP is will be the first to say well if she doesn't provide childcare remind her that you won't help look after her when she needs some care

jackiebenimble · 07/12/2021 12:24

I think you are getting a hard
Time OP. Your reality is very different to someone of the same age with a
Mortgage almost paid off. And you have to live to your reality.

As a child i wouldn't want my parent to be missing out on their chance to have a home in retirement because of me living it up with zero responsibilities in my 20s. That just doesn't seem fair. She would likely still have a lot of disposable income after paying her way well under market value to you.

Talk to her.

This is always a polarising conversation. There are many similar threads.

x2boys · 07/12/2021 12:23

@MorningStarling

£500 seems grossly excessive given that she's your daughter. I think it's wrong that you basically want your daughter to pay your pension fund for you. It would be more sensible to say she has to pay £500 into her pension each month, or maybe split 50/50 between her pension and a savings account to put towards a deposit on a property of her own. It's not right to squeeze money out of your own children, the parent should be giving money to their child, not the other way around.
What part of the Op can't afford to do any of these things are you not understanding ? Outside of the nice fluffy middle class world of Mumsnet ,adults have to pay there way once they are earning Lots of parents cannot afford to financially support their adult working sin or daughter ,so the adult offspring can build a nice pension pot or savings I know this must be a suprise to some people but we don't all live nice cushy lives 🙄
thing47 · 07/12/2021 12:18

OP you sound lovely Flowers

My DD is similar age and at similar stage (post Masters, first job) and is currently living at home. I do agree with your point that they are well versed in paying rent/bills/living outside the house because she has being doing that for 5 years at 2 different universities, so she is perfectly well aware of the 'real world' as some posters have put it.

We don't charge her rent because I'm not a single parent and we are in the fortunate position of being mortgage-free so we don't need the money. If I was in your position and struggling to meet the bills, I absolutely would charge rent.

I don't know your part of the country well enough to offer an opinion as to the monthly amount, but obviously it is perfectly reasonable to have a discussion with your DD about it.

jackiebenimble · 07/12/2021 12:14

I think you are being very fair.

I think its fair to say to her you love
Living together but it needs to be based on more of an adult 'partnership' now then a parent and child relationship giving her age and her earnings and the cost of the rent and the home not being yours. Rather then pitch it as -i want to start charging you rent. Pitch it as id like to jointly review our finances and living costs and outgoings.

You shouldn't feel poor whilst someone who loves you and lives with you had an abundance.

It may test her maturity. But you are not being unfair. She may choose to move out but then yes you can get a lodger.

MorningStarling · 07/12/2021 12:11

£500 seems grossly excessive given that she's your daughter. I think it's wrong that you basically want your daughter to pay your pension fund for you. It would be more sensible to say she has to pay £500 into her pension each month, or maybe split 50/50 between her pension and a savings account to put towards a deposit on a property of her own. It's not right to squeeze money out of your own children, the parent should be giving money to their child, not the other way around.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 07/12/2021 12:10

She is a full time working adult of course she should be paying her costs. I would explain to her that you are struggling financially and you need to get a lodger who you would charge £X amount, but if she wants to stay then she needs to pay it instead.

Bubblecap · 07/12/2021 12:08

I think it’s fine to share the expense and that amount is fine. I’m one of the posters lucky enough to not be in financial difficulty but not blinkered so as to be judgemental about it. DS lives at home and pays 80 per month and is earning about 18k per annum. But we are mortgage free and have a double income. Really we don’t need a contribution at all but I think he needs to know life isn’t free. He also occasionally buys a take away He is also saving for a house deposit.

Bumblebee2930 · 07/12/2021 12:08

Sounds about right! She's still saving a considerable amount of people compared to moving out and getting her own place.

My db is a similar age and lives at home. I think my mom charges him around £100 a week and he buys his own food so YANBU. He also pays some of the bills though. I think in this case the rent, bills and food means my fb doesn't have a lot left as he isn't on a high salary.

Saying that, Dp was giving his mum £75 a week 15 years ago and he was never earning a high salary so I would say £125 a week is reasonable now if she's on a good salary.

I moved out at 18 and never moved back. I hadn't paid much rent beforehand because I was quite young! I think my mum would have fleeced me though 😅 it was much easier to move out then though. Incredibly harder now!

FlyingSoHigh · 07/12/2021 12:01

DD24, salary £23.5k, take home £1700, pays us £400 a month - includes food, bills, takeaways. She's happy. All working adults should contribute to the house they live in.

Comefromaway · 07/12/2021 11:23

@Hillarious

Shes getting an even better deal than if she went into a houseshare as living with mum presumably means a guarantee of living somewhere with a properly fully equipped kitchen, nice comfy surroundings, the opportunity to do all the telly hogging and slobbing you want, no mould or cold issues, presumably "naice" food and home cooked meals.

That's living at home - not a house-share - and what my DS is getting, living at home post-uni rent free. I'm happy to have him, though he does eat a lot of meat and that is a stark contrast to when my vegan DD was back home before moving to London. He gets the comfortable side of being at home, complete with a laundry service and he uses my car. We live in an expensive part of the country, but our outgoings are much lower than in previous years, with a smaller mortgage and just the one DS finishing his final year at uni, so we're the most comfortable financially that we've ever been since having the DC. For the oldest two, living back at home rent free has been an opportunity to save and set themselves up for the next stage of their lives, and I see it as a short-term arrangement. DD is now living in London and paying £750 in rent and bills, with travel and food on top of that. What DS isn't getting is the opportunity to have a house full of friends every weekend, up until the early hours, with take-away boxes and empty beer bottles eventually cleared away the next day. He gets to do that instead at his friend's flat, as he's moved out to rent!

Be aware it may not be a short term arrangement if you make life too comfortable.

Dh's older sister lived at home rent free until her mid 30's. She spent every penny she earned. Meanwhile his parents never gave dh a penny parental contribution (his grant was based on their income) when he did his degree.

Hillarious · 07/12/2021 11:19

Shes getting an even better deal than if she went into a houseshare as living with mum presumably means a guarantee of living somewhere with a properly fully equipped kitchen, nice comfy surroundings, the opportunity to do all the telly hogging and slobbing you want, no mould or cold issues, presumably "naice" food and home cooked meals.

That's living at home - not a house-share - and what my DS is getting, living at home post-uni rent free. I'm happy to have him, though he does eat a lot of meat and that is a stark contrast to when my vegan DD was back home before moving to London. He gets the comfortable side of being at home, complete with a laundry service and he uses my car. We live in an expensive part of the country, but our outgoings are much lower than in previous years, with a smaller mortgage and just the one DS finishing his final year at uni, so we're the most comfortable financially that we've ever been since having the DC. For the oldest two, living back at home rent free has been an opportunity to save and set themselves up for the next stage of their lives, and I see it as a short-term arrangement. DD is now living in London and paying £750 in rent and bills, with travel and food on top of that. What DS isn't getting is the opportunity to have a house full of friends every weekend, up until the early hours, with take-away boxes and empty beer bottles eventually cleared away the next day. He gets to do that instead at his friend's flat, as he's moved out to rent!

billy1966 · 07/12/2021 11:15

OP,

I think that sounds both reasonable and fair.

She is now working and needs to pay her way.

Of course you would prefer if you didn't have to ask but this is the real world and it can be tough, as you well know.

I think you need to be very frank with her and explain your intention to take a lodger in if she would prefer to get your own place.

Working till 70 is absolutely no laugh as a prospect.

You sound like a great mum.Flowers

fairynick · 07/12/2021 11:06

I’m 24 living back at home, on not much more than minimum wage, and this is what I pay to my DM.
Half of the rent (it’s housing association so only £400pm, meaning I only pay £200)
I buy all my own food apart from things like salt teabags etc.
If we run out of washing up liquid, shampoo etc I’ll always run to the shops.
I top up the gas and electric the odd tenner here and there.
£500 sounds a lot to me, but if it’s all inclusive and you have a much higher rent than my mum, then it sounds about right.

LindaEllen · 07/12/2021 10:52

@Snoozer11

£500 sounds like almost market rate. I wouldn't charge my child that much.
She's said her rent costs £1300. Therefore her DD isn't even paying half. AND her £500 would include bills.

It's a great deal for her.

Sorry but why should one adult (OP) struggle to give another adult a cushy living when she's earning a decent wage?

Comefromaway · 07/12/2021 10:46

@julieca

So many commenting on here criticising the OP are obviously pretty financially secure. I doubt they will be paying rent on their house when their child is 24 years old.
Exactly.

We are financially secure but our situation is that dd is doing a 2 year masters and although she can take out a loan to cover just under half of the fees and she has a job which pays her living expenses, we are making sacrifices to pay her rent and loan her the rest of the fees.

So when she graduates we will absolutely no longer be able to support her and dh will need to start paying more into his pension.

julieca · 07/12/2021 10:40

So many commenting on here criticising the OP are obviously pretty financially secure. I doubt they will be paying rent on their house when their child is 24 years old.

cushioncovers · 07/12/2021 10:40

Julie. Thanks I'd forgotten the op said that.

Comefromaway · 07/12/2021 10:39

She would not be better off in a house-share. Dd is in a house-share and pays way more than the OP is suggesting.

Comefromaway · 07/12/2021 10:38

@Hapoydayz

Blimey just because you haven't put enough in your pension you are going to stop your daughter doing the same. She'd be better moving out to a house share and getting some freedom
Many, many, many parents forgo putting money into their pensions whilst their children are young so that they can afford to give them opportunities/support them through university.

It has to stop sometime.

Tee20x · 07/12/2021 10:37

@RockinHorseShit I live in London. I guess it just depends on the child. It's nice that you are thinking of putting the money you will be getting from your DD into a savings account to give back to her.

When I was living at home (rent free) I was putting away 60% of my salary into an ISA to save for a deposit. As were most of my friends. Because we were living rent free we were able to save greater amounts and see our savings grow and we weren't the type to be reckless with our money and still understood the value of money, and having to budget etc etc.

Comefromaway · 07/12/2021 10:35

Dd paid £130 per week which equated to £563 per month in a North Western city a couple of years ago, That included all bills, breakfast and evening meal. She now pays £550 per month for one room in a shared house in London plus bills of approx £80-100 per month and food.

DS was originally thinking about taking a year out after A levels and I told him that was fine but he would have to contribute to the household. I was thinking in the region of £50 per week assuming he would have been on a low wage for an 18 year old.

If dd decided to return home after her Masters she would definitely have to pay keep. An extra adult would make no difference to council tax for us so I would probably charge in the region of £350

julieca · 07/12/2021 10:32

@cushioncovers the OP has said if her DD was not living there she would take in a lodger.