Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD and charging rent?

233 replies

Nolongerachild · 06/12/2021 22:37

Long time poster, NC. Need some advice please, in case I am not being reasonable.
Single mum, no partner. DD living at home, and has finished her Masters, and started new job with a good salary.
I feel I should start charging her rent to include bills and food. Does £500 a month sound OK? My rent is £1300 a month, CT is £170 and who knows what energy bills will be this year but guessing around £100 a month. Then there’s water, internet and our food bill. She has to pay her mobile and her transport (no car). I just feel I need to put more into my pension, and I have literally nothing left at the end of every month. We’re in Bristol area, for my work, but it suits her very well for now. If she moved out I’d get a lodger. I’d really appreciate any advice particularly if someone else has had similar experiences. DD is 24. Thanks.

OP posts:
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 13/12/2021 18:01

My view is not as bizarre as @HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend thinking it’s wrong to make your ADULT child pay anything towards their keep no matter what?

Firstly I didn’t say it was wrong either, I simply said it’s not something I personally wouldn’t do!

It’s not bizarre Hmm to have different morals/values in life.

I grew up in multiple foster care homes with absolutely no stability and at 16 I was left to fend for myself.

I am not a martyr Hmm in ensuring I provide that security for my children, my children learn key skills by earning their own incomes at the age of 12 and 15, be that in their paid jobs or there household chores/family members chores etc.... they learn to budget and save for things they want and if they don’t do their chores their chore money gets reduced/taken away completely.

They save half their incomes from their paid jobs, because we teach them the value of hard work and responsibility etc...

They also need to keep good behaviour and grades at school/home to be allowed to do their privileged activities, if they don’t those those privileges removed.

All of the above will help aid them when they go into full time employment and move to their own home, at the moment what we do is age appropriate for them currently.

For me your also not teaching your children those key skills simply because they hand their board money at the end of the week/month, you need to actively involve and teach them to be financially independent.

Just because someone doesn’t pay rent does not mean they don’t learn key life and financial skills, again personally I don’t believe board money should come into it, however that my personal opinion and I don’t believe it’s wrong for someone to do this, personally it’s something me and my his and would personally never do.

At 16 - I moved to another country alone, had a full time job, in full time education, plus my own home paying full bills with no support behind me, except from my now husband who was also 17 at the time, my childhood wasn’t traditional and my own children will never have to experience even a quarter of what I had to.

Mommabear20 · 13/12/2021 16:18

I paid £650 at 18 as that was the average for rent and bills in our area at the time. If she's got a good salary, why should you subsidies her?

tallduckandhandsome · 13/12/2021 16:17

@MorningStarling

£500 seems grossly excessive given that she's your daughter. I think it's wrong that you basically want your daughter to pay your pension fund for you. It would be more sensible to say she has to pay £500 into her pension each month, or maybe split 50/50 between her pension and a savings account to put towards a deposit on a property of her own. It's not right to squeeze money out of your own children, the parent should be giving money to their child, not the other way around.
Jesus Christ again.
tallduckandhandsome · 13/12/2021 16:16

@CatsArePeople

So you want your DD to pay your pension contributions?
Jesus Christ.
housemaus · 13/12/2021 16:07

YANBU. £500 presumably includes food and bills too? She's getting an absolute bargain there.

These threads drive me mad.

If you can afford to support other adults in your household, that's great. Good for you.

But most people can reasonably expect (or would have reasonably expected, 24 years ago when OP had her daughter) that their adult children would have long flown the nest by 24.

Parents can't be morally expected to financially support their children their entire life, and 24 is plenty old enough to get herself in a house share if she doesn't want to pay what will amount (with £130 for her half of the council tax and bills, and say £100 for food) to £270 a month rent.

It's not terrible parenting not to be able to factor supporting a whole other adult in your life when said adult is earning a wage.

vodkaredbullgirl · 13/12/2021 15:35

ffs,

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 15:14

So you want your DD to pay your pension contributions?

thing47 · 13/12/2021 15:13

This is why we have so many selfish, supposedly clever, but totally unprepared for the world graduates crippled with anxiety because they’re unable to cope with real life.

This would be a totally valid point if a child had never left home, Pink, then I would 100% be in agreement with you.

But I am assuming here that graduates have learnt how to pay rent, bills, cover their food, travel etc while at university, in which case they have had 3-4 years of coping with real life. I didn't get involved in any of that while they weren't living at home. I'm just not convinced that a short period living back in the family home is going to set them back that much.

Moonface123 · 13/12/2021 14:12

This post just proves how inept most people are at understanding a situation different to their own, how bloody helpful is it for the OP to be told by the smug ones " We dont charge rent, or we take x amount and keep it in savings for them for later ? "

I personally don't know of any single parents in real life who are in a position to do this.
OP l would have posted this specifically in lone parents section to avoid some of the totally irelevant and pointless replies.

julieca · 13/12/2021 13:44

Sad to see those with money berating those without money for having to make different choices to them.

hettie · 13/12/2021 13:41

£500 would be a room in a house share in Bristol (and in not the nicest most convenient area either). She'd then have to pay bills etc.. So it's a pretty good deal. Tbh I don't understand why you would encourage your adult children to live with you by giving them a rent free bonus ball (even if you can afford it). I get people like having their kids around, but you are keeping them in a perpetual adult child dynamic if you don't encourage them to leave. The shitty hard choices of adulthood (what do I spend my very limited wage in, nicer accomodation or going out, holidays or decent food etc, should I get extra qualifications/retrain...) are tough. But the learning through making those choices is so important. They need to transition to adulthood is important and our job is to enable them to make those tough chpices not to enable them avoiding them....

witsendeverytime · 13/12/2021 13:26

If my kid were to be still living at home I wouldn't charge rent but I'd expect them to be saving the equivalent for when they do it to buy a car or whatever. I'd expect them to contribute to food costs.

PinkSyCo · 13/12/2021 13:00

My view is not as bizarre as @HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend thinking it’s wrong to make your ADULT child pay anything towards their keep no matter what? This is why we have so many selfish, supposedly clever, but totally unprepared for the world graduates crippled with anxiety because they’re unable to cope with real life.

thing47 · 13/12/2021 11:20

@PinkSyCo

personally I’d never charge my children rent to live at home.*

You plan on infantilising your offspring forever? How sad.

What a bizarre view of a parent-child relationship. I'm not infantilising my adult children because they have both lived at home for periods post-university. I actually like having them live with me. I'm mortgage-free so I don't need to charge them rent, though they do buy their own food, run their own cars etc.

OP does need the money so she is perfectly reasonable to ask for rent.

tallduckandhandsome · 13/12/2021 07:36

How did the talk go, OP?

FlipFlops4Me · 13/12/2021 07:12

My parents always charged me one third of my net. That included absolutely everything - food, hot water, mum's home cooking, heating, a comfortable private room and use of every facility in the house. I thought that was more than reasonable, and when I left home I wasn't too horrified by the bills I had to pay because I was used to paying out.

mogschristmascalamity · 13/12/2021 07:06

I paid 25% of my wages to my parents for board & keep 30 years ago.

I would definitely ask your daughter to contribute. Best to have a discussion to see what she says.

Sandinmyknickers · 13/12/2021 06:33

I also would not want my mums pension to be suffering so I could live rent free. Also ultimately, if my mum ends up broke in her retirement, I would see that as my problem too

Sandinmyknickers · 13/12/2021 06:31

I was your DD and lived at home for a bit after graduating. As soon as I had a job, I brought the conversation up with my mum as to how much I would pay and we sat down and worked it out. I can't imagine just expecting my mum to house her adult daughter for free whilst I sit there and eat her food and generally have all the perks of living at home (which is very different to a housewares or flatmate). Im surprised it hadn't come up already!! Have the talk, and I'm sure as two adults (who also care about each other), I'm sure you will work out an appropriate amount between you.

PinkSyCo · 13/12/2021 03:07

OP £800 is more than I and many other people have left to play with/save at the end of every month. Don’t listen to the privileged posters on here who are happy to keep their equally privileged kids reliant on them for ever.

PinkSyCo · 13/12/2021 03:03

personally I’d never charge my children rent to live at home.*

You plan on infantilising your offspring forever? How sad.

CallMeNutribullet · 07/12/2021 22:52

Plenty of privileged people getting up in arms about you asking an adult with a good job to start paying their way. Actually is IS something to do with ops DD if having a 24 year old living at home and not paying her way means op is struggling to pay into her pension. If she wasn't living there op could take in a lodger and get much more.
Of course if she thinks she can find a cheaper house share ops DD is free to do that

Enough4me · 07/12/2021 22:40

Hi OP, please let us know how the discussion went.

Midlifemusings · 07/12/2021 22:23

I lived back at home for a couple years around OPs DD's age and I definitely paid my expenses. I was an adult, saw myself as an adult, and wanted to have adult responsibilities. I would never have wanted to burden them and expect them to finance my adult life. I liked the independence too, I wasn't a child and didn't need to be looked after like a dependent child. I can't imagine working full time in a good job and not contributing to the any of your expenses and just expecting others to pay your way. I would have been embarrassed to mooch off others as an adult.

x2boys · 07/12/2021 20:46

@Daffodil123456

At 24 I had my own place
I had my own place at 24 too but that was 24 years ago when rent was much cheaper and I lived in greater Manchester and still live there in fact I now live in a council house and my rent for a two bed is even cheaper But I don't live in Bristol with a parent ,I still think £500 all in is cheap particularly if I had no other outgoings .