Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see the point of this Xmas present system?

91 replies

iDontKnow83 · 06/12/2021 22:21

MIL texts her 8 adult children (and their partners) with a list of exactly what they should buy for each sibling. Eg, we've been told we need to buy SIL1 a lilac cashmere scarf, SIL2 some Chanel perfume, BIL1 a Nike Hoody and BIL2 a set of ear pods.

We've been asked what we would like and we suggested some general ideas like candles, sports stuff or booze but she replied asking for a specific link to the item we wanted.

It all feels so prescriptive and I just think it's pointless! No creativity in buying gifts, so materialistic! I feel saying let's just buy ourselves what we want and not bother with the gifting!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blackmagicqueen · 08/12/2021 08:31

my*

Blackmagicqueen · 08/12/2021 08:30

@JKDinomum thats nuts! She sounds like me estranged FIL who was an utter control freak and loved to make decisions like that for others as well!

JKDinomum · 08/12/2021 08:04

We used to do this kind of madness with my brother and sister in law. We'd send them a list of dvds and CDs we wanted and they'd send us the same. Eventually we figured it was better to buy our own.

For some things, having a specific link to a particular thing is useful and saves people getting something which is similar but not actually the thing they want. But a bit of a surprise is nice. When my mum asks what I want I try to give a vague answer like "warm gloves" and let her choose the design/brand etc.

I think the issue here is the controlling and the MIL telling everyone what to do. My ex-SIL used to do this. She decided that we should spend x amount on her son, and sent us lists of stuff to choose from. Any presents not from the list were frowned upon. And they would spend the same amount on my three kids (in total, so my kids got a third of the value of presents than her son!!!) I didn't really care about the money as my kids got plenty from us and grandparents but I did object to her deciding what we should do.

Present buying is optional and how much you spend and what you buy should be up to the buyer. These days we give my nephew a gift voucher and my useless brother gives my kids nothing. They don't seem to have noticed and get plenty at Xmas so I don't care.

mnp321 · 08/12/2021 07:56

I love giving presents but I find buying for adults really hard. I'd rather have prescriptive guidance than waste money on presents they won't use.

Fortuitously we only buy for our parents and just the kids for siblings. I'm also happy to get a website link for the kids' presents I buy. Not because I'm lazy and not willing to put in the time, but I'd rather give presents that I know will be enjoyed and aren't duplicates.

Tayegete · 08/12/2021 07:52

We used to do secret Santa for the adults in my family but it got a bit ridiculous as we all swapped ideas and often just exchanged vouchers. DBs are in their 50s and just don’t need anything. We’ve scrapped buying gifts two years ago which sil thinks is very bah humbug. The point of Xmas is spending time together though.

MsWalterMitty · 08/12/2021 07:30

Personally I prefer to receive something I actually want!…. Is a right pain having to take stuff back to the shops when you don’t live near any. Or it cluttering up your house until you eventually charity shop it.

GADDay · 08/12/2021 07:24

@HeddaGarbled

Gift giving should involve personal thought - or just don't bother

Just because you say it, doesn’t make it true.

Why else give a gift? It is not compulsory (unless you are OPs MIL).

This bizarre enforced swapping of often unwanted tat or vouchers (the gift that says I can't be arsed to make an effort), is IMO just silly. If you don't care enough about somebody to choose a gift then why give them anything at all?

Rainartist · 07/12/2021 20:21

I wouldn't be buying anything that my mil told me to get for her children. Who does she think she is Shock

HeddaGarbled · 07/12/2021 20:12

Gift giving should involve personal thought - or just don't bother

Just because you say it, doesn’t make it true.

iDontKnow83 · 07/12/2021 18:36

@GADDay

Gift giving should involve personal thought - or just don't bother.
Exactly! I love finding gifts for loved ones when I get to choose and find something they'd love that is a real surprise. This just kills all that.
OP posts:
iDontKnow83 · 07/12/2021 18:34

@LampLighter414

To be clear do you have to buy all the presents on the list, or amongst the group of siblings and partners, the presents need to be bought? i.e. you buy for just the one Brother and then perhaps the Sister buys for your DH?

If all... wow that adds up!

You have to buy a gift for everyone. MIL doesn't include her own name on the list, but a gift is expected.
OP posts:
gogohm · 07/12/2021 17:01

@ClintBartonsWife

My ex's family were £20 notes in the cards all around!

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 07/12/2021 16:43

I would refuse to partake in this, it's a cynical exercise which has no meaning at all. I would rather stay and home.

LampLighter414 · 07/12/2021 16:02

To be clear do you have to buy all the presents on the list, or amongst the group of siblings and partners, the presents need to be bought? i.e. you buy for just the one Brother and then perhaps the Sister buys for your DH?

If all... wow that adds up!

GADDay · 07/12/2021 15:58

Gift giving should involve personal thought - or just don't bother.

CSJobseeker · 07/12/2021 15:55

@phishy

You said people were embarrassed to say they only got one present. I said I had never been asked how many presents I received.

Yes, but that would happen if someone asked you what you received for Christmas, and you answer 'perfume'. Not necessarily that someone asks you 'how many presents did you receive?', which would be crass.

Exactly. I don't think anyone has ever asked me how many presents I received in my entire life.
CSJobseeker · 07/12/2021 15:54

Utterly pointless. Tbh, I'd opt out of the whole thing.

Just10moreminutesplease · 07/12/2021 15:52

“Thanks for the suggestions MIL, but we’ve already sorted our presents for everyone.”

Blackmagicqueen · 07/12/2021 15:49

@allIvalueloyaltyaboveallelse that's really nice of your family. Despite saying just a card fine mine would be a bit put out if i got them nothing esp dm. It is abit of a hassle as i have enough to get for the dc as it is and could do without adults!

HollaHolla · 07/12/2021 14:14

@trumpisagit

SIL said "shall we not bother with presents for adults". Everyone happily "yes". MIL horrified so she is doing presents and we will buy her a present. Other adults not.
This happened when we were kids, in that my Grandad gave to us, but not my Mum, for example. It changed again as we got older, though. Now, for Xmas, there is my parents, my Aunt, my DSis & BiL, my DBro, SiL & their two kids, and me. Where there are kids in a family, we only get a tiny thing for the adults, but for the rest of us, it would mean no gifts. Which isn't the point of Xmas, I know, but, it would be kind of miserable....

So, I know my DSis is getting me a jumper (in blue or green, preferably), but not which one, and that my DBro has asked for some running shorts, so I will check with my SiL on which type he likes. I have bought a heated throw for my DDad, as he keeps complaining about the cold - I'm hoping he'll find it as genius as I do!! It's about giving some guidance, but not being prescriptive.

HollaHolla · 07/12/2021 13:59

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo

MIL would have liked us to do this, instead we have wish lists on Amazon, you can add links to stuff outside of Amazon too. One for me, one for DH and one for DD. We put loads of stuff on there throughout the year and at birthdays/Xmas she just picks something within budget. It's still a bit of a surprise but we all know it's something we'll like.
Yep. We do something similar. So, it means that there are always some ideas - but we also buy other items too!
simpledeer · 07/12/2021 13:56

It sounds like MIL takes her position of matriarch very seriously.

I imagine everyone will be mightily relieved if you suggest Secret Santa done electronically from now on. Such a huge expense otherwise!

IARTNS · 07/12/2021 13:31

*This is exactly why we stopped doing presents for adults in our family.

The options are stressing about ideas, wasting money on something people don't want, receiving 'stuff' we didn't want or telling people what to buy. Both pointless.*

I'd be quite happy if we stopped, I think I may suggest Secret Santa for next year if people are insistent on exchanging gifts.

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/12/2021 12:10

@Luckingfovely

Ii seems like I am the sole person on Mumsnet who loves buying presents! Grin

Across an extended family of three generations, who will all be together to open presents on Christmas Day, and all spend time choosing thoughtful gifts that each person will love.

I look forward to both buying and the opening all year! The odd mad present slips through but generally everyone is delighted. No one in the family would buy rubbish or tat, and if no idea, would ask for a hint on what to get.

There is a fair understanding of price range to buy for each generation. Often joint presents if someone wants something notably more expensive.

I get that some individuals or families can turn present giving into a competitive sport or into a waste of money...

...but there are also families (I can't be in the only one) who embrace it, put thought into it, are sensible and fair about it, and absolutely love everything about it for the joy it brings.

I suspect it's probably pretty unusual for every single person in an extended family group to enjoy everything about the gift process and all be as skilled at it as you describe here, yeah. And I imagine most of us know someone who isn't as good at choosing presents as they think they are.
trumpisagit · 07/12/2021 12:06

SIL said "shall we not bother with presents for adults". Everyone happily "yes".
MIL horrified so she is doing presents and we will buy her a present. Other adults not.