Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To doubt parents who say baby crying for one minute is cruel

130 replies

LoathlyLady · 06/12/2021 20:41

Just read a few posts about sleep and frankly don’t believe some of the responses. People saying that leaving a 12 month old to cry for very short periods (1-5 mins) is cruel and they could never do it.. really??

Ofcourse I find it horrible to listen to my 1yo son get upset but there are times when I simply can’t go to him immediately (car seat!) and recently we’ve found that letting him cry for 3 mins or so at bedtime rather than feeding to sleep seems to help with his overall sleep and mood. Are these people really saying that they never let their baby cry for more than a few seconds? Or is this just bullshit to make other mums feel terrible?

OP posts:
FoxIvy · 06/12/2021 20:49

@Skysblue

I’m not trying to make other mums feel bad, but I’ve never left my child to cry. If they cry I go to them asap.
So you've never done a long motorway journey with them? And do you only have one child? I've let my baby cry when my toddler was also crying...
Echobelly · 06/12/2021 20:48

I was always a heartless cow about this when it happened Wink, though I was lucky mine weren't big criers. I had to do it when DD was tiny to get her to settle in a cot after waking in the night, as we were both a bit worried about her being in bed with us (she'd go down for the night in cot, but only seemed to settle again on DH's chest!); it really wasn't that bad, she got it after short bouts of crying for two nights.

Some people do have different tolerances. Some people are frankly martyrs but see not allowing any crying at all as being a good parent.

Skysblue · 06/12/2021 20:46

I’m not trying to make other mums feel bad, but I’ve never left my child to cry. If they cry I go to them asap.

BabyRace · 06/12/2021 20:45

I don't think the intention is to make other mums feel bad, but rather to make themselves feel better. My baby doesn't cry for long so I must be doing a good job sort of thing. You find what works for your babybut frankly anyone that could stop DD crying in under a minute when she was newborn would be a bloody miracle worker

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 20:43

Everyone has different tolerance levels. I find it awful if I can’t pick up my 16m old when he cries in the car, but there’s not much I can do about it. It does make me feel like I want to peel my skin off though, so if he cries at home I have to pick him up! Everyone is able to withstand different things and it’s also to do with how your able to frame it. I’m sure at 12m a couple of minutes isn’t going to kill him, especially if he sleeps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread