Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that potential Christmas guest should just make their bloody mind up! This is actually rude, right?

90 replies

MincePieBreakfast · 06/12/2021 13:47

Hi,

So I'm hosting Christmas this year and invited everyone we wanted to come a couple of months ago now. Everyone gladly accepted, apart from my cousin who I'm very close to, but who is still undecided. She just can't make their mind up whether they want to spend Christmas with us or just with dp and dc. I wouldn't be offended at all if it was the latter and in the beginning, I was happy for them to take a little time to decide, but now we're into December and needing to order food/drink territory, I kind of need to know!

I actually think it's getting quite rude now. I have made it clear we won't be offended if they decide to stay at home, but I asked again last night and I got "oh, we still don't know yet" and I did for the first time say "okay, but we really do need to know soon for the shopping and bedding etc" and she said "oh don't worry, if we do come we'll just slot in" 🙄The bizarre thing is, she's a really good host herself and knows how it works. Knows that realistically, people don't just "slot in".

Is this getting rude or should I really just chill out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bookworm20 · 07/12/2021 10:36

Yes it is a bit rude not to know for sure by now. As for slotting in, it depends how many you've invited. I mean if you've a house full of about 30, then 3 would likely just slot in. But if you've only got anothe 4 then absolutely can't just slot in!

I'd probably go with something like, 'I'm thinking of ordering these gorgeous individual starters I've seen, need to order them this week though so I really need to know if you are coming so I order enough. And they are pretty expensive so at same time don't want to order one for you all if you are not going to come.

thedefinitionofmadness · 07/12/2021 09:19

@neverbeenskiing

Those telling OP to "just buy a bit extra" in case her cousin decides to make an appearance, why should she have to though? It's thoughtless and rude to neither accept or decline an invitation but expect to be catered for (along with your family) just in case you do feel like showing up at the last minute. Enough extra food to feed another family of three is actually a fairly substantial amount of food, especially if they could be there over a couple of days. Even if OP isn't worried about the cost, what about the waste if they don't turn up? Quite enough food is wasted over the Christmas period in most households as it is!
They only need a few more roast spuds and a loaf for the freezer though? Extra packet of crackers. Indecisive cousin can bring some extra bits. Most people, as you say overcater anyway, and if host family you know eat food all year round, it doesn't need to be wasteful.

It's rude (ish), but it is the kind of rude that only happens in families where people love each other and can put up with it.

lightisnotwhite · 06/12/2021 18:16

“ Hi Cousin, actually I need to know numbers by Weds otherwise it won’t work - there’s so much to organise when you’re hosting as you know”

neverbeenskiing · 06/12/2021 17:25

Those telling OP to "just buy a bit extra" in case her cousin decides to make an appearance, why should she have to though? It's thoughtless and rude to neither accept or decline an invitation but expect to be catered for (along with your family) just in case you do feel like showing up at the last minute. Enough extra food to feed another family of three is actually a fairly substantial amount of food, especially if they could be there over a couple of days. Even if OP isn't worried about the cost, what about the waste if they don't turn up? Quite enough food is wasted over the Christmas period in most households as it is!

WonderfulYou · 06/12/2021 17:12

I agree with PPs you need to give a deadline.

You can do it in a kind way like - just to let you know I’m doing an online shop on Friday so let me know if you decide to come by then so I can make sure I don’t order more than needed.

Hesma · 06/12/2021 17:00

Just rescind the invite

5thnonblonde · 06/12/2021 16:56

I’d go the other way

‘Couldn’t remember if you’re coming or not and I think I’ve promised your bed/chairs to DH’s cousins- eep! You had other plans though didn’t you tho’

MrsLarry · 06/12/2021 16:55

Definitely not unreasonable. I had this with a family member. Total narcissist unfortunately and was clearly keeping her options open.....right up until Christmas eve. I never invited them again.

PuppyMonkey · 06/12/2021 16:54

"Oy, Very Close Cousin. Stop being a rude twat and give me a definite answer today so I can plan the food and get things sorted, 'slotting in' isn't going to happen. Lotsa love, MPB xx

NumaNumaYay · 06/12/2021 16:52

@NellieEllie

I think I’d do a “Oh, I know I’m a pain but I’m far too much of an organising freak to cope with last minute ‘“slotting in” - Can you let me know by……. I’ll hang on til then with the shopping but I daren’t leave it any later. So if I don’t hear, I’ll assume you’ll stay at home. We’d love to see you but quite understand if you don’t come..”
Nope. There is nothing 'freakish' about needing to know who is coming for Christmas!

"Hi, would love to see you at Christmas but absolutely fine too if you want to stay home. If you are coming, please can you let me know by tomorrow lunchtime? Thanks! xx"

greenpolkadot55 · 06/12/2021 16:48

Id make her mind up for her,
Tell her that you assume she wont be coming so youll see her after christmas.
And if she does turn up,,dont bend over backwards to accomodate her,,,

eg..she sleeps on the sofa as all beds are taken..

cheeky mare

thedefinitionofmadness · 06/12/2021 16:44

Only 3 of them? Of course you can slot them in, buy extra spuds and cream just in case, because you can never have too much. And they can bring their own bedding.

But I would be "Babes just give us the percentage likelihood of you coming because I have hospitality control issues. "

It might be that she's getting inlaw pressure or toying with a flight to Lanzarote. Chill. Your day won't be ruined either way.

Ourlady · 06/12/2021 16:40

So rude, you can't just slot 3 people in for Christmas day dinner like that. I would definitely give her a deadline and soon

FetchezLaVache · 06/12/2021 16:38

I have a cousin to whom I am extremely close and in this situation, I would say "Look, knobhead, I can't just slot you all in last minute, I need to know how much food to order and like shite am I going to buy a new duvet and bedding just on the off-chance you grace us with your presence, so you need to let me know by tomorrow or the whole deal's off!" Would something like that work?

thedefinitionofmadness · 06/12/2021 16:38

Assume they are coming and have a little too much of everything if they don't?

I'd go with the flow. Its a family xmas dinner not a formal wedding reception

TheCanyon · 06/12/2021 16:28

Could be worse, several times my parents have phoned Christmas morning and said they're just popping through, it's a near 3 hour journey so of course they're not just popping through.

Benjispruce5 · 06/12/2021 16:26

Just rude. Tell her you need to know by Friday at the latest.

NellieEllie · 06/12/2021 16:22

I think I’d do a “Oh, I know I’m a pain but I’m far too much of an organising freak to cope with last minute ‘“slotting in” - Can you let me know by……. I’ll hang on til then with the shopping but I daren’t leave it any later. So if I don’t hear, I’ll assume you’ll stay at home. We’d love to see you but quite understand if you don’t come..”

stalkersaga · 06/12/2021 16:20

Truthbomb: at this stage no answer is an answer and she isn't coming. If she wanted to come she would have confirmed long ago.

I'd skip the "let me know by Thursday" stage and just say "looks like you coming for Christmas isn't going to work out this year, hope you have a lovely time at home and see you in the NY".

GloriaSicTransitMundi · 06/12/2021 16:17

@MincePieBreakfast

"Sounds like she is holding off incase she gets a better offer..."

@Santahatesbraisedcabbage Shock It can't be that! We're an absolute hoot!! Wink

Seriously though, I genuinely don't think so. I'd be shocked if she went anywhere else.

If we weren't so close, I'd probably be okay with the whole deadline idea, but it just feels so abrupt, even though it's perfectly reasonable!

I

With all the news about lack of delivery drivers and empty shelves, and the recent petrol crisis, it is perfectly reasonable to require a response to your kind invitation within a deadline - end of this week latest, I should think.
fabricfanatic · 06/12/2021 16:13

if you're too close to set a deadline (I get that it depends on the relationship), I'd tell her that you'll be making your orders on X date, so if she hasn't given you a final answer by then, you might be asking her to bring some things to pad out the meals/sheets, since you want to be sure everyone has enough/is comfortable. That's reasonable! And maybe it will be the kick up the arse she needs to make up her mind!!

The worst that happens is she thinks, "Gosh, didn't realise she was so uptight! Better give her an answer." Not everyone likes to wing it, and if you're as close as you say, she probably knows you're a planner and like to be prepared.

Findingthelight1 · 06/12/2021 16:04

If she's usually a really good host herself then I'm inclined to cut her some slack and wonder if there's something else going on. Significant Covid anxiety, or health issues, or a potential pregnancy announcement, or something similar that is making her dither out of character?

I'm very relaxed about Christmas so if it were me (and presuming I had a house big enough to host, and enough chairs etc) I genuinely wouldn't care. I'd order a big enough turkey to include the additional 3 and work on the theory that veg, desserts, etc aren't such an exact science anyway. They can bring their own wine if they turn up..!

noscoobydoodle · 06/12/2021 15:55

My SiL is still undecided. She is undecided every year- most years she finally decides to stay at home but one year she did actually turn up at ours. I count her and her husband as one extra portion for food. We usually have enough left over to feed at least 2 (probably more). We make clear there's no space for them to stay over at ours as those with definite plans get the beds/sofas/mattresses! The first couple of years totally stressed me out but a good 10+ years later it doesn't even register! If you are cooking something that doesn't lend itself to extras, just say if they haven't confirmed when you order then they are welcome to come before/after dinner (or a set time) for a mince pie and coffee or whatever.

Chocolatewheatos · 06/12/2021 15:55

I tell people when I invite them the deadline and if I don't hear back they're not coming. I ordered my meat and veg weeks ago, no way would I have waited until now to do it. They've right taken the piss. Just tell them you've had to order and couldn't afford to buy stuff that wouldn't get used so you'll catch up with them some other time. Probably waiting to see if they get a better offer.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 06/12/2021 15:54

This is very rude! I have one guest dithering but it's just the one and he won't 'stay overnight so he can literally just 'slot in'. But 3+ and overnight is very different.