Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 20:47

@Warmduscher yes dear

Saskatcha · 06/12/2021 20:45

Definitely not. It’s one of the things that really worried me about the Uk leaving the EU that it could potentially be brought back. I recently watched ‘The Penalty’ on Netflix. Really harrowing.

Echobelly · 06/12/2021 20:43

Nope, it won't stop anything.

I think the worst crimes tend to happen either in a red mist, where the perpetrator likely regrets it for the rest of their lives and if they didn't have time to stop and think they were about to kill someone, I doubt they'd have time to stop and think about the death penalty; or else they happen because the person is psychopathic, in which case they don't care. So death penalty would not stop anyone committing these crimes - doesn't seemed to have worked in US.

Fidgetty · 06/12/2021 20:39

My penfriend has been on Death Row in Nevada for 34 years. He has had medical treatment withheld, delayed and botched. He now has a limp and several of his teeth have fallen out. Is that really what you’d want to happen to prisoners? (I have a horrible feeling you’ll say yes).

What is your "pen friend" convicted of? If it's death row it's safe to assume he did something heinous to another person? In which case he deserves everything he gets IMO.

TheVolturi · 06/12/2021 20:34

I think paedophiles that rape and abuse children should be killed yes, because they can't be rehabilitated and will always be at risk of doing it again.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 06/12/2021 20:33
  • despair
Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 06/12/2021 20:32

I think for me it would be about securing the ultimate justice for the person they committed the crime against. I have always been against the death penalty because it doesn’t seem like it should have any place in civilised society. However I am so appalled and horrified at what Tustin and Hughes did to that poor little boy that I am reconsidering my view and I think if it can be proven without a shred of doubt that someone is guilty of such a crime then frankly they don’t deserve to walk this earth.

Our justice system is such that many murderers do get to experience freedom again - even when they have been jailed for life you can never guarantee they won’t get out at some point in future on appeal. There was a case recently where a man who murdered two young girls was released on parole. I can’t remember his name but it was all over the news. He then started prowling young girls in the street. He should never have been released back into society.

It’s also the cost of keeping these people locked up, fed (ironic given their treatment of Arthur) and ultimately kept alive. They are a waste of good oxygen.

I will never ever forget the look of sadness and disparity on that little boys face on the video still (I’ve chosen not to watch the actual video) and have cried so many tears for him. I feel so utterly heartbroken 💔 😔

RIP Arthur 💙

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/12/2021 20:31

Nah. It's inevitable that there would be mistakes, whatever foolproof conditions you think you could put on it. The state simply shouldn't be trusted with that kind of power, and that would be true even if we weren't governed by incompetents and there weren't serious structural problems in the police. And it isn't a deterrent.

OhGiveUp · 06/12/2021 20:27

No. I don't want to drag myself down to the level of the killer.

MynameisWa · 06/12/2021 20:26

Can you imagine the law suits stretched out, the media storm and activism leading up to each case? Human rights lawyers would go into a feeding frenzy.

I don’t think it would deter crime. Many murders like Tustin are so out of touch they think they can get away with it completely. There’s not much rational thought involved. They are usually deluded into thinking they are justified, exonerated in some way or too clever to get caught.

In my mind there is simply no good reasons for the death penalty.

Perhaps it sends a clear message loudly but to say ‘it’s wrong to kill’ and then kill on command of the state is just ridiculous.

In no way should the death penalty be reintroduced.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 20:23

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher I'm not going to explain the difference again, you clearly just want an argument. [/quote]
Who’s arguing? I think you’d struggle to explain the difference between saying you would like something awful to happen to someone and wishing it would.

Frankola · 06/12/2021 20:20

Absolutely not.

Too many innocent people have been put to death and it isn't a proven deterrent anyway

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 20:14

@Warmduscher I'm not going to explain the difference again, you clearly just want an argument.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 20:14

@OpeningY

Yanbu. I dont care if its not a deterrent, it is certainly retribution. Alternatively make sure the prison conditions are really shit, don't give them medical treatment etc.

Let them suffer like their victims did.

If all you want is retribution, we don't need a justice system at all. Let anyone who thinks they've been wronged deliver whatever retribution they think is appropriate upon whoever they deem responsible.

Sound like a good idea?

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 20:06

@OpeningY

Yanbu. I dont care if its not a deterrent, it is certainly retribution. Alternatively make sure the prison conditions are really shit, don't give them medical treatment etc.

Let them suffer like their victims did.

This happens in the US.

My penfriend has been on Death Row in Nevada for 34 years. He has had medical treatment withheld, delayed and botched.

He now has a limp and several of his teeth have fallen out. Is that really what you’d want to happen to prisoners? (I have a horrible feeling you’ll say yes).

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 20:02

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher never said I wished it, I said part of me would like it to happen (I also qualified this by saying it would be wrong for it to actually happen), there's a difference. If I "wished" for it to happen then I would agree with it, which I said I didn't in my first post.

We're not going to agree, let's be big girls and leave it there. [/quote]
You’re right, you didn’t say you “wished “ for it to happen. You said you’d “like” it to happen. Which I think is no better.

And I’m not a girl, big or otherwise Grin

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 19:42

@OpeningY

Yanbu. I dont care if its not a deterrent, it is certainly retribution. Alternatively make sure the prison conditions are really shit, don't give them medical treatment etc.

Let them suffer like their victims did.

So you want it to be someone's job to keep humans locked up in horrible conditions with no medical treatment. Watching them get ulcers that become infected, teeth that rot and chest infections that leave them permanently impaired etc.

Is that good for the prison worker? Would prisoners come out of prison rehabilitated, or brutalised? What would it do to their families? Would you want that for your child if they got into trouble with drugs etc?

Just what is it that makes you better than those people, if you'd support a systematic regime to torture people?

OrinocoGlow · 06/12/2021 19:40

What a dreadful thing to witness DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes, I can't imagine the fear and horror. It's all so grim isn't it. There will always be mistakes, even with the best trained officers, and there's no coming back from it. Another reason why CP must never be re-introduced in this country - there would be a miscarriage of justice at some point, it's inevitable.

FangsForTheMemory · 06/12/2021 19:40

I haven't RTFT but did you know that one reason capital punishment was abolished in the UK was that juries were refusing to convict criminals they knew were guilty of serious crimes BECAUSE they knew it meant the death penalty for the accused?

OpeningY · 06/12/2021 19:37

Yanbu. I dont care if its not a deterrent, it is certainly retribution. Alternatively make sure the prison conditions are really shit, don't give them medical treatment etc.

Let them suffer like their victims did.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 19:30

@Warmduscher never said I wished it, I said part of me would like it to happen (I also qualified this by saying it would be wrong for it to actually happen), there's a difference. If I "wished" for it to happen then I would agree with it, which I said I didn't in my first post.

We're not going to agree, let's be big girls and leave it there.

DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes · 06/12/2021 19:26

@OrinocoGlow

I am completely against death penalty, even for the worst of crimes, in a civilised society for the reasons mentioned by many others. But this thread got me thinking as I am not opposed to armed police shooting a criminal, for example, a terrorist shot in the act. Maybe because it's less of a pre-meditated execution and undertaken only for safety of the police or public in the immediate moment and not in lieu of a lifetime in jail. Or maybe I am not as "civilised" as I thought. Of course, sometimes this goes wrong too and someone innocent is killed. It's all very complex the more I think about it.
I think I’m fine with what you describe and my logical brain thinks “oh well if people are in danger…” and then I remember Jean Charles de Menezes and feel sick. I was on the Northern Line at Oval that morning and remember the evacuation and fear, the fear first of all that there were more bombs after the horrors of July 7th, and then the horror realising that normal, workaday folk like me on the tube had witnessed an innocent man’s death because of police incompetence. Never mind the police who killed him because of their colleagues incompetence/false information etc. They’re murderers now and for literally no good reason. Once you start examining this stuff it fucks you up. I can’t stand the thought of that ever happening again, let alone premeditated executions of wrongly accused people.
MiniPumpkin · 06/12/2021 19:19

Absolutely not. No. Never. You are meeting violence with violence.

To those saying life should be life, I can understand that viewpoint but those who get ‘life’ remain on licence when released and must abide by those conditions or will be swiftly returned to custody. They are not released to live life as they wish

YokoOnosHat · 06/12/2021 19:17

[quote PicsInRed]This is capital punishment.

www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2014/12/18/the-rush-job-conviction-of-14-year-old-george-stinney-exonerated-70-years-after-execution/[/quote]
LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE AT THE BACK

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 19:05

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher yeah part of me would like Arthur's killers to have the same treatment they gave to him. It doesn't mean I would condone it if I saw it happening, It doesn't mean I would encourage it and it doesn't mean I wouldn't stop it if I had the power to.

We can all have dark thoughts, that doesn't mean we are "bloodthirsty". Obviously not you, but then we can't all be angelic perfection. Smile[/quote]
Not everyone would want to see killers like Tustin and Hughes tortured, not because we’re “angelic perfection” but because wishing the worst kind of cruelty on people who have committed terrible crimes debases us all and does nothing to alleviate the pain of the victim’s family.