Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Platax · 06/12/2021 22:50

Why are we spending money on the likes of Brady and hiNdly

We aren't spending a penny on Brady and Hindley, @Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas.

OneTC · 06/12/2021 22:47

If it was that safe to assume then he wouldn't have the right to appeal for 34 years

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 22:42

@Fidgetty

My penfriend has been on Death Row in Nevada for 34 years. He has had medical treatment withheld, delayed and botched. He now has a limp and several of his teeth have fallen out. Is that really what you’d want to happen to prisoners? (I have a horrible feeling you’ll say yes).

What is your "pen friend" convicted of? If it's death row it's safe to assume he did something heinous to another person? In which case he deserves everything he gets IMO.

We’ve been writing to each other for 30 years. No need for speech marks - he’s actually my penfriend.

With respect, what he was convicted of is none of your business (nor mine) and as you know nothing about his case, your opinion about what he does and doesn’t deserve is irrelevant.

sjxoxo · 06/12/2021 22:35

Never x

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 22:31

Our justice system needs to be impartial, unemotional and ensure a punishment that brings some sense of closure. That's why juries are selected randomly and not from the families of victims.

Justice systems cannot be a personalised, vindictive or retaliatory - that would just lead to a free for all where vigilantes and lynchings were possible!

Hertsgirl10 · 06/12/2021 22:30

The truth is people can say no way or morally it’s wrong but when it happens to one or theirs, feeling change.

Take Arthur’s grandad’s change of opinion on it as an example.

Fidgetty · 06/12/2021 22:29

Yes and justice is legal jargon for giving people what they deserve by assigning a suitable punishment for crimes committed. It's revenge in all but name.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 22:25

@Fidgetty

Thank goodness we have a justice system that has nothing to do with 'revenge'' or retaliation.

Yes it does, it's just covered up with legal jargon. Punishment/incarceration is revenge - what else could you call it?

Justice.
iklboodolphrednosedpaindear · 06/12/2021 22:20

Yes it does, it's just covered up with legal jargon. Punishment/incarceration is revenge - what else could you call it?

And what do you suggest as an alternative?

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 22:18

Punishment/incarceration is revenge - what else could you call it?

It's a penalty for an offence, and these penalties are laid out in law.

pointythings · 06/12/2021 22:15

Topseyt you are right but you are also wrong - the death penalty did not get taken off the statute books in Northern Ireland until 1998.

Saskatcha · 06/12/2021 22:14

I’m not. Below from the Council of Europe which adopted protocol number 13 of the convention into European Law -

In 1989, abolition of the death penalty was made a condition of accession for all new member states. Since then, all countries are committed to introducing an immediate moratorium on executions and ratifying Protocol No. 6 when joining the organisation. A number of mechanisms have been set up to monitor the respect of those commitments while assisting governments with their implementation.

In 2002, an important step was taken by the Council to ban the death penalty in all circumstances with the adoption of Protocol No. 13 to the European Convention on Human Rights, which requires the complete abolition of capital punishment - even for acts committed in time of war.
As a result, there has not been a single execution in any of the member states of the Council of Europe for 10 years

Fidgetty · 06/12/2021 22:12

Thank goodness we have a justice system that has nothing to do with 'revenge'' or retaliation.

Yes it does, it's just covered up with legal jargon. Punishment/incarceration is revenge - what else could you call it?

Topseyt · 06/12/2021 22:12

@Saskatcha

Definitely not. It’s one of the things that really worried me about the Uk leaving the EU that it could potentially be brought back. I recently watched ‘The Penalty’ on Netflix. Really harrowing.
The UK abolished the death penalty in 1965. Well before we even joined the Common Market (which later evolved into the EU). It thankfully looks likely to stay that way.

It isn't an issue which is related to Brexshit.

pointythings · 06/12/2021 22:09

[quote MynameisWa]@Saskatcha are you taking the piss? The UK abolished the death penalty long before other European countries did.

What on earth makes you think that the EU has been keeping the UK in check on capital punishment?

I mean we’re not even remotely close to reintroducing it.[/quote]
Not true - the UK did not formally abolish the death penalty until 1998. The last execution was much earlier than that, but the death penalty was still on the statute books formally speaking. Most European countries formally abolished considerably earlier.

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 22:06

Thank goodness we have a justice system that has nothing to do with 'revenge'' or retaliation.

Saskatcha · 06/12/2021 22:03

Members of the EU are not allowed to use the death penalty. Policy position here:

www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/world/20190212STO25910/death-penalty-in-europe-and-the-rest-of-the-world-key-facts

Leaving the EU makes restarting the death penalty potentially possible in legal terms. Several polling analysts showed a link in voter preferences between the two issues.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-36803544

There has been a fair bit of coverage on Priti Patel’s stance on the death penalty. However you interpret it it is hard to see her as an opponent.

Whether or not you liked being in the EU it did give certain protections to individuals which you may or may not agree with. I was always grateful that it gave us some protection over the possibility of the death penalty returning at the whim of a particular government.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 06/12/2021 21:51

I agree with you @Fidgetty, if a family member was killed in any of those circumstances I wouldn't care why they had done it, only that they had and I would want revenge.

Fidgetty · 06/12/2021 21:45

@fidgetty you are naive, I'm afraid. You have to be found guilty of a serious offence to end up on death row but it doesn't always translate into doing something 'heinous'. Eg it could be someone who committed a robbery as a teen, got scared and shot someone. Or killed someone because they were ordered to by a gang leader who would have killed them otherwise.

No not naïve. If they had killed my family member in those circumstances I would consider that henious regardless of their race/income level. I would have no care for their circumstances, I would be content with seeing vengeance rightly served.

cabingirl · 06/12/2021 21:40

Apart from the fact that it doesn't work as a deterrent and mistakes happen in convictions.

Murder / killing a human being on purpose is wrong.

Revenge or punishment doesn't make it right.

"Let's show everyone just how bad killing people is by... killing people"

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/12/2021 21:37

Perhaps confusing the EU with the ECHR? As one of the articles is the right to life.

Flapjacker48 · 06/12/2021 21:36

No.

And there is a reason that sentencing is done by experienced judges and not victims/families of victims of crime, let alone "the court of MN/the people/the tabloid press"

MynameisWa · 06/12/2021 21:34

@Saskatcha are you taking the piss? The UK abolished the death penalty long before other European countries did.

What on earth makes you think that the EU has been keeping the UK in check on capital punishment?

I mean we’re not even remotely close to reintroducing it.

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 21:32

@Fidgetty

My penfriend has been on Death Row in Nevada for 34 years. He has had medical treatment withheld, delayed and botched. He now has a limp and several of his teeth have fallen out. Is that really what you’d want to happen to prisoners? (I have a horrible feeling you’ll say yes).

What is your "pen friend" convicted of? If it's death row it's safe to assume he did something heinous to another person? In which case he deserves everything he gets IMO.

@fidgetty you are naive, I'm afraid. You have to be found guilty of a serious offence to end up on death row but it doesn't always translate into doing something 'heinous'.

Eg it could be someone who committed a robbery as a teen, got scared and shot someone. Or killed someone because they were ordered to by a gang leader who would have killed them otherwise. Or went out robbing with someone else, then the other person murdered the victim.

Those are all awful things that should be punished, but it's by no means all psycho evil sadistic murderers who end up on death row. There are plenty of people who had bad luck and made a wrong choice under pressure. Lots of them are also poor and black, funnily enough.

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 21:12

Absolutely not.
*We should not have state sanctioned murder. It brutalises society - just look at the hordes who turn up to celebrate executions in the USA
*Execution is no deterrent - if it was there would be no crime in places where they have capital punishment
*No 'evidence' is foolproof - even DNA can be 'planted' on purpose or by accident. There is corruption in the police as well as inadequacy in scientific testimony
*Many jurors would not pass a 'guilty' verdict if the death penalty was a possibility (or would be forced off a jury)
*Many will not inform on a criminalif they feel they will be executed
*Many guilty people have severe learning difficulties (low IQ's), products of abusive upbringings or have a mental illness
*Capital punishment can lead to more murders - 'better to hang for a sheep than a lamb' - so murderers will kill the witnesses, police etc as you can only be hung once!

  • the fact that many prisoners sentence to 'life without parole' kill themselves in prison (think Shipman, West) shows life sentences are not soft options *If we get it wrong an innocent person will have been killed by us. That is unacceptable on every level *Just as it is in the prison system, there will be a disproportionate number of people from certain groups affected (in the USA 40% on death row are Black people despite Black people only being 13% of the population) *Life is sacred and as a society we need to demonstrate that by our actions.
Swipe left for the next trending thread