Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Bananarice · 07/12/2021 06:01

No, I would not like capital punishment back.

I rather money went into prevention, rehabilitation and care for the jury members. Not to mention more police officers.

EnidFrighten · 07/12/2021 05:50

@Chloemol

I believe if you are hailed for 10 years you do 10 years. I believe you should all be treated the same in jail, so no open prisons, a cell no tv, possibly a radio, books etc but also you work during the day doing something productive, but not for money, but to recompense for what you have done

Prison is tough, but you have committed a crime against someone and all crimes affect those who it’s don’t to on some way. By making things tough hopefully people won’t want to do the crime because of the punishment

@chloemol doing something productive is good but costs money to run. Prisons often just keep prisoners in their cells because they can't afford to do anything else with them.

Can you really imagine being in a blank box day in, day out for years with no access to the outside world and possibly a dodgy or scary cellmate? TV is a cheap way to stop prisoners getting so bored and frustrated that they become angry, self harm, beat up others etc.

As for treating everyone the same - so murderers and drink drivers and people who got in a fight outside a pub and people who fiddled their taxes should all be treated the same? That would put them all on maximum security with extra staff, which would cost much more.

And if you're given ten years with no way of earning early release, there's no incentive to behave yourself. If you're given a 10 year sentence with a six year minimum term, you're going to try your best to deserve to get out after six. It's a low cost, effective way to get prisoners to behave themselves. Otherwise you have no leverage.

Have you watched that time prison series? I think it gives a fair view of what prison is like.

EnidFrighten · 07/12/2021 05:44

Basically the people on here calling for maltreatment in prison, death penalty etc are calling for an end to human rights.

Human rights mean that every single person is entitled to certain rights such as freedom from inhuman and degrading treatment. Everyone. If you start deciding certain people have done things that are terrible enough to justify breaching their human rights, you hand the government authority to torture or degrade anyone they like.

These rights were all put in place after WWII to prevent countries falling into tyranny and horror again. The people who put them in place weren't naive about how abusive and disgusting people can be. They put them in place because of that.

A lot of people on here seem to want to fixate on details of the Tustin and Hughes case in a really ghoulish, grisly way.

anon12345678901 · 07/12/2021 05:36

@OhWhyNot

Prisons are not comfortable

I have no idea why people think this. Many prisoners are traumatised from their time in prison which leads to mh issues

I don't have any sympathy I'm afraid. Why should they be comfortable? Prison should be a deterrent. Capital punishment, I'm not sure. I don't really want my money to pay to house murderers or child molesters for years. But as far as I know, people can be on death row for years, so that wouldn't change.
EnidFrighten · 07/12/2021 05:31

@ufucoffee

No but I do wish that prisons were less comfortable places than they currently are.
@ufucoffee

"The Ministry of Justice announced that they were taking over the running of HMP Birmingham, following witnessing ‘appalling’ levels of violence and squalor. Inspectors found corridors filthy with blood, vomit and cockroaches, amid damning levels of violence, drugs and alcohol abuse. One in seven prisoners admitted they had developed drug addictions whilst that they had been inside the prison."

blog.insidegovernment.co.uk/criminal-justice/blog/prison-reform

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 07/12/2021 00:18

The most successful rehabilitation is in countries that invest heavily in rehabilitation
I agree, but majority aren't interested in this fact.

Chloemol · 07/12/2021 00:14

I believe if you are hailed for 10 years you do 10 years. I believe you should all be treated the same in jail, so no open prisons, a cell no tv, possibly a radio, books etc but also you work during the day doing something productive, but not for money, but to recompense for what you have done

Prison is tough, but you have committed a crime against someone and all crimes affect those who it’s don’t to on some way. By making things tough hopefully people won’t want to do the crime because of the punishment

Psuedoshoes · 07/12/2021 00:05

No, I don't believe we should ever go back to that

user1471519931 · 07/12/2021 00:01

No, never

LoisWilkersonslastnerve · 06/12/2021 23:53

I would never want the death penalty brought back but if Hughes and Tustin were beaten to death in jail, I would have zero sympathy. I get why people want it back when you read stories like that but we are supposed to be better than them, not murderers ourselves.

OhWhyNot · 06/12/2021 23:50

So what

What countries are you comparing us to. South America, US, Russia all have mush high violent crime rates than we do here l.
Prison is not a deterrent

The most successful rehabilitation is in countries that invest heavily in rehabilitation

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 06/12/2021 23:49

@MynameisWa

Can you imagine the law suits stretched out, the media storm and activism leading up to each case? Human rights lawyers would go into a feeding frenzy.

I don’t think it would deter crime. Many murders like Tustin are so out of touch they think they can get away with it completely. There’s not much rational thought involved. They are usually deluded into thinking they are justified, exonerated in some way or too clever to get caught.

In my mind there is simply no good reasons for the death penalty.

Perhaps it sends a clear message loudly but to say ‘it’s wrong to kill’ and then kill on command of the state is just ridiculous.

In no way should the death penalty be reintroduced.

I don’t think it would deter crime. Many murders like Tustin are so out of touch they think they can get away with it completely.

Maybe it won't deter crimes, but I can't see the point of the taxpayer feeding these degenerates for 20-30 years either.

ufucoffee · 06/12/2021 23:47

@OhWhyNot

Prisons are not comfortable

I have no idea why people think this. Many prisoners are traumatised from their time in prison which leads to mh issues

They are more comfortable than prisons in many other countries
OhWhyNot · 06/12/2021 23:45

Prisons are not comfortable

I have no idea why people think this. Many prisoners are traumatised from their time in prison which leads to mh issues

sleepwouldbenice · 06/12/2021 23:45

No I don't want capital punishment

There will be cases where the innocent are executed
I don't believe in an eye for an eye whatever the circumstances
I would prefer extremely long sentences and shabby conditions. I am thinking if the shawshank redemption v the green mile

OhWhyNot · 06/12/2021 23:44

No

I think on the very rare occasion it is better to execute someone (when their capture could cause civil unrest)

ufucoffee · 06/12/2021 23:41

No but I do wish that prisons were less comfortable places than they currently are.

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 23:22

Vigilante

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 23:20

"From the body cam footage I don't believe ET believes she did anything wrong. I think she'll go to her grave believing that Arthur was at fault and she was disciplining him."

I can believe this. I know a psychopathic child abuser and he believes he was acting in love (yes, police already involved)

I despair at the fact that some people are just psychopaths. Afaik it is a mixture of genes and upbringing - what can be done to protect others from these people?

From what I've read, you can be genetically predisposed to be a psychopath but if your upbringing is good, you don't become one. No idea what her background was like, but being egged on by Hughes could well have flipped a switch.

I have long felt that proper parenting classes should be compulsory for all expectant parents, but that's a whole other discussion really.

OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2021 23:19

AFAIK child abusers/murders are treated terribly in prisons as a huge proportion of prisoners have kids/nieces/nephews/kid siblings etc. And rightly so

Absolutely appalling that we would even think to condone or praise the behaviour of drug dealers, terrorists or murderers who think they should suddenly become 'law enforcers' inside prison. These are the same thugs that attack our police officers and prison officers and who'd shed no tears for attacking you or your family members.
To elevate them to 'defenders of justice' in an insult to us all. They were imprisoned for being ruthless murderers and drug gang enforcers - that is what they are. Don't think for a minute they give a shit about the 'Arthur's' of this world - they don't. They don't even care about their own kids or they wouldn't be in prison! They are just sickos showing off their strength behind bars.
They would have sold 'Arthur' drugs as a teenager and not give it a second thought, they would have shot 'Arthur' if he got in the way - have we forgotten about Rhys Jones? They'd have blown up concert halls full of 'Arthurs' if hit suited their purpose.

It really is unbelievable to me how many 'mums' on here think any of these evil thugs can be seen to 'do good' by 'revenge' beatings and stabbings in prison.

These thugs make it even harder on underpaid prison officers to keep order. Don't forget theses officers put their lives on the line every day to ensure the court sentences are served as they should be and to stop the 'vigilant' thugs adding on a bit of blood sport for fun.

The ones some Mumsnet posters are encouraging to 'give them a going over' are likely to be the same ones that will burglarise your house, mug your granny, stab your child or make your neighbourhood hell to live in.

ohfook · 06/12/2021 23:05

@fournonblondes

I would bring it back for cases where there is not doubt. Terrorists for example and serial killers.
But when people are wrongly convicted, at the time the judge will think there is no doubt. They don't sentence someone to life imprisonment because they're fairly sure they're guilty or just to be in the safe side.
ohfook · 06/12/2021 23:01

Absolutely not. I wouldn't want to pay my taxes to a state that murdered people.

Unconscious biases always come into play and we would 100% end up with a system where rich people who could afford the best legal representation would get let off for crimes that people without good representation would be left to die for. It would amplify the inequalities that already exist in our system. I have no doubt that uneducated people, black people and poor people would, by a country mile, be the people who were executed the most.

It has not been proven to be a deterrent at all. Most people either commit crimes on the spur of the moment, don't believe they're doing anything wrong or don't believe they'll get caught. From the body cam footage I don't believe ET believes she did anything wrong. I think she'll go to her grave believing that Arthur was at fault and she was disciplining him.

Lengthy appeals and plea bargains make it an expensive and inefficient system.

Possibly of error is also a worry.

And just in my opinion encouraging people to relish in violent means of retribution and revenge does not create a healthy society.

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 22:53

@Hertsgirl10

The truth is people can say no way or morally it’s wrong but when it happens to one or theirs, feeling change.

Take Arthur’s grandad’s change of opinion on it as an example.

Yes, but criminal cases are brought on behalf of the crown, not the victim's family.

Otherwise, what if you had a victim no one cared about? Eg someone with no relatives or friends. Should their murderer be punished less?

I'm sure if anything awful happened to one of my loved ones, I'd want terrible things to happen to the perpetrator, but justice is supposed to be impartial.

Platax · 06/12/2021 22:52

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea

AFAIK child abusers/murders are treated terribly in prisons as a huge proportion of prisoners have kids/nieces/nephews/kid siblings etc. And rightly so.
No, not rightly so. The punishment should be prison and nothing more. The notion that we should give thugs carte blanche licence to attack anyone they fancy is almost as bad as condoning capital punishment.
Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 22:51

@OneTC

If it was that safe to assume then he wouldn't have the right to appeal for 34 years
As I said, it’s irrelevant what you think about my own friend’s case.

I mentioned him because someone proposed that certain prisoners should have medical treatment withheld as well as loss of liberty and I wanted to inform them that it was already being done in a so-called developed nation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread