Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Offmyfence · 07/12/2021 21:31

@StoneofDestiny

I hope people will look at the case of Stefan Kiszko. A completely innocent man with a mental age of 12, he was wrongly convicted for killing a young girl. He served 16 years in prison where he was regularly beaten up by convicted prisoners because he was a 'child killer'. 16 years of terror and abuse. He developed a severe mental illness as a result. Those who believed in him fought for justice. It was found witnesses had lied, police AND forensic scientists had hid evidence that would have proved his innocence. He was eventually freed only to die a year later as did his mother soon after.

Never imagine that evidence or witnesses or indeed our justice system can be relied upon to prove a case. There is human error, deceit and corruption not far from many decisions or conclusions we humans make.

Stephan could have been hung based on 'the evidence' presented. As it was, he lived 16 years of his life in a living hell that so ebon Mumsnet would have said 'on the evidence' was well deserved.

Also remember the case of Colin Stagg luckily the judge threw it out, but the police had a very good attempt to get him convicted.

He was innocent.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 21:21

Pemba

More than 30 years after Leslie was killed, the real killer, Ronald Castree, was caught as a result of his DNA sample matching the semen found on Lesley’s clothes

Stefan was infertile and the police and forensic team hid that very easy to check fact.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/12/2021 21:13

A lot of people are not interested in justice, but in vengeance. They’re not overly concerned about who that vengeance is visited upon, as long as they see it played out.

And the machinery of the law knows that. They understand the public needs to see someone pay. So they’ll find someone.

Pemba · 07/12/2021 19:52

God, that's horrendous. Poor man, and his mother. Did they ever find the real culprit?

It's like that solicitor (Sally Clarke?) who was jailed for supposedly killing her babies. After several years it was realised that she was totally innocent (a genetic problem with the babies was the cause) and she was eventually released. But they had taken her youngest into care, and too late to reverse that. She was free but her life was destroyed and she died not long after. Poor, poor woman.

Under CP they would both have been executed perhaps. Can't believe some pps think this is acceptable 'collateral damage'.

See also Guildford 4, Birmingham 6 etc. Their 'crimes' seem to have been being Irish living in England. Gerry Conlon and his father also died before their time.

Miscarriages of justice have happened frequently. We can never go back to capital punishment.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 18:28

I hope people will look at the case of Stefan Kiszko. A completely innocent man with a mental age of 12, he was wrongly convicted for killing a young girl. He served 16 years in prison where he was regularly beaten up by convicted prisoners because he was a 'child killer'. 16 years of terror and abuse. He developed a severe mental illness as a result.
Those who believed in him fought for justice. It was found witnesses had lied, police AND forensic scientists had hid evidence that would have proved his innocence.
He was eventually freed only to die a year later as did his mother soon after.

Never imagine that evidence or witnesses or indeed our justice system can be relied upon to prove a case. There is human error, deceit and corruption not far from many decisions or conclusions we humans make.

Stephan could have been hung based on 'the evidence' presented. As it was, he lived 16 years of his life in a living hell that so ebon Mumsnet would have said 'on the evidence' was well deserved.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 18:08

There is a difference between 'not ever being freed from prison or secure mental hospital' and being 'imprisoned for life with the additional daily torture from other prisoners whose equally vile crimes got them incarcerated in the first place'.
We need protecting from dangerous people. We also need to intervene much sooner that we do now to stop people becoming such a danger to us.
We need to value our public services much more than we do - the people,e we expect to notice, intervene, refer and change things.

It says a lot about our societies values that these professional people are the ones who are often paid the least and are the most difficult to recruit and retain.

OhWhyNot · 07/12/2021 17:49

I think Venables is so damaged he can’t live in the community

The damage started from before he was 10 years old

I agree some people should never be free

hazelnutpraline · 07/12/2021 16:12

I have always been against the death penalty for all the very good reasons pp have listed. And I still am. But I do wish pain and suffering on those who hurt children.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/12/2021 16:07

@sashh

As James Bulger has been mentioned, I'd like to add a thought, and this is taking nothing away from James' family or keeping his memory alive.

Two 10 year old boys had their life chances and education drastically improved by killing a toddler.

Just think about that.

Before we think about bringing back the death penalty we should be thinking about the circumstances some children live in.

Venables has had chance after chance and doesn't appear to have changed. At what point do we say enough is enough, he is a permanent danger to society and doesn't deserved any more chances?

Before someone twists what I'm saying I am NOT suggesting we execute him, that he should have been executed as a child or that he's handed over to a baying mob. I feel that at some point when people show no inclination or ability to change they should be removed from society and remain in prison until they die.

toolatetooearly · 07/12/2021 15:51

There are few things I feel more strongly about than keeping the death penalty banned, no matter how horrible the crime being punished.

Offmyfence · 07/12/2021 15:50

@StoneofDestiny

Scary stuff on here - particularly the proposal to hang the likes of 'Venables'.

Look at it this way. There are many baby 'Arthur's out there. There really are. Children subjected to severe neglect and abuse. Children with no positive example in their lives other than the vile parents or guardians they have been exposed to.
They don't stay 'baby Arthur's' or 'baby Venables'. If they survive the chronic neglect they may grow up into 'feral youths' or just an 'Arthur' or 'Venables' - the prisons are littered with them.
Mumsnet often talks about these 'hooligans' than none of us want to live next to.
Society does not sympathise after the baby stage - it directs its fury at the teenage thugs, out of control youth, or gang member. Somehow we imagine the 'baby' finds normality and good morals magically in the years between babyhood and adulthood. Those years where the 'child' is often not even accessing full time education, parental supervision or employment.
How is that 'baby' ever going to have a chance of being a responsible citizen.
Do we really sympathise with the baby 'Arthur's' and hate the adult 'Arthur's', or weep over the death of the baby 'Arthur's' and call out for the execution of the adult 'Arthur's'?

Fabulous post!
Georgeskitchen · 07/12/2021 15:48

Tbh Emma Tustin has probably signed her own death warrant. Somebody, somehow, will get to her. There is usually a price on the head of those who have committed unspeakable crimes. There are people in jail who have little to lose so my guess is eventually, she will be killed.
The only way for it not to happen is keep her in solitary for the entire sentence e

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 15:42

sashh
Indeed. We need to put more into the early stages of children's development, including Social Services support for parent and child. No different to healthcare - prevention much cheaper and better in the long run than treating the illness.

Look at how public services are funded - we have insufficient social workers, mental health professionals, teachers, prison officers and police. Those who fall through the net inevitably end up in prison.

We know prisons are over crowded and it's unreasonable to expect a prison officer to be a jailer, counsellor, mental health expert, social worker, guardian, teacher and sympathetic ear. They cannot do all these things to a community of prisoners made up of some very disturbed, violent, vulnerable, aggressive, illiterate, mentally ill, suicidal people - some times prisoners are all these things at once!
That, as well as trying to keep themselves super vigilant in case they are attacked themselves. Prisons need to rehabilitate - but with so few officers in a poorly paid profession, it's not likely to happen any time soon!

sashh · 07/12/2021 15:28

As James Bulger has been mentioned, I'd like to add a thought, and this is taking nothing away from James' family or keeping his memory alive.

Two 10 year old boys had their life chances and education drastically improved by killing a toddler.

Just think about that.

Before we think about bringing back the death penalty we should be thinking about the circumstances some children live in.

5128gap · 07/12/2021 15:11

@StoneofDestiny

Scary stuff on here - particularly the proposal to hang the likes of 'Venables'.

Look at it this way. There are many baby 'Arthur's out there. There really are. Children subjected to severe neglect and abuse. Children with no positive example in their lives other than the vile parents or guardians they have been exposed to.
They don't stay 'baby Arthur's' or 'baby Venables'. If they survive the chronic neglect they may grow up into 'feral youths' or just an 'Arthur' or 'Venables' - the prisons are littered with them.
Mumsnet often talks about these 'hooligans' than none of us want to live next to.
Society does not sympathise after the baby stage - it directs its fury at the teenage thugs, out of control youth, or gang member. Somehow we imagine the 'baby' finds normality and good morals magically in the years between babyhood and adulthood. Those years where the 'child' is often not even accessing full time education, parental supervision or employment.
How is that 'baby' ever going to have a chance of being a responsible citizen.
Do we really sympathise with the baby 'Arthur's' and hate the adult 'Arthur's', or weep over the death of the baby 'Arthur's' and call out for the execution of the adult 'Arthur's'?

Completely agree. There are many parallels between the childhood of Robert Thompson, who no doubt they would have hanged alongside Jon Venables, and that of Arthur. One was tragically killed, the other tragically survived with severe damage.
StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 15:00

Scary stuff on here - particularly the proposal to hang the likes of 'Venables'.

Look at it this way. There are many baby 'Arthur's out there. There really are. Children subjected to severe neglect and abuse. Children with no positive example in their lives other than the vile parents or guardians they have been exposed to.
They don't stay 'baby Arthur's' or 'baby Venables'. If they survive the chronic neglect they may grow up into 'feral youths' or just an 'Arthur' or 'Venables' - the prisons are littered with them.
Mumsnet often talks about these 'hooligans' than none of us want to live next to.
Society does not sympathise after the baby stage - it directs its fury at the teenage thugs, out of control youth, or gang member. Somehow we imagine the 'baby' finds normality and good morals magically in the years between babyhood and adulthood. Those years where the 'child' is often not even accessing full time education, parental supervision or employment.
How is that 'baby' ever going to have a chance of being a responsible citizen.
Do we really sympathise with the baby 'Arthur's' and hate the adult 'Arthur's', or weep over the death of the baby 'Arthur's' and call out for the execution of the adult 'Arthur's'?

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/12/2021 13:51

*words are twisted to suit

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/12/2021 13:51

You seem to be suggesting that he should be torn apart in the street by a mob. That's what would happen if he was not protected in any way.

Aah Mumsnet, the place where words are to suit.

Im not advocating anything other than Venables be locked up for life. Some prisoners cannot be rehabilitated and he is clearly one of them.

If unfortunately he has to be let out of prison then I don’t understand why the taxpayer has to fund yet another new identity if he’s too stupid or too arrogant to keep his original identity secret.

Thelnebriati · 07/12/2021 12:46

@DrSbaitso

There should always be a case that makes you stop, think, and re-evaluate your stance of issues like capital punishment

Hard cases make bad laws.

You've misunderstood my post. I'm happy not to have my beliefs set in stone. They need to be re-evaluated once in a while, to absorb new info and keep them up to date and fit for purpose.
EnidFrighten · 07/12/2021 12:24

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

He was 10 wasn't he? You are genuinely advocating killing a mentally disturbed 10 year old.

A 10 year old should never be killed, however now he is an adult and will clearly never change he should not be let out of prison again. I have no idea if he's in or out of prison at the moment but if he's out and he blows this new identity he shouldn't get another one. He's had more than enough chances.

You seem to be suggesting that he should be torn apart in the street by a mob. That's what would happen if he was not protected in any way.

Would that be a good kind of murder, whereas he committed a bad kind of murder? If it was the good kind of murder, what if they picked on the wrong person? Would that make it the bad kind of murder?

We protect people from brutality, even when they are brutal themselves, because we are a civilised society and failing to do so harms everyone.

DrSbaitso · 07/12/2021 12:23

There should always be a case that makes you stop, think, and re-evaluate your stance of issues like capital punishment

Hard cases make bad laws.

Thelnebriati · 07/12/2021 12:21

There should always be a case that makes you stop, think, and re-evaluate your stance of issues like capital punishment, but I haven't read anything so far that makes me want to support it.
I find the revenge fantasies to be nearly as disturbing as the original crimes. I have a problem with people wishing harm on those convicted - especially if you passively accept that a percentage of innocent people will be among them.

IMO, cases like this should make us want to strengthen safeguarding and prevention.

Thecurliestwurly · 07/12/2021 11:49

No. It's not a deterrent. Anyone sadistic and narcissistic enough will think they will never get caught and do it anyway. I think some killers are so detached from reality that it wouldn't really cross their mind.

All it does us run the risk of someone innocent dying for a crime they didn't commit. Then what would you do with the person who ran the investigation, pressed the button etc? The justice system still gets it wrong, despite advance in forensic science. I think it will actually create more caution in convicting someone of a crime if CP is the punishment. I wouldn't want to be on a jury and play a part in sentencing someone to death.

I think death is almost the easy way out anyway. Yes we pay taxes to keep them alive, but it gives them a very long time to suffer with their conscience if they have one, or feel hard done by if they are the sort of person who doesn't.

OhWhyNot · 07/12/2021 11:43

Hertsgirl10 prison has never been a deferent

Do you think a rapist thinks oh better not rape that women tonight as I might get caught and go to prison

Do you think someone who inflicts pain on the most vulnerable in our society stops to think oh better not I may have to go to prison

Prison takes away your right to make choices. You don’t choose when you eat when you shower when you can talk to family. What we could today in prison is try our best so people don’t repeat the crimes which is better for society, stops other people getting hurt.

Some people are beyond rehabilitation (I would include all child sex offenders) but the majority I believe can be

And while someone may get three cooked meals a day don’t kid yourself into thinking that they won’t live in fear or life will be pleasant for them they will be protected as we shouldn’t have vigilante rule in prison m. There is a hierarchy and at the bottom are those that harm children.

Should the child that has been bought up in care, never really known love and stability for caught up and taken advantage of not be given the chance to lead a good honest and happy life or was their life mapped out from them at the start because for whatever reason their parents couldn’t cope

luverlybubberly · 07/12/2021 11:42

I think that CP is wrong but when I read about cases like little Arthur, I start to waver and think that we should have an eye for an eye sort of system even though adults being tortured can't be made equal to a vulnerable person like a child being tortured. CP is a quick ending and in an ideal world, the perpetrators of crime should be thinking about their victims pain and feeling remorse.

On the other hand I know someone who has spent a lot of time in prison (for non violent crimes so wouldn't face CP ) and they last committed a crime 20 years ago. It's a difficult task - how do you balance the people who do change with the ones who are going to reoffend the moment they are released like Pitchfork?