Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
BluebelllsRosesDaffodills · 09/12/2021 10:18

5128gap- what about those on a ‘whole life’ tariff?

They still manage to control those, and they can never be released. They can take away visits and other privileges and put them in segregated cells as punishment

safclass · 08/12/2021 22:18

I'd worry about miscarriage of justice. Even with DNA innocent people have been jailed.
HOWEVER the murder / torture of a child should IMMEDIATELY be life in prison, and I mean life not 20+yrs and def no ahnce of parole.

Beebababadabo · 08/12/2021 22:14

No but I think tougher sentences. Maybe a way to make the prisoners contribute to society more like working in secure factories with only prisoners and high security. If they refused they don't get to have TV and other privileges just food and life's basics. I think incase like those who took Arthur's life should have a long prison sentence with no chance to get out after a certain amount of extended time like decades they may have a a chance if they have worked and proven themselves to be changed and are no danger to society but it must be a very hard test to past that takes years and years to prove. They don't get to have a new identity and live off the tax payers out of prisons. They can change their name themselves but they have to live with the consequences of their past.

5128gap · 08/12/2021 21:53

@Stomacharmeleon

I personally just wish that life would mean life and that we kept people in prison but we just don't have the room.....

I also think if you are a repeat offender you should spend a larger amount of time in prison. (Katie Price)

The trouble with life being life, is that it gives the offender nothing left to lose and nothing to work towards, which makes them very dangerous and difficult to manage within the prison system. The hope of parole is a useful means of control.
StoneofDestiny · 08/12/2021 21:45

Just the sort of trash I'd expect The Sun to peddle. Liverpool has the right attitude to that rag.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 08/12/2021 10:03

A while back, a child was murdered and the perpetrator was given a life sentence. The tabloids - The Sun, particularly - went into their usual ‘string ‘em up’ frenzy, and said that anyone who disagreed should ask the family of the victim what they thought. The family, they said, would want to see the murderer hang, and their views should be taken into account.

Then the family released a statement that, in accordance with their religious views, they would strive to forgive the murderer and would pray for his eventual redemption.

There was a short, perplexed silence from the Sun. Then they started to peddle the editorial line that the family was addled by grief, didn’t know what they were saying and nobody should pay any attention to them.

Platax · 08/12/2021 07:22

I'm sure I'd probably change my mind if someone harmed my partner or child mind

I suspect that, in that situation, I'd want the person responsible torn limb from limb. But, fairly obviously, I recognise that in a civilised country you cannot build a justice system based on people's primitive revenge responses.

Stomacharmeleon · 08/12/2021 06:50

I personally just wish that life would mean life and that we kept people in prison but we just don't have the room.....

I also think if you are a repeat offender you should spend a larger amount of time in prison. (Katie Price)

sashh · 08/12/2021 06:47

@BigYellowHat

You are missing my point.

No child should have such a bad home life that inflicting harm on another improves it.

There is nothing we can do to bring back Arthur, or James Bulger but there are things that could and should be done to children living lives of misery.

Sure Start centres were a great idea but have all closed. We don't know the consequences of those closures.

LobsterNapkin · 08/12/2021 02:46

No.

It's not a good deterrent anyway.

But it is also the case that there will be errors. Maybe not often. But there would always be someone mistakenly convicted, at some point.

I don't think that's justifiable in our society.

There may be places where in some cases, where there are no prisons, where it's not possible to lock someone up long term, that it may be justifiable to protect the community. But we are way past that.

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/12/2021 00:06
  • There's no evidence it's a deterrent
  • It costs a fortune - the legal fees on death row are extraordinary, far more than prison
  • It is unfairly applied - you are far more likely to be executed in the US if you are poor and non-white
  • There would be miscarriages of justice, eg Guildford 4 etc
  • It has no place in a civilised society - if murder is wrong then state sanctioned murdered cannot be right
CourtRand · 07/12/2021 23:47

No. I don't believe in taking life even that of monsters. And there are cases of innocent people being killed under CP.

I'm sure I'd probably change my mind if someone harmed my partner or child mind.

Platax · 07/12/2021 23:44

@UserOfManyNames

And in the case of Thompson and Venables, the vast majority of abused children (I think that was overplayed as well) don’t go on to commit crimes like that, especially at that age. Ever read A Child Called It? Obviously it is a step too far to euthanise children but they both should have been in a secure facility for life without ever being released. That they could ever have a normal life after the horrific and savage acts they committed on James Bulger is even worse than that.
The argument that two abused children who killed can't have any sort of leeway because other abused children don't ill simply isn't sustainable. No two children have the same characters or go through the same abuse and you simply can't compare them. It's like saying that because one person survived, say, a car crash without ongoing trauma then no one else in the same crash is allowed to be traumatised.
Duckrace · 07/12/2021 23:41

No Pritti, I would not.

OhWhyNot · 07/12/2021 23:41

Wasn’t Amanda Knox found guilty partly through so called DNA evidence along with a very strange story the prosecution put forward for the murder of Meredith Kercher

That was not so long ago (2009)

And numerous people have admitted to crimes that did not commit some have had no connection at all

Platax · 07/12/2021 23:40

@Chloemol

I believe if you are hailed for 10 years you do 10 years. I believe you should all be treated the same in jail, so no open prisons, a cell no tv, possibly a radio, books etc but also you work during the day doing something productive, but not for money, but to recompense for what you have done

Prison is tough, but you have committed a crime against someone and all crimes affect those who it’s don’t to on some way. By making things tough hopefully people won’t want to do the crime because of the punishment

But think about what it would be like guarding prisons when the prisoners have absolutely no incentive to behave and far too much time to build up resentment for what they are going through and plot their revenge.
Platax · 07/12/2021 23:37

@ufucoffee

No but I do wish that prisons were less comfortable places than they currently are.
Have you ever been in a closed prison? If you know anything at all about the subject, you would know that they aren't at all comfortable. How comfortable would you feel if you had to share a small cell with a couple of thugs and an open toilet, being locked up in there frequently for most of the day? And if you were kept awake all night by the noise of people shouting out to each other, singing, moaning etc?
AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 07/12/2021 23:29

The cases PP are referring to were long before the DNA technology we have today, and CCTV, mobile phones and internet history etc. Nowadays it’s much easier to prove guilt. Also quite a few murderers admit guilt (obviously try to get off on manslaughter though)
There have been cases where evidence has been covered up, twisted or straight up fabricated. Examples in this thread.

I am just not OK with the state taking away the basic right to live from people, regardless of what they have done. If they take away human rights from one, it's feasible they can take them away from others.

CSJobseeker · 07/12/2021 23:16

It’s actually cruel as I can’t imagine be able to live after taking someone else’s life

So you're pro-capital punishment, but who do you think is going to carry out the killings? Someone has to.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 23:13

Nothing would 'deter' some of the killers, rapists, abusers or terrorists we are talking about. They assume they will never be caught. Indeed, if they thought they would face the death penalty for their crime, they most likely will kill any witnesses to their offence - they can't be hung more than once.
Rose West is in prison - so we are safe from her. Killing her doesn't make us any safer.
If you really think our "advances" in evidence gathering is foolproof, you've not been keeping up with the news. Countless scientific theories are upturned on a regular basis.
Your faith in CTV is even more amazing - because Arthur's guardians and killers installed CTV to show what good parents they were - proving even that can be manipulated to tell a different story,

Innocent people are in prison still because of police and scientific failures. Guilty people remain at large because of police and scientific inadequacy.
They can be anaesthetised
Have you heard how that's going on in the USA?

UserOfManyNames · 07/12/2021 23:02

And in the case of Thompson and Venables, the vast majority of abused children (I think that was overplayed as well) don’t go on to commit crimes like that, especially at that age. Ever read A Child Called It? Obviously it is a step too far to euthanise children but they both should have been in a secure facility for life without ever being released. That they could ever have a normal life after the horrific and savage acts they committed on James Bulger is even worse than that.

UserOfManyNames · 07/12/2021 22:45

The cases PP are referring to were long before the DNA technology we have today, and CCTV, mobile phones and internet history etc. Nowadays it’s much easier to prove guilt. Also quite a few murderers admit guilt (obviously try to get off on manslaughter though).

Does anybody think Rose West is innocent? She is living a good life in prison with Christmas parties and lesbian lovers from accounts I’ve read in the past. We all like to think they suffer in prison but in reality, they are protected. eat well, never have to worry about a roof over their heads, get medical care, study, have a gym and carve a life out there. Adapt and normalise it. So the argument that that capital punishment is an easy way out and they should live to suffer for the rest of their lives falls flat somewhat.

I don’t believe capital punishment is ‘state sponsored murder’. We’re OK with abortion, wholesale slaughtering of sentient animals for food, putting dogs down when they bite. Why not putting adult humans down when they kill premeditatedly and in cold blood? As far as I’m concerned they have then crossed a line that can never be rehabilitated and it serves no purpose to keep them housed and have staff to look after them. It’s actually cruel as I can’t imagine be able to live after taking someone else’s life, and on the staff having to deal with these people knowing what they’ve done

There are many ways to make it humane, massively than their victims death. They can be anaesthesitised.

It also doesn’t matter if it’s not a deterrent as it’s not supposed to be, it’s a sentence but it may make some people think twice. It would me!

I’m sure the families of most murder victims would prefer they weren’t breathing the oxygen that their loved ones had taken away from them or have the stress of them getting out. I think society owes them that.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 22:05

Possibly the most famous case -

Timothy Evans, a 26-year-old man in London was hanged for the murder of his wife and daughter in 1950. Three years after his execution it was concluded Timothy Evans was innocent of the crime. The real perpetrator was his housemate at the time, John Christie, who had testified against Evans at his trial.

StoneofDestiny · 07/12/2021 21:49

Oops
that so many on Mumsnet would have said 'on the evidence' was well deserved

luckylavender · 07/12/2021 21:44

No, it's barbaric