Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Platax · 06/12/2021 07:17

I find the idea of the state cold-bloodedly killing people, no matter how evil they are, absolutely abhorrent. I don't want that to be done in my name.

Platax · 06/12/2021 07:15

Clearly it isn't a deterrent. We had capital punishment for most of the time the Moors murders were going on - obviously Brady and Hindley weren't deterred.

megletthesecond · 06/12/2021 07:07

No. It doesn't seem to be a deterrent. We're better than that.

ShouldersBackChestOutChinUp · 06/12/2021 07:06

It's not a deterrent.

State murder is also wrong.

Long incarceration is the best punishment.

ICanSeeARainbow123 · 06/12/2021 07:04

An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind

Shoxfordian · 06/12/2021 07:04

I don’t agree with the death penalty

It lowers the state to the same level as the criminal; there’s something wrong in the idea that you should not kill but if you do then you will be killed.

There are still miscarriages of justice and you can’t reverse the death penalty.

A lifetime in prison to think about what you’ve done and live with it should be punishment enough

logsonlogsoff · 06/12/2021 07:02

Not in a million years. It’s revenge not justice and will be used in politically motivated cases or against non-whites more ( as it is in the USA) or against vulnerable people.
It’s not a deterrent. It never will be and therefore cannot be justified.
Lock up those vile child murderers forever but our government killing them would only shame us all.

TidyDancer · 06/12/2021 07:02

I don't agree with CP under any circumstances. The potential for mistakes to be made should rule it out on that basis alone. But I don't think it's a deterrent anyway and two wrongs don't make a right.

maddiemookins16mum · 06/12/2021 06:52

For those who’d want it back, I ask this…..could you pull the switch or carry out the injection? You’d be taking the life of another person.
It must never come back.

topcat2014 · 06/12/2021 06:49

Arthur's case made me think. But on balance I say no. I did jury service recently for a child related case. It felt a big responsibility getting a verdict. Glad that verdict couldn't have lead to CP.

saoirse31 · 06/12/2021 06:43

Awful idea, think of the amount of innocent people who would be killed. Not convinced it acts as a deterrent in any way.

RedRobin100 · 06/12/2021 06:23

Eh, NO!

It’s not a deterrent, and the consequences of error too great.

tigger1001 · 06/12/2021 06:19

I don't agree with cp.

You are asking someone to kill another human.

It doesn't work as a deterrent and one mistake is too many.

Bagelsandbrie · 06/12/2021 06:17

I don’t agree with the death penalty. I think it’s a step backwards morality wise but I do agree with more funding being put into the whole legal system and more prison spaces so we can give out more whole life sentences. I also think prison should be harder and harsher than it is. Why should Rose West be able to have a budgie and spend her days watching TV? Madness.

Tustin tried to commit suicide twice during custody in the trial and has tried a few times before; once throwing herself off a car park. Why should we give her what she wants (death)?

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 06:13

And the reason why we have parole and early release for good behaviour etc is that otherwise there is very little incentive for people in jail to behave well.

The hope of getting out slightly earlier is a powerful way to make people learn to control themselves. Otherwise prison would become a total horror show. You might say that's fine, leave them to rot but tbh anyone can end up in prison, you don't have to be a total monster. A bad decision to drive after drinking etc can do it.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 06/12/2021 06:10

It’s not the fear of capital punishment or even jail time that deters me from heinous crimes.

I feel that anyone who is capable or willing to commit these crimes wouldn’t be put off or would think they wouldn’t get caught. Child molesters and abusers are famously known to suffer in prisons at the hands of the other prisoners and that doesn’t stop people.

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 06:09

No. I find it weird how people are fetishizing their hatred of Tustin, it's a real baying mob vibe.

The criminal justice system is there to keep dangerous people out of circulation, rehabilitate people wherever possible and act as a deterrent. If needs more funding to do the first two things. It's not there to satisfy the public's bloodlust when bad things happen.

Plus, even with DNA and forensics there is always scope for miscarriages of justice, people being fitted up etc. And capital punishment is very expensive to administer, lots of appeals and long waits and special facilities etc.

Do you really think someone considering murder thinks 'oh well, life in jail is not so bad, I wouldn't do this if the death penalty was in place?'

HeartsAndClubs · 06/12/2021 05:59

So you agree with murder just not all murder?

allyjay · 06/12/2021 05:56

There was a man on death row in the US, Louisiana I think it was, several years ago. He was there for murder. He was clearly from an under privileged back ground, had pretty severe learning difficulties and a mental age of a child. His case was highlighted in one of our papers. The article pointed out that he lacked the cognitive ability of an adult and that it was possible that he'd been pressured/coerced into confessing. It wasn't obvious that he'd even committed the crime.i wrote to the Governor of Louisana highlighting these points, as did presumably many others, but he was executed anyway. Do we really want THAT system over HERE?

EdgeOfTheSky · 06/12/2021 05:51

No.

A civilised society does not execute people. We cannot allow our own standards to be dictated by those who have no morals of their own.

Let life mean life, keep us safe from them, let them live without liberty or ability to do further harm.

BritWifeInUSA · 06/12/2021 05:48

Not every state in the US has capital punishment. My state recently abolished it. Has crime gone down? Nope. If anything, it’s increased. Having capital punishment or not makes no difference to peoples behavior.

Penners99 · 06/12/2021 05:47

Yes, in an instant.

Youhaveyourhandsfull · 06/12/2021 05:40

It’s not a deterrent, and it’s wrong. So, no.

Patapouf · 06/12/2021 05:38

Capital punishment is not an effective deterrent.

It wasn't stopped because of errors it was stopped because it's fucking barbaric and no matter how unthinkably awful the crime committed, as a society we cannot murder people.

loislovesstewie · 06/12/2021 05:28

The death penalty doesn't stop murder. Once upon a time people were tortured by the state and hung, drawn and quartered. It didn't stop people doing anything. I would suggest that people who commit crime, any crime don't expect to be caught. And sometimes they aren't. Neither do I believe that DNA is the miracle proof we all seek.

Swipe left for the next trending thread