Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/12/2021 15:53

I would be quite happy to be an executioner

….That's what anti-CP people misunderstand. An execution is as much an art as a science. It's a job that most people couldn't do very well, and that's fine. Society works because people have different skills.

Seek help, I beg you.

DrSbaitso · 09/12/2021 15:43

That's what anti-CP people misunderstand. An execution is as much an art as a science.

You think that's what we're objecting to? Lack of artistry?

5128gap · 09/12/2021 15:41

@MorningStarling

I would be quite happy to be an executioner, but no way would I ever be a prison officer. Prison officers have a very difficult job and are forever dealing with violence. An executioner is just a public servant in the same way a doctor or social worker is - just a human being, trained to do a job which is necessary for society to function.

Obviously the pay needs to be appropriate, one of James Berry's complaints was that he was paid by the job and there weren't always enough customers. He advocated a fixed annual salary which seems sensible. Maybe a combination of the two, a decent salary (say 100K?) plus a couple of grand per person executed. Before Berry, the executioner used to be able to keep the condemned's clothing and personal effects which could be sold for additional income. I don't think this aspect is correct and think the personal property should be returned along with the corpse to the executed person's family.

I have a good friend who is a prison officer, who is a thoroughly lovely man. I’d hate to think of him being given such a task.

I think this is the important thing, prison officer and executioner are two completely different jobs. No way should a prison officer be expected to carry out an actual execution, that is a different skill set entirely. Just as in a hospital the porter who brings the patient to the operating theatre is a different person to the one who performs the surgery. The prison officers would be in charge while the person awaited execution, and obviously assist in forcing them to the place of execution if they resisted. Then their job done, the executioner could perform their art.

That's what anti-CP people misunderstand. An execution is as much an art as a science. It's a job that most people couldn't do very well, and that's fine. Society works because people have different skills.

Execution as an art? What a very disturbing way to look at it.
LizzieW1969 · 09/12/2021 15:37

No, I was talking about the PP’s suggestion of making whole life prisoners’ lives a living misery, without any privileges, not capital punishment. I know that’s a different job (which I don’t think it’s fair to give anyone to do).

SexyBoris · 09/12/2021 15:33

I believe we should have the death sentence for anyone that kills a child

MorningStarling · 09/12/2021 15:30

I would be quite happy to be an executioner, but no way would I ever be a prison officer. Prison officers have a very difficult job and are forever dealing with violence. An executioner is just a public servant in the same way a doctor or social worker is - just a human being, trained to do a job which is necessary for society to function.

Obviously the pay needs to be appropriate, one of James Berry's complaints was that he was paid by the job and there weren't always enough customers. He advocated a fixed annual salary which seems sensible. Maybe a combination of the two, a decent salary (say 100K?) plus a couple of grand per person executed. Before Berry, the executioner used to be able to keep the condemned's clothing and personal effects which could be sold for additional income. I don't think this aspect is correct and think the personal property should be returned along with the corpse to the executed person's family.

I have a good friend who is a prison officer, who is a thoroughly lovely man. I’d hate to think of him being given such a task.

I think this is the important thing, prison officer and executioner are two completely different jobs. No way should a prison officer be expected to carry out an actual execution, that is a different skill set entirely. Just as in a hospital the porter who brings the patient to the operating theatre is a different person to the one who performs the surgery. The prison officers would be in charge while the person awaited execution, and obviously assist in forcing them to the place of execution if they resisted. Then their job done, the executioner could perform their art.

That's what anti-CP people misunderstand. An execution is as much an art as a science. It's a job that most people couldn't do very well, and that's fine. Society works because people have different skills.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 15:26

I’m not talking about your average prisoner, I’m talking about the likes of Bellfield, Couzens and anyone serving a whole life sentence as they will never be rehabilitated. Surely no prison officer would form any sort of relationship with scum like that? Why should prisoners like that have any more than the basic necessities?

And yes, those two are pure evil even if you don’t believe it exists.

LizzieW1969 · 09/12/2021 15:18

@5128gap

Yes that’s true enough. I have a good friend who is a prison officer, who is a thoroughly lovely man. I’d hate to think of him being given such a task. He would quit, as would other decent prison officers leaving only sadists staying on.

Considering how vulnerable a lot of prisoners are, that’s something we really shouldn’t allow to happen.

5128gap · 09/12/2021 14:49

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

Oh and there's a huge difference between an executioner putting someone to death and having to shove a plate of food through a hatch in a cell door 3 times a day.
Do you think that over the time of a long sentence no relationship develops between prisoners and their officers? That interactions are conducted in silence? Its really not the case. Officers and prisoners chat and interact, with many officers highly committed to the welfare and rehabilitation of prisoners. Its unfair to ask decent human beings to treat other people as caged animals to satisfy a thirst for revenge on the part of people who will never have to carry it out.
5128gap · 09/12/2021 14:44

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

I'm not suggesting they are abused or neglected *@5128gap*, just that they only have the basics they need - somewhere to sleep and 3 meals a day. Perhaps they could earn small extras for good behaviour but they shouldn't be a right.

BTW, I notice you put evil inverted commas. How else would you describe Bellfield, Couzens etc?

I was referring to you saying they should live their lives in misery without any special requirements met. I put 'evil' in inverted commas because I don't really care for it as a term. People commit horrendous crime for a variety of reasons, illness, diminished responsibility, greed, depravity. They are not suddenly possessed by the devil. Using the cover all term 'evil' is a lazy way of lumping perpetrators together by their deeds, rather than their motivations; and understanding motivation is important to prevention.
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 14:27

Oh and there's a huge difference between an executioner putting someone to death and having to shove a plate of food through a hatch in a cell door 3 times a day.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 14:26

I'm not suggesting they are abused or neglected @5128gap, just that they only have the basics they need - somewhere to sleep and 3 meals a day. Perhaps they could earn small extras for good behaviour but they shouldn't be a right.

BTW, I notice you put evil inverted commas. How else would you describe Bellfield, Couzens etc?

5128gap · 09/12/2021 14:13

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

I suppose the answer to that *@TheNinny* would be to keep them alive but without any comforts, just the basics. Don't pander to any special requirements that they decide they need. Make them live out their lives in misery. Bellfield (local to me, hence my interest in his case), Couzens etc gave up their rights the minute they killed those women.
People have already posted about the impact on executioners of carrying out their roles. I think it would be very unfair to expect prison officers to facilitate a life of misery and neglect of their charges. Its all very well advocating it from an armchair, but what sort of person would actually seek a job that involved seeing human beings, however 'evil' suffering daily, and bring instrumental in that? I'm sure there would be some, but probably not the sort of person who should actually be trusted in the role.
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 13:39

I suppose the answer to that @TheNinny would be to keep them alive but without any comforts, just the basics. Don't pander to any special requirements that they decide they need. Make them live out their lives in misery. Bellfield (local to me, hence my interest in his case), Couzens etc gave up their rights the minute they killed those women.

SamhainToImbolc · 09/12/2021 13:36

*death penalty.

DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes · 09/12/2021 13:36

@Ostagazuzulum

Who would be comfortable being an executioner.....
Precisely.

"The law of capital punishment falls with terrible weight upon the hangman and that to allow a man to follow such an occupation is doing him a deadly wrong…" So said Victorian executioner-turned-evangelist (and prominent campaigner for the abolition of the death penalty) James Berry. One only has to look at the case of Dr. Crippen’s executioner to see the truth in this. John Ellis suffered poor mental health after several years on the job. After a traumatic hanging in 1923 (he was forced to hang a woman who had passed out in terror, she then suffered a vaginal haemorrhage and lost a huge amount of blood, shocking onlookers) he didn’t last much longer in the job and took to heavy drinking and then the next spring, shot himself in the face.

He didn’t succeed in killing himself, but was given a suspended sentence for attempting suicide (which was a crime at the time). He later attempted suicide again and finally succeeded when he was just 57, leaving behind a wife, children and grandchildren.

TheNinny · 09/12/2021 13:33

I think people can do things so terrible, that their life is forfeit. So theoretically yes. I suppose the issue is how it’s applied and risk of false conviction. It’s never been a deterrent so I don’t buy that argument either for or against it. But Wayne couzens, little Arthur’s killers, paeodphiles who commit abhorrent abuse, serial killers….I just don’t see the point of keeping them alive 50 years in comfort.

SamhainToImbolc · 09/12/2021 13:32

Furthermore, I read a book about Ruth Ellis, the last woman to be hanged in England. Her executioner, Albert Pierrepont was quoted later as saying he believed the death was not a deterrent to murder.

SamhainToImbolc · 09/12/2021 13:29

No. It is never right to take another person's life, even if they are a proven murderer.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 13:26

I'd forgotten him @Stomacharmeleon. There will always be people who cannot be rehabilitated and unfortunately there will always be people who think we should try to rehabilitate them. The likes of Pitchfork and Bellfield should just be left to rot.

Stomacharmeleon · 09/12/2021 13:18

Exactly @PinkSparklyPussyCat and look at what happened with Colin pitchfork.

I did see an interview with Dominic rabb then and he said the rules were changing with parole and rather than an automatic right that prisoners have (and the state has to make a case for why they would be a risk) it will be the other way round.

Ostagazuzulum · 09/12/2021 12:57

Who would be comfortable being an executioner.....

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/12/2021 12:53

So the likes of Levi Bellfield could in theory be released? What a joke. Evil bastards like him should never see daylight again, let alone have the chance to be out of prison. No doubt some do gooders somewhere will think he could be rehabilitated but I think most people know what he is.

Stomacharmeleon · 09/12/2021 12:52

I am sure there are only between 30-40 full life tariff lifers in prison at the moment.
I do think tougher sentences and longer and I mean much longer periods would be better as a deterrent (some sentences are laughable)
I disagree they are any different to manage. Start with a basic bed and bog and you earn your privileges- you can lose them as easily as earn them.
But we do need better prisons and an overhaul of the system. We need to make it harder.

5128gap · 09/12/2021 11:36

@BluebelllsRosesDaffodills

5128gap- what about those on a ‘whole life’ tariff?

They still manage to control those, and they can never be released. They can take away visits and other privileges and put them in segregated cells as punishment

There are very few of these, and I believe even they are entitled to a review of their sentence after 25 years. So while unlikely, it isn't definite they will never be released.