Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
BeyondMyWits · 06/12/2021 08:35

No. Killing people is wrong.

Cam2020 · 06/12/2021 08:33

Absolutely not. State killing is completely barbaric.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/12/2021 08:28

No. I don’t want to live in a society where state sponsored murder is accepted. Countries with high death penalty rates are not safer or more just.

In addition the justice system is flawed, it is filled with fallible humans with all the foibles and biases that we all have. One wrongful execution would undermine the integrity of the whole system for me.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 08:26

I completely understand the sentiment behind the desire to bring back the death penalty, especially after hearing the harrowing details of the killing of Arthur.

But instead of responding by baying for someone’s blood, why don’t people put their energies into raising funds for children’s charities, lobbying the government for better support for struggling parents, role modelling compassionate behaviour to our own children?

Where is the logic in responding to a case of unimaginable cruelty by calling for a cruel and barbarous punishment for the perpetrator?

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/12/2021 08:22

If you concentrate on the idea that it's a Punishment rather than a deterrent (which we all know it's not) I can see the appeal to some people.

squashyhat · 06/12/2021 08:20

No

SlamLikeAGuitar · 06/12/2021 08:19

No.
The way I look at it, capital punishment has no place in a civilised society.
If, god forbid, I found myself in the position where a member of my family had been murdered, I’d want to know that the perpetrator was spending the rest of their life in prison, spending every day fearing for their safety. Prisons aren’t safe places. And when it comes to high profile cases - Emma Tustin for example - that particular brand of scum have a lot to be fearful about.
Capital punishment removes all the suffering those people deserve to feel in the blink of an eye. I’d rather see their punishment dragged out.

LadyCampanulaTottington · 06/12/2021 08:18

Tempting but no.

I would like to see a more punishing sentence than just incarceration. Hard labour for example.

ToughTittyWhompus · 06/12/2021 08:15

No. To quote Jessica Jones:

“There are worse things than death. Once you’re worm food, it’s over. Painless. Quiet. Whilst the rest of us are stuck digging holes, picking up the pieces. Remembering.”

What I would like to see is proper punishment. No concurrent sentences. More whole life tariffs. 23 hours a day stuck in a cell with nothing but the bare basics.

FreezerBird · 06/12/2021 08:14

@Seafog

I don't support capital punishment because it can't be undone. I would love to see flogging brought back though.
This makes no sense. Flogging can't be undone any more than the death penalty.
ManicPixie · 06/12/2021 08:14

No. People who want it are full of bloodlust (see the recent Arthur case) and that’s not a good foundation for such an important law.

Still, the way things have gone in this country nothing would surprise me.

thepeopleversuswork · 06/12/2021 08:10

Absolutely not. It's not an adequate deterrent, it costs the justice and penal system vast amounts of money and its not something civilized countries do.

DeadButDelicious · 06/12/2021 08:09

No. Never.

It is not a deterrent. It's state sanctioned murder. It's uncivilized. It's morally reprehensible. Any error is too grave a mistake to make.

Would those calling for it to come back be happy to be the ones 'pulling the trigger'? What does that say about you? And how keen you are to kill?

Life in prison should mean just that in some cases. Some people are too dangerous to have wandering around free. Killing them is not the answer.

wombat1a · 06/12/2021 08:06

I think some of it depends on how you do it, where I am at the moment - and no I don't get the vote here - if someone is sentenced to death then it is carried out within a month. The death penalty is given by the supreme court after they have reviewed the case from the high court where the high court judge has recommended that penalty. There is no jury system here such as in the UK, there is a panel of 5 judges who decide guilty/innocent and the sentence.

As a system in that you do not have a long appeals process and the penalty is given only in clear cut cases - ie the murderer is caught on CCTV doing it and then later with the knife/blood on hands etc. Also drug dealers/smugglers here can be sentenced to death too.

RobinPenguins · 06/12/2021 07:45

No. Capital punishment has no place in a civilised society. It doesn’t act as a deterrent. Capital trials are expensive and lengthy. Miscarriages of justice still occur, even with scientific advances in evidence. It’s just a fucking awful idea all round.

Outlyingtrout · 06/12/2021 07:44

I would rather see a complete overhaul of the justice and prison systems. Reintroducing the death sentence would be a sticking plaster that does nothing but appeal to people's base instincts.

I think a lot of people end up in prison serving very short sentences who don't need to be there. I'm thinking about people such as all the women who are in prison for crimes like theft and fraud which they have often committed to support the drug habit of a male partner. A lot of these kinds of crimes would be prevented if we had a fairer society. The women who end up in prison are overwhelmingly from extremely vulnerable backgrounds. I would support other means of preventing these kinds of crimes. I don't believe prison is the solution. If we could free up space and resources in prisons by reducing low level crime in other ways, then we would be able to properly manage serious offenders.

There are certain crimes that should always, in my opinion, attract a whole of life tariff. Any murder with a sexual motive. Child murder. I would like to also say rape and child rape, but I think that punishing these offences to the full extent of the law actually encourages offenders to murder their victims in order to remove the key witness (I.e. I've already crossed the threshold for the maximum sentence possible - there's nothing further to lose by killing this person and reducing my chances of being caught). This one troubles me though as I don't think a rapist can ever be safely released. Nor do I think a paedophile can ever be rehabilitated.

I'd also like to see concurrent sentences scrapped. If you have committed several crimes then you should be serving each sentence that is handed down. Having sentences run concurrently just means that only the longest sentence is actually served and the other crimes go unpunished.

We also need to invest heavily in rehabilitation of prisoners who are not serving whole life tariffs. If we intend to release somebody at some point in the future then we need to have significantly reduced the likelihood that they will reoffend. At the moment prisons are not fit for purpose. We are just turning people back out onto the streets who have achieved nothing during their incarceration other than to become better acquainted with and submerged in a criminal lifestyle.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 07:41

Also, it doesn't get applied equally. Have a think about which people will be more likely to be sentenced to death for the same offence...

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 07:40

Some cases do tempt me, but no. Hard cases make bad laws.

There are some things it isn't the state's place to do and the cost is too high.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 06/12/2021 07:34

@RilkeanHeart

No. Some people do abhorrent and barbaric things. The state shouldn’t do abhorrent and barbaric things in response.
Completely agree with this. A state should not lower itself to the level of murderers.
youvemademyshitlist · 06/12/2021 07:33

Some crimes are so abhorrent that they provoke an emotional response in people when they hear about it. It's understandable that those emotions make us think that the perpetrators shouldn't live anymore.
But I don't think state sanctioned murder is right, and I don't think it's a deterrent.
I wonder if those advocating for capital punishment would be willing to take the job? And spend their working life putting people to death? Could you actually do that?
Or are you happy to call for it as long as someone else actually does the deed?

It dose annoy my that in the UK sentences for multiple charges are served concurrently, what's the point? In Arthur's case, the charges for cruelty and the charges of murder and manslaughter should be served consecutively, they won't be in prison thinking about the number of crimes they're serving time for, they're just in prison. So the length of time should be increased to reflect the crimes they've done, the victims of these crimes deserve that.

Okbutnotgreat · 06/12/2021 07:30

I must admit I can see the attraction. Prisoners get a far better quality of life than my DM in a funded care home. There is far more staff, they have access to all sorts of enrichment and get medical treatment when needed. I’m pretty sure the food couldn’t be any worse either. When Covid19 was at its worst were they prevented from seeing their loved ones totally for months on end or was it their human right to have contact.

Personally I don’t think prison in this country is much of a deterrent to those who are that way inclined and I’m not sure why they deserve to live when their victims didn’t. Let’s save a few billion and make old age better for the ones who didn’t do anything wrong maybe. There’s not an infinite pot of money and I think maybe it should be spent on those who’ve lived a more law abiding life.

FelinaDaHousecat · 06/12/2021 07:29

Think about if from this viewpoint:

Killing another human is the ultimate crime in our society. The ultimate taboo in many respects.

The state is the guardian of our justice and morality.

Can the state kill and appropriate the ultimate crime for itself?

In other words, if killing humans is so bad, why can the state do it?

For me, the answer to this dilemma will always be NO.

More death does not resolve a death.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 06/12/2021 07:29

@RilkeanHeart

No. Some people do abhorrent and barbaric things. The state shouldn’t do abhorrent and barbaric things in response.
This.
icedcoffees · 06/12/2021 07:23

No, for several reasons.

  • one innocent person being killed by the state is one person too many.
  • it's not a deterrent.
  • it's more expensive to keep someone on death row than it is to have them spend their lives in prison due to all the appeals etc.
  • you can't murder someone because you think murder is wrong. The logic there is all kinds of messed up.
  • why would you want to live in a society where it's the states' right to end your life?
clarepetal · 06/12/2021 07:22

No. In case they get it wrong, also, an eye for an eye and the world is blind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread