Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 06/12/2021 09:17

No, for me I want them to suffer. Not for seconds but for a life time. Jail needs to be as heinous as possible for the worst offenders.

Aussiegirl123456 · 06/12/2021 09:16

@ErickBroch

So many people who want to bring back capital punishment are also against compulsory vaccinations/maskwearing/anything coronavirus-forced because of too much state control. The irony.
Where did you get the research to establish that correlation?
DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 09:15

@EnidFrighten

And also, the question: does this person deserve to live? is a different question to: should this person be killed by the state?
That's a brilliant way of putting it.
ErickBroch · 06/12/2021 09:12

So many people who want to bring back capital punishment are also against compulsory vaccinations/maskwearing/anything coronavirus-forced because of too much state control. The irony.

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 09:08

And also, the question: does this person deserve to live? is a different question to: should this person be killed by the state?

EnidFrighten · 06/12/2021 09:07

The people who commit the most horrible offences have often had terrible backgrounds themselves. Read up about the childhoods of the likes of Rosemary West and Fred West.

It does not excuse their crimes but they are messed up people who have had terrible things done to them as well as doing awful things themselves. Better social services would be a much better use of money than the death penalty.

anxiouswaiting · 06/12/2021 09:03

Many times I have heard of horrific crimes and thought the perpetrator deserves capital punishment.

But of course there is still room for error and it would lead to innocent people who are wrongly convicted dying and that can never be ok - that is why I couldn't get on board with returning to capital punishment.

I do however think that life should mean exactly that - little Arther likely had another 70+ years ahead of him, that evil woman has a sentence of just 29 years. She will be out before it's time to get her pension, she still has a life to look forward to and that is not ok, highly insulting to that poor little boy.

threebillboards · 06/12/2021 09:00

No, it's barbaric.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 08:59

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

I have mixed feelings. Prisons are very expensive to run and sentences are absurdly lenient in many cases - due to them running concurrently. I don’t really believe that child killers snd paedophiles and rapists can be rehabilitated; it’s shown time and time again when they are released and reoffend. I resent my taxes paying for these scum in prison. Maybe prisons need a tier system re comfortability; really serious crimes could have more of a Victorian, bread and water, straw mattress element. Lesser crimes less awful living conditions. There’s no easy solution.
Research done in the US shows it is significantly more expensive to execute someone than to incarcerate them for life. Yes, that’s due to the lengthy appeals process, but if you decide to shorten that, you risk executing more innocent people.
SelfIdentifiedRightsHoarder · 06/12/2021 08:56

I agree that a life sentence should mean, life spent in prison for certain people rather than life on license. From an ethical and logical standpoint, no I don't think capital punishment should ever be brought back. How can you say that killing someone is wrong, and then kill them to show how wrong killing is? It just doesn't make sense. Who gets to decide what actions/circumstances are deemed 'enough' to justify intentionally killing in some situations?

CSJobseeker · 06/12/2021 08:56

I find it appalling and depressing that 21% have voted YANBU. 21% of MN thinks that state sanctioned murder is acceptable.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 06/12/2021 08:56

Of course it would not make a good deterrent, it doesn't in countries that do have it, look at the US.

I would never support the return of capital punishment.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 08:56

I have mixed feelings. Prisons are very expensive to run and sentences are absurdly lenient in many cases - due to them running concurrently. I don’t really believe that child killers snd paedophiles and rapists can be rehabilitated; it’s shown time and time again when they are released and reoffend. I resent my taxes paying for these scum in prison. Maybe prisons need a tier system re comfortability; really serious crimes could have more of a Victorian, bread and water, straw mattress element. Lesser crimes less awful living conditions. There’s no easy solution.

dworky · 06/12/2021 08:56

The deterrent argument has no validity. American states with the death penalty do not have lower murder rates.

user1471505494 · 06/12/2021 08:53

OP nobody is ever released from prison for good behaviour. The sentence given often includes a proportion served on probation

CSJobseeker · 06/12/2021 08:53

No way, not ever. Bringing back the death penalty would stop us from being able to call ourselves a civilised society.

Everybody 'knew' that Gerry Conlon and the rest of the Guildford Four were definitely guilty. Except they weren't.

BlueFlavour · 06/12/2021 08:49

No. An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
I do think there should be longer sentences for violent and sexual crimes.

tara66 · 06/12/2021 08:48

The thing about capital punishment is that it makes the state a ''murderer''.

pointythings · 06/12/2021 08:46

No, for the simple reason that even one innocent person executed is too many. Look at how it works in the US - a deeply racist system where if you're black, you're likely to have poorer legal representation and be punished more harshly for the same crime than if you're white. Let's not be naive and think it would be any different here.

Also anyone thinking this would be a good idea should look up the case of Stefan Kiszko.

MrsColon · 06/12/2021 08:45

It's a terrible idea, and not just because mistakes are made - it costs millions per individual on death row because of the huge legal burden and appeals. Much cheaper to let scumbags rot in prison.

IncompleteSenten · 06/12/2021 08:42

No. I think a society needs to be better than its worst members.

Level75 · 06/12/2021 08:42

It's the sign of a backwards country (and backwards thinking) to want capital punishment. I can't believe so many people have voted yanbu.

Google the list of countries that still have it and consider whether they are the places we want to emulate.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 06/12/2021 08:40

Absolutely not.

There is evidence to suggest that certain criminal actions are made significantly worse where a country has capital punishment; especially child abuse and rape cases.

The perpetrators either go further than they otherwise would trying to cover up evidence because they know if they get caught they'll be put to death or they fall into the 'might as well be hanged for a sheep as for a lamb' thought process.

So 100% no. I actually think capital punishment would lead to more children and women being murdered.

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 08:39

No.

Aside from the never ending fact that too many black men are arrested and imprisoned for crimes they didn't commit, there are miscarriages of justice in other areas too.

Would Sally Challon be alive now if we had capital punishment?

Iggly · 06/12/2021 08:37

Priti Patel supported capital punishment and that’s enough for me to not 😂

In all seriousness; it is not a deterrent. Any countries with capital punishment should make that obvious and I’m always rolling my eyes at people that ask.

Personally I think awful crimes are a failure of our society to protect the vulnerable. Too much focus on the perpetrators after the event and not enough on providing safeguarding measures to stop this happening in the first place.

You’ll always get crime and even more crime when you have a shitty unequal society. How does more killing via the state help?

Swipe left for the next trending thread