Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
changingstages · 06/12/2021 09:54

good grief, absolutely fucking not and if this becomes a serious debate in this country we are finished. Fucking hell.

YokoOnosHat · 06/12/2021 09:52

Literally all research indicates that capital punishment acts as no deterrent to capital crimes.

All it does is pile death and criminality onto death and criminality. Whole life tariffs for sure, but prison is as much about rehabilitation as punishment. Now, some criminals will never be rehabilitated into society but they will be rehabilitated in terms of finding a wider purpose, education, receiving therapy. A civilised society has a moral obligation to provide that for its convicted criminals.

LizzieW1969 · 06/12/2021 09:50

@SlamLikeAGuitar

No. The way I look at it, capital punishment has no place in a civilised society. If, god forbid, I found myself in the position where a member of my family had been murdered, I’d want to know that the perpetrator was spending the rest of their life in prison, spending every day fearing for their safety. Prisons aren’t safe places. And when it comes to high profile cases - Emma Tustin for example - that particular brand of scum have a lot to be fearful about. Capital punishment removes all the suffering those people deserve to feel in the blink of an eye. I’d rather see their punishment dragged out.
This is true. And there’s also the fact that a lot of these killers attempt suicide once in prison. (Emma Tustin has already attempted this.) Capital punishment would arguably be giving them what they want.

I’m against capital punishment for other reasons, but it is something for those arguing in favour of it to consider.

My view is that life should mean life for those who commit such heinous crimes.

QuizzlyBear · 06/12/2021 09:50

@Okbutnotgreat

I must admit I can see the attraction. Prisoners get a far better quality of life than my DM in a funded care home. There is far more staff, they have access to all sorts of enrichment and get medical treatment when needed. I’m pretty sure the food couldn’t be any worse either. When Covid19 was at its worst were they prevented from seeing their loved ones totally for months on end or was it their human right to have contact.

Personally I don’t think prison in this country is much of a deterrent to those who are that way inclined and I’m not sure why they deserve to live when their victims didn’t. Let’s save a few billion and make old age better for the ones who didn’t do anything wrong maybe. There’s not an infinite pot of money and I think maybe it should be spent on those who’ve lived a more law abiding life.

Except it costs more to keep prisoners on death row than to keep them in prison for decades.
gannett · 06/12/2021 09:49

@HalfWomanHalfMincePie

No, never.

I understand the human urge for revenge when they see an appalling wrong/crime committed. I feel it myself and half imagine how satisfying it might be to really hurt someone back after seeing them hurt another.

But I want and need the law to be better than that.

Exactly.

It's not about whether a criminal deserves capital punishment - it's about what dealing out capital punishment turns us into.

I understand the fury and the emotion that makes you want to kill someone you think is evil. I'm 100% sure I could fire a bullet into Jair Bolsonaro myself and never feel a twinge of guilt.

I don't want that emotion to be enshrined in law. I want to be protected from it.

Overtime2019 · 06/12/2021 09:49

Of course it should be brought back if you take a life then your life should also be taken

Iggly · 06/12/2021 09:47

@AndStand

Even Albert Pierrepoint, the UK's last hangman stated that capital punishment wasn't a deterrent. He even had to hang someone who personally knew Albert, it hadn't deterred him from murdering. However in cases where it's so cut and dried, like Emma Tustin or Ian Huntley I'd have no objection purely on a monetary basis. It'd save millions of pounds in prison costs.
The problem though is it isn’t always cut and dried and it doesn’t make you much better, if you’re prepared to advocate for murder. It is murder, give it a different name of capital punishment but it remains murder.
AndStand · 06/12/2021 09:45

Even Albert Pierrepoint, the UK's last hangman stated that capital punishment wasn't a deterrent. He even had to hang someone who personally knew Albert, it hadn't deterred him from murdering.
However in cases where it's so cut and dried, like Emma Tustin or Ian Huntley I'd have no objection purely on a monetary basis. It'd save millions of pounds in prison costs.

QuizzlyBear · 06/12/2021 09:45

@Penners99

Yes, in an instant.
Your eagerness to see people murdered by the state is pretty disturbing.
BigYellowHat · 06/12/2021 09:41

I just can’t say yes to it I’m afraid. It doesn’t matter if only one innocent person every century is put to death, it’s one too many. Think about it, if someone is put into jail at 18 and knows they’ve got 50 plus years in jail, surely it’s more of a punishment to be stuck in a 6x9 cell eating shit food. Imagine the boredom and depression, sounds like hell on Earth to me. Personally, I’d rather be executed so don’t give them the easy way out.

QuizzlyBear · 06/12/2021 09:41

I'm also afraid that she won't have too bad of a time in prison

She'll be in a prison filled with women who are separated from their children - and she abused and murdered a little boy. She'll be eviscerated.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 06/12/2021 09:40

No, never.

I understand the human urge for revenge when they see an appalling wrong/crime committed. I feel it myself and half imagine how satisfying it might be to really hurt someone back after seeing them hurt another.

But I want and need the law to be better than that.

FallingStar21 · 06/12/2021 09:38

i don't think CP can be much of a deterrent sadly. These people either think they are too clever, that they'd get a lighter sentence, or simply don't care/can't stop themselves.

What it could improve though is:

a) Murderers not able to come out after lenient, concurrent sentences and murder again.

b) Prisons won't be so overcrowded

c) Huge amounts of tax payers' money saved, rather than spent on keeping monsters alive. That money better spent on children services.

If CP is to come back though, must be only in 100% proven, particularly awful cases (e.g. Cousens, Hughes and Tustin).

GoldenBlue · 06/12/2021 09:35

There are people that don't deserve to live.

However I can't support the death penalty as I believe asking someone to kill someone else in order to deliver this judgement will permanently harm them.

I don't think it is right to ask that of anyone and I would be uncomfortable with people that volunteered to deliver a death sentence

FuckinGoddess · 06/12/2021 09:35

Tustin attempted suicide - capital punishment would be a gift to her, you’d be giving her what she wants.

Do you really want to give her what she wants, an easy way out, so she won’t have to live out her days behind bars, and really pay for what she’s done?

Ozanj · 06/12/2021 09:34

Where capital punishment exists people are more likely to murder their victims to avoid capture. Eg in India ever since capital punishment was introduced for rape (including child rape) the rate of murders of victims has also increased. One of my cousins is a Police Inspector and he said he and his colleagues have dealt with more female and child murders (that have combined rape etc) after the legal changes were introduced than before; whereas previously when a child was kidnapped they knew they could have 24 hours to find them before they were were harmed.

But from an emotional perspective, if it didn’t result in more murders, then yes I would love to see it return for the worst crimes. But then, having said that, I’m sure Arthur’s murderers will need to watch their backs in prison as murdering them may become a badge of honour to all the other inmates & that lifetime of terror might be a more appropriate punishment.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 06/12/2021 09:33

@CounsellorTroi

Never. No place for it in a civilised society.
This
SpiderinaWingMirror · 06/12/2021 09:32

Nope.
Too many miscarriages of justice.
Plus. Rest of life in prison as a marked child murderer seems a more fitting punishment to me for that vile specimen. I don't beleive in heaven or hell so having an injection and going to sleep is no punishment at all for me.

BlueFlavour · 06/12/2021 09:30

@Pinksloth
I completely agree. Early intervention needs to be prioritised. And where appropriate restorative justice. That’s where the money should be going.

Fatandfifty49 · 06/12/2021 09:27

I understand people's emotions around the death penalty. Truly. But I think we need to get to this at a far deeper level. What has gone so wrong in our society that there are people that think this is OK to treat your children like this?

Pinksloth · 06/12/2021 09:23

No. It's barbaric and no criminal justice system is foolproof. Plus it's not a deterrent and costs a lot of money anyway with all the appeals.

I'd much rather see more money put into social services. Have judges overrule experts less in cases of child cruelty/neglect. Have more money put into supporting vulnerable families (not saying that would have helped in the most heinous cases but might have freed up time for SWs to devote to these kind of cases).

Topseyt · 06/12/2021 09:23

@ErickBroch

So many people who want to bring back capital punishment are also against compulsory vaccinations/maskwearing/anything coronavirus-forced because of too much state control. The irony.
What bollocks. There is zero connection between capital punishment and Covid issues.

I am against the return of capital punishment for all of the reasons stated in my first post on this thread and further ones given by others. That doesn't make us all anti-vaxxers or any such nonsense.

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 09:20

Never. No place for it in a civilised society.

BaublesAndGlitter · 06/12/2021 09:20

I used to think CP should be brought back however, the amount of people in America who are wrongly convicted and later exonerated is too high - and that's only the people who manage to get good lawyers and court dates etc before their time is up. I don't like to think about the amount of people who get killed while innocent but unable to make anybody listen.

I know that's America and it's a little different here because prosecutors aren't necessarily trying to make a name for themselves or get re-elected but I think there is too big a chance of error.

What I would like to see would be proper sentences (I am a supporter of the American sentencing of 100years etc) so the victim / victims family can be reassured that person isn't getting out.
Plus I don't think prisons should be quite as relaxed as they are. I don't want slave labour / chain gangs etc but I do think you should be made to do something useful to society while you're in there.

Bluntness100 · 06/12/2021 09:17

@ErickBroch

So many people who want to bring back capital punishment are also against compulsory vaccinations/maskwearing/anything coronavirus-forced because of too much state control. The irony.
Um what? There’s obsession with Covid and then there is this. Provide a link to that research please.
Swipe left for the next trending thread