Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
OooohAhhhh · 06/12/2021 10:24

Also the media play a very influential part on wether someone gets a fair trial or not.

Biscuitsneeded · 06/12/2021 10:23

God no. It's barbaric, and absolutely not a deterrent, otherwise those US states that still have the death penalty would have no murders, which clearly isn't the case.

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 10:23

In my (inexpert opinion) there are 4 broad categories of criminals:

Crimes that happen in a moment that if that moment hadn't happened, those people would probably never have been criminals e.g.
A lapse of concentration when driving
Getting pulled into a bar fight not of your making and killing someone because they had an unexpected medical condition
An abused person killing their abuser (not exactly the same, but essentially the abused person would be unlikely to be a criminal if they weren't being abused)
etc

Longer sentencing and capital punishment will not reduce this

More educations about consequences, greater police presence (unbiased police presence), greater funding for domestic violence victims, earlier better police intervention may help. Also potentially more education in youngsters, particularly boys to help encourage them not to use violence as a solution.

This is where a prison sentence is almost more of a penance than anything else, a debt to society because these people are highly unlikely to commit another crime.

Crimes of circumstance
If you put people in poverty, with little to no job opportunities, poor educations, a lack of positive role models, with parents who have little time to parent due to trying to survive and provide in poverty, then crime is all but inevitable to an extent.

Longer sentencing and capital punishment will not reduce this.

Better benefits, no zero hours contracts, a living minimum wage, long term investment in education in deprived areas, smaller class sizes, government incentives to bring jobs and free/subsidised sporting options. Bring in IT companies to teach coding, sports companies to teach sports, construction companies to teach construction skills etc. Provide real tangible ways for people to escape poverty and crime. It wont cut down all crime it will reduce it.

If it gets to prison then this is where rehabilitation is much more likely to reduce re-offending than a pure punishment

People with mental illnesses which now end up in the prison system due to poor funding of support services

Longer sentencing and capital punishment will not reduce this type of crime.

Greater funding in mental health, alcoholic and drug rehabilitation services etc will do. Anyone can end up in this category, everyone who has ever had an alcoholic drink had the potential to be an alcoholic, its just medically they aren't. There are parts of the brain/genes etc which dictate can this. And people can be helped, not thrown in prison then released to start the same cycle again.

This is where medical rehabilitation is of more benefit than punishment

Psychopaths
People who rape and kill and fight and steal because they can. Not because they need to, or have been brought up to but because there is something wrong in their brain which means they do.

Longer sentences and capital punishment will not deter these people.

However longer sentences are potentially the only way to prevent reoffences happening. (My personal opinion is that psychopaths are in fact a subset of group 3, in that its a brain wiring issue and a secure medical facility where people are not released unless their medical, in this case mental, issue is shown to be cured, in the same way as people who end up in institutions for crimes due to medical insanity etc, would be the appropriate result)

In general longer sentencing will not prove a deterrent. However early years intervention, money spent on eradicating poverty, greater opportunity and proper rehabilitation can.

So if you are advocating money spent on longer sentencing over money spent on preventing punishment then you are essentially enjoying meting out punishment over stopping crime, that does not make you a good person.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 06/12/2021 10:21

@afaloren

Absolutely not, and it has nothing to do with people maybe being found innocent later. I am just fundamentally opposed, regardless of guilt. I do understand that there are some crimes which seem to horrific imprisonment doesn’t seem like ‘enough’ but in a civilised society there is no place for CP.
Agree.

I think as a civilised and compassionate society we have to accept that a chunk of our money and time resources must go towards responsibly dealing people who operate outside of it.

And yes, I do believe that includes the humane treatment of prisoners, attempts at rehabilitation (which doesn't mean what a lot of people think it means) and a robust courts and justice system, with checks and balances for human error and abuses.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 10:21

A jury is likely to subconsciously set a higher burden of proof if they know that a conviction will lead to death.

If I were a juror, there'd be nothing subconscious about it. I'd be very aware and deliberate in doing it.

OooohAhhhh · 06/12/2021 10:20

No, because of miscarriages of justice. The risk is too big. There have been plenty in the past.
Also it is very unethical. The law says murder is a crime, yet the state take it upon themselves to murder people. It gains nothing, as people still continue to commit crimes punishable by death. There is no evidence to say capital punishment works. The system needs to look into rehabilitation for offenders more. This shows more success than the death penalty. I'm not talking about those that have committed the worse crimes to be let back into society, but more concentrating on programmes for adults in jail, courses, employment within jail etc. This has the potential to stop them from committing crime within prison also, as they feel a sense of self worth etc.
Also there is a psychological reason as well, many people who commit the worse crimes have had a troubled childhood. There is usually a trail relating back to their childhood. This has been proven to have a negative psychological effect later on in life. As a result they repel these negative emotions later on in life, by committing crime. They have developed mental health issues, so instead of the state just killing them they are overlooking psychological issues. These people need help.
The death penalty will never return in the UK.
Many countries around the world are starting to abolish the death penalty too.

CSJobseeker · 06/12/2021 10:19

I think I've read that there is evidence that this was the effect when CP was last legal. Not sure where I read it though.

CSJobseeker · 06/12/2021 10:18

I suspect some jurors might be reluctant to convict if they thought execution was a likely outcome

This is true. A jury is likely to subconsciously set a higher burden of proof if they know that a conviction will lead to death. So more killers will be found not guilty.

Think about it - you're a juror, and you're pretty sure the person you are trying is guilty. Lets say you're 90-95% sure. That's probably beyond reasonable doubt, and normally enough to make you vote 'guilty, but is it enough to make you sign their death warrant?

afaloren · 06/12/2021 10:17

Absolutely not, and it has nothing to do with people maybe being found innocent later. I am just fundamentally opposed, regardless of guilt. I do understand that there are some crimes which seem to horrific imprisonment doesn’t seem like ‘enough’ but in a civilised society there is no place for CP.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 10:16

Where are people getting this info re Tustin?

ArabellaScott · 06/12/2021 10:15

There is no credible argument for the death penalty, and many very strong arguments against it.

FuckinGoddess · 06/12/2021 10:15

Also if it makes you feel any better, Tustin is already being bullied by fellow inmates - having salt thrown at her, for example, and I’m fairly sure there’s more waiting for her as time goes on. 😊

As things are, Tustin has decades at least or maybe a lifetime of being bullied and suffering ahead of her. If she was killed, she would not suffer and would not need to worry about being bullied. She would feel no fear, no anxiety, no sadness, no stress, no pain, nothing. Cause she’s be dead. Which I too would choose if the alternative was suffering... that’s why Tustin must live.

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 10:12

@Guavaf1sh

As Barack Obama said in his second book - sometimes the abhorrence of a particular crime is such that capital punishment is the only way for society to express its anger and indignation. So it’s for the good of society that it is done in certain very specific cases. Would I be pleased to see Tustin hanged? Yes. It seems like the right thing. For everyone. Including her
So you'll hang the assassin, how about the man who gave the order.

Is it not more abhorrent that the child's own father encouraged, participated, celebrated the abuse, then sent a message "just end him" to the person who dealt the final blow?

The problem is that true evil often uses others' hands.

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 06/12/2021 10:10

No.

Guavaf1sh · 06/12/2021 10:09

As Barack Obama said in his second book - sometimes the abhorrence of a particular crime is such that capital punishment is the only way for society to express its anger and indignation. So it’s for the good of society that it is done in certain very specific cases. Would I be pleased to see Tustin hanged? Yes. It seems like the right thing. For everyone. Including her

Toofuckingearly · 06/12/2021 10:09

100 % no

Idolovetrees · 06/12/2021 10:08

No I don't think it is right to kill anybody regardless of what they have done.

Pyewackect · 06/12/2021 10:04

If there is no restoration of capital pumishment, as I doubt it will ever get through parliament, then a life sentence should mean life , irrespective of your age or sex : you die in prision, behind bars and in solitary confiment, if necessary.

We need a justice system, not just a legal framework.

Sittingonabench · 06/12/2021 10:03

I go back and forth on this issue regularly. For me there are behaviours that are unacceptable in society - theft, aggression, fraud etc. For which jail is appropriate along with reparations such as paying the money back and behavioural support such as anger management. But then there are a few occasions where that person is not acceptable in society - where there is little to no hope of helping them understand the impact of their behaviour and they will refuse to change. In this case I don’t see how prison or any amount of support is going to change their behaviour and yes I think the best thing for society is capital punishment.
But then the arguments against are definitely something to think on. That rape turns into murder, that society itself becomes morally corrupt, that sometimes the system (particularly an underfunded system) gets it wrong.
I don’t necessarily believe it is or is not a deterrent and if you’ve got to the point where it needs deterring like that then the poison is already there and society is so big that it is too far removed to encourage change. It’s such a tricky topic. It’s good to talk about it though, even though every time it is talked about I get less certain of the right thing.

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 10:01

I dont believe in hitting children to stop them from hitting others, I dont believe in biting children to stop the from biting others, I dont believe in murdering people to stop them murdering others

LakieLady · 06/12/2021 10:00

@Aussiegirl123456

I think if there’s absolutely zero doubt that the perp committed a heinous crime then yes.

I mean zero doubt though, so not just relying on DNA evidence alone if there’s a million to one chance it could have been planted, a set up or a coincidence.

I know a million people will disagree though.

Where I live, years ago a young teenage boy was lured into a car, sexually assaulted and killed. His killer is frequently tortured in prison despite being in protective custody. That makes me guiltily happy he’s still alive to suffer. I don’t even care if that makes me sound heartless.

When juries convict, they do so on the basis that they believe the case against the accused has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt, but there have still been numerous wrongful convictions.

Just think of the number of innocent people who would have wrongly executed had we had capital punishment: Guildford Four, Birmingham 6, Maguire 7, Tottenham 3, Bridgewater 3, Stefan Kiszco, Judith Ward, M25 3 - and that's just off the top of my head.

Someone's DNA can be at the scene of a crime because they were there for innocent reasons totally unconnected with the murder.

And I suspect some jurors might be reluctant to convict if they thought execution was a likely outcome.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 06/12/2021 09:56

I voted YANBU but having thought about it more i think it would be giving these heinous people what they want, as a lot of them would prefer a fairly instant, painless sort of death over spending time in prison. I do think sentences should be longer though and child murderers should have to do life.

Outlyingtrout · 06/12/2021 09:56

The problem though is it isn’t always cut and dried and it doesn’t make you much better, if you’re prepared to advocate for murder. It is murder, give it a different name of capital punishment but it remains murder.

I don't agree with capital punishment for many reasons, but this argument is not going to win anybody round if they do. The kinds of criminals that people generally tend to want CP restored for are people who rape and murder children. People who torture and murder children. Serial killers. To accuse people like those on this thread who support the idea of CP of being "not much better" than these depraved and evil people is really quite offensive. The crime of raping and murdering a small child is infinitely, immeasurably worse than advocating for the execution of someone who has committed that crime.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 09:55

@Overtime2019

Of course it should be brought back if you take a life then your life should also be taken
What’s your solution for ensuring no innocent person is ever put to death then?
ChaToilLeam · 06/12/2021 09:55

I do not want to see CP return. It is clear that it is no deterrent, and it has no place in a civilized society. Miscarriages of justice still happen and you can release a wrongly imprisoned person, but you cannot bring someone back to life once executed. I would like to see the worst criminals permanently out of circulation, that means properly long or full life sentences, and conversely we should stop imprisoning people for failure to pay fines and other minor, non-violent crimes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread