Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 10:57

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentencing_disparity

BoredZelda · 06/12/2021 10:56

It would be a money saving experience.

It doesn’t save money.

RedToothBrush · 06/12/2021 10:55

No. Never. Not for any reason.

5keletor · 06/12/2021 10:55

I wouldn't want it, for a few reasons. I'm against the "eye for an eye" mentality, it solves nothing. There is also too much potential for miscarriage of justice and people being wrongly executed.

EmeraldShamrock · 06/12/2021 10:55

Also, we have a justice system which is systemically racist and sexist, where women and people of colour get handed out disproportionally harsher sentences than white men for example
100%.

BoredZelda · 06/12/2021 10:54

Nope.

There is no evidence of deterrent. It is way more costly than keeping someone in prison. People want it for revenge, not for punishment.

We are supposed to be a civilised nation. Killing criminals isn’t civilised.

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 10:54

I think the death penalty is slowly dying g out in the US. 27 states currently have the death penalty and of those many rarely use it. 3 of those states that have it are under moratorium.

23 states have abolished it.

deathpenaltyinfo.org/state-and-federal-info/state-by-state

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 10:54

*That Hughes arsehole ordered the murder of his own son and was convicted only for manslaughter, 21 years.

His girlfriend, who did the murder he demanded was convicted of murder and won't see light of day for at least 29 years*

That’s not sexist: they are fundamentally different crimes they each committed. Both are as abhorrent as the other but one is murder and one is not. The crimes carry different sentencing snd different tariffs.

EmeraldShamrock · 06/12/2021 10:53

It would be a money saving experience.

Very controversial however I'm an eye for an eye person, some killers deserve death for their crime.

I like to see some have the pain they've inflicted on another used against them.

The innocent people is the only reason I'd be against it, especially in countries where they have police brutally lying and planting evidence without question.

Chasingaftermidnight · 06/12/2021 10:53

No, personally I wouldn’t. Mainly because it necessitates an endless appeals process which winds up being extremely expensive for the taxpayer.

Lifeisforalimitedperiodonly · 06/12/2021 10:53

I used to agree with the death penalty but I've changed my mind. I read that Pierrepoint (who pulled the trap door on many a murderer) said that after all the years he was an executioner he did not think the death penalty was a deterrent for murder. It was based on the belief that if you kill someone, you are 'not right in the head' so you just don't think you will be caught, or you are a psychopath and don't care.

Much better to keep someone locked up for the rest of their natural lives with every possible liberty taken from them.

For Tustin, I hope she is looking over her shoulder for the rest of her life. She is the epitome of evil.

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 10:44

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

Also, we have a justice system which is systemically racist and sexist, where women and people of colour get handed out disproportionally harsher sentences than white men for example

What?!?! Racist, yes. It’s a very valid point. Sexist, yes, against men! Men get far harsher sentences than women!

That Hughes arsehole ordered the murder of his own son and was convicted only for manslaughter, 21 years.

His girlfriend, who did the murder he demanded was convicted of murder and won't see light of day for at least 29 years.

That is sexism in conviction and sentencing.

BiBabbles · 06/12/2021 10:44

We've enough deaths in state custody by those working for the state (not even including where they've turned a blind eye for others in custody to do it for them) that giving them further authority to justify killing without consequence makes me uneasy to say the least. Reducing violence in society needs to include reducing state-sanctioned violence.

I do think it's reasonable to think there needs to be a shift away from prison being seen as a time out deterrent for the types of crimes we would associate with the death penalty. Time is an okay starting point, but really, we need better assessment on how much of a risk someone is to others and ways to handle those who will continue to be threat. Part of me sees the appeal of having them work for life under supervision, doing something of use to wider society, but how that's worked in the US, I'm wary of how our systems would work that out when there is profit involved.

Horizons83 · 06/12/2021 10:42

No, I fundamentally disagree with the death penalty in all cases.

I have no problem with a whole life tariff.

Tal45 · 06/12/2021 10:38

@ArabellaScott

There is no credible argument for the death penalty, and many very strong arguments against it.
Surely a credible argument is that the murderer/abuser will never have the chance to escape or be freed and hurt anyone again? Pretty compelling argument if you ask me even if you don't agree with the death penalty.
Roominmyhouse · 06/12/2021 10:38

@jaffacakesareepic makes lots of excellent points. I’m absolutely against the death penalty for all those reasons.

Fidgetty · 06/12/2021 10:37

In theory I think paedophiles deserve to die and would support the death penalty in that case. They can't be "rehabilitated" and are worthless to society. I would prefer they were actually locked up forever and had a miserable time in prison but with sentences so abysmal that doesn't happen and so out they come free to be a threat to other children and I think it's so, so wrong considering the lives they ruin.

There is always the fear of miscarriage of justice though which is what it will always come back to. Same with euthanasia. In theory I agree with it but I'm not sure I could fully support it as of fear there will always be people who will exploit it. Honestly though, in my angrier moments (I have worked with victims of child abuse) I would vehemently support CP for child abusers and would sacrifice the potential for miscarriages of justice if it meant saving other children from abuse. So I'd sacrifice an innocent adult male for innocent children every time. It's all so needlessly complex really. If men would just stop being so fucking degenerate these ethical issues wouldn't exist! NAMALT blah blah blah...

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 10:37

Also, we have a justice system which is systemically racist and sexist, where women and people of colour get handed out disproportionally harsher sentences than white men for example

What?!?! Racist, yes. It’s a very valid point. Sexist, yes, against men! Men get far harsher sentences than women!

Tal45 · 06/12/2021 10:33

@Biscuitsneeded

God no. It's barbaric, and absolutely not a deterrent, otherwise those US states that still have the death penalty would have no murders, which clearly isn't the case.
A deterrent doesn't mean nobody does it though. It could mean that only half as many people do it for example.
Tal45 · 06/12/2021 10:30

There isn't enough evidence to say whether the death penalty is a deterrent or not in the US as so few people out of the total population are given a death sentence. There will always be people who think they can get away with it one way or another though, otherwise surely having to spend years in prison would be a deterrent.

I think in this day and age though, with DNA testing/technology, miscarriages of justice could be prevented if you only give black and white cases the death penalty rather than those 'without reasonable doubt', ie only those with concrete/physical proof.

People always think of the US when they talk about people be wrongly given the death penalty and often they are either pre DNA or they are cases where there's a bit of a grey area ie relying on people's statements or they are cases of probable racism.

If you read about Nathaniel Woods on wiki for example, a black man involved in drugs, he surrendered to police in a crack den but another man came down and shot 3 officers. The shooter said Nathaniel was innocent but the prosecution said he had lured the officers to their death. In a majority black area only two of the jurors were black and the jury voted 10-2 in favour of execution. In Alabama there only has to be a majority and he was executed in 2020.

So what I see from the US is that potentially the biggest problems with the death penalty are bigotry, bias and presumption. The other issue is the years of appeals it takes to even get to that point. I like the idea of a quick execution of anyone like Tustin who is proved without any doubt to have abused a child but in reality it just doesn't work that simply. Nathaniel Woods was on death row for 15 years, Kerry Spencer who actually pulled the trigger is still on death row now awaiting execution. There is no quick, clean end.

Antsgomarching · 06/12/2021 10:29

I do think some people are so dangerous to others that they shouldn’t be allowed out of prison though.

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 10:26

Also, we have a justice system which is systemically racist and sexist, where women and people of colour get handed out disproportionally harsher sentences than white men for example.

So you are looking and a justice system that is more likely to kill a black man than a white man if you want capital punishment.

How about the people who are supposed to be the good guys actually get their house in order first, instead of essentially murdering people for the colour of their skin?

PenguinTattoo · 06/12/2021 10:26

No.

LindaEllen · 06/12/2021 10:25

If life imprisonment isn't a deterrent then I don't see how CP would be, to be honest.

The issue is that the people who commit such crimes aren't particularly bothered by deterrents. It might sound like it would reduce crime from our POV, but we're not (or at least I'm not!) the kind of person who would murder someone. People with that mindset and temperament wouldn't be deterred.

Just10moreminutesplease · 06/12/2021 10:24

No, it doesn’t work as a deterrent and I don’t believe anyone has the right to decide whether a person lives or dies. And that’s without considering the possibility of false convictions.

Of course, when child murderers etc are in the news, I want them to be executed… but that doesn’t make it the right choice.