Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 11:31

Hanging is too good for them.

Sentences are too short though. With remission you're out in a ridiculously short length of time. Should be time added for bad behaviour, not time off for good. Sentences should also be served consecutively, concurrent sentences are an insult to the victim.

planteen · 06/12/2021 11:30

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

If killing people is wrong, how can it be right if that State does it?

Imprisoning people is also wrong, yet we lock people up when they do bad things.

No punishment deters crime, crime exists everywhere. Punishment is a form of justice.

PurpleDaisies · 06/12/2021 11:29

No. We shouldn’t kill people.

I’m surprised that controversial.

planteen · 06/12/2021 11:28

@BoredZelda

Nope.

There is no evidence of deterrent. It is way more costly than keeping someone in prison. People want it for revenge, not for punishment.

We are supposed to be a civilised nation. Killing criminals isn’t civilised.

That's exactly right. Of course it's not a deterrent, they're dead? Life in prison isn't a deterrent either.

The worst crimes should be punished.

This doesn't mean we have to kill every murderer or rapist. But the ones we deem particularly heinous and where there is no reasonable doubt, and the victims families support it- the criminal should be executed.

Might only be used twice a year. Some people deserve it. Defending people who commit atrocities comes from a place of privilege imo (as in insisting they shouldn't be punished). You're able to have that opinion next your not the victim, nor your loved ones.

Obviously if a family chooses to forgive that's their choice, but that's different to someone talking from the outside

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/12/2021 11:27

Even DNA isn’t as infallible as people think
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1769721220302895

There are rare situations where people have two different DNA profiles - DNA chimera

Stompythedinosaur · 06/12/2021 11:24

No, absolutely not.

There's no evidence that it deters crime.

Two wrongs don't make a right - there are some inhuman things we shouldn't be whatever someone has done.

stillmorerubbish · 06/12/2021 11:23

No, innocent people will always be killed in this system.

And when you look into the history of people who have done truly awful things, they have often had truly awful things done to them in their lives, often as children.

FestiveMelts · 06/12/2021 11:22

Yes, for the most severe cases and where guilt is 100% certain.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/12/2021 11:20

If killing people is wrong, how can it be right if that State does it?

RedBonnet · 06/12/2021 11:19

Its, not it's (for pedants like me)

2boysDad · 06/12/2021 11:19

Anyone remember the miscarriages of justice relating to Professor Roy Meadows and cot-death.

"one sudden infant death is a tragedy, two is suspicious and three is murder, until proved otherwise"

Sally Clark and Trupti Patel were both sentenced to life for child murder. Both were innocent.

A question for those who favour the return of the death penalty. How many deaths of people who would subsequently be acquitted are you prepared to accept?

RedBonnet · 06/12/2021 11:19

No
It is barbaric and not a deterrent. It's only use is for vengeance. If it worked as a deterrent then there'd be no killings in US states and the various countries where they still have capital punishment

TheCatWearsPrada · 06/12/2021 11:18

Absolutely not, innocent people have been executed and mistakes are made.
The death penalty is legalized murdered and murdered is never right. Anyone who agrees with the death penalty is twisted

backtoschool1234 · 06/12/2021 11:17

For certain cases, where they is no doubt, etc it should be brought back. I don't think for one minute it would deter the psychopaths that commit the crimes but it would mean that money wasn't required to keep them in prison for decades, freeing up money to fund departments such as social services which might actually prevent these cases.

These people don't feel any remorse so having to 'live with it' isn't going to bother them anyway and the fact that prison provides three meals a day and a roof over their head is too good for them.

3peassuit · 06/12/2021 11:14

No. I would like to see life to mean whole life imprisonment.

SpindlesWinterWhorl · 06/12/2021 11:13

Death penalty? No thank you.

I support whole life tariffs.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 11:13

@jaffacakesareepic

Totally understand what you’re saying; thanks for taking the time to explain!

Aussiegirl123456 · 06/12/2021 11:11

I dunno, I’d happily push the likes of Ian Huntley, Wayne Couzens, Steven Barker - to name a few, into an inferno….or deep wet concrete… Low cost and will free up their prison beds. I know CP may not be a deterrent but means these people can’t ever be happy or hurt anyone again.

Barbaric? Yep, and so was what they did. Someone who picks up a 17 month old baby by the legs and swings him hard so his head hits the wall…multiple times, so hard that teeth fall out, deserves the most inhumane and barbaric death. Ironically being pushed in lava will actually cause less suffering than he caused his baby victim.

fakereview · 06/12/2021 11:10

The death penalty is mob justice. The State has to rise above that.

Although there are some cases where I'd turn a blind eye to mob justice - Wayne Couzens being one of them.

The main issue with locking people away is that you then have do-gooders trying to get them out, like Myra Hindley. Thank goodness she died before she got out.

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 11:10

@Chasingaftermidnight

That Hughes arsehole ordered the murder of his own son and was convicted only for manslaughter, 21 years.

His girlfriend, who did the murder he demanded was convicted of murder and won't see light of day for at least 29 years

Whilst this is true, he was charged with murder by the CPS. The murder charge failed because the jury didn’t feel they could be certain that he intended to order Emma Tustin to kill or cause grievous bodily harm to his child so he was convicted of manslaughter instead (with a high degree of culpability).

Frankly I was surprised, based on what I read of the evidence, that the jury weren’t at least happy to conclude that he intended her to cause his son grievous bodily harm. I read the sentencing remarks and I thought the judge’s comments implied that he disagreed with the jury - but the jury’s verdict is what it is.

"But the jury's verdict is what it is"

And therein lies the sexism.
Juries convict or acquit and they bring their own prejudices to the table in doing so.

Under identical circumstances, they would disproportionately convict more women (and many more ethnic minorities) of capital murder than men (and white people) due to racist fear, and harsher judgment of women's actions than men's.

Skysblue · 06/12/2021 11:09

Yes. For people where the evidence is 100% clear that they killed or tortured children.

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 11:09

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

From the prison reform trust:

  • It is important to note that while many women appear in Court following arrest and charge a great many more women are prosecuted for non-criminal offences. This includes TV licence evasion, welfare fraud, fare evasion and sanctions relating to the non-attendance of children at school. Because these cases are not dealt with by the police there is no option to use an out of court disposal. • TV licence evasion accounted for 36% of all prosecutions for women, but only 6% for men. In 2015, 70% of all the 189,349 defendants prosecuted for this offence were women.*

In my opinion I think putting a hell of a lot more women than men in prison for tv licence evasion is harsher sentencing for women, but I dont think I explained it well so I apologise.

I guess what I meant is that women are more likely to receive a prison sentence for things like tv licence evasion and school non attendance than men (where are the fathers in the school non-attendance sentencing. Father leaves mother to raise child alone, often with little to no financial support and if the child is a school refuser the mother is often the only one to end up penalised.) In my opinion that is both sexist and harsher on women.

However, you are correct, men are receiving harsher sentencing for the exact same crime which is also sexist and should also be stamped out I am against sexism in any form, I just didnt explain myself well so apologies!!

EmeraldShamrock · 06/12/2021 11:05

A friends father was brutally kicked to death by a thug he was a ft taller than his innocent victim.
My friends father was a slim man, he was unrecognisable after the beating.
The likes of him and Arthur's murderers don't deserve air.

Chasingaftermidnight · 06/12/2021 11:02

That Hughes arsehole ordered the murder of his own son and was convicted only for manslaughter, 21 years.

His girlfriend, who did the murder he demanded was convicted of murder and won't see light of day for at least 29 years

Whilst this is true, he was charged with murder by the CPS. The murder charge failed because the jury didn’t feel they could be certain that he intended to order Emma Tustin to kill or cause grievous bodily harm to his child so he was convicted of manslaughter instead (with a high degree of culpability).

Frankly I was surprised, based on what I read of the evidence, that the jury weren’t at least happy to conclude that he intended her to cause his son grievous bodily harm. I read the sentencing remarks and I thought the judge’s comments implied that he disagreed with the jury - but the jury’s verdict is what it is.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 10:58

@EmeraldShamrock

Not 100% - her statement is 50% accurate only

Swipe left for the next trending thread