Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
avocadotofu · 06/12/2021 12:42

Absolutely not!

TurquoiseDragon · 06/12/2021 12:39

I believe capital punishment fails as a deterrent. There's more punishment in making people work for restitution.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 12:38

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens.

What's the "greater good" when it comes to the "small percent" of times an innocent person is killed and a true killer remains at large?

Viviennemary · 06/12/2021 12:36

I wouldn't oppose it.

housemaus · 06/12/2021 12:34

@RilkeanHeart

No. Some people do abhorrent and barbaric things. The state shouldn’t do abhorrent and barbaric things in response.
Exactly this.

"Murder is the worst possible thing you can do... but it's okay when we do it to show you how bad it is" makes no sense.

OrinocoGlow · 06/12/2021 12:34

I agree with PPs that CP is not carried out in a civilised society, it's barbaric and wrong. People do of course have a strong emotional reaction after a particularly horrific crime and there is a desire for vengeance. But I strongly believe that the law should be free from emotion and desire for revenge. Law and justice should be cold and clinical in their application. However I would support whole life sentences for the vilest crimes to reflect their severity and the possible danger to society of these offenders being released. Imagine being the judge having to pass a death sentence or the person having the carry it out - horrific. And of course there is the risk of errors as well. So I would be strongly opposed to CP.

NotquitewhatImeant · 06/12/2021 12:32

God no - it’s barbaric and ineffective. We’re better than that

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 12:30

@Dasher789

Yes, I would fully support it coming back for the worst crimes - eg, crimes against children, murder, proper life in prison sentences etc.

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens. Out of the small % of times miscarriages happen, I think the % of complete no smoke without fire will be tiny eg. If someone is stabbed in London and the wrong gang member is found guilty but this gang member is still a very violent individual carries a knife etc, is it a huge loss to society that a mistake has been made? I do think the number of times this would happen though are very small.

If the death penalty is not on the cards though, apparently it costs £45k per year to keep a prisoner in jail. I believe they should have to offset that balance through labour - making things to be sold, manual labour etc. Sitting in a room for most of the day is no good for anyone. The current system has many failings.

How about if the miscarriages of justice started to fall on the white neighbourhoods near you.

Where your son hung out in the park with his mates on a late summer evening.

Would you feel the same if it could be your son picked up for "fitting the description"?

Or would you want for there to be the time to uncover the miscarriage and reverse it?

pointythings · 06/12/2021 12:23

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens. Out of the small % of times miscarriages happen, I think the % of complete no smoke without fire will be tiny eg. If someone is stabbed in London and the wrong gang member is found guilty but this gang member is still a very violent individual carries a knife etc, is it a huge loss to society that a mistake has been made? I do think the number of times this would happen though are very small.

Look up the case of Stefan Kiszko who was knowingly framed by the police and then say that again. Bringing back the death penalty means that fully innocent people will die and it is horrific that you think this is a reasonable price to pay.

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 12:17

@PurpleDaisies

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens. Out of the small % of times miscarriages happen, I think the % of complete no smoke without fire will be tiny eg. If someone is stabbed in London and the wrong gang member is found guilty but this gang member is still a very violent individual carries a knife etc, is it a huge loss to society that a mistake has been made? I do think the number of times this would happen though are very small.

Bloody hell. I can’t believe anyone could actually think like that.

I agree.
GreenWhiteViolet · 06/12/2021 12:16

I'm against it. I do think some people deserve it, but even one innocent person being executed is too many. That, and it doesn't actually work out cheaper than life in prison.

PurpleDaisies · 06/12/2021 12:16

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens. Out of the small % of times miscarriages happen, I think the % of complete no smoke without fire will be tiny eg. If someone is stabbed in London and the wrong gang member is found guilty but this gang member is still a very violent individual carries a knife etc, is it a huge loss to society that a mistake has been made? I do think the number of times this would happen though are very small.

Bloody hell. I can’t believe anyone could actually think like that.

Dasher789 · 06/12/2021 12:12

Yes, I would fully support it coming back for the worst crimes - eg, crimes against children, murder, proper life in prison sentences etc.

There are miscarriages of justice but I think for the greater good, it is worth the small % of times this happens. Out of the small % of times miscarriages happen, I think the % of complete no smoke without fire will be tiny eg. If someone is stabbed in London and the wrong gang member is found guilty but this gang member is still a very violent individual carries a knife etc, is it a huge loss to society that a mistake has been made? I do think the number of times this would happen though are very small.

If the death penalty is not on the cards though, apparently it costs £45k per year to keep a prisoner in jail. I believe they should have to offset that balance through labour - making things to be sold, manual labour etc. Sitting in a room for most of the day is no good for anyone. The current system has many failings.

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 06/12/2021 12:09

God no.
We are better than that.
Civilised states don't kill citizens.

FelinaDaHousecat · 06/12/2021 11:53

@planteen

"Imprisoning people is also wrong, yet we lock people up when they do bad things. "

No, we do not 'lock them up' - the prison system is meant to rehabilitate. I agree it does not always work that way but that is the intent.

The state is the moral arbiter of behaviour, not a 'punishing' institution. We live in a civilised society, not an 'eye for an eye' wilderness.

The death penalty is an aberration.

DeeCeeCherry · 06/12/2021 11:44

No. Mainly because I dont trust that it wouldnt result in total bias miscarriages of justice followed by "lessons learned" years later after a person guilty of no crime has lost their life whilst real killer roams free

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 11:41

If a criminal is eligible for the death sentence (shocking crime/indisputably guilty) the family get the final say.

I think that puts people who are already indirect victims of the crime in an absolutely intolerable position. Asking someone who is grieving to make a decision over someone lives or dies, and then asking them to live with that decision on top of their grief for the rest of their lives is just hideous.

Its all very well to think if someone murdered my child I would want them to be put to death, that's understandable its a visceral emotion driven reaction to a hideous unthinkable situation.

But on top of your grief for your murdered child do you really want to be responsible for their murders sentence directly? To live with that, to agonise over whether you are doing the right thing or not?

Victims and family members should not be burdened with deciding what appropriate justice is. Not when they are grieving. That's why we have a supposedly neutral court system in place.

Besides, practically how does this work. You believe in the death penalty and your husband doesn't, who gets the deciding vote, how many family members are included, are aunts, uncles, cousins, grandparents included. What about estranged family etc? The reality is this is completely unworkable and could divide families at a time when they need each others support, deepening the wound caused by the original crime.

PurpleDaisies · 06/12/2021 11:39

What if the family regret choosing death for someone in the future? What a thing to have to live with. There’s a reason why this decision is down to a judge.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 11:38

First of all there are absolutely things in our society that are deemed particularly heinous. Crimes involving children, exhibit A.

We will need a definition to identify them. Would all crimes against children meet the definition? What else? We already have certain things classed as aggravating factors.

If a criminal is eligible for the death sentence (shocking crime/indisputably guilty) the family get the final say.

Even though that would make it inconsistently applied? Leave it wide open to racism or sexism?

Pugdogmom · 06/12/2021 11:36

Absolutely 100% against the death penalty. It was the tragic case of Ruth Ellis that brought about the end of this barbaric system.
A simple Google will show that in the US , in the states where the Death penalty has been repealed, the murder rate has dropped.

I know that certain crimes make us angry and people want retribution, but as murder is wrong, why is State Sponsored suddenly OK? Not only that, death is too easy.
Let the murderers of that wee boy suffer in prison, and hopefully stay there for whole life terms.

PurpleDaisies · 06/12/2021 11:35

If a criminal is eligible for the death sentence (shocking crime/indisputably guilty) the family get the final say.

That’s an awful responsibility to put on a grieving family.

planteen · 06/12/2021 11:34

@DrSbaitso

But the ones we deem particularly heinous and where there is no reasonable doubt,andthe victims families support it- the criminal should be executed.

If it's dependent on whether the families support it, it's going to be inconsistently applied.

We'll also need a definition of "particularly heinous".

First of all there are absolutely things in our society that are deemed particularly heinous. Crimes involving children, exhibit A.

If a criminal is eligible for the death sentence (shocking crime/indisputably guilty) the family get the final say.

ManicPixie · 06/12/2021 11:32

There are countless reasons why CP is a shit idea, but another one to consider: juries may be less likely to prosecute a seemingly guilty defendant if they think the punishment is death rather than a long sentence.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 11:31

But the ones we deem particularly heinous and where there is no reasonable doubt,andthe victims families support it- the criminal should be executed.

If it's dependent on whether the families support it, it's going to be inconsistently applied.

We'll also need a definition of "particularly heinous".