Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
aliasname · 06/12/2021 16:46

@Nc123

Christ no, it’s barbaric. Let them suffer.
People saying that justice shouldn't be about revenge, and capital punishment is morally wrong... but then go on to hope that certain criminals suffer horrendously in prison?
pigsDOfly · 06/12/2021 16:44

No never.

A society that sanctions murder, for whatever reason, is not a society I want to be part of.

The death penalty isn't a deterrent any more than prison is. I very much doubt that people who commit horrific crimes are weighing up the odds of what will happen when or if they're caught.

Life however, should mean life. There should be no come back from that.

Whether or not people feel that life in prison is not hard enough is irrelevant.

When you are dealing with the sort of evil people who killed that poor little boy you deprive them of their liberty and keep them in prison until they die. What purpose is served by killing them.

The death penalty is all about revenge and shouldn't be part of a civilised society.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 16:36

And I was talking about Arthur's murderers specifically. My point was- when feelings are running high and as much as it might seem like justice, it's still not right.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 16:33

@Warmduscher ... It's not right though, we can't reduce ourselves for murderers to feel a sense of revenge. The same for the death penalty, it might make people feel better but we're not a barbaric society.

Posting half a quote is an asshole thing to do

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 16:31

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher you've wilfully misunderstood me, I said I didn't think it was right.

[/quote]
But you did say you would “like” it:

I'd like for certain people to be tortured and murdered in the same way they tortured and murdered their victim.

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/12/2021 16:30

@Nat6999

If not the death penalty then there should be hard labour for offences like this.
How would you define hard labour? I have visions of chain gangs or Handmaid's tale colonies. I wouldn't want to go down that route?
sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 16:22

@Warmduscher you've wilfully misunderstood me, I said I didn't think it was right.

Allthatglittersandgold · 06/12/2021 16:22

I have never been able to articulate my feelings and opinions on the subject. I just cannot make my mind up about it. I mean, on many levels.

Should they be punished by death, punished by being in prison for the rest of their lives? Which is worse, knowing you are going to die or knowing you are going to live your life out in misery? Then I think some of it is my fascination with what actually goes on during the act of being on death row and the time of death.

5128gap · 06/12/2021 16:19

@Mynameisnew

I also wonder what the instance of error would be now that we have DNA technology. And the Tustin and Hughes case is cut and dry - or is there a cause for doubt? He admitted it didn't he?
I think its very difficult for people to be clear sighted about this question when you are referencing a particular case that is current and has caused tremendous upset and outrage. A great many more people may feel comfortable about the people you are referencing being executed, on the wave of emotion that this case has aroused, and as you say, its cut and dried. But this is not the same as rationally supporting a return of the death penalty, when presented with all the arguments, and when it would be applied to other forms of murder as well as that of a child.
IncompleteSenten · 06/12/2021 16:18

Civilised societies? Aztecs? Romans etc?

Seriously?
Human sacrifice, slavery, 'Damnatio ad bestias', crucifixion...

Sure as shit not my idea of civilised societies

caketiger · 06/12/2021 16:17

*convict

Nat6999 · 06/12/2021 16:17

If not the death penalty then there should be hard labour for offences like this.

CousinKrispy · 06/12/2021 16:17

Just a technical point, in British courts, whenever a verdict of "guilty" was given for a murder charge, the judge reached for the black cap. He had no choice but to sentence the prisoner to death. This relieved judges from any matters of conscience on that score. The question of whether someone actually did hang would depend on the family asking the Home Secretary to ask the Queen for clemency. At this stage, yes there is potential for unequal treatment.

That's very interesting (I mean that sincerely, not sarcastically!) but there are plenty of other opportunities for both inconsistencies and errors--in the investigation of crimes, who gets charged and with what, how effective their defense is (remember that some on death row in the USA were represented in court by solicitors who SLEPT through parts of the trial!), etc.

caketiger · 06/12/2021 16:16

God no, never. Under no circumstances. Reasoning. Corruption. We might have DNA now but we will always have corruption too. The pressure that police forces are In to convince.....

JaneJeffer · 06/12/2021 16:15

I would prefer a medieval dungeon for them.

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 16:10

I don't think that prison is a deterrent for people like Arthur's killers.

OP posts:
gogohm · 06/12/2021 16:07

No because we are better than them. But we do need a long term facility for those not suitable for release into the public where they can live out their days, there's a community in Florida for ex offenders that seems to be a good idea though I don't know the details.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 16:06

Just a technical point, in British courts, whenever a verdict of "guilty" was given for a murder charge, the judge reached for the black cap. He had no choice but to sentence the prisoner to death.

When murder always results in a death sentence, the inconsistency will appear at the conviction stage...

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 16:05

I also wonder what the instance of error would be now that we have DNA technology. And the Tustin and Hughes case is cut and dry - or is there a cause for doubt? He admitted it didn't he?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 15:57

@DrSbaitso

Also, it doesn't get applied equally. Have a think about which people will be more likely to be sentenced to death for the same offence...
Just a technical point, in British courts, whenever a verdict of "guilty" was given for a murder charge, the judge reached for the black cap. He had no choice but to sentence the prisoner to death. This relieved judges from any matters of conscience on that score. The question of whether someone actually did hang would depend on the family asking the Home Secretary to ask the Queen for clemency. At this stage, yes there is potential for unequal treatment.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/12/2021 15:53

On moral, ethical and above all financial grounds, capital punishment is a step that is well worth taking.

Well very obviously that depends on your view of morality and ethics. Mine is that murder is morally and ethically wrong - and that includes judicial murder.

DrSbaitso · 06/12/2021 15:53

The Romans had a slave trade too.

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 15:50

The ancient Athenians and Romans were civilised societies, so were the Aztecs, so to a large degree is the USA today - but all kept the death penalty.

The Romans were not civilised by modern standards. They lit the colosseum with human torches.

bandek · 06/12/2021 15:50

@MorningStarling

Agree with most of your points. Really don't get why people think that we need to rehabilitate or care for every person, or that life in prison is a deterrent- one of the stupidest arguments

But nobody should be wrongly executed it is very sad when you actually see the faces behind those stories

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 15:49

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher part of me would, yes.

In the same way that people hope those going to prison get a hard time in there.

But as I said, it's only revenge, not punishment and sentencing should never be based around revenge. [/quote]
You think it’s ok because other people want prisoners tortured too? At least own your bloodlust.