Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want capital punishment back?

542 replies

Mynameisnew · 06/12/2021 02:07

There are people who do such vile things in this country and are jailed for a decade or two. Perhaps released for good behaviour a bit earlier.

Afaik CP was stopped amongst other reasons because there were a number of errors made and innocent people being convicted.

But these days with DNA proof or cases where it is on cctv /phone messages or has been admitted (thinking of Emma Tustin)

Would it not make a good deterrent? Even if one person is saved from being murdered...

I appreciate that in the USA people still commit murder, but they also have guns there which means a higher incidence of spur of the moment violence.

But a sustained campaign of abuse - would such an abuser as Tustin have been put off if CP was an option, even if very rarely used?

It's easy for me to say that I would be deterred, but I'm not a psychopathic and sadistic person so the issue is, it's hard to say if people like that would be put off such a crime. Perhaps it doesn't even enter their heads that it's wrong.

OP posts:
OrinocoGlow · 06/12/2021 18:53

[quote jaffacakesareepic]@OrinocoGlow

But this thread got me thinking as I am not opposed to armed police shooting a criminal, for example, a terrorist shot in the act.

I feel like that's closer to death through self defence, than murder?[/quote]
Yes @jaffacakesareepic and 5128gap I think that is what I was trying to say in my clumsy way. I agree with you both. It's not done as an act of revenge, it's to prevent further danger.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 18:41

@Warmduscher yeah part of me would like Arthur's killers to have the same treatment they gave to him. It doesn't mean I would condone it if I saw it happening, It doesn't mean I would encourage it and it doesn't mean I wouldn't stop it if I had the power to.

We can all have dark thoughts, that doesn't mean we are "bloodthirsty". Obviously not you, but then we can't all be angelic perfection. Smile

KTheGrey · 06/12/2021 18:41

@Aussiegirl123456
How do you know he is tortured? Is this kind of thing reported?

I am against in CP because somebody has to carry out the sentence and it's unfair on them.

I believe the statistical odds of child murderers ending their own lives is one in five, which isn't entirely surprising given that well balanced people don't do much murder at all, let alone of children.

Aprilx · 06/12/2021 18:39

I think once it is gone it is gone, to the extent that I think discussions about it and calls for it to come back are pointless. I cannot imagine any civilised society reintroducing the death penalty. And rightly so, we need to be better than that. I would like to see better sentencing though, we are far too soft far too often.

PinkAndPurpleClouds · 06/12/2021 18:33

YES. But several years on death row first. Just in case... Although, a miscarriage of justice is way more unlikely these days than it was like 50+ years ago.

5128gap · 06/12/2021 18:30

@OrinocoGlow

I am completely against death penalty, even for the worst of crimes, in a civilised society for the reasons mentioned by many others. But this thread got me thinking as I am not opposed to armed police shooting a criminal, for example, a terrorist shot in the act. Maybe because it's less of a pre-meditated execution and undertaken only for safety of the police or public in the immediate moment and not in lieu of a lifetime in jail. Or maybe I am not as "civilised" as I thought. Of course, sometimes this goes wrong too and someone innocent is killed. It's all very complex the more I think about it.
Theres a big difference between killing to save lives and killing in revenge for lives already lost.
Hertsgirl10 · 06/12/2021 18:28

I’m shocked they last so long in prison without being killed.

I think it definitely depends on the circumstances but yes any child abuse I think the perpetrators should be killed, including sexual abuse and child rape. Why should they get to live a happy normal life when they’ve ruined the innocence of a child/baby? It’s proved nothing cures these sickos so get rid of them.

I think they should have to endure exactly what they put the kids through, till their pathetic bodies give in

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 18:26

[quote sqirrelfriends]@Warmduscher well you commented on half of a thought, you quoting half of what I said kind of gave the impression that that was the only thing I said, which was wrong.

I don't want capital punishment, that was my point. I couldn't make that point without pointing out that sometimes there are crimes that make us so angry that we might wish the worst on the perpetrators (capital punishment), I also made the point that that it is wrong to kill people despite its legality or how it's done.

All ok now? [/quote]
That’s not really what you said. You said you would “like” prisoners to be tortured. It doesn’t matter that you said in the second paragraph that you don’t support the death penalty.

Maybe you regret posting that you’d like prisoners to be tortured, which is fine. Lots of people have said things on this thread that they’d probably back down from irl.

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 18:23

@OrinocoGlow

But this thread got me thinking as I am not opposed to armed police shooting a criminal, for example, a terrorist shot in the act.

I feel like that's closer to death through self defence, than murder?

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 06/12/2021 18:21

I'm not sure, I've always been dead agaisnt it, but as I get older and my hope for some time people reforming fades and how short we are off money for sw etc I feel maybe... There should be exceptional circumstances like tustin.

Where a committee can say.. Is it possible really worth housing and feeding this person for thirty years, plus costs of watching them when they are out.. The appeals they will want. Is it worth it?
Why is rose west still with us? Why are we spending money on the likes of Brady and hiNdly?

jaffacakesareepic · 06/12/2021 18:20

@Mynameisnew

I don't think that prison is a deterrent for people like Arthur's killers.

But people on this thread have shown how its highly unlikely capital punishment would have been as well, so if your end goal is stopping people like Arthur's killers then capital punishment wouldnt.

The death penalty, as discussed is expensive. Instead lets focus that money where it helps.

More social workers, more early years support, more free childcare, all of which put more trained adults with more time to look out for markers of abuse and children in vulnerable situations.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 06/12/2021 18:18

AFAIK child abusers/murders are treated terribly in prisons as a huge proportion of prisoners have kids/nieces/nephews/kid siblings etc. And rightly so.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 18:14

@Warmduscher well you commented on half of a thought, you quoting half of what I said kind of gave the impression that that was the only thing I said, which was wrong.

I don't want capital punishment, that was my point. I couldn't make that point without pointing out that sometimes there are crimes that make us so angry that we might wish the worst on the perpetrators (capital punishment), I also made the point that that it is wrong to kill people despite its legality or how it's done.

All ok now?

OrinocoGlow · 06/12/2021 18:12

I am completely against death penalty, even for the worst of crimes, in a civilised society for the reasons mentioned by many others. But this thread got me thinking as I am not opposed to armed police shooting a criminal, for example, a terrorist shot in the act. Maybe because it's less of a pre-meditated execution and undertaken only for safety of the police or public in the immediate moment and not in lieu of a lifetime in jail. Or maybe I am not as "civilised" as I thought. Of course, sometimes this goes wrong too and someone innocent is killed. It's all very complex the more I think about it.

DrCoconut · 06/12/2021 17:29

No, it must never be brought back. The state not being entitled to kill you must be absolute. Otherwise it's the thin end of the wedge to people being eliminated when their face doesn't fit. Start with paedophiles (it would be popular), then over time bring it in for murderers, then thieves, then onto benefits claimants, "political threats" aka immigrants and so on. I absolutely believe this could happen with the amount of open hate that is being thrown around at the moment. We must do all we can to prevent it.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 17:14

[quote sqirrelfriends]**@Warmduscher* ... It's not right though, we can't reduce ourselves for murderers to feel a sense of revenge. The same for the death penalty, it might make people feel better but we're not a barbaric society.*

Posting half a quote is an asshole thing to do[/quote]
Leaving aside your unnecessary rudeness, you posted two separate paragraphs and I commented on one of them.

Was that not obvious to you when I only quoted one of the paragraphs you posted?

EdgeOfTheSky · 06/12/2021 17:09

Our criminal justice system needs sorting out.

There should be a proper distinction between criminals who would benefit from proper rehab, A well thought out, well resourced strategy, and those who are locked away for the safety of society or because their crimes are so great that the punishment is absolute: a whole life tariff.

Platax · 06/12/2021 17:08

More of @MorningStarling's arguments:

7. Civilised societies have been killing their citizens since the first civilised society developed. The ancient Athenians and Romans were civilised societies, so were the Aztecs, so to a large degree is the USA today - but all kept the death penalty

Neither the Athenians nor the Romans could be described as civilised societies. The fact that a supposedly civilised society currently is resorting, in some states, to using the death penalty is a massive weakness in any claim to be civilised.

8. Capital punishment is significantly cheaper than keeping someone in prison for decades. It's about 44K per prisoner per year. An execution could be done for a fraction of that, I think I could do it for under 2K per criminal including disposal of the body, less if they have family who want to reclaim it.

On that basis, again, let's not bother with keeping alive people with long term illnesses, the seriously disabled, etc etc. Indeed, why keep any prisoners alive? It would be so much cheaper to kill them. Saving money can never be a justification for deliberate state killing.

9. "Collateral damage" - what do you mean? The fact that innocent people could be wrongly executed? Guess what, people are wrongly convicted already, sometimes having decades of their life taken away from them. Execution is just a natural extension of this miscarriage of justice.

We can release people from prison, we can pay damages as compensation for wrongful conviction. It's not ideal, but it's a hell of a lot better than killing them. Would you feel this relaxed about it if it was you or someone you loved who had been wrongfully convicted and was going to be hanged tomorrow morning?

10. Execution achieves all aims of punishment - the forfeiture of the offender's life. That is the ultimate punishment. Execution might not allow for rehabilitation but rehabilitation is not supposed to be "punishment" - it's supposed to help the offender.

So does life imprisonment achieve all aims of punishment for appropriate offences.

11. On moral, ethical and above all financial grounds, capital punishment is a step that is well worth taking

Deliberate, cold-blooded killing is never either moral or ethical, and finances are irrelevant.

Throckmorton · 06/12/2021 17:05

It's amoral and doesn't work as a deterent, so no.

EdgeOfTheSky · 06/12/2021 17:03

@MurielSpriggs

People saying that justice shouldn't be about revenge, and capital punishment is morally wrong... but then go on to hope that certain criminals suffer horrendously in prison?

I somehow think they are two different groups of people!

I think that capital punishment is morally wrong and I also think that allowing prisoners to attack each other is also not right!

The punishment is loss of liberty, the effect is to keep dangerous people from doing further harm. Not to form a lawless violent vigilante mob attacking other criminals on our behalf.

Platax · 06/12/2021 17:00

Taking @MorningStarling's argument in stages:

1. It doesn't matter that it's not much of a deterrent. The fact that murders still happen when capital punishment is available is not an argument against capital punishment. If it were, prisons should clearly be scrapped, community service got rid of and fines abolished, because those punishments don't seem to act as a deterrent either.

No, it probably doesn't: but many of its proponents put this forward as justification, so the facts need to be known.

2. It doesn't matter that it's useless for rehabilitation because by definition it removes any need for the criminal to be readied for reintroduction to society.

On that basis, let's just kill off all criminals, shall we, and remove the pesky rehab issue altogether?

What are you going to do about, say, mercy killers? Or the wrongfully convicted? Are they not worth of help and rehabilitation?

3. The criminal justice system isn't focused on revenge so it doesn't matter "it's not great" for it

I don't follow this one. Revenge shouldn't come into the sentencing system.

4. It's not always quick, depending on your definition of the term. Taking a few minutes to be strangled by hanging is quicker than being tortured over a prolonged period by the people who are supposed to care for you I suppose

And? How about being strangled as against living in confinement without being tortured? And have you ever thought about the mental torment of living through weeks or months of knowing that you are going to be taken out one morning and cold-bloodedly put to death and there is nothing you can do to prevent it?

5. You don't know that death is the end, there is plenty of unsubstantiated opinion that consciousness doesn't die when the body does.

This is utterly irrelevant.

6. Removing dangerous people from society is a good thing

And we can achieve that by locking them up.

GrimDamnFanjo · 06/12/2021 16:57

No.
Killing people is wrong.

MurielSpriggs · 06/12/2021 16:57

People saying that justice shouldn't be about revenge, and capital punishment is morally wrong... but then go on to hope that certain criminals suffer horrendously in prison?

I somehow think they are two different groups of people!

dumdedumpop · 06/12/2021 16:55

Absolutely not. The death penalty is not the mark of a civilised society at all. And now is not the time to have a reasoned debate about it.

Platax · 06/12/2021 16:51

@Mynameisnew

I also wonder what the instance of error would be now that we have DNA technology. And the Tustin and Hughes case is cut and dry - or is there a cause for doubt? He admitted it didn't he?
DNA evidence is certainly not infallible.
Swipe left for the next trending thread