Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sister's family shouldn't self isolate with elderly parents over christmas?

61 replies

antigenrapidtest · 05/12/2021 18:03

My sister and her husband, and their children come over to the UK for christmas every year. Obviously covid meant that they couldn't last year. They live in Vienna so would need to do all sorts of covid tests when coming over.

They have flights booked to the UK on Christmas eve. The new testing rules mean that they would have to self isolate until their day 2 test came back. Because it's Christmas, it could take longer than usual.

They stay with my elderly parents (84 and 86). This would mean that they would have to self isolate too, until the results came back. So firstly there is the risk of covid being brought to their house.

But secondly. It would mean that my children wouldn't be able to see their grandparents on Christmas day/Boxing day etc. I raised this with my parents and they didn't seem massively concerned, and said we would manage something and just meet outside in the garden (not allowed if self isolating).

AIBU to think they shouldn't self isolate with them over christmas? or am I being a bit selfish as I get to see my parents all year round, as I didn't decide to move to Austria.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
How2Help · 05/12/2021 23:29

The thing you have forgotten here is that yes OP might be the sibling who has done all this. But without a doubt also the sibling who has childcare in form of grandparents at the drop of a hat.
Well I can’t speak for OP but as this was in response to my post I can tell you without a doubt that this is 100% not true in my case.

The thing about living abroad winds me up no end. It isn't a holiday it is just life in a different country, without your family. Quite often it isn't what you really want but it is what is best professionally or financially.
This is such a ridiculous thing to say. The whole point I was making is that a decision such as moving abroad (as you say, for your own professional and financial benefit) often has an impact on other family members that gets ignored. This wasn’t about the difficulty or necessity of moving abroad, it is about looking more broadly to understand why the OP might feel aggrieved.

As you can tell I'm the sibling that moved abroad.
Indeed.

TakeMe2Insanity · 05/12/2021 21:19

I’m fairly sure and the current guidance your parents would not have to self isolate with them.

lesenfantsdelesperance · 05/12/2021 21:00

So unreasonable. What on earth qualifies you to say that it'll be longer at Christmas? It wasn't longer in the summer when it was all new and loads of people were travelling.
Plus, why would your parents self isolate? I read the rules, I can't find that part at all.
Given all the restrictions in Austria at the moment, you are very unreasonable to think that in the land of 10 masks for £5, your sister's family are going to be the ones that are a danger to your parents. Take a look at yourself. For so many reasons.

HolidayTime2021 · 05/12/2021 20:41

@DebIr

Easy to get results within 24 hours using a drive through. No requirement for anyone to isolate unless they travelled so your parents don’t need to isolate.
Where?

Since the get brought in the 2 day test to release a couple of days ago the providers seem to have withdrawn the rapid PCR for arrivals-but it is still available for departures.

KaycePollard · 05/12/2021 20:26

You sound very self-centred in your OP, especially your point about your children not seeing their grandparents.. your sister and her children haven’t seen your parents for almost TWO years.

YABU.

I find it hard to believe that a grown up would think the way you think in your OP. Is there some sort of back-story? Why do you resent your sister so much?

julieca · 05/12/2021 20:00

I am assuming the sister and family are coming on Xmas Eve for a reason rather than a few days earlier. Getting annual level off work, kids being at school will all determine when they can fly.

NoKnit · 05/12/2021 19:51

@How2Help

I think the problem here may be that you spend most days of the year looking out for you parents: from doing odd jobs, to making sure they have got toilet rolls when there is panic buying, to making sure their heating is on, to changing lightbulbs - or to some degree of full on caring. Then you are considered selfish for not giving up the opportunity to share an enjoyable family day of the year with them do that the absent family members can - having not been consulted and just told what will be happening.

Been there, done that and this makes me err towards YANBU.

The thing you have forgotten here is that yes OP might be the sibling who has done all this. But without a doubt also the sibling who has childcare in form of grandparents at the drop of a hat.

The thing about living abroad winds me up no end. It isn't a holiday it is just life in a different country, without your family. Quite often it isn't what you really want but it is what is best professionally or financially.

As you can tell I'm the sibling that moved abroad.

Yes OK so your kids don't see their grandparents on Xmas day, but how often do your sisters kids see them?

At the end of the day this is all futile anyway. Nobody in their right mind will be traveling from Austria into the UK come Christmas so their trip would likely be off anyway

EasterIssland · 05/12/2021 19:48

Xmas is just a day … doesn’t have to be the day the calendar says so. You get to see your family all year round and she comes around and has to accommodate you?? You sound selfish. Why don’t you celebrate Xmas together on the 26-27-28?

I agree with others that I don’t think your parents have to self isolate. But I might be wrong about this.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 05/12/2021 19:44

I’m not entirely sure why you’re asking… it’s entirely the choice of your parents and they seem to be happy with your sisters plan.

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/12/2021 19:43

I can see it doesn’t suit you - but it’s up to your parents and them isn’t it?

Don’t get bent out of shape, just do a second C’mas day btwn C’mas and NY.

MiddleParking · 05/12/2021 19:39

I’d get round this by you all going there on Christmas Day anyway and sod ‘self isolating’, personally.

gogohm · 05/12/2021 19:38

Why not take 3 hour tests or same day on Christmas Eve?

lebkuchenforxmas · 05/12/2021 19:36

I think YABU.
They will have all had to PCR test before they fly over.
They can test at the airport as soon as they land and can pay a premium to get faster results which will minimise the time your parents need to isolate. They're presumably flying in before Xmas Day itself so results should come through before Boxing Day, if not Xmas Day.
Have you & your DC been visiting them during this? Have you PCR tested every time you've been? Or at least lateral flow tested? Are you perhaps the greater risk here?

OnAWobblyFence · 05/12/2021 19:30

@greenlynx

Your sister should isolate in a hotel. And visit your parents only when she’s in clear. You are not petty or mean at all. I’m your sister in this situation and would never put my parents under such considerable risk.
What risk? In order for the sister in Austria to visit she has to have a negative test before departure and be vaxxed. Meanwhile the UK daughter can visit without needing to be vaxxed or have any testing. The UK daughter may well be vaxxed, we don’t know. But I’ll bet she’s not doing a negative PCR every time she visits them like the Austria daughter will have to. If she has a negative test to come into the country, she can’t pass to the parents a virus that she does not have.
PinkiOcelot · 05/12/2021 19:23

Why would your parents have to isolate?

endlesswinter · 05/12/2021 19:21

We are the family traveling back in this situation.
You dsis family will have done their first pcr test before traveling and can take their second as soon as they arrive.
I don't see that they pose more of risk than your family would?
Your DP's don't need to isolate just the traveling family and likely only 12 hours before second test comes back.

We offered to stay elsewhere MiL said not to be daft, your parents are allowed to make their own decisions around risk.

I suspect this is more about resentment about other things.

PrincessPaws · 05/12/2021 19:20

@MargosKaftan

I would ask my sister if there is any way she can come over 2 days earlier so you can all spend Christmas day together.
Absolutely agree with this. An earlier flight, and a test on the way back from the airport
thegcatsmother · 05/12/2021 19:10

YANBU. I'm another one whose sibling is abroad. I moved back, knowing returning to UK would mean I'd get landed with sorting Mum out when necessary. Db is the golden child, and dispenses criticism, 'advice' and suggestions from afar. I'm the one who does the shopping, fills her car up with petrol, sorts any problems, changes her bed and does her bins fortnightly, and I work full time.

How2help has nailed it for me.

Ericabro · 05/12/2021 19:07

They do not have to wait until day 2 to test they could pay at airport for a fast track test and know the results in a few hours if you are so concerned maybe you could offer them a few of the covid tests you could obtain for free?

Africa2go · 05/12/2021 19:02

YANBU - I had a similar situation last year when my relative did come back and moved in with my parents (with children that didn't need to be tested Hmm) to 'isolate', asked parents to collect them from airport etc when they'd be so careful for months. That was completely selfish in my view.

There is a really simple solution here. They come back a couple of days earlier, get a hotel for a night or two until the results come through and then go to your parents and you can all have Xmas together.

GetOffTheTableMabel · 05/12/2021 19:01

The thing is, it’s not your decision. Four other adults, in full possession of the facts, are choosing to spend Christmas together. Covid means difficult choices. They are entitled to make theirs. It’s reasonable for you to feel disappointed but it’s not reasonable for you to try and get anyone to change their minds to suit you.

WonderfulYou · 05/12/2021 19:00

It sounds like your parents okay-ed this with your sister? If so, as adults, your parents are entitled to spend Christmas however, and with whoever, they want/chose to.

I agree.

You sound quite selfish seeing as you can easily see them the other 365 days of the year.

Kshhuxnxk · 05/12/2021 18:51

It's your parents house and they want them to stay so it doesn't really matter what you want.

BlueRabbitWasNaughty · 05/12/2021 18:50

Do your parents definitely have to isolate too?

Pop in to see them on Christmas Eve before your sister arrives and then they should be clear again by Boxing Day.

LethargicActress · 05/12/2021 18:48

Yabu, and yes you do sound like you’re being a bit selfish.

You are not more important than your sister to your parents because you live in the same country, and you and your dc get to see your parents regularly. You can still do some kind of Christmas celebration with your parents before your sister arrives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread