Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if life was better under a Labour government?

241 replies

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 14:56

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

OP posts:
FluffyBooBoo · 05/12/2021 16:43

@Wasloafbetter

Fluffy you did ask me if I you was getting confused with the 60s, so I’m not sure what you meant if you didn’t think that was my opinion.

No, it isn’t a thread about a thread.

I did. Because you posted it.

It's possible to get confused about what other people say, without it being a reflection of your opinion.

So what thread did someone say that on?

BananaBlue · 05/12/2021 16:42

Gay marriage! How could I forget that ShockSmile

crackofdoom · 05/12/2021 16:41

ElsieMc the three day week and power cuts occurred under Ted Heath’s Conservative government.

BananaBlue · 05/12/2021 16:41

In fact, what has got better since coalition/Tory govt?

I think childcare is better (new user, we get 20% tax free)

Personal tax allowance - me and DH tax bill reduced quite a bit.

I cannot think of anything else. I might start a thread.

AliceAldridge · 05/12/2021 16:38

I remember Blair first coming to power being a time of great hope and the first years of New Labour being exciting. Politics seemed to be full of credible thinkers.

But that said I agree that there are a lot of varying recollections and rose tinted glasses on Mumsnet.

Personally, there were very many bog standard average moments for me personally during the 90s and 2000s and I also don't recall the 80s being a time of great acceptance. MPs resigning because they were gay for example.

Tanaqui · 05/12/2021 16:37

Sure start was great but tax credits were a disastrous idea- enabling companies to pay a less than living wage and meaning so many people became reliant on government support.

BananaBlue · 05/12/2021 16:35

Depends on your life situation.

I have more money under the Tories, but public services are so much worse that I worry about social ills that may affect me in/directly (courts blocked up, getting ill, losing our jobs and being skint).

I understand even pre-Covid the Tories spent more public money than last Labour govt and at least with Lab we had something to show for it - schools, libraries, more police nurses etc.

PFI is a huge issue but this lot are just scamming us and siphoning public money to cronies.

We had more global influence I think?
Right now everyone is laughing at us Sad

In any case, we’ve had 11 years of Tory and I’m struggling to name anything that’s got better…

ElsieMc · 05/12/2021 16:34

Honestly, not much different apart from seventies Labour and the three day week and power cuts which was bloody awful.

Under Blair, there were some good ideas such as Care to Learn funding single mum's nursery places so they could continue in education. Great idea, but no local co-ordinator making sure people did not fall through the gaps.

Same for Special Guardianship for children. Again, good idea in principle but the legislation was weak and still enabled abusive parents to take people back to court again and again for contact which it was meant to deter.

Tbh, expecting a labour party to make life better will not happen. There is huge division between Keir Starmer/Angela Rayner at the moment. You have to present a united front if you are to win an election or make the voters believe you are. As much as I dislike Angela Rayner, leaving her out of a so called drinks party says it all.

Spoke to DH who is the same age and he says it is better under the Conservatives and he is from a pro labour family.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 05/12/2021 16:30

It was better, but it laid down the foundation for a lot of today's problems.

Beginning of unlimited immigration which led to Brexit, the Iraq war which destabilised the whole region and which is now the root of many of today's problems.

duffeldaisy · 05/12/2021 16:29

"This thread is making me think I'm not going to bother voting in future. What's the point?"

Are you reading the responses? Lots of people are telling you the difference.
Even if you're not in a marginal your vote counts because parties are always looking to gain seats. So if you do something like vote Green in a place with no hope of them getting in, then next election, the parties will scan the votes and make changes to try to win you over.

If you're in a marginal then you have the power to vote tactically and make real change.

Not voting gives you no power whatsoever.

Thursdaymiami · 05/12/2021 16:21

Wealthy people will come on and tell you it was no different and they did nothing.
But they aren’t the people they benefitted from things like sure start.

I have to go to some really grim parts of London, and the difference between now and then is the utter lack of hope. People just ground down completely and utterly by life and how hard it is.

GreenLunchBox · 05/12/2021 16:21

This thread is making me think I'm not going to bother voting in future. What's the point?

crackofdoom · 05/12/2021 16:17

Although no fan of Blair, I still benefit every day from some of the things that New Labour introduced. I’m still on tax credits, and every time I go for a walk in my closest National Park and look at the big purple edged areas on the OS Map I’m grateful for the Right to Roam legislation.

ILoveHuskies · 05/12/2021 16:15

I was 17 when Blair was voted in

For me personally I benefitted from a Labour government

I became a single mum in 2006 (fleeing an abusive partner) and was able to claim benefits to rent a house and have a basic standard of living for me and my dc
then I got a place at university to train as a nurse. I didn't pay fees and got a bursary of about £20k a year. I also was lucky enough to get a council house in 2009 due to my private rental being mouldy and dangerous. Then Due to having affordable rent I managed to save a deposit and buy a place in 2015. I've made money on that house and upsized two years ago.

I don't think any of this would have happened if the Tories had been in charge.

stealthninjamum · 05/12/2021 16:13

Actually just remembering my poor midwife and health visitor experiences giving birth in the Labour years and the closure of maternity units due to large debts built up.

Having said that things are probably worse under the Tories but I do hate blinkered Labour supporters who are unable to see that some things were bad even before 2010z

duffeldaisy · 05/12/2021 16:11

"Although, we’ve been most financially comfortable under a conservative government I don’t think poor people were better off under Labour and their keenness to get everyone to university misunderstood the needs of the country."

  1. If you're more financially comfortable under the conservatives you are lucky and you're in a minority.
  1. I was poor under Labour, and they massively improved my life with their introduction of a minimum wage.
  1. People were offered the chance to go to University. They weren't pressured, and young people took up that chance in huge numbers. Because they wanted to and felt capable of it. And why not? Other countries encourage their population to get as educated as they want to. It's only here that it's thought of so badly.

Labour weren't perfect. They didn't go nearly far enough, especially with building more social housing, mainly because, I think, they were afraid of being seen too socialist. But I can guarantee - as other people have written here - for those on low incomes, those who were ill, the difference was radical and hopeful.

stealthninjamum · 05/12/2021 16:11

I think people remember the Blair years with nostalgia and forget even in the mid 2000s 1 in 3 children were in poverty. It upsets me that successive governments have failed to address child poverty.

x2boys · 05/12/2021 16:10

I didn't have my children untill 2006 and 2010,so didn't really take much notice of tax credits etc ,but was there not something available to low income families prior to tax credits ,I vaguely remember supplementary benefit ,family income support?

LethargicActress · 05/12/2021 16:06

I remember the feeling that there was a lot more money around. My friends and family who had always been on a low income suddenly became able to afford things like foreign holidays thanks to tax credits. I think tax credits were far too generous personally and the system was very flawed, but at least we didn’t need food banks.

My children were at school during that time, one of them has SN, and they were able to meet his needs without it being issue, even when input was needed from specialists from outside school. Now I work in a school and can see the huge difference between the support that was available then and the severe lack of it for children nowadays. I also preferred the system of levels that children were assessed with at school, it was much more efficient and easier to understand than it is now.

duffeldaisy · 05/12/2021 16:05

It was far, far better under Labour. But they came in after a period of long Tory rule - so they had to make huge investments in public services. Hospitals were falling apart under the Tories, though less than they war now.

As a young person working extremely long hours on low pay, just the bringing in of the minimum wage made a huge difference to my income. For the first time, I could take part in society more. I didn't have children at the start, but benefitted briefly before the Coalition got in and slashed all the funding. We had so many baby groups which all disappeared overnight.

Under the Tories, I'd had to wait for a minor operation (that was causing me enormous pain while waiting so I was on painkillers throughout) for months and months. Labour made a huge difference in hospital waiting times - brought in minimum standards.

They introduced employment rights - paternity pay, etc.

The biggest lie is that the parties are all the same. They are not.
Labour was built out of the unions, which protected workers' rights, which brought in the NHS, which basically has protected or given us a better quality of life.

Conservatives do not care about normal people. They never have.
Saying that, this government is not strictly conservative. It's far, far to the right of tories. It's opportunistic, it really doesn't care and in fact makes decisions which shorten or worsen people's lives.

If you think they're the same, please read up on the history of both parties, and what they have both brought/done to the UK.
There is a huge, huge difference, and until people take a really active interest in that, this country will keep being destroyed.

Essexmum321 · 05/12/2021 16:00

I remember on Gordon Brown’s last day a little girl whose mum got up at 3am to clean the Houses of Parliament every day asking him why life was so hard :-(

Essexmum321 · 05/12/2021 15:59

It was actually under John Major that the gap between the rich and poor last narrowed.

I wonder what it would have been like had John Smith not died and we had old labour rather than new labour.

AuntieJoyce · 05/12/2021 15:55

There was more money for public services but my abiding memory is them constantly tinkering with things that didn’t need changing. All loads of his nanny state legislation. I remember constantly rolling my eyes at breakfast TV in the latest bit of pointless legislation that was going through.

Tax credits and the introduction of tax on dividends for pension funds have had far-reaching and unintended consequences for salaries and pensions. Gordon Brown has one hell of a lot to answer for

RancidOldHag · 05/12/2021 15:52

The Labour governments of the 1970s were pretty disastrous.

And New Labour was all fur coat and no knickers.

JaniceBattersby · 05/12/2021 15:52

I grew up in a very deprived area under Thatcher in the 80s. Life was horrific. My dad had an ok job in local gov but some weekends my mum (v strict budgeter, absolutely no frivolity whatsoever) ran out of food and we were pretty hungry until we got our family allowance on Monday. I still remember my first new outfit that wasn’t a handmedown or made of curtains. I was 11-years-old. Things were bleak.

I was at secondary school when Blair took power. The lives of me and my family were infinitely better. Our school had more money, those less better off were given more aspiration to be whatever they wanted to be, there was good public transport and, crucially for us, public sector pay increased so my dad could afford to give us a bit more money. Clothes and shoes became a lot cheaper too, which may not mean much to some but when you have fuck all, having shitty clothes can really affect your confidence and have a knock-on effect on your ambition. You learn to stand in the background.

I genuinely don’t think me and my siblings would have gone on to uni if there hadn’t been that aspiration for us from our teachers and the means to get there through my dad’s improved pay. My younger siblings went all the way through school with a Labour Gov and have done much better than ‘poor’ kids would have done in the 80s.

Look at the state of public transport, of town centres, infrastructure, health care now. How anyone can objectively think that this government is an improvement on anything at all is a mystery to me (although I guess they’re doing well for rich people. Great.)