Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if life was better under a Labour government?

241 replies

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 14:56

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

OP posts:
FuckYouCorona · 05/12/2021 20:30

There was a massive improvement when Labour went into power under Blair. Waiting lists got far shorter, schools & hospitals were better funded. The difference was like night & day. Blair & chums were certainly not perfect, but in comparison with the Tories, they were 1000% better for normal families.

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:27

@crackofdoom

I think on there are legacy tax credit claimants plus UC just masks those in low pay paying high rent.

I also don’t think we should underestimate the resentment and loss of morale in some communities as they saw some living good lives on benefits, new immigrants taking control of their lives and working hard and then they were left in a kind of no man’s land. There are a lot of single women, no pension, no property, no real security as they hit their 50s that will be an issue for the future and I think there absence in the job market can be traced back to that period (lack of it skills, no route in to new jobs, ?)

crackofdoom · 05/12/2021 20:25

In addition, the US has also seen massive stagnation in real wages- and do they have tax credits, or anything comparable? They do not.Poor working people there are struggling in appalling levels of poverty, and are employers saying “Oh no, look at our poor employees- we must pay them more because they have to visit the food bank to get by”? Are they fuck.

The drivers of higher wages are: Labour shortages, legislation ( like the NMW- introduced by the Blair government), and collective bargaining.

Cattenberg · 05/12/2021 20:25

Street Homelessness wasn’t quite at the appalling situation it’s in now

I was thinking the same! There were plenty of rough sleepers in my town in the 1990s. When Labour got in, they didn’t solve the problem overnight, but sometime in the early 2000s I realised I hadn’t seen a any rough sleepers for a long time (with the exception of one old man who’d been through the system a few times, but even he got the help he needed in the end).

Unsurprisingly, this improvement didn’t last long once the Tories got back in.

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:22

My issue is that those in re riot of support like these things may often be, on balance, better off than those who don’t and have p/t jobs throughout sixth form/university. I know that there have to be some measures to define need but I can’t help agree that all Labour was doing was securing support for the future. That doesn’t mean it is ok to make it harder for those who didn’t get benefits, worked in low paid jobs, etc. I’m not explaining myself well - there is more nuance needed here. I want to support those who need it but we also need to manage other groups and it is difficult to balance this. I think they ruined some well thought out strategies that kept lower middle class communities afloat.

crackofdoom · 05/12/2021 20:21

This is nonsense. If tax credits are the main driver of low wages, we should have seen a measurable growth in real wages as they were phased out in favour of Universal Credit. Has this happened?

toolazytothinkofausername · 05/12/2021 20:16

I went to college during Tony Blair/Gordon Brown. I received EMA (education maintenance allowance) which meant if I attended all my lessons I received £30 a week. This helped me financially so much, including paying for my travel card and daily lunches.

sst1234 · 05/12/2021 20:15

@LethargicActress

I remember the feeling that there was a lot more money around. My friends and family who had always been on a low income suddenly became able to afford things like foreign holidays thanks to tax credits. I think tax credits were far too generous personally and the system was very flawed, but at least we didn’t need food banks.

My children were at school during that time, one of them has SN, and they were able to meet his needs without it being issue, even when input was needed from specialists from outside school. Now I work in a school and can see the huge difference between the support that was available then and the severe lack of it for children nowadays. I also preferred the system of levels that children were assessed with at school, it was much more efficient and easier to understand than it is now.

And therein lies the problem. Tax credits were a calculated scheme for labour to create a dependent class that would never get to commmad market rate wages and would always be ‘grateful’ for state handouts attributed to labour policies. Tax credits are the reason we have have had some of fhe of the lowest wage growth in the developed world in the last 20 years. Anyone applauding tax credits is economically and socially illiterate. And cognitively impaired to boot - even after seeing the damage done.
Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:13

I remember reading that there had always large scale migration upwards in Africa that bottlenecked at Libya. Under Gadaffi, an unofficial agreement was made to intern refugees in camps. When he went, there was nothing so people pushed northwards and it is only since then we recognise it as a European concern.

lljkk · 05/12/2021 20:12

I always find Angela Raynor's story about how SureStart changed her life -- to be very moving.

Blair's govt did a lot of things I liked.

I liked the coalition govt -- that was reasonably balanced too.

Johnson's Big Spending 'conservative' govt is a curious beast.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2021 20:10

@tarasmalatarocks

Can we not keep bringing up the Iraq war— that was voted on by all parties, it simply was not just a unilateral decision and hindsight is an amazing thing.
I don’t think you can expect such a big part of Blair’s time and impact to be ignored.

And I did think he was good, at the start anyway.

sst1234 · 05/12/2021 20:08

@tarasmalatarocks

Can we not keep bringing up the Iraq war— that was voted on by all parties, it simply was not just a unilateral decision and hindsight is an amazing thing.
Should we brush under the carpet that Iraq was the reason that Syria is where is it is today? That the mass movement of people happened this decade? It’s not in our imaginations, and there is no collective responsibility here. Blair pulled the trigger.
sst1234 · 05/12/2021 20:06

Hang on here, are we forgetting:
PFIs which structurally damaged the NHS and was a corrupt idea if not incompetent
Bringing in tuition fees
Plundering off our gold reserves at rich bottom prices
Mass immigration which led to Brexit eventually
Creating a culture of low wages through benefits which saw UK gal behind the entire developed world on pay
Iraq
All of these things did so much damage to this country, most of which could only be counted after labour got kicked out.

tarasmalatarocks · 05/12/2021 20:04

Can we not keep bringing up the Iraq war— that was voted on by all parties, it simply was not just a unilateral decision and hindsight is an amazing thing.

tarasmalatarocks · 05/12/2021 20:02

I certainly think the vibe was better under labour and councils had more available to them. My sons school environment improved massively under labour. I’m sure if you are loaded it’s fine under the Tory’s but they have created huge instability— many friends who had nice little enterprises around their kids have had to stop because of Brexit , as lots of their customers were non UK and it is now non viable.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2021 19:55

@thepeopleversuswork

It depends what you mean by a Labour government.

It's not a popular view but I happen to think Blair was the best PM of my lifetime (born early 70s). He got a lot of things wrong but in terms of supporting the economy, trying to create a more equal society but without overspending and support for more social mobility he was certainly better than anything I've seen before or since.

If you're talking about a Corbyn government though my answer would be very different. I think he was at best dangerously misled and naive. And while I loathe this current government I think a Corbyn government would not have handled the pandemic any better.

I thought Blair good until the end - and war part

I wonder where we’d be if the other Milliband went forward

But a Labour government doesn’t make me think they’d do a pandemic better. Starmer wanting to close nurseries at one point, any stronghold by unions would concern me

Maybe people are more affected if they are in public services. Here for twenty years and apart from feeling better about Labour in the past it’s more a mood than something tangibly different for me

Dh talks about free tuition fees which was a big change, I was o/s for study.

I’d welcome a more Blair like Labour - positive and with opportunities but without the war. And a good economy but they need to have good economic policies. Not convinced Starmer does.

OpeningY · 05/12/2021 19:47

I think the current government is crap - very high taxation whilst also providing poor public services. Paying this much tax you would expect education and the NHS to be leading the world but class sizes are still high and waiting lists are long.

The debacle of migrants crossing the Channel continues in their thousands but the government does nothing.

I think it was better under Blair, but he benefitted from a booming global economy. Labour now are likely to be even worse than the tories.

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 19:38

@BananaBlue

I mean the way W/c communities were depicted (through the media) but also the perception that they had little say or knowledge of how to improve their environment.

I know you cannot blame politicians for media spin but where was the comeback? The defence of communities and histories? Why was everyone deemed racist in areas that had high immigration historically and comprised of groups as diverse as Jewish to Vietnamese? Why couldn’t there have been a recognition of what things those groups had done to help and we could build on that instead of writing off every area and blitzing old communities in disadvantaged areas. I grew up in an area where the far right was always known of and watched carefully from a distance yet I also saw people enter teaching at that time who had some very dubious views and since then it is really apparent the contempt some of them have for poorer communities. There was a middle ground that was destroyed. I have seen in my borough that many of the most disadvantaged families from one ward were pushed out to another ward just as the funding came through for them. Who got that funding? The new graduates in the area and the college which got university status and completely obliterated the old immigrant community that lived there before.So, a double blow to a vulnerable community. I also can’t believe the snobbishness that has crept in to these gentrified areas. So many people have moved in to my old area and I find the way they describe it and the people so disparaging. It was hardly the Bronx. It’s actually much worse now with the smell of weed in so many residential areas. I just feel really pushed out work and home wise.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/12/2021 19:24

@Pleasebeafleabite

I hope that every MNer who whinges about boomers and their gold plated final salary schemes is fully aware that they were very much alive kicking and well funded until mr brown introduced tax on dividends and changed the funding regime

Better off you all ain’t

It is (as I suspect you well know) much more complex than that. The Maxwell affair and reforms to governance and reporting also made a huge difference to final salary pensions, as did Thatcher’s contracting out changes and plummeting investment returns. Brown’s change made a difference but it didn’t destroy DB pensions - that’s a gross partisan over simplified bit of revisionist history.
thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2021 19:23

It depends what you mean by a Labour government.

It's not a popular view but I happen to think Blair was the best PM of my lifetime (born early 70s). He got a lot of things wrong but in terms of supporting the economy, trying to create a more equal society but without overspending and support for more social mobility he was certainly better than anything I've seen before or since.

If you're talking about a Corbyn government though my answer would be very different. I think he was at best dangerously misled and naive. And while I loathe this current government I think a Corbyn government would not have handled the pandemic any better.

BananaBlue · 05/12/2021 19:14

Half the country on tax credits to keep the labour vote

Wouldn’t we still have a Labour gov if this was true?

Long term TC weren’t a good idea - I’ve never been a recipient btw.

But folk working decent hrs on UC and still piss poor isn’t progressive either in my opinion.

There must be a midway.

BananaBlue · 05/12/2021 19:12

*Torys would never have dreamed to do in uncoupling some mechanisms that protected W/c.

And it was during their reign we had the absolute public humiliation of W/c values and histories.*

What does this mean @Choirgirl2021?

Can you give examples because I don’t understand?

Againstmachine · 05/12/2021 18:55

*Choir girl, the housing mess started with Mrs Thatcher selling off council housing, and refusing to allow councils to build more with the receipts"

The problem is council housing sell offs were happening into labours days and they had no intention of stopping it.

I absolutely hate Thatcher and what she did to this country but labour didn't do enough to reverse it.

Thecurliestwurly · 05/12/2021 18:47

It does feel like everything has gone backwards in the last 10 years. I'm not saying Labour would be better, but we have not reached our potential under the Tories and I think a lot of things have gotten worse, not better. Labour appeared to be a much better government for families and social mobility, but I won't forgive them for the Iraq war.

Anything good that has happened in the last 10 years is due to social change and not political change.

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 18:40

I agree. And what about the people who were just above the level of benefits/tax credits and had student loans to study ? Propping up one group of people and shifting the weight on to another group is not the answer. It just creates a new group of need.

Btl was unleashed under Labour and they ramped it up. I really feel that Labour did what the Torys would never have dreamed to do in uncoupling some mechanisms that protected W/c.

And it was during their reign we had the absolute public humiliation of W/c values and histories. Much of it was unforgivable and I think it’s the humiliation people won’t forget and forgive Labour for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread