Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if life was better under a Labour government?

241 replies

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 14:56

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 05/12/2021 21:45

@DroopyClematis

Life in the 70s , Labour, was pretty dire. Bodies stacked up, ripped bin bags in every street due to no in collections, endless strikes, loads of blackouts. Thatcher halted the union power but her reign saw endless pit /steel/shipyard closures. It was a good thing as she ended the era of Mike putting a bolt in but Arnold, who tightened the bolt, went on his fag/tea break and so Mike wasn't allowed to tighten the bolt in Arthur's place due to union rules. So production kept stopping.

Let's not forget those car workers who demanded to be allowed to work nights, with their sleeping bags despite production being halted as people weren't buying their cars.

Yes a lot needed to happen but she put nothing in place for those communities, just told people to get on their bikes to London.

Blair just pussyfooted until he left.

She did what needed to be done. Someone had to take the thought decisions. Yes, she didn’t focus enough attention on left behind areas, but she course corrected the economy to have at least some chance of keeping up with the changes coming down the line. The hard left Marxists would still be fighting to keep the mines open today. Imagine that.
UndertheCedartree · 05/12/2021 21:42

Personally, life was better for me. My DS was young and there was so much support. We had a lovely Children's centre. Lots going on, groups, courses etc. There was a great breastfeeding group. Rates of breastfeeding actually increased in our area. The Centre did so much outreach work as well it was so valuable. Every school holiday there was a brilliant timetable of activities for school children. As soon as the Tories got in they started trying to shut it down. We fought and fought but eventually they got their way. I don't know that there are any Children's centres in our town anymore. There were other ways life was better too but that was a big one.

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/12/2021 21:41

New Labour brought cuts in along with the funding - they forced 'efficiency savings' first, which could not be taken from anywhere but the staff thanks to ring-fenced funding, and then started closing services or forcing them into the voluntary sector. It was 2006 in my area when places started closing. Too many seem to think it all happened after 2008. Too many are prey, now, to the propaganda-driven media circus, that was formed in the Blair years. 'Post-information' and 'post-truth' came into being thanks to New Labour political-correctness that was already turning into outright lies and misinformation.

3cats4poniesandababy · 05/12/2021 21:34

I was brought up during Blair and I don't remember things being great.
Before the 2010 election labour were also saying austerity policies were coming same as the conservatives.
The town I live in doesn't have a fully hospital anymore because of a contract/policy Gordon Brown introduced. He murdered NHS services in my area all for some private investment.
Gordon brown sold the national gold reserves.
The financial crisis - yes it was global but the high borrowing in the preceeding years did not help. It is quite easy to spend spend spend when borrowing. Unfortunately ypu can't borrow forever.
Conservatives are nit perfect either but I definitely don't look back on the Blair years thinking all was fabulous.

Dreamstate · 05/12/2021 21:25

@ParsleySageRosemary

There have already been various more intelligent comments about education through New Labour. Labour always claims to be better on education, but I think it's an area that's best developed over time using practice gained at the coal face rather than jumping for the latest fads, whether they come from 'progressives' or not. Both for teachers and students! The much maligned rote learning works, practice and more practice works, and believing students know everything does not. You need to know the rules of how things work, and understand them, before you can use them creatively. Maths education is only now beginning to get going again, stressing meaning and understanding.

@Choirgirl2021 - A lot of the things that came in didn’t really seem designed to solve problems but rather pacify people and create jobs...I remember feeling as though someone was having a party in my house, eating my food and playing my music but they had locked me out and every time I tried to get in they made it harder.

Beautifully put. It felt to me as if they were desperately papering over cracks in the walls with ever more fancy wallpaper, and pretending they'd fixed the cracks.

I think icsharr the same thoughts. I look bsck and think it felt like life was better, people having a good life, good job and a sense of you can make it. But I cant really pinpoint anything more substantive to back that feeling up.
Andante57 · 05/12/2021 21:20

I wanna emigrate

Skysblue where would you like to emigrate to?

DroopyClematis · 05/12/2021 21:15

Life in the 70s , Labour, was pretty dire.
Bodies stacked up, ripped bin bags in every street due to no in collections, endless strikes, loads of blackouts.
Thatcher halted the union power but her reign saw endless pit /steel/shipyard closures. It was a good thing as she ended the era of Mike putting a bolt in but Arnold, who tightened the bolt, went on his fag/tea break and so Mike wasn't allowed to tighten the bolt in Arthur's place due to union rules. So production kept stopping.

Let's not forget those car workers who demanded to be allowed to work nights, with their sleeping bags despite production being halted as people weren't buying their cars.

Yes a lot needed to happen but she put nothing in place for those communities, just told people to get on their bikes to London.

Blair just pussyfooted until he left.

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/12/2021 21:13

There have already been various more intelligent comments about education through New Labour. Labour always claims to be better on education, but I think it's an area that's best developed over time using practice gained at the coal face rather than jumping for the latest fads, whether they come from 'progressives' or not. Both for teachers and students! The much maligned rote learning works, practice and more practice works, and believing students know everything does not. You need to know the rules of how things work, and understand them, before you can use them creatively. Maths education is only now beginning to get going again, stressing meaning and understanding.

@Choirgirl2021 - A lot of the things that came in didn’t really seem designed to solve problems but rather pacify people and create jobs...I remember feeling as though someone was having a party in my house, eating my food and playing my music but they had locked me out and every time I tried to get in they made it harder.

Beautifully put. It felt to me as if they were desperately papering over cracks in the walls with ever more fancy wallpaper, and pretending they'd fixed the cracks.

VestaTilley · 05/12/2021 21:10

It was so much better than this shit show - domestically anyway.

Minimum wage, 2 million out of poverty, winter fuel allowance, all the new schools and hospitals, fox hunting ban, right to roam, smoking ban, independence for the Bank of England, devolution, billions in to public services.

I’d go back to Blair being PM tomorrow. I watched the Blair Brown documentary recently and actually cried at the end.

They responded robustly to the global financial meltdown, terror attacks, foot and mouth, the death of Diana, and other huge challenges. Until Iraq all the foreign policy interventions seemed the right thing to do and worked well too.

Today’s Labour Party is a joke in comparison, and don’t get me started on the havoc the Tories have managed to wreak in just eleven years. Heart breaking.

If only Gordon had won that election. What might’ve been.

user1471538283 · 05/12/2021 21:08

It was so much better. I remember the sheer relief when Blair got in. I had a top up of family credit of £75 a week under the tories I had nothing.

The way it is at the moment I would take anyone rather than the infant.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 05/12/2021 21:03

We have a Labour government in Wales. Huge waiting lists for NHS, no carers for people, everything just as shit but it’s fine because we are Welsh in Wales.

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 21:03

How different would we be now if John Smith RIP had been PM?

I don’t know.

Pixxie7 · 05/12/2021 21:00

I don’t think you can compare things like freedom of expression as that isn’t really determined by political views but by society as a whole. We have come a long way as far as equality etc since the 80 which still has a long way to go. However I think in general labour are far more aware of social inequality. Additionally not sure if Blair is a good example as he instigated new labour with similar values to the Tories.

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 21:00

@teaandbiscuitsforme

OP You need to go and spend a week in a school. The difference will be apparent very quickly!! Teaching is nothing like it was pre-2010, primary education is nothing like it was pre-2010. It makes me so sad for those kids (including my own DC!)
Holidays and maternity leave aside, I’ve spent every week in a school since 2002!
OP posts:
Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:58

@ParsleySageRosemary

That was my experience too. I am a bit older than you but we had worked so hard for every penny, played by the rules and I think the frivolous nature of public spending that was dangled into peoples faces to show they were mugs for working in boring 9-5s, that’s the kind of thing that shakes your confidence in knowing what is really going on and who to trust. Every seemed to jump into teaching for the pensions and many just pushed the really genuine teachers put, imv.

I used to see schools with a huge number of very busy and self important support staff and yet the most basic of things were overlooked and some very vulnerable children missed the small but crucial input they needed on a daily basis (that well placed and conscientious support staff were desperately trying to do).

VickyEadieofThigh · 05/12/2021 20:52

@Wasloafbetter

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

I was a headteacher when Blair came to power, having spent all my career under the Tories until then.

Schools were starved of funding under the Tories; we were actually properly funded under Labour.

Not sure why you think it was worse...

Pazuzu · 05/12/2021 20:51

If you massively expand NHS debt then it's easy to "fund it properly"

Student loans? Didn't see Labour bring back grants.

There were plenty of homeless people around during the Labour years too.

As for the effect on families, ask those in Iraq...

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:49

My take on it is that there may have been money but was it put to good use in areas that had a defect for so long? For example schools where generations had lacked real funding suddenly for good funding whilst those families moved to other areas that lost their funding. The political games were huge and only some could play them. It is good imv that people move to areas and rejuvenate them, it’s progress and healthy for everyone but it didn’t need to be so aggressively done and exclude existing communities. My parents were immigrants here - everyone benefits from an existing structure and over time you understand why things are the way they are and can look for initiatives that help everyone but I didn’t see any of that happening - I just saw some pretty crude tactics at play that were always going to lead us to where we are now.

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/12/2021 20:49

Sorry that was long. I never voted for New Labour, and I will not be voting for a renewed version of it. I guess I won't be voting any more.

Cattenberg · 05/12/2021 20:48

I was a teenager when Blair got in. Life did seem better then, except for the house price inflation that made me despair of ever owning my own home. And tuition fees. The economy was booming, but it very much felt to me as though the older generation had pulled the ladder up after themselves.

Now our infrastructure just feels so rundown and neglected. Our schools, hospitals, social services and justice system/legal aid seem to be running on fumes and the goodwill of the staff. And whatever happened to SureStart centres, daycare centres for adults with disabilities and respite care?

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/12/2021 20:47

I'm mid-40s and remember New Labour - it was New Labour, not Labour remember - with distinctly mixed views. Good bits - Surestart, more money in public services than in the 80s I'll admit, idea of lifelong learning.

Bad bits. Lifelong learning via tuition fees and privatised Unis. That's the kind of creation of mixed feelings I saw all the way through. Budgets were highly controlled through this time and an awful lot was just waste. Patterns of public finance changed hugely in this time. No longer was money given to the council who could decide where it was spent, money was put in different pots, every penny had to be specifically requested, huge sectors were set up specfically to write the requests, internal marketplaces were set up that were hugely wasteful, and everything was target-based. Those targets became what public services were all about and the actual needs they were supposed to deal with were rated as secondary and have now been forgotten entirely. There were some people who made an absolute fortune out of all the bureaucracy that was set up. There were also large numbers of unelected quangos set up, and again some people made a fortune. The net result was that an awful lot of public money made its way into private purses at this time. Worse, that became the established pattern and only way to operate. Giving money to the loud and vocal became the norm.

As a young working person at the time, who was trying to work up the ropes from nothing I discovered that the work and wages I'd tried hard to get into became lower valued, because giving wages to people who worked for it became a dirty idea rather than just giving money as freebies to the loud and vocal. The people who made a mint were generally the older generations. Meanwhile this was also when buy-to-let landlords were set loose on us, and the cost of housing quadrupled. No one gave a shit, because some were making a fortune - again transferring public money to private purses - and that made it all right.

In short it was a time of strange marriages of right and left ideas that didn't really go together, and unsurprisingly a time when inequality and divisions started to grow. Working people were the losers, and the already rich and feckless were the winners. Not to mention of course, this was when intergenerational inequality kicked off.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 05/12/2021 20:38

There was a massive improvement when Labour went into power under Blair. Waiting lists got far shorter, schools & hospitals were better funded. The difference was like night & day. Blair & chums were certainly not perfect, but in comparison with the Tories, they were 1000% better for normal families.

Of course it did. There was money, they spent it and left the infamous "I'm afraid there is no money left" note when they lost to Cameron.

teaandbiscuitsforme · 05/12/2021 20:35

OP You need to go and spend a week in a school. The difference will be apparent very quickly!! Teaching is nothing like it was pre-2010, primary education is nothing like it was pre-2010. It makes me so sad for those kids (including my own DC!)

Choirgirl2021 · 05/12/2021 20:33

Not all @FuckYouCorona that’s my point. We are ordinary and we’re much worse off. We’ve never recovered. I feel they just took from some and gave to others but only within W/c communities. Better off communities had all the real advantages.

crackofdoom · 05/12/2021 20:32

*Choirgirl2021

Oh and the housing market mess started under Labour as did student loans*

It started with Thatcher deregulating financial markets while also selling off council houses. (But the Blair government failed to do anything meaningful to alleviate the damage).

Swipe left for the next trending thread