Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if life was better under a Labour government?

241 replies

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 14:56

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

OP posts:
Choirgirl2021 · 06/12/2021 12:17

@x2boys

I was a nurse throughout the labour years ,I do remember more building going on ,I also remember the huge amounts of money hospital trusts paid private companies for the building work ,it was very top heavy management wise ,ever increasing tiers of management ,where as staff on the actual wards ime ,was as sparse as ever
I was redeployed twice due to cuts in service between 2005 and 2006
So I don't remember the halycon days tbh

My experience too. It was though all of this money was floating around me but just out of my grasp whilst o got buried deeper and deeper under the pressures of work.

DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 12:05

@jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey

Honestly they are all crap! Regardless of party, once elected, they just do what they please.
Yep, it doesn't matter who you vote for because the Government always gets in.
x2boys · 06/12/2021 12:00

I was a nurse throughout the labour years ,I do remember more building going on ,I also remember the huge amounts of money hospital trusts paid private companies for the building work ,it was very top heavy management wise ,ever increasing tiers of management ,where as staff on the actual wards ime ,was as sparse as ever
I was redeployed twice due to cuts in service between 2005 and 2006
So I don't remember the halycon days tbh

shinynewapple21 · 06/12/2021 11:58

I am sure it depends a lot on individual circumstances.

For me personally - both myself and DH employed on average wages (him FT me PT), small semi house, one DC (now adult) - I cannot say that different governments have made a massive difference to our lives.

We always had a worry that Labour govt may impact on DH employment (manufacturing for MD contract) and Conservative govt may impact on my work (public services) but luckily always retained our jobs .

inferiorCatSlave · 06/12/2021 11:32

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I only remember New Labour - it was at a time in my life I was particularly optimistic starting University - embarking on life.

I do think new Labour was underlying more postive until the end - and all governments end in failure.

Austerity - felt very grim and I think hugly damaged parts of the country we lived in.

I'm currently under a Labour Governement in Wales - they contol NHS and Education - and some environment issues - like air polution - I have serious concerns about performance. As a result I have to admit to being a bit skeptcial of some posters claims everything will be great under a labour government.

I unimpressed with current UK government, current welsh Labour government and with the current opposition.

I think it can be hard to separate out your personal situation from wider social/poltical situation but I do think Labour tends to fund services more but I'm surpised the later austerity years when buffers and support services had been run down were worse than New Labour funded years in education.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/12/2021 11:32

@AdoraBell

All I remember of Labour before 1979 was the power cuts and rubbish pilling up due to strikes.

While we were poor my parents didn’t qualify for benefits snd my father’s work was stable and not affected by the miners strike in the 80’s. The only thing that really affected us from Thatcher’s government was the change from rates to council tax, and my parents benefited from the right to buy scheme.

I was living alone and working full time when Blair took office. While it didn’t make any difference to my situation, both my sister - single parent, and my father- pensioner, were worse off financially immediately.

I agree that once they are in power it makes no difference which party because it’s all about them and their power trip.

All I remember of Labour before 1979 was the power cuts and rubbish pilling up due to strikes

Power cuts and the 3 day week were under Conservative governments.

Railk · 06/12/2021 11:13

Remember the school renovation/ rebuilding program too.

Where we live all the new schools were given beautiful new buildings and old schools too. Luckily we still have all that from the Labour days. As soon as the Tories came in it was suddenly stopped and the schools that had not been renovated missed out. They’re now decaying wrecks.

Choirgirl2021 · 06/12/2021 11:10

Good Friday Agreement- Labour tackled that. I think it made a tremendous difference to NI

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 11:10

And devolution would not have happened under the Tories.

CounsellorTroi · 06/12/2021 11:09

The Blair government brought in devolution for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Which I think was and is a good thing.

Railk · 06/12/2021 11:07

@HappydaysArehere

Before the change from Labour it was easier to get a hospital appointment and there were more A&E’s. Within months of the Tories taking over A&E’s were being closed and the NHS has been increasingly struggling ever since. Unfortunately Corbyn and the extreme left did for the Labour Party and gave Johnson an open goal.
Yes. This is so true. I think many people are too young to remember things being better or it’s been wiped from our memories now due to so long under the Tories.

Also Covid has been convenient for the Tories. All the damage they’ve done can be blamed on that.

Shapesandcolours · 06/12/2021 11:07

I would say that the Labour years from 1997 onwards were the best government in living memory from a domestic standpoint. So much was done to attempt to improve society - Human Rights legislation, Freedom of Information, Data Protection, paternity leave introduced, Good Friday Agreement, Tax Credits (aimed to lift people out of poverty), huge reduction in child poverty etc. The Tories seem to have no plans to change society for the better for ordinary people and seem to coast along without much of an agenda for change or improvement.

ShinyHappyPoster · 06/12/2021 10:57

I'm laughing that a poster suggested more people had holidays because they spent their tax credits on them. Grin
Research from the ONS shows there was a surge in overseas holidays in that period because of the budget airlines and the common aviation area. Nothing to do with tax credits Hmm

LakieLady · 06/12/2021 10:51

@EngTech

Labour had 13 years in power, could never figure out why all the Utility Companies and the railways were not nationalised 😳😳
There was no appetite for it and they'd not long been privatised. Nationalisation was regarded as near-Soviet by many people.

I've spent most of my working life in the public sector and started work in 1972. Public services were always better resourced and funded under Labour governments.

ShinyHappyPoster · 06/12/2021 10:48

@Choirgirl2021

So, it really depends on your specific circumstances. Many with young children say it was better but what about the teen/young adults for that time and older adults?

It seems so many good initiatives were started and I think they probably tackled the hidden poor and many ethnic communities who had been completely locked out of the money/education system. That’s good. Perhaps on balance it was better ?

The outreach work in communities wasn't just around parents and young children. It also impacted teens and young adults. Community initiatives benefitted and focused on the elderly too.

Another difference under Labour was the maintenance and repair programmes in hospitals. There are lots of old hospital buildings but under Labour, the maintenance and staffing levels meant they were repaired.

Under the Conservatives, there are entire wings of hospitals in our area that are unusable because they've not been able to fund or schedule the necessary repairs. Research from 2019 showed that over £4 billion was cut from capital budgets which would normally have paid for maintenance and repairs. There's now over £6billion deficit for maintenance and repairs - which impacts bed availability, information technology, working lifts, drainage systems, etc.

sst1234 · 06/12/2021 10:47

@Andante57

all for the audacity of wanting to study rather than become a teenage mother as advised by SS Thousandsoftulips it beggars belief that those who were supposed to be helping you actually gave that advice. It’s really shocking and there were probably many young women who followed it.
Not surprising at all. This is what Labour stand for. Create an army of state dependent, low aspiring voters will in stay in power. Because letting people better themselves loses labour voters. Labour used to be incredibly insidious. Thankfully, now they’re just stupid.
MasterBeth · 06/12/2021 10:40

I think it’s too simplistic to look back on a period of your own life to see if things have got better. Life has got materially better for me as I’ve got older, across Labour and Conservative governments, but that’s more to do with life stages and career than politics.

What about wider society?

The first time I remember seeing homeless people on the streets locally was when John Major’s Conservative government introduced “Care in the community” (i. e. shut down lots of institutional housing and let vulnerable people largely fend for themselves).

Under Labour, you stopped seeing homeless people in my city. Funding was directed to programmes to get people into housing.

Under Cameron and austerity, they came back. Under Johnson, it’s worse than ever.

Public investment in transport, hospitals and schools was noticeably improved under Labour. Public investment stagnates under Conservative governments.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 06/12/2021 10:40

@Choirgirl2021

They aren’t the only two choices though, are they? It doesn’t need to be so polarised. That’s how right wing media likes to prevent Labour but I think many people are a mixture of both positions.

My concern is that a whole sector of people who may have made considerable gains in housing, assets, etc who would traditionally vote Labour will now vote Lib Dem / green as they don’t really want the structural reforms they once applauded now they have so much to lose. By casting a technically void vote, the conservatives will stay in. I wish Rory Stewart had won.

You're assuming that everyone votes for what they can get for themselves. As another poster said the better off isn't affected that much by either party but I vote for the kind of country I want to live in. Good NHS, education, social care, looking after less fortunate people when in need, better funded police, public transport, the list goes on. By improving these we all benefit in the long run. You won't get this kind of society with the Tories, they fundamentally believe in the survival of the fittest.
HappydaysArehere · 06/12/2021 10:33

Before the change from Labour it was easier to get a hospital appointment and there were more A&E’s. Within months of the Tories taking over A&E’s were being closed and the NHS has been increasingly struggling ever since. Unfortunately Corbyn and the extreme left did for the Labour Party and gave Johnson an open goal.

MissMinutes24 · 06/12/2021 10:21

Haven't read the full thread but one of my most acute memories was the A/AS level marking scandal in which the government ordered examiners to artificially downgrade papers because they kept being hammered for results being too good.

My AS levels were affected but fortunately I was able to retake them.

Students in the year above me lost uni places though.

That aside, in general there were a lot of things Labour did that, when you look back, ended up having terrible unforeseen consequences eg their push to get 50% of kids to uni, PFI schemes etc.

Floundery · 06/12/2021 10:15

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Choirgirl2021 · 06/12/2021 10:07

So, it really depends on your specific circumstances. Many with young children say it was better but what about the teen/young adults for that time and older adults?

It seems so many good initiatives were started and I think they probably tackled the hidden poor and many ethnic communities who had been completely locked out of the money/education system. That’s good. Perhaps on balance it was better ?

YourenutsmiLord · 06/12/2021 10:02

According to the news on the radio this morning the Gov is attempting to tackle the drugs problem - about time - but I don't think any Gov has had a decent strategy for that previously.

BigYellowHat · 06/12/2021 09:59

No

ShinyHappyPoster · 06/12/2021 09:58

Using external parameters, life expectancy was better in deprived areas under Labour because there were support networks. The area I was volunteering in at the time had SureStart, subsidised local authority gym, subsidised fruit and veg market, more outreach work, more support for parents. Outreach was doubling year-on-year. I know there was some increased paperwork around those initiatives but it was worth it - they caught lots of families who would have otherwise fallen through the cracks.

Since technology had not been embraced in the same way and social media was in its infancy, women were not subjected to daily death and rape threats for expressing an opinion or being in the public eye or just simply for existing. Instead there was a real impetus around equality programmes for women and other oft-neglected minority groups.

Swipe left for the next trending thread