Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if life was better under a Labour government?

241 replies

Wasloafbetter · 05/12/2021 14:56

Or are people looking back with rose tinted specs?

I started teaching in the Blair years and I found it pretty awful, although how much of that was down to my own lack of experience and how much was down to government policies is hard to say.

I’m wondering if people are looking back nostalgically (have seen this on a thread this morning where apparently the 80s were a great time for freedom of expression with no pressure to conform, which don’t tally with my memories at all) or whether life was better then.

I’m 42, by the way - was 17 when Blair was made PM.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tumbleweed101 · 06/12/2021 18:57

Personally speaking mine was better under Labour as they introduced tax credits and other family friendly initiatives that have been eroded under the conservatives. I'm very grateful I don't have little children now with the two child only policies, UC changes etc. As a low earner these were very important to me at the time.

Andante57 · 06/12/2021 18:53

Maybe, but women can be forced out of their jobs for saying that men are not women and that biology matters. I agree with @MorningStarling**

Parsleysage that is very true and that certainly is like North Korea in that those forced out of their jobs seem to have no recourse.
I hope the tide is turning - if it does turn I wonder if the cancellers will be cancelled.

Lolacat1234 · 06/12/2021 18:05

I often wonder this. It feels like it was better under a labour government. I remember a few times having to take my mum to A&E when she broke her hand and her foot and being in and out within 4 hours. These days it's closer to 8 no matter what time of the day you go. Also remember it was the tail end of a labour government when my son was born and I thought the provision for mums was so much better - sure start centres etc. there's nothing now. Our local birthing centre just closed and people are losing hope that it'll ever be opened again. Although of course people will say these sure start centres cost money and we were in x amount of debt as a country etc and that labour was running the country into the ground with debt so 2 sides to every coin. I will always vote labour though.

ParsleySageRosemary · 06/12/2021 18:02

@HappydaysArehere

Before the change from Labour it was easier to get a hospital appointment and there were more A&E’s. Within months of the Tories taking over A&E’s were being closed and the NHS has been increasingly struggling ever since. Unfortunately Corbyn and the extreme left did for the Labour Party and gave Johnson an open goal.
Ah yes, the extreme left of Corbyn and McDonnell that was less extreme than what exists on the European continent. The extreme left that GAVE US THE NHS IN THE FIRST PLACE. Do you like the NHS? Never had to rely on it to save a life of someone you love?

We have a bigger problem than which party is in power, which is that there is no will or vision to make lives better for people any more, and the only thing politicians can do is pretend to throw money at a problem until it goes away.

We need to start talking about public spaces and public interest again, and what they mean. We need to bring back the public sector as the defender and champion of the public interest, and discussions about what all that means. That was what Corbyn was showing signs of wanting to do. It wasn't just about letting people make money out of others, and it never can be. That has only ever led to poverty and misery for the majority. Throughout history, for 5000 years of records. When will homo sapiens sapiens ever learn anything.

I despair of this country now. If there is change, it lies on the other side of a period of brutality. I will not live to see the other side.

ParsleySageRosemary · 06/12/2021 17:51

@Andante57

Place is turning into fucking North Korea

I think the people of North Korean would love to have just some of our freedoms.
Whatever you may think of this government, as far as I know citizens here aren’t sent to labour camps for watching foreign dramas.

Maybe, but women can be forced out of their jobs for saying that men are not women and that biology matters. I agree with @MorningStarling.
LakieLady · 06/12/2021 16:45

@ElsieMc

Honestly, not much different apart from seventies Labour and the three day week and power cuts which was bloody awful.

Under Blair, there were some good ideas such as Care to Learn funding single mum's nursery places so they could continue in education. Great idea, but no local co-ordinator making sure people did not fall through the gaps.

Same for Special Guardianship for children. Again, good idea in principle but the legislation was weak and still enabled abusive parents to take people back to court again and again for contact which it was meant to deter.

Tbh, expecting a labour party to make life better will not happen. There is huge division between Keir Starmer/Angela Rayner at the moment. You have to present a united front if you are to win an election or make the voters believe you are. As much as I dislike Angela Rayner, leaving her out of a so called drinks party says it all.

Spoke to DH who is the same age and he says it is better under the Conservatives and he is from a pro labour family.

The 3-day week and power cuts happened under the Tory government when Heath was PM.
Andante57 · 06/12/2021 16:39

Place is turning into fucking North Korea

I think the people of North Korean would love to have just some of our freedoms.
Whatever you may think of this government, as far as I know citizens here aren’t sent to labour camps for watching foreign dramas.

TooManyGiraffes · 06/12/2021 16:21

@Changes17

Indeed. We are all still paying for PFI profits now. It was a ridiculous scheme.

I thought PFI was a bad idea at the time because of the costs it was adding to balance sheets - but I did think again about that when a few months ago I visited a school for my year 6 child, that was built under PFI. It's still owned by the developer, which still maintains the building, but In 15 years the funding will be paid off and the school will own it (though admittedly its an academy now so will be owned by the academy trust presumably) . It's still a great building –suddenly PFI seemed to make more sense than not having new schools/hospitals because of lack of funding.

Those were not the only two options.
HesterShaw1 · 06/12/2021 16:01

The decline of the UK started long long before Blair.

inferiorCatSlave · 06/12/2021 15:02

The decline of the UK started under Blair and has just progressively got worse. Every sector of society is so much worse than it was in the 80s and 90s before Blair. All the matters now is profit and everything has been financialised.

Is this regional thing because I grew up in midlands manufatoring area under Thacher - it was not great huge employers went - DH bit of midand also had it hard.

I don't remember anything before her but three day weeks and powercuts don't sound that great.

Then had Major years which I don't remember being that brilliant either.

I do remember finding the spin of New Labour years irriating but areas we lived in did seem more prosperous for a bit though what caused that I couldn't say- I suspect global conditions and being in uptick of ecomomic cycle and some of the money they spent.

I did notice the delcine with austerity years.

x2boys · 06/12/2021 15:02

@MorningStarling

Blair was the point when truth and facts became secondary to presentation and spin. Populist leaders like Trump are direct descendents of Blair's "the truth is what I tell you, not what I do" machinery.

Before Blair we had the Major years which were a shambles but an obvious shambles. Blair realised it didn't matter what he did so long as he convinced people he was doing the right thing.

After the slump of the early 90s, things were on the up when Blair got into power so he was able to ride the wave that was not of his making. But the austerity of the 2010s is a direct consequence of the Blair/Brown years, they are 90% responsible for the cuts that were needed once they left power.

So true he was the master of spin ,I remember as a newly qualified nurse ,Tony Blair announced they were giving all nurses a big pay rise ,actually if you read the details ,he was giving Top E grade ( before agenda for change so roughly equivalent to Band five ) nurses a pay rise once they reached top of their grade ,which I took six or eight years to get to the top of their grade .
Tanith · 06/12/2021 14:52

Early 80s under Thatcher also had power cuts due to strikes and rubbish uncollected in the streets.
I remember Edwina Curry goading the strikers - she also told pensioners who were freezing to death that they should knit woolly scarves and hats to keep warm and claimed that good Christians don't die of AIDS. All charm and compassion, that one!

MorningStarling · 06/12/2021 14:51

Blair was the point when truth and facts became secondary to presentation and spin. Populist leaders like Trump are direct descendents of Blair's "the truth is what I tell you, not what I do" machinery.

Before Blair we had the Major years which were a shambles but an obvious shambles. Blair realised it didn't matter what he did so long as he convinced people he was doing the right thing.

After the slump of the early 90s, things were on the up when Blair got into power so he was able to ride the wave that was not of his making. But the austerity of the 2010s is a direct consequence of the Blair/Brown years, they are 90% responsible for the cuts that were needed once they left power.

lonelyapple · 06/12/2021 14:42

The decline of the UK started under Blair and has just progressively got worse. Every sector of society is so much worse than it was in the 80s and 90s before Blair. All the matters now is profit and everything has been financialised. Thanks Blair! Angry
Sad: sad Sad

AdoraBell · 06/12/2021 14:15

I stand corrected daimbar thank you. I had mistakenly thought it was later in my childhood, mainly due to my parents ranting about unions and Labour politicians. They were staunch Labour voters, but I think the local MP, can’t remember the name, did something that upset them.

DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 14:11

@daimbarsatemydogsbone managed to annoy the conference delegates who had already heard the speech and tuned in to hear the OJ verdict. Fact remains that overt political interference has a long history at the BBC, whereas ITN has never had trouble telling interfering spin doctors (of all parties) where to go.

Seymour5 · 06/12/2021 14:03

@daimbarsatemydogsbone whilst Heath did put some industries on a three day week in the 70s, the Winter of Discontent was under Labour’s James Callaghan, 1978/79. They were the worst strikes, with the biggest number of days lost, the bodies piling up in the streets, the rubbish uncollected.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/12/2021 13:47

@DdraigGoch

Labour didn’t try to control the media anywhere near the current level, the BBC were far less up the governments arse

@Lonelycrab you're joking, right? Alastair Campbell faxed the BBC to tell them that the Labour Party conference was far more important than the OJ Simpson verdict. And the BBC listened. ITN ignored his fax but the BBC just let him interfere and put Blair's speech up first on the Six O' Clock News.

I detest Alastair Campbell, but he was right.
Changes17 · 06/12/2021 13:15

Indeed. We are all still paying for PFI profits now. It was a ridiculous scheme.

I thought PFI was a bad idea at the time because of the costs it was adding to balance sheets - but I did think again about that when a few months ago I visited a school for my year 6 child, that was built under PFI. It's still owned by the developer, which still maintains the building, but In 15 years the funding will be paid off and the school will own it (though admittedly its an academy now so will be owned by the academy trust presumably) . It's still a great building –suddenly PFI seemed to make more sense than not having new schools/hospitals because of lack of funding.

Lonelycrab · 06/12/2021 12:46

Also putting whistleblowers into jail for ten years, if they happen to uncover “inconvenient” truths. Just call em spies and throw away the key. Place is turning into fucking North Korea.

Lonelycrab · 06/12/2021 12:43

@DdraigGoch not quite the same as threatening to remove the license fee unless they tow the party line, is it? And trying to do away with channel4s impartiality too. Get real. Even the top comments on the Mails story about being able to over rude court rulings are now saying we are heading towards a dictatorship. Looks like you’re the one who must be joking.

DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 12:36

Labour didn’t try to control the media anywhere near the current level, the BBC were far less up the governments arse

@Lonelycrab you're joking, right? Alastair Campbell faxed the BBC to tell them that the Labour Party conference was far more important than the OJ Simpson verdict. And the BBC listened. ITN ignored his fax but the BBC just let him interfere and put Blair's speech up first on the Six O' Clock News.

DdraigGoch · 06/12/2021 12:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ThousandsOfTulips · 06/12/2021 12:25

[quote Choirgirl2021]@x2boys

I was a nurse throughout the labour years ,I do remember more building going on ,I also remember the huge amounts of money hospital trusts paid private companies for the building work ,it was very top heavy management wise ,ever increasing tiers of management ,where as staff on the actual wards ime ,was as sparse as ever
I was redeployed twice due to cuts in service between 2005 and 2006
So I don't remember the halycon days tbh

My experience too. It was though all of this money was floating around me but just out of my grasp whilst o got buried deeper and deeper under the pressures of work.[/quote]
Indeed. We are all still paying for PFI profits now. It was a ridiculous scheme.

ThousandsOfTulips · 06/12/2021 12:22

@Andante57

all for the audacity of wanting to study rather than become a teenage mother as advised by SS Thousandsoftulips it beggars belief that those who were supposed to be helping you actually gave that advice. It’s really shocking and there were probably many young women who followed it.
I agree. I was very naive at the time but now (looking back over two decades later and being a mother myself now) I can't believe that was their proposed "solution" to my situation. Not counselling or financial support. A baby, when I could not even look after myself mentally or financially. It would have been a disaster. So irresponsible. No wonder these cycles of deprivation often perpetuate if social services actively facilitate that.

That baby would have had a terrible life and after my childhood my biggest fear in the world was always being a bad parent. It would have destroyed the child's life, and mine. Whereas now, my children are the biggest joy in my life. Yesterday I was told that I am "the best mummy in the world". 💙

Swipe left for the next trending thread