Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to make it illegal to hit children

118 replies

Poetrypatty · 05/12/2021 14:07

AIBU to think this should be done ASAP. I'm so annoyed that in our country it's still legal. It's not legal to hit adults. It just seems plain wrong to me.

OP posts:
hangrylady · 05/12/2021 17:46

I agree. But if you think this will stop abusive parents you are deluded. Do you think these people give a shit about the law? Oh I was going to hit my child but I'd better not, it's illegal. Please

Grayskelly · 05/12/2021 17:41

@Pumperthepumper

Another way? Like locking them in their room with no food?

I'm harping on this point because many (most) of the worst cases of abuse seem to fall along these lines. Kicking, shaking, and being hit with weapons aside it seems rare for serious harm to come to kids from smacking with a hand. Being forcibly restrained and deprived of food as punishment are much worse. And not unheard of generations ago.
My concern is an obsessive fixation on one issue can blind you to a bigger picture.

The logic of banning smacking seems founded in a slippery slope argument, whereas the worst violence against children is not even beating, it's the obliterating of the child's existence. On this basis time outs and naughty steps are actually far more dangerous.

Divebar2021 · 05/12/2021 17:34

I thought it was tbh

It’s illegal to hit people… the law doesn’t distinguish between children or adults. What the law does have is a defence of lawful chastisement/ punishment which applies in some circumstances. A parent could still be arrested and interviewed and asked to account for their behaviour ( it doesn’t necessarily follow that as a parent your actions are automatically reasonable).

Also: prostitution is not illegal in this country.

CloudyStorms · 05/12/2021 17:26

I thought it was tbh

Grayskelly · 05/12/2021 17:24

The worst child abuse cases don't necessarily involve much hitting anyway. Being starved, locked away and deprived of hygiene and warmth seem to be the end game of extreme child abuse. The starting point is being made invisible by adults who find the child annoying in some way.
The risk is resources being further tied up by reports of children being smacked, while the silent terror of children like Arthur gets ignored.
I would think forcibly restraining a child is as bad as it gets.

pangolina · 05/12/2021 17:20

I grew up in the 80s when prettt much everyone got smacked. I never did. I remember my parents having 'lively discussions' with their friends about smacking children (the friends were in favour).
My dad, who had been to a strict 1940s boarding school and been beaten/ smacked etc said all it ever taught him was that he couldn't trust his caregivers and that nobody would stand up for him.
Following that train of thought, making smacking illegal might:
A) empower children with the knowledge that being physically disciplined is wrong and not normal
B) make parents who were smacked themselves look for better methods of discipline
C) make a clear line so that if you are aware of a child being smacked/ hit, you can't absolve yourself of the responsibility of reporting by saying it is just a different way of doing things

Cattipuss · 05/12/2021 17:07

@Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss

I don’t think it would help really. Parents are already not allowed to hit a child in a way that leaves any kind of mark, so if there is ‘proof’ of the hitting it becomes illegal. If there is no proof (ie no bruise or red mark) then how would they be sure a parent hit a child anyway? It’s socially unacceptable so it’s not generally happening out and about. I think we would be better off looking at the factors that lead people to not coping, free parenting classes and better funding for sure start, social services and early help.
Yes I agree.
Pumperthepumper · 05/12/2021 17:06

@Toddlerteaplease

It will not solve anything at all.
You’re wrong about that. It makes hitting your child illegal, so parents who assault their children to teach them a lesson will have to find another way. Or break the law.
Thedogscollar · 05/12/2021 17:06

There is never an excuse to hit a child. End off.

You are teaching them violence and that to get what you want you can push/ slap someone into submission.

If as adults we are prosecuted for hitting, slapping or pushing another adult, as it is all assault, then why are we allowed in the eyes of the law to do this to children. ConfusedSad

IncompleteSenten · 05/12/2021 16:59

Are people actually arguing that because some people still do illegal things, there should be no laws? Hmm

MuguetRose · 05/12/2021 16:59

National bans on smacking results in much less youth violence

blogs.bmj.com/bmjopen/2018/10/15/national-bans-on-slapping-children-linked-to-less-youth-violence/

MuguetRose · 05/12/2021 16:56

It's been illegal in Sweden since the 70s and It's massively reduced how many kids get hit so has been a success. It doesn't seem to have turned them into massive hooligans either

Newgirls · 05/12/2021 16:54

Smack not snack 🙄

Newgirls · 05/12/2021 16:54

Yes agree

And it would reduce violence. Any snack is painful to a child.

In my many years on mumsnet this has popped up a few times and people’s attitudes HAVE changed. People used to say it’s not a big deal etc but not any more, so changing attitudes and making something culturally unacceptable does work

Toddlerteaplease · 05/12/2021 16:51

It will not solve anything at all.

Kanaloa · 05/12/2021 16:50

@dementedma

It makes no difference to abused children. DH works with children in care. Being hit is the least of their worries. ( and no, I'm neither condoning nor making light of it) but illegal things still happen. Making them illegal doesnt stop these wee ones being starved, beaten, burnt with cigarettes and sexually abused. I'll stop because you dont want the stuff that happens to these kids in your head. Smacking is the least of it
Don’t know what point you’re trying to make here. It’s ok to smack your child because other children get burned with cigarettes? So then surely it’s fine to burn your child because some children are murdered?

It’s not okay to do something bad because others do worse. Otherwise we’d be on the relationships board saying ‘your husband slapped you? So? Some husbands murder their wives or break their bones.’

Kanaloa · 05/12/2021 16:48

@gsaoej

I am not sure about this.

I think that there can be situations where a smack (on a place such as the arm or leg) is actually warranted. Such an example would be a child of 3/4/5 ish removing a car seat harness whilst the parent is driving. And this kind of smack would be a short sting designed to shock the child so that they understood the severity and dangerousness of what they had done. A simple "please don't do that" is no different to saying that same phrase for something very minor such as leaving a snack wrapper on the floor.

I wouldn't consider that assault, I'd consider it a protection against the child being seriously injured.

In case anyone thinks I'm a monster who hits little kids, my kids are teens who are bigger than me. And aren't getting hit!

I knew there would be an answer like this - I think I predicted in my post that ‘sharp shock’ would be used. Parents who hit their kids love phrases like tap, shock, last resort.

Hitting your child is bad parenting. Do you think your child is the only one ever to have removed their car seat straps? Or the rest of us are just driving around with kids jumping around the car while we weakly say ‘oh no Amelia please oh no what can I do?’

MuguetRose · 05/12/2021 16:48

The op hasn't said it stops child abuse. She's said it's wrong to hit children and should be illegal and 82% have voted that they agree with her.

RaginaPhalange · 05/12/2021 16:42

@AlphabetAerobics

It’s illegal in Scotland and therefore magically we have no child abuse. Hmm
This ^
Kippersfortea · 05/12/2021 15:55

Making it illegal removes the grey area. Whilst there is a grey area some people will abuse that to injure kids. If there is no grey area then anyone who hits a child is committing a crime, there is no more grey area. It doesn't leave it up to somebody to make a subjective choice, it becomes objective fact that hitting kids is wrong no matter how people feel about it

5keletor · 05/12/2021 15:50

I don't think it'll stop child abuse unfortunately, but yes, smacking needs to be made illegal. One of my partner's (older) family members still thinks smacking is an acceptable form of discipline, which is why they'll never be left alone with our kids, even though they apparently wouldn't do it if told not to. Hmm

MuguetRose · 05/12/2021 15:46

Yanbu. We're really lagging behind with this. Loads of countries have made it illegal now. It was 53 in 2018 but is more now. I can't believe some scumbags want to keep it legal to assault children, which is what smacking is. It's perfectly possible to bring a child up without assaulting it!

dementedma · 05/12/2021 15:44

It makes no difference to abused children. DH works with children in care. Being hit is the least of their worries. ( and no, I'm neither condoning nor making light of it) but illegal things still happen. Making them illegal doesnt stop these wee ones being starved, beaten, burnt with cigarettes and sexually abused. I'll stop because you dont want the stuff that happens to these kids in your head. Smacking is the least of it

RoseRedRoseBlue · 05/12/2021 15:40

@gsaoej it doesn’t matter whether or not YOU consider it assault....it’s assault.

Pumperthepumper · 05/12/2021 15:39

@gsaoej

I am not sure about this.

I think that there can be situations where a smack (on a place such as the arm or leg) is actually warranted. Such an example would be a child of 3/4/5 ish removing a car seat harness whilst the parent is driving. And this kind of smack would be a short sting designed to shock the child so that they understood the severity and dangerousness of what they had done. A simple "please don't do that" is no different to saying that same phrase for something very minor such as leaving a snack wrapper on the floor.

I wouldn't consider that assault, I'd consider it a protection against the child being seriously injured.

In case anyone thinks I'm a monster who hits little kids, my kids are teens who are bigger than me. And aren't getting hit!

It is assault - in law it’s called ‘justifiable assault’

And it’s always so interesting to me that people see parenting as either hitting a child, or meekly asking for compliance like there’s no in between.

Your child will not learn to stop unbuckling their seat because you hurt them. They don’t make that connection. The trick there is to get a car seat they can’t get out of, not to be physical with them afterwards. It’s shit parenting.