Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to make it illegal to hit children

118 replies

Poetrypatty · 05/12/2021 14:07

AIBU to think this should be done ASAP. I'm so annoyed that in our country it's still legal. It's not legal to hit adults. It just seems plain wrong to me.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 01:17

Children's act 2004 in included-

'58Reasonable punishment
(1)In relation to any offence specified in subsection (2), battery of a child cannot be justified on the ground that it constituted reasonable punishment.
(2)The offences referred to in subsection (1) are—
(a)an offence under section 18 or 20 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861 (c. 100) (wounding and causing grievous bodily harm);
(b)an offence under section 47 of that Act (assault occasioning actual bodily harm);
(c)an offence under section 1 of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 (c. 12) (cruelty to persons under 16).
(3)Battery of a child causing actual bodily harm to the child cannot be justified in any civil proceedings on the ground that it constituted reasonable punishment.
(4)For the purposes of subsection (3) “actual bodily harm” has the same meaning as it has for the purposes of section 47 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861.
(5)In section 1 of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933, omit subsection (7).'

CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 01:17

I thought it was illegal? There was certainly talk of a law a few years back. Can't remember what happened.

At least there was some arguing about it having a line between ok and not ok.

As others have said laws send a very strong social message about our overall values.

Plus plus with violence against children. All too often there's a feeling still about not interfering, is it for certain SS involvement etc is a big deal for families what if not that bad? Could have been a one off. Don't snitch.

Ideally people would always act. Even if not sure.

In practice it's well known people don't. And across a load of things.

This would mean if criminal imo-

People more likely to report as more concrete, against the law.
Police reports have to be logged, recorded, investigated (in theory). Not sure police would be best by themselves would need to be SS with police in background or something. Anyway that's an aside. I believe it would encourage reporting of incidents. Which would be a good result.

TurnUpTurnip · 06/12/2021 01:04

It’s not “illegal” but you still get in trouble for it so isn’t that the same thing anyway? I’ve known of people to get reported to ss for hitting their kids so if their kid tells a teacher their parent hit them they get reported to ss so I never really get how it’s not illegal then? You get reported to ss so it’s obviously not seen as “ok” like people think?

DeepaBeesKit · 06/12/2021 00:59

Isnt the difficulty around situations like:

  • where an adult restrains a child to prevent them hurting themselves or others
  • where someone "hits" in a context where its clearly a medical emergency and entirely appropriate (tapping back to help coughing mucous)
As a parent I also have had situations where I've had to physically "manhandle" a misbehaving child to get them dressed for school, or pin down a toddler to administer medicine. I'm sure a young child's recollection of these could be interpreted with a lot of confusion.
HeadPain · 06/12/2021 00:43

Agree. You can't smack an adult. No one should be able to smack a child.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 06/12/2021 00:35

@5keletor

If my partner was about to unwittingly do something dangerous, I wouldn't slap him to give him "a short, sharp shock" to stop him doing it. Hmm Grabbing a child's arm and potentially hurting them in the process, if they're about to walk in front of a car for example, is different - it's unintentional and done to stop them coming to greater harm. Hitting them in any capacity to stop them doing something dangerous is more teaching them not to do it by either remembering the shock of being hit when they did, or fearing being hit if they do it again.
Agree. I think most people would instantly grab and drag back an adult about to walk in front of a car, as well. Totally different situation and very appropriate response.
AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 06/12/2021 00:34

[quote Grayskelly]@Pumperthepumper

**It’s not to stop child abuse. It’s to clear up the grey area of ‘justifiable assault.

I'm not really convinced there is a grey area. I'm not in UK, but here reasonable chastisement means open hand, below the neck, no mark, no weapon. It's no more grey than any area of law. If it doesn't stop child abuse I'm not sure how criminalising a parent for slapping a four old for escaping from a carseat in the motorway is going to achieve anything. The harm done to the family by fining the parent seems disproportionate to the harm done to the child.

And let's not by coy, it's overwhelmingly low ses parents who'll feel the brunt of this law.[/quote]
There is a grey area of "reasonable chastisement" though.
What each person defines as "reasonable" is subjective. Nit leaving a mark- subjective. What if it leaves a mark that fades in seconds? What's the difference between smacking a leg and smacking a face, really?
Removing the subjective makes it much harder to defend the action and justify.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/12/2021 00:32

I agree OP. It would not end abuse but it would make it easier to bring charges against violent parents.

^^
Or just to intervene in the first place. If x says he was hit, you don’t have to get into a murky world of “how hard was it, was it reasonable, did it leave a mark” etc. It’s illegal from the get go.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 06/12/2021 00:24

@hangrylady

I agree. But if you think this will stop abusive parents you are deluded. Do you think these people give a shit about the law? Oh I was going to hit my child but I'd better not, it's illegal. Please
By that logic, nothing should be illegal because people will always break the law so why bother?
5keletor · 05/12/2021 22:27

If my partner was about to unwittingly do something dangerous, I wouldn't slap him to give him "a short, sharp shock" to stop him doing it. Hmm Grabbing a child's arm and potentially hurting them in the process, if they're about to walk in front of a car for example, is different - it's unintentional and done to stop them coming to greater harm.
Hitting them in any capacity to stop them doing something dangerous is more teaching them not to do it by either remembering the shock of being hit when they did, or fearing being hit if they do it again.

Kanaloa · 05/12/2021 20:10

[quote Grayskelly]@Pumperthepumper

**It’s not to stop child abuse. It’s to clear up the grey area of ‘justifiable assault.

I'm not really convinced there is a grey area. I'm not in UK, but here reasonable chastisement means open hand, below the neck, no mark, no weapon. It's no more grey than any area of law. If it doesn't stop child abuse I'm not sure how criminalising a parent for slapping a four old for escaping from a carseat in the motorway is going to achieve anything. The harm done to the family by fining the parent seems disproportionate to the harm done to the child.

And let's not by coy, it's overwhelmingly low ses parents who'll feel the brunt of this law.[/quote]
What point are you trying to make? That it’s ok to slap a pre-school aged child below the neck as long as they’re messing about in the car?

Why is it fine to slap their arm/chest/back but not their face? Is it still ok to slap them if it’s not on the motorway but a side street?

That’s the problem, it allows for excuses. Oh yes I did slap him but xyz had happened and it was only a slap on the back not his face and blah blah blah. You shouldn’t be slapping a child at all then you won’t need to try and justify it.

Poetrypatty · 05/12/2021 19:52

I like to think of it this way, when my OH pisses me off do I hit him? The answer is no, so why would I do that to my child?

Exactly

OP posts:
Lifeisaminestrone · 05/12/2021 18:36

@gsaoej

I think people are being a little unfair to you but I understand where coming from.

I remember once grabbing my pre-school hard by the arm when a car came whizzing by at drop off and said child gave me a good telling off!!! I apologised and explained the situation but it was a case of that or being run over. I also explained the situation to nursery staff and my husband as wanted to be as transparent as possible. It probably went on a file note somewhere (which I have no objection to). I was very upset by hurting my child but the nursery staff were very supportive.

It’s the same if a child is choking you would hurt them to stop it. I remember in a child first aid class we were told we were all being too gentle (pretend babies!!!) if your child was in physical danger - your actions are being done for their best interests.

Nevertheless, in my mind smacking should be illegal as it is not an appropriate form of parenting. I was smacked as a child and it just made me feel embarrassed and upset.

The law wouldn’t be aimed at anyone pursuing a one off action by a loving parent to prevent a serious catastrophe but it would create a higher parenting standard people can aspire to be and stop it being used as a form of discipline.

NeilTheBaby12 · 05/12/2021 18:33

Yes it should be illegal. Its removed the 'grey area' and will hopefully make parents think a bit more about their childs feelings before raising their hand to them.

No it wont stop child abuse but it will send a clear message that hitting a child is unacceptable. I like to think of it this way, when my OH pisses me off do I hit him? The answer is no, so why would I do that to my child?

Pumperthepumper · 05/12/2021 18:23

[quote Grayskelly]@Pumperthepumper

**It’s not to stop child abuse. It’s to clear up the grey area of ‘justifiable assault.

I'm not really convinced there is a grey area. I'm not in UK, but here reasonable chastisement means open hand, below the neck, no mark, no weapon. It's no more grey than any area of law. If it doesn't stop child abuse I'm not sure how criminalising a parent for slapping a four old for escaping from a carseat in the motorway is going to achieve anything. The harm done to the family by fining the parent seems disproportionate to the harm done to the child.

And let's not by coy, it's overwhelmingly low ses parents who'll feel the brunt of this law.[/quote]
Well, these is: you choose to hit your kid or you don’t. And now hitting your kid is illegal. So you won’t.

Grayskelly · 05/12/2021 18:15

@Pumperthepumper

**It’s not to stop child abuse. It’s to clear up the grey area of ‘justifiable assault.

I'm not really convinced there is a grey area. I'm not in UK, but here reasonable chastisement means open hand, below the neck, no mark, no weapon. It's no more grey than any area of law. If it doesn't stop child abuse I'm not sure how criminalising a parent for slapping a four old for escaping from a carseat in the motorway is going to achieve anything. The harm done to the family by fining the parent seems disproportionate to the harm done to the child.

And let's not by coy, it's overwhelmingly low ses parents who'll feel the brunt of this law.

user1999952776 · 05/12/2021 18:08

@IncompleteSenten

Are people actually arguing that because some people still do illegal things, there should be no laws? Hmm
Yeah they are, how utterly ridiculous and frustrating
user1999952776 · 05/12/2021 18:07

@Toddlerteaplease

It will not solve anything at all.
Responses and attitudes like this is why we haven’t made much progress.

Making it illegal is a step towards ending violence towards children.

Poetrypatty · 05/12/2021 18:05

It sends out a message and also children should have full protection under the law, so it's the right thing to do.

Thanks for the link MuguetRose

OP posts:
MuguetRose · 05/12/2021 18:04

@IncompleteSenten

Are people actually arguing that because some people still do illegal things, there should be no laws? Hmm
Yes they do seem to be!
jewel1968 · 05/12/2021 18:01

For those that say it will make no difference, have you any objections to making it illegal to hit children? Most posters don't seem to finish the sentence " it will make no difference therefore......."

I would make it illegal. Whether it makes any difference to the amount of abuse is a different conversation.

RandomLondoner · 05/12/2021 17:53

@TheVolturi

Well drugs, prostitution and rape are illegal but they still happen.
Prostitution is not illegal in the UK. (In Northern Ireland it is illegal to buy sex, but not illegal to sell it.)
Pumperthepumper · 05/12/2021 17:52

@hangrylady

I agree. But if you think this will stop abusive parents you are deluded. Do you think these people give a shit about the law? Oh I was going to hit my child but I'd better not, it's illegal. Please
No. Nobody thinks it will stop abusive parents.
Feilin · 05/12/2021 17:51

It wont stop the abuse. I grew up in a house with a father who thought nothing of walloping us until we were teenagers . Ill never forget the day my grandmother asked him if he hit us anymore and he replied no theyll hit me back.. ive chosen to adopt the approach that slapping or hitting a child is illegal whether it is or not. I wont be that parent . I dont want my child asking me (like i did my father) why did you hit me ( his response was often because you were thinking about it.. i have to this day no idea what i was supposed to be thinking about and i realise it was pure control on his part with a wider picture of mental health issues on my mothers part and an inabilty on his to parent appropriately alone when she wasnt capable)

Pumperthepumper · 05/12/2021 17:51

[quote Grayskelly]@Pumperthepumper

Another way? Like locking them in their room with no food?

I'm harping on this point because many (most) of the worst cases of abuse seem to fall along these lines. Kicking, shaking, and being hit with weapons aside it seems rare for serious harm to come to kids from smacking with a hand. Being forcibly restrained and deprived of food as punishment are much worse. And not unheard of generations ago.
My concern is an obsessive fixation on one issue can blind you to a bigger picture.

The logic of banning smacking seems founded in a slippery slope argument, whereas the worst violence against children is not even beating, it's the obliterating of the child's existence. On this basis time outs and naughty steps are actually far more dangerous.[/quote]
But you’re still conflating two different things. Banning assault on a child means children who would have been routinely smacked by otherwise loving parents won’t be.

It’s not to stop child abuse. It’s to clear up the grey area of ‘justifiable assault’.