Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to make it illegal to hit children

118 replies

Poetrypatty · 05/12/2021 14:07

AIBU to think this should be done ASAP. I'm so annoyed that in our country it's still legal. It's not legal to hit adults. It just seems plain wrong to me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stayignorant · 06/12/2021 12:15

@Annoymouser2

Never been hounded in your own your home by feral kids, egging your home, smashing your windows. I havent but i remember fiona and francesca pilkington case. Id love to see them punch me in the face, punch them back then punch their neglectful parents too.
But those kids aren't like that because they didn't get smacked... they're probably neglected and have no idea about boundaries
stayignorant · 06/12/2021 12:11

Completely behind this. It'll make more people realise now that hitting a child is wrong and future generations then hopefully won't think twice about doing it.

I couldn't believe it when I brought up the subject at work and two men (one mid 40s one late 60s) acted like I was mad saying I would never hit my future children. The older one was saying how 'kids these days get away with everything' as though people are too 'soft'. It's a case of not knowing how to parent imo using violence as a form of discipline. I was saying I would never hit my husband or anyone else in my family, so why would I hit my child? But sadly people like that are so set in their ways that they'd just think the law against it is ridiculous. Hopefully their own children know better from experiencing it first hand. I do think future generations will be different though.

Since recently having a baby I feel even more strongly about all this. I could never ever hurt him, and I really don't understand how people can have it in them to be violent or aggressive to such a vulnerable person that doesn't understand how the world works yet.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 06/12/2021 11:08

@Annoymouser2

I do realise what ive typed, seriously do you have to repeat it. Adults get jail, smug teenage bullies know the laws on their side and get away with it
Yes I had to repeat it because that is how the quote function works. Are you uncomfortable seeing your own words repeated?

Do you really think a “kick in the arse” will sort out those teens? How ignorant.

Confiscatedpopit · 06/12/2021 10:57

I agree- at least people know where they stand. The current law is very vague, odd and unhelpful. How can you assess when smacking anyone whether it will leave a mark or not?

We do need more support for parents however. In the ‘olden days’ smacking was seen as acceptable and a solution to bad behaviour. Some children have behaviour problems for many different reasons and the support isn’t there currently for parents and children in how to deal with it. For some children the ‘naughty step’ and reward chart techniques just won’t work. So there does need to be more practical help and support for those whose children illustrate behavioural problems. My 3 children have been on the ASD pathway for a long time- the behaviour at times can be extremely challenging. I wouldn’t dream of ever smacking them but at times it can be very hard and I’ve had NOTHING when it comes to practical support in dealing with any of the problems associated with autism.

Kanaloa · 06/12/2021 10:46

@Annoymouser2

Never been hounded in your own your home by feral kids, egging your home, smashing your windows. I havent but i remember fiona and francesca pilkington case. Id love to see them punch me in the face, punch them back then punch their neglectful parents too.
You sound like a violent thug.
Pumperthepumper · 06/12/2021 08:43

@Annoymouser2

Never been hounded in your own your home by feral kids, egging your home, smashing your windows. I havent but i remember fiona and francesca pilkington case. Id love to see them punch me in the face, punch them back then punch their neglectful parents too.
Jesus.
PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 08:36

It would also make it easier to deal with in family court.

PicsInRed · 06/12/2021 08:36

@VladmirsPoutine

I agree OP. It would not end abuse but it would make it easier to bring charges against violent parents.

This is really the short and long of it.

Yes, this is very true.
Bluntness100 · 06/12/2021 08:30

I also agree. I agree also it won’t stamp out child abuse, of course it won’t, little Arthur’s murderers for example will have known full well what they were doing was illegal, as would anyone else who murders and tortures a child, but I wholly agree hitting a child should be illegal and assault like it is an adult.

Cattipuss · 06/12/2021 08:27

There is definitely a question mark on what makes an effective deterant and way to manage teenage behaviour (beyond the usual teen stuff, I mean on the side of criminality)- but I don't see how them growing up in a household where violence is common place and seeing it as a typical punishment will really help. What does smacking really achieve? Physically its over in a few seconds (although of course mentally can last longer), I suspect most cases it's adults who respond without thinking or without much constraint and can't deal with the situation any other way, any guesses where they are likely to have learnt that growing up?

Enwi · 06/12/2021 08:25

No of course it won’t completely end all child abuse, but it will certainly make it easier to safeguard children by members of the public, people working with children and social workers all having a very clear definition of what is and isn’t acceptable.

If you see a parent in public with a child who is misbehaving and the parent hits them, what would you do? Nothing, I’m guessing. It’s perfectly legal and by itself wouldn’t constitute any form of investigation. If it was illegal, it would be more likely to be looked into.

Not to mention it also means parents are less likely to do it, and more ill informed parents who are not aware of normal child development and preserving their emotional and social well-being will have a clear boundary of what is and isn’t OK. Something being legal very much gives people the impression it is acceptable.

Annoymouser2 · 06/12/2021 08:22

Never been hounded in your own your home by feral kids, egging your home, smashing your windows. I havent but i remember fiona and francesca pilkington case.
Id love to see them punch me in the face, punch them back then punch their neglectful parents too.

Warmduscher · 06/12/2021 08:14

@Annoymouser2

Some kids are wild though, we have a group of over 12s terrorising elderly neighbours throwing eggs at their houses every single night. it shouldnt be illegal to give them a good swift kick up the arse, their neglectful parents need an even harder kick up the arse too.
So who do you propose gives them a “swift kick up there arse”? Are you volunteering?

And what will you do when they retaliate and punch you in the face for assaulting them?

Pumperthepumper · 06/12/2021 08:02

@Annoymouser2

Some kids are wild though, we have a group of over 12s terrorising elderly neighbours throwing eggs at their houses every single night. it shouldnt be illegal to give them a good swift kick up the arse, their neglectful parents need an even harder kick up the arse too.
And you think ‘violence’ is the solution to this?
Annoymouser2 · 06/12/2021 08:01

I do realise what ive typed, seriously do you have to repeat it.
Adults get jail, smug teenage bullies know the laws on their side and get away with it

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 06/12/2021 07:51

@Annoymouser2

Some kids are wild though, we have a group of over 12s terrorising elderly neighbours throwing eggs at their houses every single night. it shouldnt be illegal to give them a good swift kick up the arse, their neglectful parents need an even harder kick up the arse too.
Hmm

Some adults are wild. Terrorising people, raping, murdering. It’s still illegal to “kick them up the arse”

Annoymouser2 · 06/12/2021 07:41

Some kids are wild though, we have a group of over 12s terrorising elderly neighbours throwing eggs at their houses every single night. it shouldnt be illegal to give them a good swift kick up the arse, their neglectful parents need an even harder kick up the arse too.

CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 02:27

2004 the law was changed on it. With definitions it wasn't none at all. I posted the text upthread s bit.

All the posters saying it's not illegal to hit children I assume they thinking certain types of hitting? Not hitting full stop I mean obviously. It's not at all legal to eg punch a child in the face and hasn't been for yonks.

Given the murder this thread is prompted by, I hope no posters think the level of violence used against this child was not against the law.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 06/12/2021 02:16

@CheeseMmmm

Thing is in this case a report WAS made. SS involved with family. Visited a bit before murder and said no safeguarding issues.

I do feel for SS because 1 million helped etc one child killed and the one (for natural obvious reasons) means they are seen as massive failure.

Not saying they shouldn't apologise if missed something, investigate, report, improve etc. Of course they should a child known to them has been killed. And if the SW did not follow procedure, did not do their job properly etc then they need to go and SS need to look into how not noticed they were rubbish.

They may have saved 100s is never in the picture though iyswim.

Must be such s difficult stressful job.

Quite a lot of the worst child abuse cases (resulting in death) that have been reported in the media had social work and other agencies involved. Victoria Climbié. Baby P. Arthur. All were seen by social workers, hospital staff etc, sometimes within days of death. So where is it going wrong? Ultimate fault of course with the "parents" or guardians who abused the child, but these professionals have a role to play as well. Agree, not a job I would want to do at all.
AlwaysLatte · 06/12/2021 02:08

I thought it was illegal years ago. Who in their right minds would hit their child? 😢

Aussiegirl123456 · 06/12/2021 02:03

Definitely!
I can’t believe anyone would want to hurt or even threaten to hurt a child anyway, but it happens and is swept under the carpet as discipline. It’s not. It’s disgusting. I was hit as a child, not excessively, but it did absolutely nothing other than make me distrust my parents. I’d never want my children to feel like I did. My oldest two are 15 and 16 now, so I’m sure if I did suddenly have a swipe at them, they’d be able to floor me or run faster than me anyway. But I look at my 20 month old and know her little friends get smacks as “discipline” because their parents are of the mind of “it did me no harm”. It breaks my heart. They’re tiny. We’re supposed to teach them the difference between right and wrong, not bash them. It’s not right.
If this law protects even one child, one who’d be able to speak up in class and say sad hit me or mum smacked my sister etc, then it’s great.
Imagine getting a snack at work as an adult if you fuck up! Just no!

CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 01:44

Thing is in this case a report WAS made. SS involved with family. Visited a bit before murder and said no safeguarding issues.

I do feel for SS because 1 million helped etc one child killed and the one (for natural obvious reasons) means they are seen as massive failure.

Not saying they shouldn't apologise if missed something, investigate, report, improve etc. Of course they should a child known to them has been killed. And if the SW did not follow procedure, did not do their job properly etc then they need to go and SS need to look into how not noticed they were rubbish.

They may have saved 100s is never in the picture though iyswim.

Must be such s difficult stressful job.

CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 01:36

What might actually help, I think

Is one of those public info initiatives. TV, internet main UK sites, posters in street etc. News coverage. Like they've done with things like they've done with things in past eg sex offences, heroin, drink driving etc.

Something like-

  1. Signs. I mean I'm not expert so won't get right but I dunno things like maybe
  • Hearing adult/s shouting at child/ren and especially if insults etc at child. (Would need to have way to say not one off/ over in a sec etc as over-reporting one off lost temper over in s sec apologise cuddle would be a problem for SS and maybe other issues dunno).
  • Often bruised injured more than usual amount of child bruising / or in unusual places ie not knees etc (?)
  • See adults a lot but hardly ever child
  • Child seems to be getting thinner, looks unwell, very quiet.

I mean I don't know that's examples prob not good ones.

Anyway. Campaign with dramatised examples of when to be concerned.
Assurance that won't know who v reported

Safe lives stop suffering type message.

And urge to listen to your instinctive concern and act. One call could save life.

That sort of thing.

CheeseMmmm · 06/12/2021 01:19

It IS illegal to hit your children. It's not full stop no. There are various definitions in other acts (that I haven't read).

I saw all the posts saying not illegal to hit children full stop and was sure that couldn't be right.

StillMedusa · 06/12/2021 01:18

I work in Special Ed, with children and young people who have highly challenging behaviour. Our training includes restraint as sadly it is sometimes necessary. But as a last resort. Always last resort.... ie if a child is about to run into the road into traffic, then rugby tackling them to the ground is preventing the greater harm from occuring.
That would be preferable to the child being squished.
Hitting them because they were not complying (with a car seat or any other request) would not be ok, no matter what.
I am 54 and was never hit. I didn't hit my children and I am sure as hell not going to hit my grandchild. I'm not allowed to hit my husband or anyone else I know, so why should I be allowed to hit a child?

We all know it won't stop abusers but it send s a clear message!