Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Settle an argument please

91 replies

PuffyLittleCloud · 05/12/2021 13:14

Nc for this.

Please vote!

Argument:

DC have covid.

Parent A has health anxiety and ocd. Their reaction to dealing with the situation is to clean a lot and limit time with time with DC in the same room, open windows, wear masks etc. Therefore, their time has been spent on cleaning and not with DC, doing delightful activities like crafting, baking, garden games etc.

Parent B does not suffer with those conditions. Parent B is able to WFH so has done, in an outbuilding at the end of the garden. Had a long standing arrangement for an event this weekend, which they attended, taking them out of the house for most of the day.

Parent B has criticised parent A for not spending time with DC. Parent A responded by saying Parent B chose to attend organised event rather than spend time with DC too. Parent B says this is not the same thing, and no wonder Parent A makes Parent B feel like a bad parent, it is completely different.

YABU - Parent A is right, choosing to attend the event is the same as choosing to clean rather than spend time with DC.

YANBU - Parent B is right, it is completely different, it was not a choice between an event and DC.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RaginaPhalange · 05/12/2021 16:53

Parent A and B need to get a grip.

Parent A could've done a bit of cleaning and spent some time with dc.

Parent B had to work but I also don't think they should be out gallivanting with covid in the house regardless of what the 'rules' are.

billy1966 · 05/12/2021 15:31

Parent B sounds like a selfish arse and should have been at home more supporting their family.

HadaVerde · 05/12/2021 15:27

All I have to say is why the hell dud B go out when they quite possibly have Covid?

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 05/12/2021 15:15

It was in that parent A is using it as an example of them unnecessarily choosing to not spend quality time with the sick child, it wasn't it was simply them continuing with a pre arranged plan, it can't be compared to patent A purposefully being in a different room to the child for the duration, and staying that the child would need to entertain themselves while B was out all day, because they wouldn't spend time with the child

AllConqueringHero · 05/12/2021 15:11

@JurgensCakeBabyJesus but the question wasn’t whether parent b was unreasonable to go?

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 05/12/2021 15:09

Poor child, having a parent actively avoid them because they are unwell. Parent A is unreasonable not to get a better grip over their issues, rather than treat an unwell 9 year old like a leper.
Parent B is not unreasonable to continue their plan to go to an arranged event because they have an unwell but asymptomatic child in the house with their other parent who has no plans to be anywhere else. I'm not getting into whether or not they should've gone because of infection potential as that wasn't the basis for the AIBU and it meets current guidelines.

Gretaburley · 05/12/2021 15:01

Parent B is a hypocrite and projecting.
Parent A has done nothing wrong.
I used to avoid my (older) dc if they had a bad cold!

queenMab99 · 05/12/2021 14:58

But what happens to the children when parent A gets covid, will parent B step up then?

Shedmistress · 05/12/2021 14:58

Parent B can't have a pop at parent A, especially as they have now taken Covid outside the house, and that makes them a twat.

RandomMess · 05/12/2021 14:54

I think parent B was doing piling their guilt onto parent A.

If parent B was truly concerned they should have cut back their activities. Parent A was taking precautions so they hopefully don't catch Covid.

AllConqueringHero · 05/12/2021 14:53

@Carpetsareforflying how would you care for an asymptomatic child effectively?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/12/2021 14:52

I think both parents may have a point...but parent B lost the argument when they criticised parent A for doing something while doing the exact same thing

Carpetsareforflying · 05/12/2021 14:46

Both are unreasonable. Poor kid is sick and noone seems to want to care for him/her

LostForIdeas · 05/12/2021 14:46

Btw, @PuffyLittleCloud please take into account the fact that MN is very strongly geared against anyone having some form of illness/disability.

You have some MH problem? You should get in with it, get some help and properly engage with it and still act as if you had no issue at all.

You have some physical issues? You should still get in with it, adapt and still act as if you had no issue at all. Just push through because you always have someone who has that plus more and they were ‘fine’.

And if you have some physical issues such as a chronic illness or some LT MH problems, you are still the bad one because do you realise how hard it is to live with someone with issues like that?!? Your partner is sacrifying so much!

I suspect these views have clouded a lot of the answers on this thread!

ResentfulAF · 05/12/2021 14:44

Person A is not unreasonable to manage this situation to the best of their ability providing kid is safe and fairly happy etc

Person B is reasonable to go to an event as kid is not ill and has other parent at home.

Person B is unreasonable to criticize person A full stop. Also particularly unreasonable to critics for not spending time with kids when person B is going out, and the impulses are different - going out because you want to vs keeping some kind of distance because that's how you're managing the OCD/virus situation. Also if person B was really that concerned they would stay home to be present with their kid/support their partner. Obviously not too concerned though as going out so unfair and mean to throw a criticism person A's way.

Trisolaris · 05/12/2021 14:43

*or not

Trisolaris · 05/12/2021 14:43

Parent B shouldn’t have criticised Parent A for doing their best to manage their mental health conditions.

9 year old dc will be fine with some movie days. It is irrelevant whether these two things are exactly the same are not. Parent B should be able to attend the events as Parent A is at home and Parent A is doing their best to manage their OCD. Both parents should be kinder to each other and stop trying to point score and win the argument.

WorraLiberty · 05/12/2021 14:33

@AllotmentTime

FYI OP, the expectation on a thread like this is that you will at some point tell us which one is you.

It’s a bit rude if you never do!

It's been obvious from the start the OP is A

No matter how hard they try in the opening post, the subsequent replies are usually a dead giveaway.

AllotmentTime · 05/12/2021 14:30

FYI OP, the expectation on a thread like this is that you will at some point tell us which one is you.

It’s a bit rude if you never do!

IslaInthesun · 05/12/2021 14:27

You're A and need to seek help.

DontBeCatty · 05/12/2021 14:27

Did either of you ask the kids what they wanted. You both sound a bit tetchy. I think both parents should crack on with what suits them a d leave the other patent to do what they want. I would t have considered cancelling the activity if I was parent B but then I also wouldn’t have complained about parent A

I think you are parent A

LostForIdeas · 05/12/2021 14:26

Ok so I voted YABU because parent B participated to an event that was optional and a hobby. I’m sure they would have missed it and felt bad about about letting people down but … it WAS a choice to be away too!! And tbh, knowing that parent A was going to struggle with the situation because of a well known MH issue that they are working on, parent B left their dc KNOWING what would happen…. Is that OK in itself??

But tbh, who says that a parent has to be with a child all day along doing craft? Was the child unhappy to be watching TV whist parent A was cleaning (and generally ensuring the house was still ticking over whilst parent B was busy with their hobby)

Tbh it sounds like parent B was having a go at parent A for doing too much cleaning and basically nit controlling their ocd well enough.

goodwinter · 05/12/2021 14:23

OCD is a pretty serious disorder and you can't really say it's their choice to obsess and carry out compulsive actions

100% agree. OP says parent A has sought help in various forms for their disorders and is just currently having difficulty coping because a virus has in fact materialised in the house. I think a lot of these replies are imo emblematic of a lack of empathy with regard to mental health issues on MN.

Anyway I think parent B is more in the wrong for having a go at parent A for not doing "delightful activities" with the child. I was more than happy to entertain myself at 9yo and it sounds like this child is too, and if they're asymptomatic then they don't need constant fuss and TLC.

MrzClaus · 05/12/2021 14:18

[quote PuffyLittleCloud]@MrzClaus so does that mean you agree with Parent A?

Parent A could have spent quality time with DC instead of cleaning.

And parent B could have spend quality time with DC instead of attending the event?

It’s the same choice - a choice of how someone chooses to spend their time.

Just because youve said that yet also said Parent A is unreasonable, so I am trying to clarify.[/quote]
In this instance - no! I'm saying IMO Parent B was absolutely fine to do what they did, but if parent A had been the one to go to an event and parent B had stayed at home that would have been fine too!

IMO Parent B went to an event that was pre booked by choice, knowing that parent A was free and home to look after DC. Parent A knowing they were the only parent looking after DC (as B was out) prioritised cleaning over spending quality time with DC.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/12/2021 14:18

[quote PuffyLittleCloud]@NeverDropYourMooncup I feel you’re putting your own childhood on this post and not getting the point at all.

The argument settlement was whether parent A choosing to clean was the same as parent B choosing to go to an event or not.

I am very sorry to hear your mother was emotionally neglectful to you. I can assure you that is not what’s going on in this house.[/quote]
Ah, so you're parent A, then.

Fair enough.

B's still in the right - they aren't neglecting their child by going out when there is a perfectly capable Parent A in the house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread