Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel second best to an ex colleague who I replaced?

31 replies

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 12:29

Did not expect to get this role so was a real surprise when I landed the job.

The person who I replaced was very methodical, outspoken, in short brilliant at her job.

I wasn’t fussed in the beginning of my job but couple of months down the line it has started to annoy me that the manager will mentioned her name and how she will do it every once in a while. All of her projects which she has since pass down to me ( which I actually discover a few major mistakes, of which the manager just waved it off) still have her name attached with people speaking fondly as her projects in the meeting.

AIBU to feel a bit put out by this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mls1984btc · 06/12/2021 00:14

@Werehamster

I think you need to make a bit of a stand about things like having her name on work projects. Just say no, she doesn't work here anymore so it isn't appropriate. I think having a few stock phrases in your back pocket that you can repeat over and again. Hopefully they will get the hint.
I am going to speak up at the next meeting just to emphasise that I am the one who has been rectifying the issues that she overlooked with the shareholders. Several meetings over a couple of months of which the shareholders will not budged due to the fact it wasn’t raised when my predecessor was in charge of YEAR ago.
OP posts:
Werehamster · 05/12/2021 23:50

I think you need to make a bit of a stand about things like having her name on work projects. Just say no, she doesn't work here anymore so it isn't appropriate. I think having a few stock phrases in your back pocket that you can repeat over and again. Hopefully they will get the hint.

Justajot · 05/12/2021 23:48

I had this a few years ago. My boss who raved about her was eventually booted out and I replaced him. The woman who was mates with her and clearly resented me for taking her place (even though she resigned to move away) was also made redundant. I guess I must be ok, as I'm still there.

Bluntness100 · 05/12/2021 22:52

Yeah he is, and she was about a decade younger than him

I am just very polite when he mentions her and nice about it, but I don’t indulge it. So if he says. Oh beryl and I did this, I say wow that’s great or that’s impressive, Great job, and then change the subject. If it’s to everyone I say nothing but smile politely,

This shit has so many emotions about it, it’s foolish to meddle in it I think.

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 22:48

@Bluntness100

Yeah I hear you. As said mines the same to the extent I actually spoke to my husband about it. I can’t quite put my finger on my feelings or what’s happening, it’s only my boss who is “besotted”. No one else. Even Last week he was saying ro everyone how sad he was she left. I felt weird listening to it. Felt like blurting out “ yup. Sad times now you’ve me, eh.”

But weirdly he doesn’t seem to correlate me versus her, like when he discusses it he doesn’t seem to think well blunts here and she has her job, more he sees us as seperate entities. He’s a great guy, but several months later when he talks about her about three or four times a week every week , whenever he can, I’ve definitely got the ick over it,

I didn’t know her, as I moved divisions, and I’m too new into this one to say to anyone “wtf” but I am watching everyone’s reactions when he does it, and it’s polite smiles and no one says anything, it’s just really odd. I think he’s starting to realise as no one says anything and just smiles politely that it’s weird, but he can’t quite stop himself.

I think if I had to call it, they got very close, and he had a crush, or was in love, maybe an affair, I don’t know if she reciprocated or she left because she didn’t and he was never going to let her move away from him.

Just too, too weird for words.

Is your manager married?

Because mine is. Double eeeeekkkkk

Either he is or he is not it kind of makes me see him in a different light.

Is great to have his support but I think from now I am just going to ignore him or retort whenever he is going down that track.

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 05/12/2021 22:32

Yeah I hear you. As said mines the same to the extent I actually spoke to my husband about it. I can’t quite put my finger on my feelings or what’s happening, it’s only my boss who is “besotted”. No one else. Even Last week he was saying ro everyone how sad he was she left. I felt weird listening to it. Felt like blurting out “ yup. Sad times now you’ve me, eh.”

But weirdly he doesn’t seem to correlate me versus her, like when he discusses it he doesn’t seem to think well blunts here and she has her job, more he sees us as seperate entities. He’s a great guy, but several months later when he talks about her about three or four times a week every week , whenever he can, I’ve definitely got the ick over it,

I didn’t know her, as I moved divisions, and I’m too new into this one to say to anyone “wtf” but I am watching everyone’s reactions when he does it, and it’s polite smiles and no one says anything, it’s just really odd. I think he’s starting to realise as no one says anything and just smiles politely that it’s weird, but he can’t quite stop himself.

I think if I had to call it, they got very close, and he had a crush, or was in love, maybe an affair, I don’t know if she reciprocated or she left because she didn’t and he was never going to let her move away from him.

Just too, too weird for words.

Flossieskeeper · 05/12/2021 22:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 22:11

@Cattipuss

Get yourself out there, take ownership of the projects. For projects you are now leading on introduce yourself to the stakeholders, make it clear you are the point of contact and if anyone says Jane used to do it this way, make it clear you do it that way.
Believe me I will.

I was trying to sort out my feeling over the weekend since the meeting last Friday to ensure I wasn’t being overly sensitive. Since then I spoke to a couple of work friends from different units and of course you guys which has sort of validated my view.

Thanks you peeps

OP posts:
Cattipuss · 05/12/2021 22:07

Get yourself out there, take ownership of the projects. For projects you are now leading on introduce yourself to the stakeholders, make it clear you are the point of contact and if anyone says Jane used to do it this way, make it clear you do it that way.

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 21:57

@Bluntness100

Omg I think we are in the totally similar position!

I think so, yes, as soon as I read your thread I thought, yup, I’m going through exactly this, the only difference is I don’t feel inadequate, at all, although I totally get the “am I jealous” thing, I don’t think I am, but I do recognise I don’t usually react like this, and have actually wondered if I am.

I find myself very curious about her. I simply can’t understand rhe constant mentionitis, the repeated “did I tell you I called beryl and asked her” . Yeah mate you did, several times,,eye roll, ,,,then is it me?

I don’t think it’s envy, but god I’d love to sit her down and say alright what was the deal here, why did you leave? Something isn’t right, I get that much but really that’s all I know.

For me, I’m just getting on with it and pretending it’s not happening and hoping he gets over it in time,,I don’t think any thing else can be done.

The person who I replaced was an Oxford graduate so I can totally understand why people were ‘besotted’ with her. Like I say she was really good but not PERFECT for god sake. In fact nobody is.

But you cannot disguise the admiration and something I cannot quite put my finger on whenever my manager mentioned her.

In the parallel universe I would also love to find out why she left. The real reason.

For what I can see I can imagine there’s some sort of unreciprocated feelings from someone towards her. No price on guessing who🤮

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 05/12/2021 20:11

Omg I think we are in the totally similar position!

I think so, yes, as soon as I read your thread I thought, yup, I’m going through exactly this, the only difference is I don’t feel inadequate, at all, although I totally get the “am I jealous” thing, I don’t think I am, but I do recognise I don’t usually react like this, and have actually wondered if I am.

I find myself very curious about her. I simply can’t understand rhe constant mentionitis, the repeated “did I tell you I called beryl and asked her” . Yeah mate you did, several times,,eye roll, ,,,then is it me?

I don’t think it’s envy, but god I’d love to sit her down and say alright what was the deal here, why did you leave? Something isn’t right, I get that much but really that’s all I know.

For me, I’m just getting on with it and pretending it’s not happening and hoping he gets over it in time,,I don’t think any thing else can be done.

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 18:48

@Bluntness100

The one I replaced made some real errors before she left,. Some really significant that he’s had to correct, as she was senior enough that if she said it it was law, so he’s had a lot of correction behind the scenes to do to fix it,, and I’ve played nicely and said things like oh I’m sure it was the right decision just wrong procedure etc, whilst thinking fuck me that’s a dismissible offence.

He even puts team pics up and says oh look there’s Beryl, it’s so odd, no one says a word, everyone is too polite. Then he will sort of laugh and say oh well she’s not part of the team anymore, and everyone still stays silent.

I recognise I’m good at my job, he recognises that and is very complimentary, but I don’t think I shall ever have a relationship like she did with him, where clearly they were partners in crime. Oddly, I am friendlier with his boss, who comes to me directly and we speak several times a week, my boss says he doesn’t mind, but I think he really, really does.I’m not sure I quite olay ball like she did. And I strongly suspect I need to learn.

Omg I think we are in the totally similar position!

Except not his boss but I am in great rapport with someone who is much senior than him.

You had written what’s happening in my office. People just ignored him whenever he is in one of his ‘must mention her at all costs’ trajectory.

I love doing reflection so am not sure whether is because I am jealous of her or my feeling is valid. But it does makes me feel inadequate, especially when I am not even sure why was I given the job when several others who have been in the team for much longer than me lose out.

OP posts:
magicstar1 · 05/12/2021 18:34

I had a job once where all I heard about was how great Linda was. I lasted a year and left … bad owners, terrible management etc.
A few months later I got a phone call from my replacement (who I’d never met) asking if she could talk to me. She’d got my number from a file with my old cv. She said all she heard was how brilliant I was, and how she couldn’t live up to me. Seems that’s just how the owners are, and I told her to get out sooner rather than later.

Bluntness100 · 05/12/2021 18:19

The one I replaced made some real errors before she left,. Some really significant that he’s had to correct, as she was senior enough that if she said it it was law, so he’s had a lot of correction behind the scenes to do to fix it,, and I’ve played nicely and said things like oh I’m sure it was the right decision just wrong procedure etc, whilst thinking fuck me that’s a dismissible offence.

He even puts team pics up and says oh look there’s Beryl, it’s so odd, no one says a word, everyone is too polite. Then he will sort of laugh and say oh well she’s not part of the team anymore, and everyone still stays silent.

I recognise I’m good at my job, he recognises that and is very complimentary, but I don’t think I shall ever have a relationship like she did with him, where clearly they were partners in crime. Oddly, I am friendlier with his boss, who comes to me directly and we speak several times a week, my boss says he doesn’t mind, but I think he really, really does.I’m not sure I quite olay ball like she did. And I strongly suspect I need to learn.

twoshedsjackson · 05/12/2021 17:36

I once took over a rather "lively" class who constantly harked back to my predecessor, as did some of the parents.......this tailed off when I fixed some of the complainers with a knowing look and sympathised, hinting, as I agreed "Yes it's a pity that she left" that it might just have been some of their antics that drove her to it. I discovered later that some of the parents who sang her praises so vociferously had found fault endlessly with the tiniest thing, and were thunderstruck when they realised that she wasn't prepared to stand for it.

FatPatsCat · 05/12/2021 16:53

I've been in a sort of similar situation - after starting my new role, I found out it was available because the previous employee sadly died. During lockdown I was still working in the office, but many were still WFH. When the time came for them to come back, one colleague who had become quite friendly with said that she was dreading coming back in because 'Mary' wouldn't be there (they worked/we work closely). Made me feel really shit but also selfish for feeling shit!

When colleagues reminisce about her I feel so awful that it's me sitting there instead of Mary 😔

Crimeismymiddlename · 05/12/2021 16:41

I replaced a brilliant manger who is also one of the kindest, fun people I have ever met. She moved elsewhere in the org and has helped me enormously, and been endlessly supportive. The team I manage not so much and I am looking to move on now. Such a shame but I can not live up to her-at least my replacement won’t have the same problems!

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 16:13

@DuneFan

I took over from, by all accounts for the first few months, God's gift to accountants.

I stuck to the line "A was great but we obviously think in really different ways so I need to make sure this works for me".

Most of his spreadsheets were wildly inefficient and about 6 months in the team all independently came in to say how relieved they were he'd left. Give it time!

Kudos to her who indeed done a brilliant job as far as I can see. Everything is organised which makes it easier for me to take over.

I guess the AIBU part is the fact the couple of my colleagues/manager are kept singing her praises and kept insisting her name being left on some of the projects. That’s what gets me

OP posts:
DuneFan · 05/12/2021 15:12

I took over from, by all accounts for the first few months, God's gift to accountants.

I stuck to the line "A was great but we obviously think in really different ways so I need to make sure this works for me".

Most of his spreadsheets were wildly inefficient and about 6 months in the team all independently came in to say how relieved they were he'd left. Give it time!

Werehamster · 05/12/2021 15:05

I think it's hard for some people to deal with changes at work, so it's probably nothing personal and they will get used to you. I took over my current job from someone and the first few months were tough but now they are just a distant memory.

Mls1984btc · 05/12/2021 14:56

Thanks for the explanation.

My boss does has some sort of mentionitis when it comes to her. Nobody else except a couple in the office who do not work directly with her suffer the same symptom.

I guess I will just have to smile and retort with the above the next time he mentioned her again.

OP posts:
Willowowisp · 05/12/2021 13:56

Rebecca is a Daphne du Maurier book. In it the second Mrs de Winter is constantly compared with the brilliant first Mrs de Winter ( Rebecca). Basically to cut a long story short, not everyone was such a fan of Rebecca including Mr de Winter ( who it turns out murdered her). I think the point the pp is making is that the second Mrs de Winter lived in the shadow of the first but it turned out there was a lot more to it.

Bluntness100 · 05/12/2021 13:52

I have a similar but more extreme situation on my hands, my predecessor resigned. None of my colleagues even really mention her, unless it’s very relevant, very normal behavuour about an ex colleague who resigned months and months ago, but my boss mentions her all the time. Always. He’s got proper mentionitis.

It’s all me and Beryl (made up name obvs) this and me and beryl that, oh I emailed beryl and asked her, oh I phoned beryl, (even though she’s been gone months and there was no need to phone her) it’s every single time I speak to him, he talks about beryl, I now find myself rolling my eyes.

I’m not really put out but it as such, I’m very good at my job, and I know he thinks that, but I find it really odd. Ive never encountered such a thing.

It’s to the extent I actually mentioned to my husband last week I wonder if he had a crush on her or they had an affair. It’s simply abnormal behaviour. He doesn’t talk about her as in she was great at her job or anything like that, it’s just all and any opportunities he gets he mentions her and generally for no good reason at all. Like he has to talk about her.

When I first started this role one of my male colleagues did make a cryptic comment about my boss being shocked and taken aback when she resigned, and I’m now wondering if he was hinting at something else. Another female at my bosses level actually made a subtle dig about her to him and he then phoned me and mentioned it, and I found myself agreeing with the female. In a sort of bitchy way.

I do wonder if he does it at home with his wife, I have to believe he does, it’s like he can’t stop himself, so I wonder how his wife feels about it.

LucySullivanIsGettingMarried · 05/12/2021 13:46

I've found in most workplaces people go on and on about people that no longer work there as if they're some mythical God-like creature

BigYellowHat · 05/12/2021 13:46

It’s hard when you’re the new person. I was called ‘the new Debbie’ for about three months in one job 🙄 which was so annoying. Then in one job, the woman who had gone for my job was tasked with training me before she left and was a total bitch for three weeks. I actually didn’t go in on her last day because of her behaviour. I didn’t find out for about six months that she’d gone for the job tbh and think it was actually pretty shitty of the organisation to get her to train me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread