Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if someone like me can afford an electric car?

54 replies

RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 09:46

Always had 10yr old+ second hand cars, last one I spent £3.5k on. Currently spending around £250 a month in Diesel and wondering if there's some way I could go electric and either cut costs or have it work out the same? I can't afford to buy a new car outright, we have a low household income. I've never bought a car on any kind of payment scheme and have no idea how they work but there must be some kind of scheme for electric vehicles that make it affordable for people like me?
We rent and can't put in a charging point, but there are two in the town I work in (none in our closest town or our village, but plans are in place to put a few in the village car park in the next few years). I drive to work 4-5 times a week, 30 mile round trip, very rarely do long journeys.

I'm just wondering if the amount I spend on Diesel could offset costs of getting an electric car. Is this a silly idea? I feel like they aren't for people like us, but I don't want that to be true.

I have done some Googling but it's quite overwhelming and I've no idea what I'm looking for. I work for the NHS but not directly, so my employer isn't part of any salary sacrifice car schemes.

OP posts:
RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 11:59

@GetTheFlockOutOfHere

I don't think most people can afford an electric car tbh. And many won't be able to, not even in the next few years...

No WAY is every person/family in the country going to be able to have/afford a bloody electric car within 8 years. Along with the fact there are so few charging points/charging stations; It's a ridiculously unrealistic target.

Maybe by 2040. Maybe. IF they reduce the electric car prices by 50-60%.

Good points. Though I feel like it is yet another of those situations where the more money you have, the easier it is to have something that costs less over time. It's annoying! Sam Vimes' boots analogy...
OP posts:
RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 11:58

@icedcoffees

In your shoes, I wouldn't even consider it if there were only two charging points and I couldn't install one on my property.

What happens if you need to charge your car and the charging points are both broken, in use or out of order?

You're right. Though the landlord may let me put in a charging point. I can't imagine it would do the property value any harm.
OP posts:
RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 11:55

@coachmylife

Hybrid cars are in lots of ways the worst of both worlds - all the engine stuff to maintain and drag around, as well as the battery etc.

Make sure you are realistic about your mileage. Does 30 miles 5 times a week really add up to £250 in diesel? 650ish miles for £250? We don't own a car, and rental cars are generally petrol now, but that seems incredibly inefficient (or you're driving quite a lot more than that - weekends, other trips etc.) Don't under (or massively over-) estimate or it'll be expensive...

I've probably overestimated, but DH uses my car too as he has a van for work and we live rurally. I feel like I'm filling up every week at the moment, but it may be more like every 10 days, in which case it's only £200 a month. My car has a 45l tank and does around 380 miles for that, costs nearly £70 to fill up.

Looking at it, I probably can't afford to switch yet but maybe in 3-4 years it will be a more realistic option.

OP posts:
GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 05/12/2021 11:43

I don't think most people can afford an electric car tbh. And many won't be able to, not even in the next few years...

No WAY is every person/family in the country going to be able to have/afford a bloody electric car within 8 years. Along with the fact there are so few charging points/charging stations; It's a ridiculously unrealistic target.

Maybe by 2040. Maybe. IF they reduce the electric car prices by 50-60%.

icedcoffees · 05/12/2021 11:41

In your shoes, I wouldn't even consider it if there were only two charging points and I couldn't install one on my property.

What happens if you need to charge your car and the charging points are both broken, in use or out of order?

coachmylife · 05/12/2021 11:37

Hybrid cars are in lots of ways the worst of both worlds - all the engine stuff to maintain and drag around, as well as the battery etc.

Make sure you are realistic about your mileage. Does 30 miles 5 times a week really add up to £250 in diesel? 650ish miles for £250? We don't own a car, and rental cars are generally petrol now, but that seems incredibly inefficient (or you're driving quite a lot more than that - weekends, other trips etc.) Don't under (or massively over-) estimate or it'll be expensive...

RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 11:26

@insancerre

Have you looked at hybrid cars? We have one and the fuel costs are so much lower plus no charging points to worry about You can get a bank loan to finance it
I did wonder about that, I have a good credit rating and income is due to increase next year, so I could manage a loan. I have no idea what I'm looking for, hybrid wise though. I'll see if I can find some good articles.
OP posts:
RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 11:23

[quote TreeLawney]@RagzReturnsRebooted your first payment is a larger amount - 3, 6, 9 or 12 months worth of the monthly payment. The larger upfront the lower the monthly cost for the remainder of the lease. You also choose how long you want the lease for - again monthly cost is lower usually for a longer lease time. The annual miles you want also changes the monthly cost.

Having just gone through this - deals were a lot cheaper 6 months ago (!) and it is also very hard to find any cars in stock right now.[/quote]
I found a reasonable looking one, around £230 a month, but it was only for 5k miles. I do over 10k miles, with work and ferrying DCs around, that pushed it up to £370!

My workplace is a small GP surgery, so no provision at the moment but we are now run by a larger (NHS owned) organisation so may be able to persuade them that it's a good idea to look into the salary sacrifice schemes. Some of our GPs may be interested, especially if there are tax benefits!

OP posts:
TimeForTeaAndG · 05/12/2021 11:14

We are looking at a self-charging hybrid for our next car. Charging points are not really anywhere near the places we go most often and a friend pointed out to us that a lot of points are in car parks and places which are not the best for safety if you're a woman alone.

Hoppinggreen · 05/12/2021 11:10

Aside from costs I really think you do need a driveway to charge the car on. Relying on charging points elsewhere is risky.
I actually think that in a lot of areas that will be the biggest block to people getting electric cars

Mirrorxx · 05/12/2021 11:08

@RagzReturnsRebooted no it was just one month up front. You just need to look for special offers

insancerre · 05/12/2021 11:06

Have you looked at hybrid cars?
We have one and the fuel costs are so much lower plus no charging points to worry about
You can get a bank loan to finance it

TiddleTaddleTat · 05/12/2021 11:02

We were thinking about this a couple of years ago but couldn’t make the numbers work. Had always bought older cars and run them into the ground. In the end we got a hybrid on a HP deal around £200 a month then I paid it off. Hybrid cars obviously still require petrol but my experience has been very positive and we spend about half as much on fuel as we did on the petrol car. The infrastructure just isn’t there yet for EVs here and it’s only wealthier people that can buy upfront that seem to be taking the plunge here. I’m not a fan of leasing either as I worry about being liable for damage

mogsrus · 05/12/2021 10:55

Just wondering about lease. If you cannot meet repayment for whatever reason ....like when the world stopped in 2020 does the car get taken back. Guessing I know the answer.

TreeLawney · 05/12/2021 10:45

@RagzReturnsRebooted your first payment is a larger amount - 3, 6, 9 or 12 months worth of the monthly payment. The larger upfront the lower the monthly cost for the remainder of the lease. You also choose how long you want the lease for - again monthly cost is lower usually for a longer lease time. The annual miles you want also changes the monthly cost.

Having just gone through this - deals were a lot cheaper 6 months ago (!) and it is also very hard to find any cars in stock right now.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/12/2021 10:42

You do sound like the type of person for whom an electric car would be worthwhile and should be workable.

I'd firstly explore if there are any work schemes, also whether it is possible to charge your car at work?

If you can't do salary sacrifice, then look at lease or PCP, because a lot of the cost will be offset by the cost of diesel and road tax. Also see if there are any scrappage schemes available to get your dirty diesel off the road to help with the deposit.

RagzReturnsRebooted · 05/12/2021 10:41

@Mirrorxx

We have leased a Hyundai Kona for 239 a month for 2 years. It was a pre registered car which meant it was delivered within 3 weeks of ordering.
Were there a lot of extra/upfront costs with that? I could afford the monthly costs.
OP posts:
mogsrus · 05/12/2021 10:35

Charge a vehicle by normal plug & you are talking serious amount of time. The maximum draw from a household plug is 3k, this means 13hours fora 40 Kv battery hopefully no power cut during the night

Mirrorxx · 05/12/2021 10:30

We have leased a Hyundai Kona for 239 a month for 2 years. It was a pre registered car which meant it was delivered within 3 weeks of ordering.

TreeLawney · 05/12/2021 10:26

I’ve just organised to lease as the best way I can afford one currently. Only need something small as it’s our second car so for a little runaround VW will cost me around £150 pm for 2 years, then we’ll reassess (we are also usually buy something a couple of years old & keep forever). I contemplated something a bit bigger / more luxurious for around 250-300 pm but in the end decided little & more money to save for the next car was more practical!

We will put a charging point in at home though.

Currently it is very frustrating that an electric version of petrol cars around £20k new costs more like £30-35 but I’m hoping in a few years the balance will shift & buying outright will be more affordable for ordinary families.

MissyB1 · 05/12/2021 10:24

We are doing it through salary sacrifice, will work out about £250 a month.

Singleorigincoffee · 05/12/2021 10:24

Leasing a car is the way to go. But the best thing to do is to look for the best deals and not a specific car.

For example electric cars are still quite expensive ATM so you could do hybrid instead for now. We usually set a budget per month such as £300 a month and see what's on offer. Stick to 2/3 years as it's essentially brand new car and under warranty so less likely to go wrong or need stuff fixed.

Be aware of deposit costs, admin costs and service costs, end costs, higher mileage is higher price etc (mroe expensive brands would have higher service costs)

topcat2014 · 05/12/2021 10:23

What car is £16k, I thought the cheapest was nearer £30k?

Bubblecap · 05/12/2021 10:21

It’s a simple enough cost benefit analysis. A quick google shows the cheapest electric cars are around 16k. It also shows how the rate per mile varies depending on when you charge up your electric car. Next door have a nice looking 40k electric car that they have charging up overnight so use cheaper electric. Though this is not strictly accurate and a very rough estimation electric cars cost about a third per mile as a petrol or diesel car to run energy wise. But that’s literally KW versus MPG.

Problem you have is to buy a car on credit is always pretty dire, your 16k cheapest electric car wouldn’t actually be that.

wonkylegs · 05/12/2021 10:19

We've got ours on a salary sacrifice lease £300 a month for a v.v. Expensive electric car we couldn't afford to buy.
I quite like it despite being initially skeptical as at the moment there is so much change in the electric car market it's good to be able to give it a try without being tied to a particular car (we tend to buy cars and keep them til they die so this is a departure for us)
You can charge from a normal plug it doesn't have to be a car charger it just takes longer.
We are on the octopus tariff so charge overnight but we've also got solar panels so charge from them in summer (they only produce enough for the house in winter)

Swipe left for the next trending thread