Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surcharge for unvaccinated people needing hospital treatment for covid

159 replies

Bwix · 05/12/2021 09:00

I’m just reading in the Times this morning how much cancer care, treatment of kidney and heart disease and organ transplants are being delayed and disrupted due to the strain on the NHS by unvaccinated patients. Of people needing the most intervention, 90% are unvaccinated.

Not all of these will be unvaccinated for medical reasons. We have had vaccines available for all adults for months now. I think it is reasonable for people to decide not to have a vaccine (just as they might want to drive fast without a seatbelt or climb a mountain face without a harness). But there should be a consequence that they face as individuals, as a result of that decision: that if they need care as a consequence of something they could have prevented, that they pick up the bill.

I’m really upset to know that friends and relatives with cancer may die as a result of their treatment being delayed, and it’s due to strains on the system that could be avoided.

OP posts:
PinkiOcelot · 05/12/2021 10:54

@Porcupineintherough I didn’t say the unvaccinated should be charged. I think it’s a ridiculous idea.
Also smokers and drinkers may be charged tax at point of purchase but no one is forcing them to buy see they.
On another note, I work in a hospital and every week they publish how many COVID patients we have. Last week we had the grand total of 18. I hardly think that is going to cause a big hospital to grind to a halt, cancelling clinics and treatment for others etc. It just won’t.

lljkk · 05/12/2021 10:51

people who are unvaccinated are taking up the vast majority of beds allocated to COVID patients. Causing a huge backlog in the NHS.

Something like 7% of all hospital beds are patients with Covid.
The bed-blocking problem is that it can't handle a 7% excess over 'normal'.
7% of patient beds did not cause the huge treatment backlog.

The huge backlog was caused by huge delays in non-emergency treatment imposed in 2020-early 2021 when vaccination wasn't possible, anyway.

There's no capacity in the system to catch up with 1 full year of delays and extra patients waiting. That lack of spare capacity is the result of 40+ years of voting decisions by British public. The whole British public should bear the costs of these decisions. You could take life savings of every single hospitalised unvaccinated Covid patient starting tomorrow -- and the waiting lists Will Not Go Down in time to help OP's loved ones.

Porcupineintherough · 05/12/2021 10:42

@PinkiOcelotnki good idea. Smoking and drinking are already highly taxed, nice of you to suggest the unvaccinated should be also. How do you see this working?

fournonblondes · 05/12/2021 10:38

Money grab is not the answer. People pay taxes so that they use the NHS. Do you want to start sometime that may extend to other areas that may affect people with cancer because they may have got because of being fat or smoking ? Vaccinated people are also in ICU and the new variant is affecting the double jabbed as seeing in half the cases. If you are old and with underlying conditions you may end up in UCI anyway.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2021 10:36

@Tootsey11

The point is that people who are unvaccinated are taking up the vast majority of beds allocated to COVID patients. Causing a huge backlog in the NHS.

This has been documented extensively in this article and others by healthcare professionals. I’m not sure why my views on vaccines are relevant?

PinkiOcelot · 05/12/2021 10:32

Definitely not. Don’t be ridiculous. Charge fat people, smokers and drinkers as well. Where would it end? There may not be a vaccine for smokers or fat people but no one is forcing them to smoke or over eat.

I’m sick of “the unvaccinated” being used all of the time. Why not just put a stamp on their foreheads? Unclean?!!

ComeAllYeFaithful · 05/12/2021 10:28

The consequence is that they’re seriously ill though?

Cancer and heart disease can happen through poor diet, smoking, alcohol and too much sugar, even if you quit those things 10 years ago. I wouldn’t charge them either.

P.S I am vaccinated.

Tootsey11 · 05/12/2021 10:17

@thepeopleversuswork you clearly don't believe the vaccines work if you think an unvaccinated person is a threat to you. FYI the omicron variant was brought into the UK by 4 fully vaccinated people.

Sowhatifiam · 05/12/2021 10:15

@bloodywhitecat

My husband will die as a result of the delays to his treatment but I don't see how surcharges will help.
I am so sorry to read that. It is a stark reality and one I think we need to be talking about more.

I assume the OP thinks that facing the prospect of paying for care, more people will get the vaccine. It’s certainly a possibility. But whether we make people pay for care or not, if you need a hospital bed when you have Covid, you need one and no payment is going to change that.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2021 10:10

[quote Fl0w3ry]@Lion1618 - I think the biggest difference there is the people you have mentioned who are making risky life choices generally don’t effect the health of other people, only themselves. The unvaccinated however are spreading covid to vulnerable people and others and encouraging mutations by keeping it in high circulation and affecting lots of people.[/quote]
Yep. Smoking, heavy drinking and unhealthy food only harm the individual.

Refusing a vaccine harms everyone you come into contact with basically. Unless you have a genuine medical reason not to (which they all claim to have), its unutterably selfish.

I don’t think a surcharge is workable really though. Heavy handed, hard to enforce and plays right into the government control narrative which they like. I think limiting their ability to access pubs, gigs, sports activities and leisure is probably the most effective way.

ItsSnowJokes · 05/12/2021 10:09

The smoking one has been done to death. Smoking related illnesses cost the nhs approx 2.5bn a year. The government tax revenue from smoking is approx 9.9bn a year. So smokers currently are paying for there use of the nhs. It is also not as clear cut as the cost the nhs more. A smoker dies of lung cancer at the age of 50 and has cost the nhs £30,000 in that time. A non smoker lives to the age of 80 and in that time has had a hip replacement, a heart valve replacement and various other illnesses. It has actually cost the nhs a lot more to treat that older patient over there lifetime.

People always go to smokers, drinkers and obesity etc....... a sugar tax and a larger alcohol tax should be implemented in my opinion so they can be tax positive with nhs costs like smoking is.

People who do risky pursuits should have insurance. Why should the nhs pay for skiing, mountain climbing, skydiving etc.......?

As for covid, it's a tricky one, but I do feel for people who's life saving operations are being cancelled due to selfish people refusing to get vaccines.

The nhs needs rebuilding completely, it's funding needs looking at and it needs a complete overhaul but no government have the stomach to do it.

Greenhand · 05/12/2021 10:08

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Greenhand

No. Singapore do not have free medical treatment. When covid hit, the government over there decided to pay for covid treatment because it was an unprecedented situation. Now that there are vaccines, they have decided to only continue paying for treatment for the vaccinated. If you choose not to get the vaccine then it goes back to how it is for all medical treatment out there; you pay for it yourself.[/quote]
Thank you for explaining this. So basically to qualify for free Covid treatment you have to be vaccinated?
I still think it’s a interesting example as you have vaccination as the deciding factor. But it’s not the same.
Does Singapore have a health insurance system - if so I wonder whether there are exclusions for unvaccinated people amd Covid treatment. I’m not saying it’s right

MsAgnesDiPesto · 05/12/2021 10:07

@RandomLondoner

The slippery slope arguments don't really stand up. None of smoking, eating junk or sky-diving have a significant probability of death in an ICU about four weeks of first indulging. Any change in the level of deaths can be planned for by adaptations made on a timescale of decades. The number of deaths from any of these causes is unlikely to double every three days.
That’s right. And none of them can be successfully guarded against by a vaccine which will give significant protection within 2 weeks of it being administered. That’s the primary difference. Lifestyle changes take months or years to effectively reduce risks. Vaccines take just days.
girlmom21 · 05/12/2021 10:02

@Fl0w3ry oh I completely agree, I was just focusing specifically on the people who are vulnerable because of their bad choices

Itsalmostanaccessory · 05/12/2021 10:02

@Greenhand

No. Singapore do not have free medical treatment. When covid hit, the government over there decided to pay for covid treatment because it was an unprecedented situation. Now that there are vaccines, they have decided to only continue paying for treatment for the vaccinated. If you choose not to get the vaccine then it goes back to how it is for all medical treatment out there; you pay for it yourself.

kowari · 05/12/2021 10:01

@WhenTheDragonsCame

A big part of the problem is that social care is underfunded and they struggle to employ carers. That means patients can be waiting weeks in hospital for support at home. If they are deemed to now need to move into a care home they can be in the hospital for months! These beds then can't be used for patients needing elective treatments. It is incredibly frustrating for all involved.

This has been an issue for a long time but it seems to have increased a lot since Brexit and Covid. A lot of the carers were not from the UK and some have decided to go back home.

Unvaccinated carers were sacked as well, that would have only made the situation worse.
Fl0w3ry · 05/12/2021 10:00

@girlmom21 - a lot of illnesses people have that aren’t getting treatment have not been caused through lifestyle choices. Genetics, uncontrollable environmental factors and age cause a lot of chronic illnesses that make people vulnerable.
I’m not pro people making bad lifestyle choices, and I agree some people wouldn’t be vulnerable if they hadn’t made bad lifestyle choices. I was just addressing the pps comment of ‘where do we draw the line with surcharges’.
I still think there is a big difference between someone making a ‘bad’ lifestyle choice that effects just them, compared to someone who makes a choice that effects lots of people (and I am saying that as someone who does none of the things the pp was drawing a comparison to).

RandomLondoner · 05/12/2021 09:58

The slippery slope arguments don't really stand up. None of smoking, eating junk or sky-diving have a significant probability of death in an ICU about four weeks of first indulging. Any change in the level of deaths can be planned for by adaptations made on a timescale of decades. The number of deaths from any of these causes is unlikely to double every three days.

Mouseonmychair · 05/12/2021 09:57

No surcharge because that just doesn't free up the beds. The rich can just pay. However rationing care yep absolutely. We need to do something because the NHS is overwhelmed and we already ration care pre covid so there is nothing new there.

Newgirls · 05/12/2021 09:55

There is already a ‘surcharge’ for obesity in that some treatments will be delayed until weight loss. Mostly as it isn’t safe to put the heart under more pressure.

We can vote for a government that pays for a better nhs or we can discuss who pays for certain treatments. Our choice.

byvirtue · 05/12/2021 09:54

We have an ageing population who use a large proportion of the nhs resources.

It’s like suggesting people receive free treatment up to the age of (say) 85 then they get hit with a surcharge. Slightly dystopian isn’t it.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/12/2021 09:54

@girlmom21 I agree with both your posts. The mismanagement has caused many of the problems.

@LittleWhiteCat Flowers

WhenTheDragonsCame · 05/12/2021 09:50

A big part of the problem is that social care is underfunded and they struggle to employ carers. That means patients can be waiting weeks in hospital for support at home. If they are deemed to now need to move into a care home they can be in the hospital for months! These beds then can't be used for patients needing elective treatments. It is incredibly frustrating for all involved.

This has been an issue for a long time but it seems to have increased a lot since Brexit and Covid. A lot of the carers were not from the UK and some have decided to go back home.

LethargicActress · 05/12/2021 09:49

It is not the fault of unvaccinated people that other people’s cancer or other treatment is being delayed.

It was being delayed before we even had vaccines, and the fact that so much treatment was postponed last year is a huge contributor to the waiting lists being mammoth now.

The problems are because of bad hospital management and because the plans the government should have had in place to deal with a pandemic we’re almost non existent. It is not fair to blame individuals for this mess when the situation could have been prevented or at least reduced if the people with the power had done better planning.

Tootsey11 · 05/12/2021 09:49

@TractorAndHeadphones, I'm unvaccinated, I won't be changing my tune now or in the future. Your attitude stinks. After his 2nd vaccine my Dp is now left with heart problems. He is a non smoking non drinking normal weight bloke who had no issues prior. He is now a high risk for a heart attack and cannot work. Cardiology confirmed. You can shove your vaccine where the sun doesn't shine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread