Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surcharge for unvaccinated people needing hospital treatment for covid

159 replies

Bwix · 05/12/2021 09:00

I’m just reading in the Times this morning how much cancer care, treatment of kidney and heart disease and organ transplants are being delayed and disrupted due to the strain on the NHS by unvaccinated patients. Of people needing the most intervention, 90% are unvaccinated.

Not all of these will be unvaccinated for medical reasons. We have had vaccines available for all adults for months now. I think it is reasonable for people to decide not to have a vaccine (just as they might want to drive fast without a seatbelt or climb a mountain face without a harness). But there should be a consequence that they face as individuals, as a result of that decision: that if they need care as a consequence of something they could have prevented, that they pick up the bill.

I’m really upset to know that friends and relatives with cancer may die as a result of their treatment being delayed, and it’s due to strains on the system that could be avoided.

OP posts:
SofiaMichelle · 05/12/2021 14:45

@MrsBillyNoJagNoMates

How about refunding the unvaccinated the equivalent of the cost of vaccination - as obviously that is not free and is paid by everyone's contributions ( that includes unvaccinated as well)

Pfizer is the expensive one and that's £22 per dose in the UK.

I would happily pay these idiots their £22 and revoke their rights to treatment for covid. It would be a massive positive effect on health funding.

EverdeRose · 05/12/2021 14:21

How about a surcharge for obese people needing heart treatment too OP.

Or for smokers with chest problems.

Anyone who drinks for anything alcohol related.

You're being ridiculous

MrsBillyNoJagNoMates · 05/12/2021 13:56

OP
Not this crap again
How about refunding the unvaccinated the equivalent of the cost of vaccination - as obviously that is not free and is paid by everyone's contributions ( that includes unvaccinated as well)
So maybe if we calculate that cost per vaccinated person and give that to each unvaccinated person maybe they could put that towards their treatment?
And if they never need any covid treatment they could keep the money???
Would be crazy and insane to suggest that, right???

TheCatWearsPrada · 05/12/2021 13:29

Great idea op!
And all high earners should be excluded from using the NHS because they can afford to go private
All maternity services should be stopped because really people could give birth at home without costing the NHS money
No treatment for people injured in car crashes because cars are bad for the environment and people choose to take the risk when getting in a car.

Were you just looking to stir up a bit of froth today?

Iggly · 05/12/2021 13:29

It is also worth noting that even without any top up, health spending is set to account for an ever-growing share of total day-to-day public service spending: 44% by 2024−25, up from 42% in 2019−20. At that rate of increase the NHS will prepresent 50% of ALL government spending

Where do those figures come from? IFS?

I understand that that is based on the premise of being 40% around now, which has been fact checked to be wrong?

Pyewackect · 05/12/2021 13:10

@insancerre

The strain on the nhs is from underfunding by the government
Outside of the usual Budget or Spending Review process, the government announced around £12 billion of additional spending for the Department of Health and Social Care for each year between 2022−23 and 2024−25.

It is also worth noting that even without any top up, health spending is set to account for an ever-growing share of total day-to-day public service spending: 44% by 2024−25, up from 42% in 2019−20. At that rate of increase the NHS will prepresent 50% of ALL government spending.

Perhaps we need to examine exactly how and where that money is being spent because there will come a time when health service spending is simply unsustainable ?.

Iggly · 05/12/2021 12:56

@millymolls

Well I’d put a surcharge on all obese people ( biggest drain on nhs resources statistically ) All smokers All drinkers Anyone who hasnt paid as much tax and ni as I have

Etc

Nhs is terribly over consumed rather than under funded. Throwing endless pots of money won’t solve it ever

Again, with the endless pots of money nonsense.

It is actually funded by our taxes by the way. If we move away to a different model we still have to pay.

Charging people on a “per fault” basis is stupid as many have illustrated on this thread. Where would that end?

The nhs is actually pretty efficient. It’s just hard to get your head around the huge sums of money involved - but what do you expect for a cradle to grave service with a population of over 60 million? It’s about £3,000 per head per year.

When you dig into the cost of treatments then actually that’s pretty good value IMO.

OMG12 · 05/12/2021 12:51

Like others say, charge for covid, charge for the following:

Cancer patients who smoke, are obese, have unhealthy lifestyles
Liver patients who drink
Flu victims without a job
Covid patients who are vaccinated but haven’t been strictly following scientific advice
Injured people engaging in sport
People injured through negligence/stupidity
People who have tried to take their own lives
People with HIV who have had unprotected sex

Yet another poster fixated on covid trying to demonise a group of people and blame them for an inadequate nhs.

fakereview · 05/12/2021 12:50

@sunflowerroses

My cancer operation was cancelled this week because of covid and I'm angry and bitter and wonder why it's ok to delay life saving treatment to who knows when, but don't think we can go down a charging route on the NHS.

I like we should limit activities in society unvaccinated people (by choice) can participate in though like in some other countries)

I can totally understand your anger and bitterness, but was the surgery cancelled because the surgeon has covid or because (s)he is being redeployed. I wouldn't have thought that cancer experts were covid experts?
Ghoulette · 05/12/2021 12:50

@PrivateHall

So what about people with cancer who are obese or smokers, shall we charge them too?
Cancer, no. don't be ridiculous. They can't make an effort to quit cancer or go on a diet to "lose" cancer.
tigger1001 · 05/12/2021 12:50

Simply put no.

Our healthcare is free at the point of treatment without caveats. Plenty people do things that put them in hospital. Smokers, drinkers, obesity, people do high risk sports. We treat them on a needs basis and not on a well you are at fault basis.

The issues within the health service were there before covid. Flu had an impact every year on health care, yet we didn't criticise these who were offered vaccines and didn't take them up.

Libertaire · 05/12/2021 12:48

A friend of mine broke his wrist when he fell off his bike last week. Should he have to pay for treatment?

In my view, the answer to that question is not an automatic, unthinking ‘of course not’. It is becoming clear that universal, unlimited healthcare which is completely free for all at the point of use and delivered by a monolithic, wasteful, sclerotic state bureaucracy is unsustainable. Britain needs to look at other countries who do it better, and learn from them. Germany and Israel which have hybrid public / private systems combined with universal insurance would be a good place to start.

millymolls · 05/12/2021 12:46

Well I’d put a surcharge on all obese people ( biggest drain on nhs resources statistically )
All smokers
All drinkers
Anyone who hasnt paid as much tax and ni as I have

Etc

Nhs is terribly over consumed rather than under funded. Throwing endless pots of money won’t solve it ever

Iggly · 05/12/2021 12:45

@BigYellowHat

I think there should be some consequence but I’ve still ticked YABU because at the end of the day it’s personal choice. Most people are fully paid up through NI anyway so what about that?
National insurance doesn’t go directly to the nhs 🧐🤨
BigYellowHat · 05/12/2021 12:41

I think there should be some consequence but I’ve still ticked YABU because at the end of the day it’s personal choice. Most people are fully paid up through NI anyway so what about that?

Iggly · 05/12/2021 12:39

How much money do you keep throwing at a system before it starts to work? Governments have given the system the money they ask for and they just ask for more

You are wrong. Completely wrong.

The nhs has been underfunded for years and years. As has adult social care which is intrinsically linked to the nhs. In fact, adult social care has been disgustingly underfunded by cuts to local authorities.

It’s very difficult to expect a system like the health and social care sector to do well without enough money.

GeorgiaMcGraw · 05/12/2021 12:36

As many have pointed out, OP's idea should also mean restricting healthcare for anybody who makes unhealthy choices. Not a world I'd want to live in, and it would no longer be universal healthcare. Also, the hospitals are not struggling due to unvaccinated. 80% of UK has had 2 jabs, so even more have had 1 and are likely to have more in future. Hospitalisations are down. Your surcharge idea has very little basis in reality, and much more basis in your desire to finger point and feel superior.

FreedomFaith · 05/12/2021 12:35

@cupcakedaisy

What about people who choose to smoke, drink, eat junk food, risky sports, driving too fast, etc - are we going to charge them too?
Technically we could, or even prioritise others over them.

Like for cancer, it's not like anyone can cause cancer in themselves. Even some smokers never get lung cancer. Cancer is an unfortunate thing that happens. So those who are unvaccinated and have covid don't get preferential treatment over someone who has cancer and needs life saving treatment. They have to wait. They could have got vaccinated and that would have hopefully made the effects less. If they were vaccinated, and still struggling to breathe, then they get preferential treatment over the cancer treatment as the covid patient is likely to die sooner without treatment.

Will never happen of course. Most of the suggestions we come up with will never happen. People are still paying taxes after all, so the current definition of the NHS is that they still get treatment no matter what.

SweetBabyCheeses99 · 05/12/2021 12:32

It’s an interesting concept…if you decide to get actual private health insurance then your policy is an individualised price based on a myriad of different variables such as your family history, smoking status, employment, alcohol consumption, age, even how often you exercise.
These algorithms are calculated by actuarial scientists. If we are going to suggest introducing this concept in the NHS then obviously you couldn’t just do it for one vaccine (or 2,3,4 “boosters” etc). You’d have to consider a citizens entire lifestyle as above and calculate how much they are likely to cost the NHS.
I think then we would soon see that it’s not covid vaccination status that is causing the NHS “problems.”

SnappedAndFarted18 · 05/12/2021 12:27

@RubyTuesday70

Comments like this really piss me off. I am diabetic, 1st vaccine was fine. 2nd vaccine made me horribly ill..... I had nearly 12 weeks of chronic headaches (the sort where you can't bear light and are sick with), joint pain that actually made me think I needed a hip replacement and I was barely able to function for weeks let alone work. Running my own business, it was a nightmare. I couldn't even see a Dr about it and was fobbed off constantly. I even thought I was going mad at one point.

You can't force anyone to be vaccinated. And it's horribly patronising and smug to look down on anyone who refuses it.

I’m so sorry to hear you went through that unfortunately there’s quite a lot of people experiencing this & quite a few other serious side effects of the vaccines & the boosters also unfortunately they don’t seem to be heard/reported on 😞 I hope you’re feeling better now xx
MaxNormal · 05/12/2021 12:23

Surcharge for obesity too then. A huge amount of NHS resources are spent on lifestyle related conditions.

RubyTuesday70 · 05/12/2021 12:19

Comments like this really piss me off. I am diabetic, 1st vaccine was fine. 2nd vaccine made me horribly ill..... I had nearly 12 weeks of chronic headaches (the sort where you can't bear light and are sick with), joint pain that actually made me think I needed a hip replacement and I was barely able to function for weeks let alone work. Running my own business, it was a nightmare. I couldn't even see a Dr about it and was fobbed off constantly. I even thought I was going mad at one point.

You can't force anyone to be vaccinated. And it's horribly patronising and smug to look down on anyone who refuses it.

girlmom21 · 05/12/2021 12:18

@Iggly

The whole system needs sorting, not money thrown at it

It doesn’t need a huge overhaul. It needs politicians to back off, stop meddling and let health experts do their job. If they say it needs funding, they should be listened to.

How much money do you keep throwing at a system before it starts to work? Governments have given the system the money they ask for and they just ask for more.
Yogaandcocoa · 05/12/2021 12:17

So what about people with cancer who are obese or smokers, shall we charge them too?

This is what I was going to say

Lilifer · 05/12/2021 12:16

@Maverickess

The flaw in that suggestion is that we had to shut the country down and restrict access to NHS services when covid hit before vaccines because the NHS wouldn't have coped. The NHS wouldn't have coped because they don't have enough resources, staff and money and what they do have is being managed over a cliff. The NHS isn't in the shit solely because of unvaccinated patients, it's been teetering on the brink for years.
Snap! I couldn't agree more 👏🏻
Swipe left for the next trending thread