Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surcharge for unvaccinated people needing hospital treatment for covid

159 replies

Bwix · 05/12/2021 09:00

I’m just reading in the Times this morning how much cancer care, treatment of kidney and heart disease and organ transplants are being delayed and disrupted due to the strain on the NHS by unvaccinated patients. Of people needing the most intervention, 90% are unvaccinated.

Not all of these will be unvaccinated for medical reasons. We have had vaccines available for all adults for months now. I think it is reasonable for people to decide not to have a vaccine (just as they might want to drive fast without a seatbelt or climb a mountain face without a harness). But there should be a consequence that they face as individuals, as a result of that decision: that if they need care as a consequence of something they could have prevented, that they pick up the bill.

I’m really upset to know that friends and relatives with cancer may die as a result of their treatment being delayed, and it’s due to strains on the system that could be avoided.

OP posts:
Thecurliestwurly · 06/12/2021 14:07

@insancerre

The strain on the nhs is from underfunding by the government
This is the issue. Huge shortage of nurses and underinvestment, plus an unhealthy lifestyle of people in the UK, probably due to being one of the countries working the longest hours in Europe. COVID hadn't helped, but some people don't have vaccinations for a variety of reasons, not just because they are stupid in your eyes or anti-vax. To me, anti-vax means that you don't want the world to be vaccinated, not that you just don't want a COVID vaccine but are happy for the rest of the world to be vaccinated - although some people love to put a simple label on a complicated issue.

What about all of the people who refuse to manage their weight, drink heavily, don't exercise, smoke? They take a lot out of the system, overwhelm services and not everyone will be putting in what they get out. People having children - what bastards - creating more people to use our services! Grin

I think vaccinations are a good thing BTW - but I think you are purposefully being antagonistic and divisive at a time when people are very anxious. Shameful.

Lavender24 · 06/12/2021 13:56

SW1amp I believe someone on the first page did.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 06/12/2021 13:50

Wouldn't it be better to just not prioritise an unvaccinated COVID case over a life saving cancer (or other urgent) surgery. Both might die as a result of a delay - why does the covid case get treated but the cancer case gets left?

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 06/12/2021 13:38

Every time anyone starts a thread about surcharges or refusing treatment to the unvaccinated, you just get a million posts saying 'bUt wHAt abOUt sMoKerS'. There were several on the first page and yet people are still saying it!

I'm not going to get into an argument about whether it's comparable (it's not...) because people have already done that and it's clearly not sinking in.

FWIW I also don't think a surcharge or refusing treatment is the answer. It has to be the carrot rather than the stick, unless and until the NHS is fully overwhelmed, rather than hanging on by a single peeling fingernail like it has been forever.

So I'd be in favour of incentives, better education and engagement via TV and SM, making it easier for people to get walk in jabs, etc. It feels like there's a lot more we could be doing, but aren't.

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 13:36

@Lavender24

Do people on here seriously believe that only the unvaccinated are spreading Covid? Come on now.
No one has said that But when the stats are that over 90% of people in ICU with covid are unvaccinated, it is clear that the burden of covid on the NHS is coming from unvaccinated people
Lavender24 · 06/12/2021 13:32

Do people on here seriously believe that only the unvaccinated are spreading Covid? Come on now.

RealBecca · 06/12/2021 13:17

Let's hope none of them are obese, smokers, drinkers, junk food eaters, not exercising, type 2 diabetic etc.

Bloody stupid idea to screen unless you want a fully private health service.

Get on to gov about air pollution which causes more deaths per year than covid.

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 13:10

@Spidey66

I fell off my bike and fractured my shoulder needing surgery. Silly me, getting on my bike.

My colleague, early 30s, non smoker, moderate drinker, healthy bmi, regular exercise, caught covid despite both jabs. Fortunately he didn't need hospital admission, but he was badly affected.

I'm pro vaccine but think there's an ethical dilemma there.

I don't think it is an ethical dilemma.

I've seen it explained several times that on a population level, people who like riding bikes, doing team sports etc have fewer health conditions across their lifetimes than the sedentary.

So we 'put up with' the occasional accident requiring treatment as the cost for lots of people doing that activity, although we might require or pressure them to take some sort of responsibility such as wearing a helmet, using bike lights or banning them from cycling on motorways

Alcohol and tobacco - governments tax the fuck out of it, so users are pre-paying for their treatment at the time of consumption

None of that is the same as vaccine refusers
Their refusal doesn't bring any benefits at a population or individual level, despite the scaremongering around risks of death or injury

They are just a drain and burden which is entirely preventable at very little cost to themselves

Spidey66 · 05/12/2021 22:38

I fell off my bike and fractured my shoulder needing surgery. Silly me, getting on my bike.

My colleague, early 30s, non smoker, moderate drinker, healthy bmi, regular exercise, caught covid despite both jabs. Fortunately he didn't need hospital admission, but he was badly affected.

I'm pro vaccine but think there's an ethical dilemma there.

Wannakisstheteacher · 05/12/2021 17:37

Obese people, alcoholics, drug addicts, people who take part in dangerous sports. Do they pay a surcharge too?

Bwix · 05/12/2021 17:34

9 deaths attributable to the vaccine.
blog.ons.gov.uk/2021/10/04/how-many-people-have-died-as-a-result-of-a-covid-19-vaccine/

OP posts:
gsaoej · 05/12/2021 17:19

My brother who’s 40 this week had a massive amount of intervention, in intensive care. He’s triple vaccinated. I don’t believe the stats. The hospital he’s in isn’t clogged with the unvaccinated. It’s actually clogged with the vaccinated.

I am vaccinated. 2 x AZ. But 73 deaths were attributed to AZ so I do not blame the unvaccinated for worrying about the vaccine. I had the second AZ despite the blood clot risk but still worried about it.

I was absolutely shitting myself about getting my 2x 12-15s done but again I risked it.

The unvaccinated are not some kind of scum.

RandomUsernameHere · 05/12/2021 17:07

YABU. Many injuries and illnesses are avoidable to some extent but people suffering from them don't get charged, I don't see that covid is any different. People who drive without a seatbelt (which is illegal) don't get charged for their treatment when they're injured in a crash.

Grapewrath · 05/12/2021 16:56

Brilliant idea! Adding surcharges to everyone who goes against NHS advice would save so much money- those who smoke, vape, drink alcohol, are sedentary, eat red meat regularly.

I’d hate to think one of my loved ones might not have treatment due to other people’s lifestyle choices!
I assume the op is/does non of these?
These threads are getting hysterical and ridiculous now.

seb342 · 05/12/2021 16:51

Most of us pay every month for our healthcare in the form of taxes. The problem is this country has changed so much since the NHS was formed, a bigger population, a different welfare system etc, it wasn't designed for the situation we are in now and it needs a huge overhaul.

I agree with the people who've mentioned the social care sector causing the NHS problems as well. It's on its knees and as a result people are bed blocking because they have nowhere to go. The care sector needs to be better paid and more respected to make jobs more appealing.

hangrylady · 05/12/2021 16:29

I can't abide vaccine refusers, but as ridiculous as I think they are, we can't go down this route. It's the same principal of making smokers pay for cancer treatment. Where does it end? Do we charge overweight people? People injured doing a sport?

QueenofKattegat · 05/12/2021 16:17

Yeah I'm totally on board with this. Also, people who get cancer but haven't attended smears and mammograms etc. should be charged. That'll learn the bastards.

Women who knowingly continue high risk pregnancies should also be charged. They're choosing it so should definitely be made to pay if they expect care for them and the baby. Or maybe forced abortions would be cheaper for the NHS?

Hopefully none of the supporters of this idea will have a bad reaction to booster no.3 and not want to take no.4 or 5 or 6. They would be fine with then being classed as unvacconated and made to pay I assume?

KarmaStar · 05/12/2021 15:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SofiaMichelle · 05/12/2021 15:35

[quote MrsBillyNoJagNoMates]@SofiaMichelle

Pfizer is the expensive one and that's £22 per dose in the UK.

You obviously forgot all the costs associated with the vaccination process, right?
Do you really think that the full cost of vaccination per vaccine per person is £22???[/quote]
Do you really think the vaccination centre and distribution costs would be increased to any great extent by an extra 10% of people being vaccinated, given they're running at nowhere near full capacity?

The cost of vaccination is absolutely tiny compared to £1,500 per day per bed in ICU.

There are currently approximately 800 unvaccinated people on mechanical ventilation in ICU for covid in the UK, so even ignoring all the other unvaccinated who are in ICU receiving other treatments than mech. ventilation , that's £8m per week wasted.

And we already know from the stats that you're 81 times more likely to need ICU treatment if you're unvaccinated.

flipflop76 · 05/12/2021 15:21

@PinkiOcelot

Definitely not. Don’t be ridiculous. Charge fat people, smokers and drinkers as well. Where would it end? There may not be a vaccine for smokers or fat people but no one is forcing them to smoke or over eat.

I’m sick of “the unvaccinated” being used all of the time. Why not just put a stamp on their foreheads? Unclean?!!

100%
sunflowerroses · 05/12/2021 15:16

@fakereview surgeon was there and ready to go but still needed NHS nursing care for recovery which apparently wasn't available because of 'covid'. I don't know the detail though and trying to find out.

sunflowerroses · 05/12/2021 15:13

@fakereview first time my op it was cancelled as surgeon had to isolate, second time I don't know exactly why, I'm trying to work it out. It was blamed on covid and staffing at very last minute after isolating, testing and starving. This is private too, but surgery in an NHS theatre so still reliant on NHS staffing.

MrsBillyNoJagNoMates · 05/12/2021 15:04

@SofiaMichelle

Pfizer is the expensive one and that's £22 per dose in the UK.

You obviously forgot all the costs associated with the vaccination process, right?
Do you really think that the full cost of vaccination per vaccine per person is £22???

Volhhg · 05/12/2021 15:01

This idea that the hospitals are "clogged" with unvaccinated is daft. You could then say the hospitals are "clogged" with anyone who has ever made poor lifestyle choices. Obesity, coronary disease, diabetes, the list is huge really. The fact that we have a normalised unhealthy drinking culture too. So many people are alcoholics without thinking. So many people are clinically obese and think it's ok until they hit 50 and get some other diagnosis linked to the obesity. The hospital's have been disfunctional, lacking in beds with huge waiting lists for the last 10 years before covid came along.

Jaxhog · 05/12/2021 14:49

It's from piss poor management. Various governments have given the NHS more and more money but they've got the same people 'running' the shit show.

Exactly. It's a money pit that badly needs reform. Throwing more money at it doesn't work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread