Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surcharge for unvaccinated people needing hospital treatment for covid

159 replies

Bwix · 05/12/2021 09:00

I’m just reading in the Times this morning how much cancer care, treatment of kidney and heart disease and organ transplants are being delayed and disrupted due to the strain on the NHS by unvaccinated patients. Of people needing the most intervention, 90% are unvaccinated.

Not all of these will be unvaccinated for medical reasons. We have had vaccines available for all adults for months now. I think it is reasonable for people to decide not to have a vaccine (just as they might want to drive fast without a seatbelt or climb a mountain face without a harness). But there should be a consequence that they face as individuals, as a result of that decision: that if they need care as a consequence of something they could have prevented, that they pick up the bill.

I’m really upset to know that friends and relatives with cancer may die as a result of their treatment being delayed, and it’s due to strains on the system that could be avoided.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ItsSnowJokes · 06/12/2021 20:52

@Hesma

So should there be a surcharge for smokers? How about overweight people who have health issues? Surcharge for maternity services - you don’t have to get pregnant, we do have contraception. You are being ridiculous
There already is a surcharge for smokers in the form of 9.8bn of tax from them to more than cover the 2.5bn cost to the nhs.
Hesma · 06/12/2021 20:43

So should there be a surcharge for smokers? How about overweight people who have health issues? Surcharge for maternity services - you don’t have to get pregnant, we do have contraception. You are being ridiculous

Maybebaby8 · 06/12/2021 20:34

Medical treatment is being delayed to focus on vaccine roll out, nothing to do with hospital beds. They are putting all NHS staff and resources into vaccinating people. But let's all blame the unvaccinated...

PerditaNitt · 06/12/2021 20:19

Vaccine passports seem like a sensible halfway house.

I do wonder if the anti-vaxxers would refuse the new covid anti viral drug? At the point patients would receive it, they would already be infected with covid and taking it would prevent severe illness. Would the fear make them take it or would they stick to their guns and refuse…? Honestly curious to see how it plays out.

Trinacham · 06/12/2021 20:10

@Ylvamoon

Where would you stop? Diabetics type 2? Smokers? Problems with jonts due to extreme sports?
You do realise type 2 can be genetic right? Same as gestational diabetes. I guess that just proves your point more though. Yeah, it wouldn't be fair!
kowari · 06/12/2021 20:09

No, have you ever read a newspaper? They don’t link to data sets from named public bodies
It was just a question. I've tried to find the data online and haven't been able to.

FrothyDragon · 06/12/2021 20:00

As much as I'd rather people were vaxxed (where possible), a surcharge for unvaccinated people sets a dangerous precedent that those with other preventable conditions may forfeit their right to NHS funded treatment. Not comfortable with a healthcare system that runs on the idea of deciding who deserves their funded treatment, and who doesn't.

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 19:48

[quote kowari]**@SW1amp
Thanks for that, did the article have a link to the NHS England data?[/quote]
No, have you ever read a newspaper? They don’t link to data sets from named public bodies Confused

The article goes on to say this though:
“ Between July and November, NHS England said that 150 patients were referred for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, or Ecmo, where blood is cycled through an artificial lung machine before returning it to the body. Of these patients, only 6 per cent had been fully vaccinated.

The treatment is usually reserved for younger patients and is a last-ditch effort to buy their bodies time to recover from the virus.”

kowari · 06/12/2021 19:19

@SW1amp
Thanks for that, did the article have a link to the NHS England data?

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 19:16

@kowari

That’s not what The Times is reporting within the last couple of days:

“Between 20 per cent and 30 per cent of critical care beds in England are occupied by Covid patients and three quarters of those have not been vaccinated, according to the latest data up to July this year.
Separately, NHS England said that between July and November more than nine in 10 patients receiving the most specialist care, in which artificial lungs were used to try to save their lives, were unvaccinated.”

UthredofBattenberg · 06/12/2021 19:13

Yes, they should if they are unvaccinated by choice, rather than medical exception.

I dont believe the extreme sports comparisons are quite fair. Broken legs from rock climbing arent spreading to other people who are likely to die from a broken leg. Also fairly unlikely to be spending days and weeks in ICU.

kowari · 06/12/2021 19:00

@SW1amp
But when the stats are that over 90% of people in ICU with covid are unvaccinated, it is clear that the burden of covid on the NHS is coming from unvaccinated people
That figure is not correct, it is now about 35%.
fullfact.org/health/economist-vaccination-status/
"The report did say that83.7%of Covid patients admitted to hospital were unvaccinated—but this covered the period between 8 December 2020, when vaccination started, and 28 July 2021. This includes a time ofvery high hospital admissions around the new year, when few people had been vaccinated."

CovidCurious · 06/12/2021 17:57

I don't think a surcharge is the way to go but I do agree that more pressure ought to be brought to bear on those who are refusing vaccines. I am in favour of vaccine passports to access everything except essential services.

HotPenguin · 06/12/2021 17:13

I have sympathy with you OP, but really the solution is to fund the NHS better so that we can deal with the impacts of covid without cancelling masses of surgery.

BigWoollyJumpers · 06/12/2021 17:10

@RoastPotatoQueen

Absurd way of thinking, shall we charge the obese people who can't stop eating themselves to death and then wonder how they end up with umpteen health conditions?
No - but I think if a vaccine was introduced that stopped the behaviour, and easily led to weight loss, and therefore decreased disease and ultimately led to a reduction in hospitalisations you might think they ought to have it for the good of their health, and of society?
Bwix · 06/12/2021 16:47

@Thecurliestwurly

‘I think vaccinations are a good thing BTW - but I think you are purposefully being antagonistic and divisive at a time when people are very anxious. Shameful.’

I wasn’t intending to be antagonistic or divisive, but I can see how it could have landed that way. Sorry. All too easy to get it wrong on such an emotive topic.

OP posts:
RoastPotatoQueen · 06/12/2021 16:36

Absurd way of thinking, shall we charge the obese people who can't stop eating themselves to death and then wonder how they end up with umpteen health conditions?

FlibbertyGiblets · 06/12/2021 16:28

Oh I get it. XX

FlibbertyGiblets · 06/12/2021 16:27

What kind of people get pregnant 🤔

HelplesslyHoping · 06/12/2021 16:10

In that case we need to charge cyclists, pregnant people and smokers. They all choose to need healthcare, they should factor in such costs to their choices

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 14:50

@SW1amp

It’s just such an impossible situation

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 14:46

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

*If those beds are already full with covid patients, what do you propose happens? Eeny meany miny mo to decide which of them gets slung into the street to free up that bed for the cancer surgery?

When a covid patient either gets better, or dies, and that bed frees up, do you then give surgery to the person who was scheduled for today, or the person who was scheduled and cancelled last week?*

Can they not split the beds in half? Half the beds are for covid people and if those filll up then tough luck? Half the beds are allocated for cancer etc and can continue as planned

I can see the Daily Mail sad face photos now... 'Dad dies in corridor after doctors refuse him lifesaving treatment, despite beds lying empty in fully-staffed ICU metres away from where he perished'

I think that puts doctors into an incredibly difficult moral, if not legal, position?

This was obviously the rationale behind the Nightingale hospitals, but overlooking the very crucial point that there is a finite number of medical staff, so opening up a new hospital doesn't suddenly magic up enough staff to run it

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 14:42

*If those beds are already full with covid patients, what do you propose happens?
Eeny meany miny mo to decide which of them gets slung into the street to free up that bed for the cancer surgery?

When a covid patient either gets better, or dies, and that bed frees up, do you then give surgery to the person who was scheduled for today, or the person who was scheduled and cancelled last week?*

Can they not split the beds in half? Half the beds are for covid people and if those filll up then tough luck? Half the beds are allocated for cancer etc and can continue as planned

SW1amp · 06/12/2021 14:27

@BewareTheBeardedDragon

Wouldn't it be better to just not prioritise an unvaccinated COVID case over a life saving cancer (or other urgent) surgery. Both might die as a result of a delay - why does the covid case get treated but the cancer case gets left?
Because surely cancer surgery requires a bed in ICU to be empty for after the operation, and enough nurses, plus an empty theatre

If those beds are already full with covid patients, what do you propose happens?
Eeny meany miny mo to decide which of them gets slung into the street to free up that bed for the cancer surgery?

When a covid patient either gets better, or dies, and that bed frees up, do you then give surgery to the person who was scheduled for today, or the person who was scheduled and cancelled last week?

It's a horrible situation for staff and patients, but it is unforgivable that there is SUCH a clear link between being unvaccinated and being in ICU, and surgery waiting lists are building up at a massive rate in the meantime

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/12/2021 14:27

I’m vaccinated. Everyone I know is vaccinated…BUT

It’s not right to force people to get vaccinated, via fines or vaccine cards or any other social pressure. I can understand why people don’t want to get vaccinated - I would not vaccinate my children with this new vaccine, although I am generally a big vaccination person (my children get all the extra vaccinations privately eg chickenpox).

It makes a lot more sense to use fines for things like smoking or being overweight, than to force people to receive a vaccination. It makes more sense to make older and proven vaccinations for children mandatory than doing this. I’m sorry for everyone who is suffering though.