Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wish I’d never been told a huge secret?

162 replies

Careve · 05/12/2021 00:58

A few yrs ago, my SIL (DH sister), confided to me that their brother had sexually assaulted her as a child and again as an adult.
She told their parents but wasn’t believed (or they buried their heads in the sand) that it never happened.
SIL has had counselling most of her life because of what her own brother did to her.
My DH doesn’t know, SIL begged me not to tell him as my DH would want to kill his own brother and be fuming with his parents and they’d be a big family bust up.

So far, I’ve kept this a secret from DH, however,
his parents always go on about this (perverted) brother, about how much he’s achieved and how he’s buying a big new house. I’m screaming inside that he’s disgusting and should have gone to prison and that my in laws should have believed and protected their own daughter!

Sometimes, my DH will say something negative (a throwaway comment) about someone in my family and I feel like saying ‘yeah, we’ll at least my brother isn’t a monster’ but I can’t as I’m sworn to secrecy.

It feels like either I keep things a secret (as SIL wishes) or I tell DH and the whole family implodes.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 05/12/2021 07:40

@julieca

And if you tell your DP, you are blowing your DPs family apart. And SIL will probably not to speak to you again either. I am not for keeping families together no matter what, but the decisions to blow the family apart is not yours to make.
So what if it blows apart a family where one is an abuser and where the parents of the abuser is more concerned with protecting him rather than believing their abused daughter.
PicsInRed · 05/12/2021 07:39

@Kshhuxnxk

Honestly I would just tell him. If you have kids you are never I assume having him anywhere near them. At this point you are going to have to say why. That then brings up a whole host of other issues because you've kept it a secret.
This.

Unfortunately you need to tell him in order to ensure your kids aren't ever unknowingly left alone with that man - i.e. God forbid you died and you husband accepted "kind" offers of childcare from his brother?

I would let your SIL know you need to tell him for this reason but that no one else in the family will need to be told and continue to offer her support.

Alittlepotofrosie · 05/12/2021 07:37

I'm sorry I would be telling my husband and trying to get him out behind bars

And how would you do that? SIL is the victim. She may not want to go through everything that would entail.

HeartsAndClubs · 05/12/2021 07:36

I wonder how many of Jimmy Saville’s victims told someone in confidence and those people kept that confidence?

Not that I’m comparing the BIL to Jimmy Saville’s level of abuse, but the fact here is that so much abuse goes on unchecked because people feel the need to keep it a secret even when they’re told by the victim. Instead of protecting future victims, somehow the sanctity of this family is being protected, and yet this BIL presumably has a wife, children who he is probably abusing, the friends of his children who he may be abusing, children of him and his wife’s friends who he may be abusing.

He may hold a position of trust in his community, maybe a scout leader or something to do with sport or giving lifts to children to events…

I am going to say the opposite to “it’s not your secret to tell.” IMO it’s not your secret to keep.

You have an obligation to make this known, because there are countless others who need to be protected, and who may be going through the same thing at the hands of the same person, and who may be afraid to tell because they fear they won’t be believed.

I’m sorry for your SIL, but the moment she told you she lost the right for it to be kept secret.

Alittlepotofrosie · 05/12/2021 07:35

My aunt confided in my uncle (D) that my other uncle (F) had abused her. She wanted to find out if F abused D too. She swore D to secrecy but D went straight off and told their parents, who didn't know. It completely imploded the family at every generation. In this case F got cut off by everyone but it was incredibly messy and painful for everyone, not least my aunt who had to deal with her most personal and private secret being leaked by someone she trusted.

Don't tell dh. Encourage SIL to tell him if she wants to, but it's not your secret to tell and SIL deserves to be able to control the narrative. If your dh will go off and attack his brother or whatever (and make it all about him) how does that help the actual victim here which is your SIL?

RosieLemonade · 05/12/2021 07:34

"Sometimes, my DH will say something negative (a throwaway comment) about someone in my family and I feel like saying ‘yeah, we’ll at least my brother isn’t a monster’ but I can’t as I’m sworn to secrecy."

It would be a bit low to bring it up too poor DH for making a through away comment. That would be very hurtful.

Dancingsmile · 05/12/2021 07:32

The huge problem I'd have is that he may abuse or did abuse others.
The moral obligation to prevent him hurting other children
I think I'd have to say something. This is beyond being kind to your inlaws. They had a moral obligation to stop him and they didn't. Protect on person which could destroy many.

Georgy12 · 05/12/2021 07:30

@Ellen888

Do not tell DH, that will only open a can of worms.

Just keep out of BIL's way for the moment.

Sometimes it's a case of "least said, soonest mended".

Have you read the news this week? After the fact everyone always asks why nobody did anything. Well this is why right here in black and white.
Indoctro · 05/12/2021 07:27

He is a predator and should be in prison. Yet he is free to walk the streets and abuse more children and women

I'm sorry I would be telling my husband and trying to get him out behind bars

How many other people ha he abused.? Or will go onto abuse.

Georgy12 · 05/12/2021 07:27

@madisonbridges

So if your best friend told you a personal secret, you'd immediately go home and tell your husband? Even though it would embarrass your friend?

This isn't the same at all, your best friends secret is unlikely to affect your marriage/family/future plans/entire sense of self and is also probably something your DH would have zero interest in 🙄🙄

dworky · 05/12/2021 07:22

@MorrisZapp

She shouldn't have told you that, it's totally unfair. Has she had counselling? She needs love and support, but not from you in secret. My sil unloaded some stuff onto me, of a similar magnitude re breaking up the family. I was really touched at the time that she trusted me enough to confide in me. But soon I felt pretty pissed off to be honest, as I was put in a potentially really tricky position.

You can't win this one, just try to persuade her to confide elsewhere next time.

She has every right to tell whoever she feels appropriate, the shame is not hers! You know, victim blaming is a large part of the problem.
Georgy12 · 05/12/2021 07:20

It's a massive secret to keep but she's done you a great favour by sharing this with you. Think about it, this is the biggest secret in her life, I beg you wouldn't usually be the person she would discuss something so big. She's done it so you and any future children you have will be safe. Not only from the brother but from the parents (who you know have facilitated brothers abusive behaviours in the past). Your bigger problem is going to be how you explain to your husband why nobody on his side of the family is never allowed to be alone with the kids ♥️

luckylavender · 05/12/2021 07:20

OP -your SIL trusts you very much. She's put you in a difficult position but it's not your secret to tell. It's a wonderful thing you're doing fir her as difficult as it is for you.

On another note posters, especially with something as sensitive as this, read the post. The OP says in her first post that her SIL has had ongoing counselling. Almost the first question is 'has your SIL had counselling?' Later on the OP discloses she herself had a miscarriage and has no children. Still asked if she has children. 🤷‍♀️

IAAP · 05/12/2021 07:18

@ablutiions

If it were me, i'd refuse any and all contact with the offending brother. When DH asks why, explain that you can't tell him, but there are very strong reasons that you know he would agree with, and to ask his sister to explain.

I'd also support the sister in keeping away from him at future family events by offering her an alternative invite to yours whenever a family event involving him, is planned. Give her a safe 'out'. Show her you believe and support her. Don't be part of the head burying, perpetuating the travesty into a second generation.

The parents, bastards the pair of them.

Yes I’d try to empower her first but then this - refuse to be the same room or phone him etc everything in this post else you condone what he did
IAAP · 05/12/2021 07:16

I would try to empower her - I appreciate this is your experience but I really want DH to know so we can all support you rather than brush what this monster did under the rug - if you want me to be there I will - but you need to be heard and believed -again if you went to the police I would support youn100 % .

I woul try that angle first and then say this is family abuse and you want to tell your DH as you feel he has a right to know

I know someone in exactly this situation she was abused by her brother sexually - in this case she is 45 and her parents don’t know as they idolise her and she managed to see him one a year and copes - but she shouldn’t have to criminals need to take responsibility. Although as my friend says he was a teenager too - she was 12 he was 14. She is planning on not telling her parents - I strongly believe if one of my children did something like this I would want to know

MimiDaisy11 · 05/12/2021 07:15

It’s a horrible situation. Damed if you do, damed if you don’t.

I’d talk to SIL about the situation. Mention about how you might have children in the future and your husband will need to know for that. Also someone mentioned her health isn’t good and she has girls. What will stop the pervert from being with them should anything happen to her?
Also are we so sure it’s all historical abuse? Does he have access to children now he could be abusing?

Lasair · 05/12/2021 07:14

I’d tell my husband. I’d no longer see the brother. Sorry op I think you should tell.

Cattitudes · 05/12/2021 07:09

@GeorgiaGirl52

You say your SIL is very ill, and also that she protects her daughters from her brother. What happens if she dies and the brother wants custody of the girls? No one knows the truth except you and yours is uncorroborated hearsay. If her parents wouldn't protect her, would they protect their granddaughters? You should tell your DH and also encourage your sister to talk to a lawyer. She could at least dictate a legal deposition detailing the event and the reasons she never wants her brother to have any contact with her daughters. This could be done without her elderly parents knowing or being distressed.
Yes I would encourage her to at the very least do this and maybe write a letter to you and your husband to read after her death.
Iamanicepersonreally · 05/12/2021 06:59

It's not your secret to tell and not your choice to make. How would your SIL feel to know you'd betrayed her confidence? Respect her wishes

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 05/12/2021 06:57

I lived with an ex and had a similar situation. His sister told me something similar, told me to keep it a secret. Tbh I told my ex. I just didn’t want to spend time with the brother and thought ex should know. Didn’t do much good as ex was a cunt who didn’t believe her but I just wanted to wash my hands of the problem in all honesty - it was causing me a lot of anxiety and upset carrying. I’m especially pleased I did now we have broken up as one day maybe the parents will find out now that the ex knows.

I couldn’t keep a secret of that magnitude from my husband.

Cattipuss · 05/12/2021 06:54

It sounds like she told you as you were pregnant, and if her own parents didn't believe her, sadly she probably saw little point telling her brother which is heartbreaking. She obviously trusts and thinks a lot of you, and although yes it puts you in a tricky position, she obviously weighed up the risk of not saying and potentially putting a hypothetical child at risk of abuse over your feelings, fair enough imo.

I wouldn't tell him as she evidently doesn't want this, but you could try and empower her to tell him, and let her know you have her back.

I can bet my DH would never want to be told this

Why. Because it might make him uncomfortable? She lived it and has had to live with it since, she shouldn't feel like she has to be quiet in case the family implodes; that's on the brother who abused her.

ablutiions · 05/12/2021 06:54

If it were me, i'd refuse any and all contact with the offending brother. When DH asks why, explain that you can't tell him, but there are very strong reasons that you know he would agree with, and to ask his sister to explain.

I'd also support the sister in keeping away from him at future family events by offering her an alternative invite to yours whenever a family event involving him, is planned. Give her a safe 'out'. Show her you believe and support her. Don't be part of the head burying, perpetuating the travesty into a second generation.

The parents, bastards the pair of them.

Ellen888 · 05/12/2021 06:54

Curtain,
"Yes, and that’s how abusers get away with abuse and continue to commit abuse."

If the OP raises this she will blow the whole family dynamics to $h!trags. Abuse cases from many years ago are incredibly difficult to prosecute, especially in this case where there is no corroborating evidence.
There is always the possibility that SIL is either lying or suffering from 'false memory syndrome'. Or, as another poster said, may well deny it when it is made public.

CurtainTroubles · 05/12/2021 06:38

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

CurtainTroubles · 05/12/2021 06:37

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Swipe left for the next trending thread