Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wish I’d never been told a huge secret?

162 replies

Careve · 05/12/2021 00:58

A few yrs ago, my SIL (DH sister), confided to me that their brother had sexually assaulted her as a child and again as an adult.
She told their parents but wasn’t believed (or they buried their heads in the sand) that it never happened.
SIL has had counselling most of her life because of what her own brother did to her.
My DH doesn’t know, SIL begged me not to tell him as my DH would want to kill his own brother and be fuming with his parents and they’d be a big family bust up.

So far, I’ve kept this a secret from DH, however,
his parents always go on about this (perverted) brother, about how much he’s achieved and how he’s buying a big new house. I’m screaming inside that he’s disgusting and should have gone to prison and that my in laws should have believed and protected their own daughter!

Sometimes, my DH will say something negative (a throwaway comment) about someone in my family and I feel like saying ‘yeah, we’ll at least my brother isn’t a monster’ but I can’t as I’m sworn to secrecy.

It feels like either I keep things a secret (as SIL wishes) or I tell DH and the whole family implodes.

OP posts:
Thwackit · 06/12/2021 10:11

What a difficult situation. Sounds like she’s trying to protect any children. It makes me so angry that survivors of abuse end up effectively ‘protecting’ shitbags simply because they don’t want to hurt innocent other family members by speaking out about what shitbags they really are. It’s a selflessness that must be excruciating.

Could you possibly talk to her and tell her that you are finding it so hard to keep this from your husband because he too will need to know to keep children away from his brother.

Donebeingitchy · 06/12/2021 10:10

Secrets have a funny way of surfacing. Maybe not now but sometime down the line.

Do you think your dp would be happy if he found out you know something of this extremity and kept him from being able to protect his sister? It sounds like he would be the only family member that would be support for your sil and would actually give a damn

ALSO

There is the big issue of children here. IF you happen to get pregnant again by any chance and you start "acting cagey against your dps brother" which is how it will be perceived in your dps eyes when he wants his brother to meet his first child and you dont, eyebrows will be raised and it will cause unnecessary problems/tension between the two of you.

Surely you know op this secret cant last. It will affect you, it will affect your relationship with dp. Better to have a mature level headed conversation with your dp about it now than wait for it to explode in your face and become a heated emotional mess

RealBecca · 06/12/2021 09:41

Id also tell on the grounds that of you passed and had children with DH, or potentially, he had kids with someone after you, he would be informed to protect them

RealBecca · 06/12/2021 09:37

I would take the view that you can only control your behaviour, not DHs or his parents. And, in the same vein, she might trust you not to tell but she can't actually stop you.

If you have children DH will need to know to keep them safe.

Protecting DH from stress results in the same as parents not acknowledging it through shame - protecting the abuser.

I would speak to SIL again and start laying the groundwork for telling your husband. Broach it and say you the secret is weighing on you and you dont want to keep it. Then again a month later, then 2 weeks, then 1 week and make clear that noone will make her formally report it but DH needs to know so he can deal with his feelings and consider how he wants to manage the situation RE you and him having kids. Finally tell her you will be telling him and sorry to break her confidence but you need support to deal with what you now know and he is your support system.

Santahatesbraisedcabbage · 06/12/2021 09:37

Surely by keeping quiet more people are at risk?

HiJenny35 · 06/12/2021 09:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MeltedButter · 06/12/2021 09:13

@FiveShelties

I don't think it is your secret to tell. Your sil trusts you and you have no idea what would happen to her if you break that trust.
I don't agree with that. it depends on the values you hold for your marriage. I couldn't keep something like that from my husband. If it did implode it wouldn't be because of the disclosure it would be because it what happened.
Santahatesbraisedcabbage · 06/12/2021 09:12

No way would his dps be seeing my dc. Ultimately your loyalty is to your dh.

5128gap · 06/12/2021 09:08

@AvocadoTrees

It’s completely inappropriate for someone to tell you a secret *IF* keeping it from your partner will have a negative impact on your relationship with your partner. For that alone, I would tell your SIL that you are going to tell your DH.

If it was a secret that didn’t impact you or your relationship with your partner I’d say you should keep it secret, but it’s wrong to keep this type of secret from your partner because it’s about his own family, and it’s wrong that you can’t let your DH know why you are upset with his parents and his brother.

You are part of the secret in the family now, and your Dh is not. Wrong, and bad for your relationship with him.

If your SIL had told you she’d been abused by someone outside the family - yes, keep that secret. But keeping it from your DH when it’s his brother and parents who are complicit, and not giving him the opportunity to support her, is so so wrong.

I think it is a greater wrong to break the trust of a vulnerable woman who has confided in the OP. Its not OPs secret to tell and its only her husband's business if the sister chooses to tell him. I get keeping secrets from a partner can feel uncomfortable, but sometimes life is like that, its part of being an adult. It would be different if breaking trust was necessary to prevent immediate harm, but OP seems to be mainly tempted to tell as a retaliation for comments about her family, which would be unforgivable.
Ducksurprise · 06/12/2021 08:16

@lljkk

OP doesn't have to do anything. Not right now, anyway.

It's uncomfortable, but if/when this comes out, it will implode the family. Does OP really want to know she triggered a great big family split?
SIL obviously doesn't want that to happen. And doesn't need it to happen.

It's also SIL's story, not OP's story to tell.

Other people's secrets can be very uncomfortable, yes.

It would not be the OP that triggered a family split.

Real children could be being abused right now, someone's son or daughter by this man. If he was dead I'd agree that it was SILs story to tell but he isn't and SIL obviously believes he would be a risk to ops child (I'm so sorry you had a miscarriage) so she obviously thinks he is still a risk now.

BarkminsterBlue · 05/12/2021 17:59

Is it possible that on some level she wants you to tell DH?

CherryBlossomAutumn · 05/12/2021 17:53

@Aimee1987

After thinking about this, I would ask social services what can be done. Be honest and say you have been made aware of a historical case of child abuse by x and that you are concerned that this is not an isolated incident and there may be more children at risk. It means if he is dbs checked it may flag ( not actually sure but this is where the conversation would help).
This. Do this.
NeverChange · 05/12/2021 12:45

Your SILs trust has been violated in the past, please don't violate her trust in you also.

She told you solely to protect and future children you may have. Had you not been pregnant she may never have said a word.

I know it must be impossible not to tell your husband and she did put you in a difficult position, by not intentionally.

She is I'll, unclear, how serious but is it worth having a child with her in relation to her kids, provisions for them if she passes, ask her how you will tell your husband about his brother when she does, ask he would she prefer to write a letter etc.

I know many posters will say it's her duty and your to stop him abusing other child. You cannot do this, you have no evidence and nothing to report and if she isn't able to, then she isn't. It's unfair to put this burden on people who have suffered enough already. No one know what they would do until they are in someone else's shoes.

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/12/2021 12:30

Christ…

In general I don’t think you should keep secrets from your partner, especially when they are about his family. How would he feel about you not telling him if he were to find out? Would he understand you have kept it quiet to protect his sister’s mental health? If so, and his knowing serves no practical purpose, I guess you can justifiably keep it quiet - especially if you don’t think he’d respect his sisters wishes to keep a lid on it.

But equally it’s a massive secret to keep, so if you want to tell him, you are fully entitled to. Your SIL is ill so I wouldn’t blame her for not understanding that there are some secrets you cannot keep.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 05/12/2021 12:03

Christ on a bike. Some posters are weird. SIL can't tell anyone, OP is like Jimmy Saville victims and/or excusers and a lot of other twaddle.

OP. All you can do is talk to your SIL and tell her how conflicted you are by what she has told you. How much you want to support and help her. That you feel very torn by knowing this and your DH not being told. That you feel obliged to help her but can't without telling DH. That you know this may not be what she wants, that is your help let alone anything else. Discuss it with her. Find out what she wants to do.

But, in real life, I'd find it very hard not to tell DH. The two betrayals would tear my conscience apart.

On balance, maybe I'd keep quiet and concentrate on not being more of an emotional burden on SIL, nor feeding her negative emotions either.

First and foremost avoid becoming complicit with her. That wouldn't be healthy for either of you.

I can see how this could change lives completely. Good luck working through it.

HeartsAndClubs · 05/12/2021 12:02

There’s something else to consider here aside from whether the dh might go and beat the shit out of the brother. There’s a chance that he might not believe your SIL either, in which case wouldn’t you want to know? I certainly wouldn’t want to stay married to someone who protected a child abuser and who might potentially have no qualms in my children having a relationship with that abuser and, not believing them if they themselves were abused.

So not only would I feel I had to tell him because it’s the right thing to do, but I would also have to tell him so that I could consider my marriage if it came to that.

lljkk · 05/12/2021 11:51

OP doesn't have to do anything.
Not right now, anyway.

It's uncomfortable, but if/when this comes out, it will implode the family. Does OP really want to know she triggered a great big family split?
SIL obviously doesn't want that to happen. And doesn't need it to happen.

It's also SIL's story, not OP's story to tell.

Other people's secrets can be very uncomfortable, yes.

colouringindoors · 05/12/2021 10:55

Sympathies OP.

For me the safety of children and women trumps everything else in this case. This man can reasonably said to be a danger to children. For that reason I would be looking for way to take this further.

I'd definitely start by talking to SIL a lot more. As others have said, part of her telling you may well have been in the hope that you would do something about it. Her DD and any future children of yours could certainly be at risk from this man. How would you keep your DCs safe from BIL if no-one else knows his history?

I would also explain to SIL that this is not a secret you can keep any longer, it's too much for you personally. And that you really want to tell your DH.

Yes it will cause an explosion in the family. But that is all your BIL fault ultimately and as others have said, he does not deserve to be protected, let alone praised. Good luck.

wannalivelikecommonpeople · 05/12/2021 10:50

Gosh, what an awful secret and burden

Does it make you wonder about other awful secrets the family may have? Maybr brother was abused himself?

I would have to tell my husband. Share the load. Its his family's shame. Not yours

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/12/2021 10:42

I think on balance I'd keep the secret for your SIL sake. She did what she thought was the right thing telling you at the time you were pregnant, not because she wanted to burden you. To the people saying it might keep others safe - only if the SiL agrees to talk to the authorities, and I think this would be very harsh to make this decision for her and take the control out of her hands especially if she is very ill. It sucks but she wasnt believed and had the control taken away the first time she told someone and I just don't think I could do that to her the second time. Especially if you only see him once every year. You could talk to her and encourage her to speak to the authorities or her parents again with your support or say you are struggling with the knowledge yourself and want to say something to her parents along the lines of 'please stop going on about what an amazing son he is, I know about what he did to SIL' but given this may have repercussions for her I wouldn't do it behind her back. Remember the repercussions will be worse for her than anyone else out of this if you do say anything (unless you think your husband can be trusted to keep the secret which it doesn't sound like)

beastlyslumber · 05/12/2021 10:23

What a difficult situation, OP. I feel for you.

As others have said, this isn't really a secret you can keep. I would suggest talking to your SIL and explaining that you cannot keep this secret, and agree with her how to proceed from there.

I would also want DH to know, before you have kids together, as his reaction to this information is going to tell you a lot about the kind of man he is/father he will be.

maryberryslayers · 05/12/2021 10:20

She told you so you could protect your unborn child the poor woman.

Personally I'd tell her that you want to ensure he never does what he has done to her to another person and will therefore support her in coming forward to the police. But explain in any event you need to tell DH as you are finding it too upsetting to deal with alone.

Hopefully your DH will be respectful of your SIL in the way he handles it.

Aimee1987 · 05/12/2021 10:01

After thinking about this, I would ask social services what can be done. Be honest and say you have been made aware of a historical case of child abuse by x and that you are concerned that this is not an isolated incident and there may be more children at risk.
It means if he is dbs checked it may flag ( not actually sure but this is where the conversation would help).

SilverPeacock · 05/12/2021 09:57

Realistically unless SIL wants to take it further what is anyone going to be able to do? Op has no evidence other than what sil has told her so would be only be reporting heresay. If OP had more concrete concerns about some potentiial risk to someone else this would be different. Betraying SILs trust at this stage would probably have very real and potentially devastating consequences for SIL on the other hand and risk retraumatising her. OP should support sil to think about reporting it herself.

billy1966 · 05/12/2021 09:47

First off I would not want to be around your parents in law.

What a shower.

Their daughter has most likely had issues her whole life because of this.

That he assaulted her again as an adult indicates a feeling of invincibility.

He is a truly evil person.

I certainly do not tell my husband everything and would never betray a confidence of a friend to my husband, it simply is none of his business.

This feels very different to me.

I would not want to be anywhere near your BIL ever again and his parents likewise.

I feel very sorry for your SIL but I would not be keeping something like this from my husband.

I couldn't anyway because there is NO way I would be in his company again.

This is a very dangerous man and he needs reporting.

I don't believe for a second your SIL is his only victim and I couldn't stay silent on that basis.

The impact on your in laws wouldn't concern me at all, however elderly.

They know bloody well what he did but have sacrificed her for their own selfishness.

Awful people, completely unforgivable.

Flowers
Swipe left for the next trending thread