Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish schools would scrap Christmas jumper day?

408 replies

Notspeakingup · 04/12/2021 17:59

DC2 has a couple of little classmates with difficult home lives, one in particular without much money. There are some Christmas jumper days coming up and I have been thinking about how tough it must be to always be the child with no jumper.

I know as children grow up you can't avoid the inequalities but it would be great if we could at least stop it being an issue at primary school. (And of course there are the families who buy jumpers when they can't really afford them).

OP posts:
NewlyJingle2021 · 04/12/2021 22:31

My DC school are not only doing the Xmas jumper day (suggested donation of £1) but they are also asking the kids to wear Xmas jumpers for 2 days the following week for the nativity and other activities. So realistically that's going to require multiple Xmas jumpers, or else somehow washing and drying the same 1 overnight for the following day. Or else they'll have to wear a dirty jumper on day 2. There is no way either child will keep it clean on day 1. We are in a deprived area and usually the school provide the nativity costumes which I always thought was good, so this is a change for the worse. Some families will literally have no heating and be living off food banks right now. I'm on UC but thankfully not as badly off as some of our local families, but I can't stretch to a load of new overpriced jumpers, I'm hoping last year's still fit the kids or that maybe that their dad will spring for a couple. It's especially annoyed me as it's coming off the back of many other themed and 'suggested item of clothing and donation' days in recent weeks.

fournonblondes · 04/12/2021 22:25

May more creativity should be encouraged to use recycle items to attach to jumpers. It is a fun day I would not scrape it entirely.

Breadpapercone · 04/12/2021 22:22

cpag.org.uk/cost-of-the-school-day

Ivalueloyaltyaboveallelse · 04/12/2021 21:53

Yeah it’s not the best idea. Its definitely added pressure for parents. I always bring my DCs old Christmas jumpers (my DC grow very quick and I’m a bit of a hoarder) along on Christmas jumper day as back up plan for any children who’s parents have forgotten or can’t afford to do so. Luckily no one has taken offence so far but I've only passed out three.

MehhyMehMeh · 04/12/2021 21:47

Yep. Our school is also making the kids do a sponsored thing on Christmas jumper day, (well one of them they're having two.) So not only do we need to fork out on new jumpers that they'll wear twice, but we have to send money in too, and are guilted into sending in extra ourselves as we hardly have any family left to sponsor the stupid, crappy 'fun' thing that my children will hate.

GoodnightGrandma · 04/12/2021 21:46

I remember that we made crowns to wear at the school Xmas party, as not everyone put party clothes on. Perhaps they didn’t have clothes to change into.

Babyshadows · 04/12/2021 21:46

I buy Xmas pajamas and send them in the top from that. It's fine for the day and then they wear the pjs all year round

Cam2020 · 04/12/2021 21:44

My DD loves a Christmas jumper and will wear one at any opportunity (but she is only 4), so I don't personally see it as waste for us. Always plenty in charity shop windows and free on selling groups so I don't think cost is much of an issue. If she wasn't into it, I'd probably just make or get some sort of applique or something for an old jumper.

She missed out on wear your football kit day ay nursery last year because she doesn't have one and was largely unaware of professional football until the world cup. She felt miffed but she lived!

People are different and that always impacts their children, whether that be economic differences, beliefs or a complete lack of interest (as with us and the world cup). It's uncomfortable but inevitable. I think children become aware of the difference quite early on, sadly.

I agree a PTA run swap would be great and I'd always happily donate to the school to spare a child feeling left out, though.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 21:44

But I don't think clothes are seen in the same way eg as a status symbol but maybe that's because we have uniform in the UK whereas when you are non uniform day in day out it's comfort & practicality.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 21:42

I think non uniform can't happen in isolation though. My guess is it works in Sweden because there is less inequality.

Lots of EU countries don't have school uniform.

LazySundayPlease · 04/12/2021 21:40

We were told on Tuesday last week that Friday would be 'bright clothes' day and the following Friday 'Christmas jumper day'. Absolutely ridiculous when we have 2 children in the school.

I 100% agree. Our usually very sensitive headmistress has really lapsed by not putting her foot down on this with the PTA (run by someone who doesn't even have children at the school anymore!)

Notspeakingup · 04/12/2021 21:38

How on earth is it virtue signalling??

OP posts:
BettyOBarley · 04/12/2021 21:37

Yes I agree. I think Christmas in general in primary schools is too expensive.
I mean obviously it's lovely for the kids, but so far we've had £15 for the nativity video as we can't go to it, £5 for the Christmas fair, Christmas jumper day coming up so you need to buy the jumper and then pay £1 for the priviledge of wearing it, a non uniform day last week where we had to bring a bottle or sweets so that's another few quid, nativity outfit to buy... and that's just one school, I have kids in two schools. That's before feeling like you have to buy gifts for teachers etc.
Some families must be so completely stressed out by it.

Notspeakingup · 04/12/2021 21:36

It’s already an issue at primary school. Was long before Christmas jumper day and will be when it falls out of fashion.

Which doesn't mean things can't be changed? Like you say yourself, many schools do try to make school life inclusive. Although these well intentioned schemes/etc to have jumpers available, they don't entirely deal with the shame.

OP posts:
Elephantsparade · 04/12/2021 21:33

I find the dress up relevant to the topic days seem to leave kids out more thinking about this. Parents either buy costumes or make quite elaborate stuff so anyone with no money or time is stuck and these are much shorter notice.

JustLyra · 04/12/2021 21:33

@BoredZelda

Penalised? No. Open to bullying? Yep.

If kids are getting bullied for it, they are getting bullied for the rest of the year too.

So what's your suggestion?

Just ignore it and let the kids missing out just miss out on more?

FinallyMrsE · 04/12/2021 21:33

Our school does a non uniform day and they can wear Christmas colours if they wish instead of jumper day and ask us to make a donation to the local food bank if we can so nobody has to worry about finding the £1 either.

JustLyra · 04/12/2021 21:32

@BoredZelda

It is, however, another highlighter for some children that they don't have what their friends have.

These kids feel it every day regardless of Christmas jumper day. To focus on it as an issue is pointless virtue signalling.

No, it's not pointless virtue signalling.

Schools are limited in what they can do.

They can, and thankfully many are, scrap stupidly expensive uniforms with bollocks like £40 for trousers in a slightly different shade of grey to the supermarket.

And they can also do it by massively minimising the number of days that they emphasise the differences. This is one of them.
The fact it is there every day isn't a reason to just shrug it off and have another day where the poor kid the only one in uniform or the only one in the ill fitting borrowed top that everyone saw the teacher lending them.

KateInHappyland · 04/12/2021 21:32

YANBU, I wish everywhere would. We're doing it at work, so there's the expectation to buy one as well as a £15 Secret Santa!

I can't help but think there are a lot of people who couldn't afford these things, especially at an already expensive time of year and especially when it involves children who will end up feeling left out.

I love the idea of having them decorate paper Christmas hats or something as a class. It's fun, creative and something they can all enjoy.

foxgoosefinch · 04/12/2021 21:32

H&M or Tesco often have some on the £3 sale rail in the summer, I find.

If schools are going to do it then they ought to make it any own clothes, and at least have a couple of spare or some tinsel and festive deely boppers for kids who don’t have any or forget. Not all of the kids want to wear a Christmas jumper either!

BoredZelda · 04/12/2021 21:31

Penalised? No. Open to bullying? Yep.

If kids are getting bullied for it, they are getting bullied for the rest of the year too.

Welcometothejingles · 04/12/2021 21:30

@isthismylifenow

And what about the families who don't celebrate Christmas? Do they just go along with it so the DC are not feeling left out? .
Anybody can wear a winter themed jumper with a snowman, penguin, Snowflake or penguin etc. You don't have to be a Christian to wear those, I'd assume none Christians would avoid father Christmas etc. Although Christmas has become a very secular festival and a vast majority of those celebrating probably aren't officially practicing Christian. So it doesn't matter really.
BoredZelda · 04/12/2021 21:27

It is, however, another highlighter for some children that they don't have what their friends have.

These kids feel it every day regardless of Christmas jumper day. To focus on it as an issue is pointless virtue signalling.

RodneyIsDave · 04/12/2021 21:27

Norma sweater and sew a few baubles and tinsel on it. I do it for work Xmas jumper day.

Beseen22 · 04/12/2021 21:27

Our school has a real mix of pupils and are well funded due to this. They get donations for 3 weeks and children who need them are given a Christmas jumper. There are a few non uniform events throughout Dec including a party clothes day but its usually done pretty sensitively (either Christmas jumper or pjs)