Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish schools would scrap Christmas jumper day?

408 replies

Notspeakingup · 04/12/2021 17:59

DC2 has a couple of little classmates with difficult home lives, one in particular without much money. There are some Christmas jumper days coming up and I have been thinking about how tough it must be to always be the child with no jumper.

I know as children grow up you can't avoid the inequalities but it would be great if we could at least stop it being an issue at primary school. (And of course there are the families who buy jumpers when they can't really afford them).

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 19:31

@2022HereWeCome

The problem is as someone posted previously schools give v little notice about this sort of thing. We were given a week's notice this year. Not really long enough to be able to guarantee getting something from Ebay / or finding something in the charity shops (when every fecker is looking for a cheap Xmas jumper).
Unless your first dc is in reception then I'm sure you had an idea that it might be happening
Mortgagetransfer · 04/12/2021 19:30

We call ours festive day and they can either wear Christmas clothes or jazz up their uniform. On Monday though we will spend tutor time making tinsel hair clips/headbands etc that kids can wear on the Friday - works quite well! Teachers and students also donate old Christmas clothes and we let kids help themselves to it

ArabellaScott · 04/12/2021 19:28
  • and it's not to do with being less fortunate, it's to do with not buying unnecessary tat to go along with the crowd.
2022HereWeCome · 04/12/2021 19:27

The problem is as someone posted previously schools give v little notice about this sort of thing. We were given a week's notice this year. Not really long enough to be able to guarantee getting something from Ebay / or finding something in the charity shops (when every fecker is looking for a cheap Xmas jumper).

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 19:27

@Elephantsparade

Buying a brand new jumper to wear one day is daft. My kids have never had a christmas jumper. They just went in a jumper that was red or green or i put a bit of tinsel on. I have bought wintery jumpers though. Do some schools really police this to christmas only.
Of course they don't police it. DD's jumper that she's worn for the last 2 years is a fluffy black one with pink sparkly leopard spots. Could be worn when cold year round. She's decided it's an Xmas jumper because of the sparkly pattern and wooliness. Can't imagie any school would have any issue with this - ours certainly doesn't
RaginaPhalange · 04/12/2021 19:27

Ds school accepts donations of Xmas jumpers to hand out to the less fortunate.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 04/12/2021 19:27

@colourfulpuddles

I’m not suggesting children miss out on stockings and presents or treats etc because some children have less. Im just talking about in school. I'm suggesting that school should be somewhere where children all have an equal experience and no one feels left out.

So you want kids to be brought up with an unrealistic expectation of the world? That everyone is equal and the same? So when they grow up and enter real life they’re shocked and unprepared for it?

I'm not the pp that you're responding to, but surely there are better ways to equip kids to handle the realities of the world than making some poor little 5 year old feel embarrassed and upset because they are sticking out like sore thumbs because they are the only one among their peers to not have a Christmas jumper? Something that could easily be tackled by schools and changed into something different ie take a piece of tinsel off the teachers desk and wear it.

I think that it's a poor indictment of our schooling system (and of adults in general) if they aren't able to think of ways to teach children about the fairness of life other than singling out poor children and putting them in the spotlight to feel embarrassed.

ArabellaScott · 04/12/2021 19:27

Never bought a Xmas jumper in my life and have no intention of starting now. My kids just don't wear one, nothing terrible has happened and they don't seem fussed.

KloppsTeeth · 04/12/2021 19:25

Our PTA collects donations of Christmas Jumpers and also costumes for dress up days. We have a cupboard in school full of freshly laundered items such as these as well as running the second hand uniform shop including trainers and football boots.
We recently started collecting second hand “labels” clothes to make sure that we have a wide ranging wardrobe of items for non uniform day. We have sports hoodies, trainers, all available for children to come and help themselves so that they don’t feel left out when others look like a JD Sports advert.
Any parent/carer that needs to can request via the school office any of our items for free. We have a box in the office where they come back and we wash them, they don’t have to come back clean.
We also provide free tickets to our events via the school office too, equality of opportunity is really important to us, everyone will get the same chances.
PTA members never know who the people we help are, we just know that we have helped some families and that is enough for us.
We are introducing a Little Library next year too so that children can access reading books.
If you have a PTA at school, ask what they can do to support disadvantaged children.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/12/2021 19:25

There are always lots of them given away free or very cheaply on local buy sell groups where I live. I actually prefer this to non uniform days as xmas jumpers tend to be completely unbranded, most come from cheaper stores like Asda (even the better off kids tend to have a supermarket type one) so they are a bit more of a leveller

Whatinthelord · 04/12/2021 19:24

“I always thought world book day should be bring in your favourite book.”

^me too. WBD has got ridiculous. I let my daughter go in an Elsa because she had the outfit already.

I think the thing with secondhand items is that it can feel very different to CHOOSE to buy something secondhand, knowing you have the option of buying new, than to buy secondhand out of necessity. It is also the stress of feeling that you are letting down your child by not being able to buy them a nice new jumper and only being able to give them secondhand.

I’m a big charity shopper and regularly buy toys second hand….but I do so because I hate waste and prefer to save money. That’s different from doing so out of necessity.

Cattipuss · 04/12/2021 19:24

I agree, although anything enforced at school or that risks making a child who cannot afford something stand out is horrible, there's no need for it. Plenty of opportunities for people to wear their Christmas stuff at home, or just have a non uniform day and then if people want to dress festive they can, if not then they don't.

Elephantsparade · 04/12/2021 19:22

Buying a brand new jumper to wear one day is daft. My kids have never had a christmas jumper. They just went in a jumper that was red or green or i put a bit of tinsel on. I have bought wintery jumpers though.
Do some schools really police this to christmas only.

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 19:22

@GrandTheftWalrus

My daughter needs 4 for school but I bought 2 from the charity shop and they'll do.
How on earth does she need 4? Our school has 12 'official' Xmas jumper days but they can wear them on the days in between too. They don't need 12 Xmas jumpers they just wear the same one on each day!
megletthesecond · 04/12/2021 19:22

Yanbu.
Children grow out of them and you have to be on the ball to find one from a charity shop. My teens will get two years out of their charity shop jumpers which is mainly luck.

2022HereWeCome · 04/12/2021 19:21

I only have one child so I don't get the multiple uses (although I do try to pass the damn things on)

2022HereWeCome · 04/12/2021 19:20

Our PTA was trying to organise a secondhand Xmas jumper stall yo prevent people having to fork out for new ones but we haven't been able to have any events because of Covid ... so DS is being crammed into the same one as last year. And to cap it all the school is now asking for a minimum donation amount. I really really really don't know why the school can't say 'wear something festive / Christmassy' instead

ElfDragon · 04/12/2021 19:19

It’s one of the school dress up days I don’t mind.

Evacuee/Tudor/Greek/Roman/around the world/etc are all more annoying for clothes that can’t be reworn.

My eldest has had 3 Christmas jumpers in total. She’s still wearing the most recent one - 3rd year now.

Middle child has had 2 jumpers (one of which was her sister’s hand me down), and 3 t shirts, which all still fit (last year for 2 of them, sadly)

Youngest has had a few t shirts, which still fit, and 3 jumpers, 2 of which still fit.

So, across 6 years or so, and 3 children, I’ve bought 7 jumpers, 5 of which are still being worn. Not exactly excessive.

My dc have also chosen well, and are happy to wear their jumpers and t shirts for most of December, so they are not worn just for one day.

I can understand the problem with children from families who cannot afford specialist clothing, but that’s not restricted to this one dress up day at school - there’s so many, often requiring weird and wonderful combinations, or last minute homemade alterations to existing clothing etc. it’s hardly a new thing.

lightisnotwhite · 04/12/2021 19:18

@EssexCat

I agree. Our PTA run a swap shop and sell them for £1 (or donation for those more or less affluent to donate accordingly) which is a really good and much less wasteful idea.

Or they just wear non uniform on that day.

This is a good idea!

The whole idea of a Christmas jumper was a crap gift your nan or aunt knitted you.
Now it’s a unecessary cheap supermarket jumper or an expensive designer job that looks cheap.

IDontThinkSoNo · 04/12/2021 19:18

I totally agree with you op. However I have found ways to make it better. Like a fair isle style jumper which my kids would wear all winter, not just Christmas jumper day. Or attaching tinsel to something more plain. Or buying big and wearing for a couple of years then passing on to second child, then cousins etc. Doesnt feel wasteful. I’d never buy a new jumper to be worn once, that’s just awful

MsDastardley · 04/12/2021 19:17

My friends DC school is doing Christmas Jumper Friday for the whole of December!

TheWayTheLightFalls · 04/12/2021 19:17

Yanbu at all. Something simple like each child wearing civvies and making a paper garland/hat would be great, with a £1 donation for those that can.

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 04/12/2021 19:15

The PTA in our school asks for donations of any outgrown jumpers and they are there available for any child who has forgotten their jumper if they would like to wear one

Sh05 · 04/12/2021 19:15

Our school has scrapped Christmas jumper day, it's 'wear what you like so long as it's comfy and warm' day.
I must say our head is very aware of the difficulties our school community faces and I've started appreciating her awareness of this since COVID.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 04/12/2021 19:14

In our DC primary in December we have to provide a nativity costume, a Christmas jumper for Christmas jumper day, a Christmas outfit for class party, £2 each ‘donation’ per child to enter the school fete in the hall plus ‘spending money’, this is during school time.