Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF! Random man comment

291 replies

KatherineJaneway · 04/12/2021 15:29

Out in a busy, lively restaurant last night catching up with a good friend. Been there about an hour when a random man walks up to our table and says to me directly 'Do you ever smile?'

I was a bit confused in the moment as I had no idea who he was and my friend and I had been talking, so I was like 'excuse me?' I must have moved from what was clearly a resting bitch face to a smile and he was like 'Oh, you do' and he walked off. I mean, why do that?

YABU - he's making conversation
YANBU - you're right, he's an annoying twat

OP posts:
SchadenfreudePersonified · 04/12/2021 18:29

@ChargingBuck

I've had people say "cheer up, it might never happen" to me, and I'm a man! I think calling a women he wasn't intimate/close with "love" makes it inappropriate, but otherwise this isn't necessarily sexist.

Thanks for popping by to mansplain sexism to the laydeez, Random Man.

Grin Grin Grin
justustwoandmoo · 04/12/2021 18:29

Absolute idiot. Says a lot about him and his need to put people down though. Feel sorry for him and glad you don't treat people that way Smile. You did well not to tell him where to go x

chloworm · 04/12/2021 18:29

@Hairycut

I find stony silence and a fixed, eye engaging stare before dropping my gaze down their body with a hint of a sardonic sneer effective.
Then say “not much to smile about here, is there?” in a similarly sardonic manner.
Lilymossflower · 04/12/2021 18:28

I agree with a pp, you were looking Lovley and nice and confident and you needed putting back in your place because how dare a single woman look and feel good without a man (presuming you were with a female friend as cannot imagine a random man would do that to a woman who is sitting with a man because clearly she has been 'claimed' already and therefore not public property but under the ownership of the man)

Butchyrestingface · 04/12/2021 18:28

"Do you ever stop being a cunt?"

I'm beginning to really enjoy early middle age.

Rawmum30 · 04/12/2021 18:27

About 15 years ago, I was walking quite hurriedly to a hospital appointment that I was anxious about and was on the verge of being possibly late, so I was fully focused on getting there.
I was semi aware of a chap cycling towards me, and as he approached and passed me, he said “oh, you’re so fucking ugly”.
He had gone before I could register what he had said properly, and I proceeded to get to my appt.
However, it took months for me to get over it.
I felt stupid for feeling so affected, and that a strangers comment shouldn’t matter to me.
My self esteem isn’t that high anyway, so it was all too easy to believe that his comment was true, and I honestly worried that was how everyone saw me…
now I know looks shouldn’t be the sole reason one is valued, but I felt so ashamed, and it took quite some time to try socialising again.
I told one or two people close to me about it, and of course they “rationalised” it by saying that maybe his mental health may be suffering.
However, it really bloomin sticks. Well, enough for me to have vivid memories of it all these years later.
Perhaps I’m at fault coz I’m too vain?

Watchingyouwazowski · 04/12/2021 18:25

There are too many posts like this. I don’t mean you were wrong to post OP, I mean men are just total dicks!

Gargellen · 04/12/2021 18:25

@Chesneyhawkes1

I remember a similar thread ages ago when the lady replied "thank you for your comment random man"
.....random ugly man with bad breath". Even better
mbosnz · 04/12/2021 18:24

@JesusSufferingFuck22

I was speaking to a (male) counsellor about a similar scenario. I was out walking, which was getting difficult because of MS rearing it's ugly head and random guy says, "cheer up it might never happen." Counsellor says to me "There's only one correct response to that really, it's FUCK OFF."
That's my kind of counsellor! Where do I get me one of those Grin
my8thMNusername · 04/12/2021 18:24

My thought was pick up line.

JesusSufferingFuck22 · 04/12/2021 18:23

I was speaking to a (male) counsellor about a similar scenario. I was out walking, which was getting difficult because of MS rearing it's ugly head and random guy says, "cheer up it might never happen."
Counsellor says to me "There's only one correct response to that really, it's FUCK OFF."

GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 04/12/2021 18:13

Surely you know YANBU. No man has the right to tell a woman to SMILE to make herself look more appealing to HIM.

What the fuck are men thinking when they say this?

SchadenfreudePersonified · 04/12/2021 18:13

[quote aspirational]Here you go OP, how to deal with that Brandon man

m.youtube.com/watch?v=AX4sf1JVY24[/quote]
Love it!

(Particularly liked the masked woman who was disposing of a body . . . )

Glassofshloer · 04/12/2021 18:11

Fuck sake what a twat! Why do men always make the ‘smile’ comments? Are we merely pretty little ornaments that must light up in their presence & provide visual positivity to men wherever we go?!

SarahDippity · 04/12/2021 18:02

Whenever a random man starts to chat, I arrange my face to ‘confused-then-recognition’ and say ‘sorry, I didn’t recognise you at first, you’re (any child’s name) Alex’s grandad aren’t you?’

5128gap · 04/12/2021 18:01

@LuluBlakey1

I remember being about 25 and out with a group of 5 of 6 friends. One of them was getting married and we'd gone out for early cocktails followed by a meal. Nothing too wild. As we were getting ready to leave the cocktail place about 8, a man, about 60, who I had seen watching us came over , put his hand on my friend who was getting married's arm and said smirking, 'A plain face like yours sometimes hides a good heart' and walked away. Only she and I heard because the others had started towards the door. She was so embarrassed and we tried to dismiss it by saying he was an old drunk and really rude and an absolute knacker etc but I could see she was shaken and upset. She was absolutely stunning on her wedding day and I always hope she never thought of that horrible man and his nasty comment again.
Thats such an upsetting story. My friend was once asked how come someone as ugly as her had such good-looking friends (not a stealth brag, I wasn't one of the friends with her) This happened over 30 years ago and she mentioned it only the other day. She often refers to herself as ugly. She isn't.
MothralovesGojira · 04/12/2021 18:00

Thank you @girlmom21
Our manager is brilliant at supporting us thankfully. A couple of weeks ago a man in his 80's (and riding a motability scooter to boot) came up to and said "I like your jumper".
I replied thank you.
He then followed up with "I like what's in it better".
I leaned over the counter and looked to the left and then the right and replied" Did you bring Leslie Phillips or Sid James in with you"?
He replied "No why?"
I replied " Because I thought we'd all fallen into some kind of 1960's comedy nightmare"
At that his daughter came rushing over and firmly wheeled him away while muttering "not again dad".

5zeds · 04/12/2021 17:58

Not all assaults are physical.

OP you were verbally attacked by a stranger. Clever retorts aren’t necessarily and will titillate as much as looking upset/silenced.

fakereview · 04/12/2021 17:57

@ChaToilLeam

Absolute twat. You’re not a performing seal!
I think you have just given me an idea for a put-down if it ever happens to me (I am probably too old now, but in case).

Women aren't here to perform for you. Goodbye.

BeardyButton · 04/12/2021 17:55

@Hairycut yes. I thank my stars for turning 35 and every day since becoming more unnoticed by these fuckers. They made me miserable.

I have so many many stories. From the waiter on holidays in Tunisia who told me my eyes were so beautiful he wanted to remove them and keep them in a jar by his bed (I was 13) to the colleague who told me the only reason my work was appreciated was because I was ‘sensual’. I ve had so many “smile it may never happens” I couldn’t count. And one guy in a restaurant tried to convince me he was a doctor and asked to feel my neck as he thought I had a goitar (I was 17, he was 50 ish and drunk).

These are not complements. They are not “characters who like to banter”. These are entitlements. They are men who believe they have the right to something (sex, prestige at work, etc etc). They use these shitty comments as ways of enforcing those entitlements.

LuluBlakey1 · 04/12/2021 17:53

I remember being about 25 and out with a group of 5 of 6 friends. One of them was getting married and we'd gone out for early cocktails followed by a meal. Nothing too wild. As we were getting ready to leave the cocktail place about 8, a man, about 60, who I had seen watching us came over , put his hand on my friend who was getting married's arm and said smirking, 'A plain face like yours sometimes hides a good heart' and walked away. Only she and I heard because the others had started towards the door. She was so embarrassed and we tried to dismiss it by saying he was an old drunk and really rude and an absolute knacker etc but I could see she was shaken and upset.
She was absolutely stunning on her wedding day and I always hope she never thought of that horrible man and his nasty comment again.

MothralovesGojira · 04/12/2021 17:45

@Mochudubh
Yes, funnily enough we thought the exact same thing! Luckily I'm older and have had a few years to perfect my resting bitch/are you on glue face but even I was gobbed smacked by this person's mother.

BeardyButton · 04/12/2021 17:44

@ChargingBuck

I did wonder if someone might say this! It's question-begging to say "why do men do this women?" when men and women also do it to men.

You wondered if you were making a plonker of yourself, but lo! - felt entitled to trot on in with an asinine remark anyway.

If you are white @Kosmin, do you also join in when black people discuss everyday racism, just to let them know whether their lifelong lived experience of microaggressions & dominance displays from white people constitutes racism or not?

Are you getting it yet?

I don't give a toss for your Whataboutery, or what women say to you in your imagination the street. Just as you wouldn't patronise & correct a black guy when he tells you he felt a comment was racist ... you don't get to tell women what constitutes sexism.

Now sod off, & don't @ me again boyo.
Women don't owe you attention or deference, especially when you tout your incorrect opinion as fact in the face of decades of our own intellect & experience.

Fair dues! Couldn’t have said it better. The NAMALTs are a pain, but worse still are the misogynistic mansplainers who think they have the god given right to decide what sexism/misogyny is and then feed it back to women who actually experience this on a day to day basis.
girlmom21 · 04/12/2021 17:43

@MothralovesGojira

We had something similar in our shop last month. One of our employee's is a young woman who is very helpful and polite but very quiet (for reasons that I won't go into). It was Saturday morning and a male customer aged about 40ish was trying to chat her up and wouldn't hand over any money until he'd had "some service with a smile" (I kid you not) to which she replied with a polite "that will be £ please". A stand off ensued with him staring her down until another customer tapped him on the shoulder and asked him to stop holding the queue up and he grudgingly paid up and left. All this is bad enough but on Monday morning the man's mother came in to the shop and loudly complained that her son had been disrespected on Saturday by some young bitch who didn't know how to treat a customer properly and that she was very upset that her own son had been treated so horrendously. She said all he'd wanted was to be shown respect due to him and to have a smile from the woman. Honestly this is absolutely true. My manager was very angry and told the mother that no one owes her son pretty and that neither of them were welcome to return. My poor colleague was so mortified but does now know that she does not have to accept men hitting on her and knows to ask for back up in future so one of us can come and explain to these random men why their behaviour is unacceptable - we only had to wait for her next shift for it to happen again.
While this is batshit, I'm glad she has the support of a variety of colleagues and she doesn't have to tolerate or confront this bullshit behaviour.

You and your colleagues are fab.

Dozer · 04/12/2021 17:41

Everyday sexism. Horrible.