Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF! Random man comment

291 replies

KatherineJaneway · 04/12/2021 15:29

Out in a busy, lively restaurant last night catching up with a good friend. Been there about an hour when a random man walks up to our table and says to me directly 'Do you ever smile?'

I was a bit confused in the moment as I had no idea who he was and my friend and I had been talking, so I was like 'excuse me?' I must have moved from what was clearly a resting bitch face to a smile and he was like 'Oh, you do' and he walked off. I mean, why do that?

YABU - he's making conversation
YANBU - you're right, he's an annoying twat

OP posts:
IntermittentParps · 06/12/2021 18:18

Everyone can and should expect privacy in the sense of people not walking up to you at random and saying things about your personal demeanour/appearance, yes.
It seems to happen disproportionately to women at the hands of men.

Maireas · 06/12/2021 17:44

@WiseMitera69

Privacy in an open place, you've got to be kidding me.
Clearly women have no right to that at all, according to some.
WiseMitera69 · 06/12/2021 17:41

Privacy in an open place, you've got to be kidding me.

Sidehustle99 · 06/12/2021 15:38

Eewww you smell like fucking feet

or

Stop following me Janine you fucking weirdo

Have always worked quite well for me. You have to say it with real disapproval though. And then sometimes hysterical laughing if they are super arrogant.

Gwrach · 06/12/2021 15:11

I have a resting bitch face, it's really Oscar worthy, it's constant I can't change it, it's how my fave muscles relax. If I'm thinking I'll also drop my brow and appear to scowl, it's just my face.

I am constantly asked to smile by men. It infuriates me and surprisingly me resting bitch face turns in to a genuine look of disgust and displeasure then.

I am so fed up of "random men comments"

Things like on the weekend a man was clearly ahead of me in the queue but we weren't arranged in a line so I said "you were before me" he replied "ah you are prettier than me, you can go first"

🙄

lottiegarbanzo · 06/12/2021 15:05

Though I am now somewhat amused at the mental image of @WiseMitera69 going about their life with a permanent rictus grin, because it doesn't cost anything to smile AT ALL TIMES (including and especially for the benefit of random passing strangers with whom one intends no interaction).

Keeeep grinning WiseMitera69 !

IntermittentParps · 06/12/2021 15:03

He was a twat with (sadly) a typically male sense of entitlement. I'd bet my bottom dollar he has never and would never say that to a man.
Don't worry about how you did or didn't respond. Store up some of these responses for if there's a next time and remind yourself he's a loser.

lottiegarbanzo · 06/12/2021 14:58

Spot on MrsTerryPratchett.

It doesn't cost anything to accord other people respect (so avoid interrupting their conversations with random rude demands), does it eh? @WiseMitera69

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/12/2021 14:46

Maybe the guy had his own demons to fight, maybe the woman reminded him of a lost love one.

And he thought he'd say, "do you ever smile?"

And every wanker who came up to me as a teenager and said similar, they were all bereaved souls too? Odd how I reminded so many men of loved ones when I was a pretty teenager. And no women. And not now I'm pissed off and menopausal.

I hear sexist comments (hooves) I think sexism (horses) not bereaved loved ones (zebras).

Maireas · 06/12/2021 14:25

it doesn't cost anything for someone to smile
Actually it doesn't cost anything for random men to stay away from women.
Why should his feelings be paramount? Maybe if a woman doesn't feel like smiling in order to please a man that's ok

WiseMitera69 · 06/12/2021 14:21

No I'm not some random man!
But it doesn't cost anything for someone to smile.
And remember we are only getting one part of the "story" there's always 2 sides.
Maybe the guy had his own demons to fight, maybe the woman reminded him of a lost love one.
We've become a nation that's too quick to judge!

OneTC · 06/12/2021 13:23

so because it's happened to you, and you're a man, it's not sexist?
Right. I think you need to educate yourself about male entitlement and harrassment. We're not talking about the odd insensitive remark here. It's about control and the perceived role of women.

I think when a bloke does it to a woman it's sexist behaviour. The bloke is exerting or attempting to exert control over the situation that's only ever going to be favourable/enjoyable for them. It's taking advantage of their likely physical primacy. It is done because the woman is perceived as weaker or more vulnerable.

Men (mostly) do say it to other men, and with similar motive, but without the sex imbalance. It's still someone normally engaging in what they'll be quick to call "banter" if you react badly to it. It doesn't mean it's not sexist when it's aimed at women though

And most importantly, it's still men that do this, and in particular with that exact motive

TinyTear · 06/12/2021 13:08

@Fatarseflanagan09

One bloke asked me why I was so skinny, I asked him if he’d got as many spots on his dick as he had on his face.
An ex (note the ex) after a lot of back story said "do i have idiot written on my face?"

for once i had the reply

"i don't know, I haven't connected the dots!"

i know it was below the belt, and he was only 20yo and self conscious about his skin, but he was also a cheat

notacooldad · 06/12/2021 13:04

We've spent nearly 2 years behind masks, and so many of us have suffered from mental health issues not seeing a smiling face
Maybe you're overreacting
What kind of knob head comment is that?

Anyway these comments have been going on for decades.
It was rude,inappropriate and gross 40 years ago when I was a teenager as it is today.

Maireas · 06/12/2021 12:41

@lottiegarbanzo - in a nutshell.

lottiegarbanzo · 06/12/2021 12:08

@WiseMitera69

We've spent nearly 2 years behind masks, and so many of us have suffered from mental health issues not seeing a smiling face. Maybe you're overreacting.
Well, that's the thin end of the incel wedge right there, isn't it.

When 'I would like to experience a particular form of human interaction' is perceived as = 'therefore a woman owes it to me' and 'I may rightfully demand that she do offer it to me' (because I am a deserving person and women exist as men's helpmeets, not as autonomous people).

(and I may rightfully get extremely angry with the disobedient bitch, if she doesn't give me what I want).

Or... you could behave like a normal, social human being; act towards others in the same considerate, respectful, thoughtful way you would like people to act towards you. Combined with your basic social knowledge, that not everyone likes exactly the same things and you'd need to get to know someone before knowing what might make them smile.

Not difficult.

Maireas · 06/12/2021 10:11

@Kosmin - so because it's happened to you, and you're a man, it's not sexist?
Right. I think you need to educate yourself about male entitlement and harrassment. We're not talking about the odd insensitive remark here. It's about control and the perceived role of women.

exiledfromcornwall · 06/12/2021 10:07

I used to get this a lot when I was a shy young woman with an inferiority complex. Oh how I wish I'd had access to something like Mumsnet in those days (pre-internet), then I would have realised it wasn't just me this was happening to. I honestly thought there must be something uniquely wrong with me.

ChargingBuck · 06/12/2021 09:04

@WiseMitera69

We've spent nearly 2 years behind masks, and so many of us have suffered from mental health issues not seeing a smiling face. Maybe you're overreacting.
& maybe OP's reaction is exactly that - HER reaction.

You don't get to scold her for it, any more than random man gets to instruct her what to do with her face.

If you have MH issues due to not sesing enough smiling faces, I suggest you talk to people you know, & be amusing or warm enough to make THEM smile.

It's not owed to you by anyone.
You seem unconcerned about the impact these constant demands have on women's MH though @WiseMitera69.
I'm guessing you're another random man.
If you are not, maybe check your internalised misogyny.
Women don't need to perform on demand for strangers.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2021 08:19

@KatherineJaneway Wow some men are just unbelievable. I think your response was good, don’t worry about not having a witty reply straight away. Lot’s of good suggestions on this thread for it ever happens again.

Snog · 06/12/2021 08:15

"Dance for me first" is a great one

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2021 08:13

@Carlissa Grin I love it! I hope I get to use that one.

montysma1 · 06/12/2021 07:54

I am in tbe throws of an argument on a newspaper thread about cat calling etc being made illegal.

Petted lip man "So how are we supposed to know if we are allowed to say hello to women"

I told him it was quite simple, that he shouldnt force an interation with strange women which he wouldnt force with men.

Apparently, according to the 100% men who responded , I am an anti social psychopath and its quite normal to day hello to people. Indeed its good manners.
I told him good manners was to leave women he doent know alone, women who simply want to go about their day without "helloing" strange men.

Totally incapable of getting the point. I was all kinds of frosty bitch apparently.

notacooldad · 06/12/2021 07:54

I remember years ago me and my friend were in a pub sat on those high tables and hugh bar stools when a randomer told her to smile. She looked puzzled and said 'Smile? Sorry, you want me to smile? What for?' and looked confysed.
He just looked like a dick in front of his mates confused.
These days she would tell him to sling his hook!

Carlissa · 06/12/2021 07:53

I once told a man to "dance for me first" when he ordered me to smile.

He was a bit confused and sadly didn't oblige.

Swipe left for the next trending thread