Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 04/12/2021 20:12

People have paid for their houses, why tf should they sell them when renters rightly get social care free. Imagine if folk in rented houses had to start selling their possessions to pay for care.

I would imagine a renter with several hundred thousand in bank deposits or shares will if anything be more likely to be liable for their own care costs than a home-owner of the same net worth whose money is tied up in their house.

It's not unusual for people who can afford to pay their own way not to be eligible for government subsidies.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 20:08

@StopGo

What I object to is the two tier charging policy. Care/nursing homes locally charge between £1000 and £1300 per week to privately funded clients. The same beds/rooms are ‘sold’ to social services for £550 per week. Self funders subsidies the rest. So so wrong.
I agree that this is very wrong! Even normal companies selling services don’t give ‘bulk buy’ discounts of over 50%.

Find the money from somewhere, tax everyone but don’t steal from the people already unlucky enough to need care. I can see why people don’t want to pay in this case

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 20:06

@ronnitz. But it’s such a huge disparity though and it only affects the people who need care.

I just think it’s awful to charge an elderly and presumably vulnerable person so much more for the same service simply because they have an asset like a house. I don’t think it’s wrong to charge them, just not two or three times more.

As PP’s have suggested, perhaps an additional, more widespread tax is needed so that working adults and elderly people who don’t need care contribute more to elder care throughout their lives.

RandomLondoner · 04/12/2021 20:06

@PurpleDaisies

It’s awful for social mobility. Rich people manage to hold on to their assets and pass them to their children. The entire value of poorer peoples houses goes on care.
I've seen people making this point vociferously on the news. It amounts to saying that people with more money can buy more before they run out of money. I think they believe if they state the bleeding obvious in an outraged enough tone, people will pick up on the tone and not register that their is no meaningful content.
OddsNSodsBitsNBobs · 04/12/2021 19:54

@Chely

Many sign their houses over to their children to avoid this. Work hard and pay taxes for most of your life then have to sell your assets to pay for care. A person who paid little to nothing gets the same care free of charge because they have no assets.
Erm, you cant do that!
OddsNSodsBitsNBobs · 04/12/2021 19:52

@changingchanges Sorry, wrong post quoted!

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:52

Do you think it’s fair to charge two people different prices for the same service though?

I think it's fair that people pay what they can. If people don't want to pay anything & want everyone to get it at the same price how do you suggest that funding model works?

Some people will pay thousands in NI & hardly need the NHS, others will contribute hardly anything & have chronic conditions.

@Cameleongirl my parents house is worth about 2m & they have holiday homes abroad. Should they pay or not?

OddsNSodsBitsNBobs · 04/12/2021 19:51

@changingchanges2

I completely agree with you OP!

It's mainly because children of adults who are in the verge don't want to miss out on inheritance from houses that have seen the fastest, biggest, rise in the last few decades, this country has ever, or will ever, see.

But no one ever seems to admit to this. I wonder why Hmm

Erm, you cant just do that....
ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:48

It doesn’t. What I mean is that charging one self-funded care home resident double or triple the amount that SS. Is paying for the person in the room next door is criminal.

Why is it criminal though? Not everyone can pay, some won't have a home, some will have had a cheap home. I've never thought it criminal that my tax funds people who never saved for a pension. Or that someone next to me in a hospital might not have paid as much NI as me or someone at nursery gets child benefit.

shouldistop · 04/12/2021 19:48

I think it's because, if you don't have any means then your care will be paid for by the state.
However to do it any other way means that poorer elderly people would be left to rot which obviously can't be allowed to happen.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 19:47

@ronnitz. Do you think it’s fair to charge two people different prices for the same service though?

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:46

I'm actually quite shocked at some of the attitudes on this thread.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 19:45

@ronniz

I think higher inheritance tax would at least be fairer than charging people double or triple for the same service.

How does this solve the problem? what about people who don't receive any inheritance but still have to self fund?

It doesn’t. What I mean is that charging one self-funded care home resident double or triple the amount that SS. Is paying for the person in the room next door is criminal.
Elsiebear90 · 04/12/2021 19:42

The problem is that people want their cake and eat it, they don’t want to pay extra money through tax to make this care “free” for everyone, but they also don’t want to pay for their own care.

You can’t have it both ways, the money has to come from somewhere, either we all pay more and the only the ones who need it benefit or we continue as we are and the ones who need it and can afford to pay for it do so themselves.

SueSaid · 04/12/2021 19:39

'It's mainly because children of adults who are in the verge don't want to miss out on inheritance from houses that have seen the fastest, biggest, rise in the last few decades, this country has ever, or will ever, see.'

It isn't that. People have paid for their houses, why tf should they sell them when renters rightly get social care free. Imagine if folk in rented houses had to start selling their possessions to pay for care.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:34

I think higher inheritance tax would at least be fairer than charging people double or triple for the same service.

How does this solve the problem? what about people who don't receive any inheritance but still have to self fund?

DaisyandSimeon · 04/12/2021 19:33

@changingchanges2

I completely agree with you OP!

It's mainly because children of adults who are in the verge don't want to miss out on inheritance from houses that have seen the fastest, biggest, rise in the last few decades, this country has ever, or will ever, see.

But no one ever seems to admit to this. I wonder why Hmm

Totally agree.
Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 19:32

@StopGo

What I object to is the two tier charging policy. Care/nursing homes locally charge between £1000 and £1300 per week to privately funded clients. The same beds/rooms are ‘sold’ to social services for £550 per week. Self funders subsidies the rest. So so wrong.
I think most posters could agree that the two-tier policy IS totally wrong. Why should two people( as in SS and a private payer) pay completely different amounts for the same service?

I know you can use the argument that SS is “buying in bulk” so to speak, but it’s still unfair.

I think higher inheritance tax would at least be fairer than charging people double or triple for the same service.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:32

But lots don’t work for whatever reason, or have not saved a pension and rely solely on the state pension

Are they statistics for this? I would argue most do work, it's just not enough though. And pension schemes are not what they were.

Chloemol · 04/12/2021 19:30

I haven’t read the whole thread. My thoughts

Because lots work hard during their lifetime, paying NI to obtain free healthcare, schooling etc. But lots don’t work for whatever reason, or have not saved a pension and rely solely on the state pension

Then when you go into a care home those who only get state pension, have never saved etc get it for free, ,and those who have saved for old age, do have another source of pension have to pay, so in effect are being penalised for being prudent during their working life. It’s demoralising to hear your fellow care home residents boasting about how they don’t pay and have never paid

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:30

And that doesn't dispute the fact that some people work darned hard without owning, which isn't fair. I'd still like to give my property to my boy, I doubt he'll be able to afford his own place, and this will help him, so though that's another problem. This is all complicated.

I completely understand the sentiment. As your say your dc is unlikely to afford his own place without your help so he's no different to those you don't want to pay for. And what happens if it isn't enough? He's now the person others feel they shouldn't pay for.

Comedycook · 04/12/2021 19:27

@clarepetal. But it's selling your home so you can live somewhere else. You cannot expect to live somewhere for free when you have the means to pay for it?

ronniz · 04/12/2021 19:27

Alternatively if you've saved hard and bought say, an expensive handbag, but your next door neighbour wants it, would you give it to them? No!

It's not the right analogy though.

The issue is housing & how it's become the main driver for the economy, the only asset most people have & the reason we have intergenerational equality re housing.

clarepetal · 04/12/2021 19:24

@Comedycook

Because I bought the house with my own money and I should have the choice to do with it what I please. This may include giving it to my kids, or giving it away to charity, my possession, my choice

You could say this about anything.

I demand free food from the government...why should I spend my own money? I earned it and I want to give it to my children.

I wouldn't expect free food! If I've bought something it's my right to do what I want with it! Alternatively if you've saved hard and bought say, an expensive handbag, but your next door neighbour wants it, would you give it to them? No!

I have a flat, it's my home, but I'd like to give it to my son. If I need it to pay for care, that's what will happen but as there is care available for people who don't have their own property, why should I be out of pocket?
Although I do understand that I am very lucky to have a property and not everyone else is. And that doesn't dispute the fact that some people work darned hard without owning, which isn't fair. I'd still like to give my property to my boy, I doubt he'll be able to afford his own place, and this will help him, so though that's another problem. This is all complicated.

StopGo · 04/12/2021 19:18

What I object to is the two tier charging policy. Care/nursing homes locally charge between £1000 and £1300 per week to privately funded clients. The same beds/rooms are ‘sold’ to social services for £550 per week. Self funders subsidies the rest. So so wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread