Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 21:07

@Intercity225
So you think an alcoholic who has an illness shouldn’t receive care when they’re older, because the illness is of their own making

5128gap · 04/12/2021 21:06

[quote Cameleongirl]@Thursdaymiami. Exactly, everyone os paying towards children’s free education, not just a certain pool of people.

If what @StopGo asserts is true, the self payers in care homes are paying double to fund fellow residents who can’t afford to pay.

Surely that cost could be spread more widely across society, just as the cost of free education is? If more funding is needed for elder care, shouldn’t everyone contribute more? Why are elderly self payers bearing so much of the burden?[/quote]
But its not really a burden on them is it? They have reached a point in their lives where their assets are of no further use to them, so what harm is being done to them if that asset funds care?

Intercity225 · 04/12/2021 21:04

Not everyone who rents is a feckless layabout who has frittered away their cash...what a weird thought process.

I didn't say everybody; but I am thinking of some real people, who are not products of my thought processes! One of whom is an alcoholic! Do you agree that some alcoholics are likely to lose everything through their addiction - their house, marriage, family.....?

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 21:04

@1dayatatime
Eh?
So it’s ok to pay for people when young so they contribute more to society,
But not ok to pay for people when their old who have contributed to society?

So basically you genuinely think people who are old and poor should get nothing, because they’ve proved how worthless they are to society. But we give kids a chance, just in case they end up paying a decent wedge in taxes.

Do you know who you sound like?

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 21:00

@StopGo. So they told you what your DF would have to pay as a self funder and what SS would pay if he wasn’t self-funding?

StopGo · 04/12/2021 20:57

[quote Cameleongirl]@ronnitz. I agree and I would far rather my Dad spent his money on good care if he needs it than inherit anything.

@Thursdaymiami. I too wouldn’t mind seeing a link showing local authority spending vs. Self-payer spending if @StopGo has one. I’m not bashing poorer people, I assumed @StopGo was basing their assertion on facts- and if it’s true, I find it a truly bizarre system, because it’s such a limited pool of people providing those funds.

It’s like saying that only parents should pay the taxes used for child benefit and schools, and anyone who’s child-free shouldn’t contribute to them.[/quote]
Personal experience. My DF had to go into respite care urgently after DM had an accident.

Both social services and the care home manager were only too keen to tell me the budget and how much higher the charges would be if DF decided to stay.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 20:56

@Thursdaymiami. Exactly, everyone os paying towards children’s free education, not just a certain pool of people.

If what @StopGo asserts is true, the self payers in care homes are paying double to fund fellow residents who can’t afford to pay.

Surely that cost could be spread more widely across society, just as the cost of free education is? If more funding is needed for elder care, shouldn’t everyone contribute more? Why are elderly self payers bearing so much of the burden?

1dayatatime · 04/12/2021 20:56

@Thursdaymiami

"Why the fuck am I paying for people who churn out children and expect to get free education for them"

++++

Well mainly because by educating children you create a more productive workforce generating greater wealth in the country and thus greater tax revenues for society.

StopGo · 04/12/2021 20:51

@ronniz

It doesn’t. What I mean is that charging one self-funded care home resident double or triple the amount that SS. Is paying for the person in the room next door is criminal.

Why is it criminal though? Not everyone can pay, some won't have a home, some will have had a cheap home. I've never thought it criminal that my tax funds people who never saved for a pension. Or that someone next to me in a hospital might not have paid as much NI as me or someone at nursery gets child benefit.

The crux of the matter is that the modern ‘care’ system is a profit making and very lucrative industry.
Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 20:48

@Cameleongirl
Exactly I don’t have children,
Why the fuck am I paying for people who churn out children and expect to get free education for them

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 20:46

@ronnitz. I agree and I would far rather my Dad spent his money on good care if he needs it than inherit anything.

@Thursdaymiami. I too wouldn’t mind seeing a link showing local authority spending vs. Self-payer spending if @StopGo has one. I’m not bashing poorer people, I assumed @StopGo was basing their assertion on facts- and if it’s true, I find it a truly bizarre system, because it’s such a limited pool of people providing those funds.

It’s like saying that only parents should pay the taxes used for child benefit and schools, and anyone who’s child-free shouldn’t contribute to them.

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 20:46

So people on this thread think capitalism is a good thing. People should keep their money. And that living in a vibrant economically stable country is good, if they owned their own business they would also think it’s good that they got cheap bulk prices for services or goods.

But if a LA gets a bulk discount because they are the biggest supplier of “clients” to care homes, that’s TOTALLY unfair and should never happen. And your grandma is being ripped off and subsidising the feckless poor.

Superstar22 · 04/12/2021 20:43

I totally disagree with you.

The public funds the things you mention, and people pay taxes all their life towards care. We should support our elderly, they have contributed a great deal to our society. I agree some aspects of care should be means tested but it should be fair.

Taking the first £80k of someone’s wealth when their entire house may be £80k isn’t fair. Many many people can afford much more IF we are charging, and many others much less. Something like 20% of your wealth could be fair. That would be the same for everyone.

yoyo1234 · 04/12/2021 20:39

Me and DH save for our retirement (we are lucky we can and our employers also contribute a lot to our pension schemes). We aim to fund any care we may need later on in life, we see it as our responsibility.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 20:37

[quote ronniz]@TractorAndHeadphones but it's way more complex than that [/quote]
How so?
Yes, collecting the taxes etc etc might not be the easiest choice although it's the most fairest. Also as @Thursdaymiami says just because you're paying more doesn't mean you're subsidising everyone else. What does this mean?

I admit that I don't know much about this first hand but in terms of understanding people's opinions - it's also complex. Not always as simple as people not wanting their inheritance taken away. In some cases children contribute to the cost!

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 20:32

@Thursdaymiami

Where are the facts that the self funded pay triple those of LA funded? Anyone got a link

Or is this a thought with no factual back up, based on bashing the poorer of society again.

And just because you pay more, doesn’t mean you’re subsidising everyone else. That’s not how economics work, it’s a bit basic. It’s far more complex.

This was on the personal experience of a pp. Again another issue is that it's very different across councils! A colleague's relative paid as much as PP said as a self funder and managed to stay in a much nicer care home with no LA funded people about. This is in the NorthEast.

Unless there's some sort of website or official MSE/Which/whatever webstie on care homes.

Maybe an MN thread should be ongoing where people cna share

ronniz · 04/12/2021 20:30

My parents are happy to pay for their care & feel lucky to have a choice. It doesn't bother me that it might impact my inheritance 🤷🏻‍♀️

ronniz · 04/12/2021 20:30

@TractorAndHeadphones but it's way more complex than that

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 20:29

@ronniz

That’s perfectly fine, but it might make sense to contribute an elder care tax now than pay double if/when the time comes that they need

People won't vote for it though cause it's the same arguments of "why should I find others" or "I've paid my taxes" etc etc

Honestly if the only solution is to for self-funders alone to subside others to the tune of double then I can see why people don't want to pay. Wouldn't blame them for taking steps to avoid it. They're not being acted by morally, so they have every right to do some 'immoral' things of their own.
ronniz · 04/12/2021 20:26

The problem is that people want their cake and eat it, they don’t want to pay extra money through tax to make this care “free” for everyone, but they also don’t want to pay for their own care.

Basically.

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 20:25

Where are the facts that the self funded pay triple those of LA funded?
Anyone got a link

Or is this a thought with no factual back up, based on bashing the poorer of society again.

And just because you pay more, doesn’t mean you’re subsidising everyone else. That’s not how economics work, it’s a bit basic. It’s far more complex.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 20:24

That’s perfectly fine, but it might make sense to contribute an elder care tax now than pay double if/when the time comes that they need

People won't vote for it though cause it's the same arguments of "why should I find others" or "I've paid my taxes" etc etc

ronniz · 04/12/2021 20:22

I just think it’s awful to charge an elderly and presumably vulnerable person so much more for the same service simply because they have an asset like a house. I don’t think it’s wrong to charge them, just not two or three times more.

But they are subsidising those that can't, like everything in life. I think it's horrific to just let someone fend for themselves because they don't have a house.

As PP’s have suggested, perhaps an additional, more widespread tax is needed so that working adults and elderly people who don’t need care contribute more to elder care throughout their lives.

I think a wealth tax is a good idea but it's not popular.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 20:20

[quote Cameleongirl]@ronnitz. It sounds if your parents could pay for their care, just as my Dad could. That’s perfectly fine, but it might make sense to contribute an elder care tax now than pay double if/when the time comes that they need[/quote]
Also - those who pay double are those who are unlucky enough to need care. The burden isn't shared.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 20:13

@ronnitz. It sounds if your parents could pay for their care, just as my Dad could. That’s perfectly fine, but it might make sense to contribute an elder care tax now than pay double if/when the time comes that they need